High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/265/2003disposed of

Harjinder Singh v. State Of Haryana

2015-07-27Mr. Justice Gopal Das Khosla13 pages

! !"#$"#%$"#&'()#*#+$,"-'.(/#%#0-%$#(1+$"#(1)#,$2 #, 3

4 5

67 5

! "

88',#( 9%&1+(#% 1+)" -"9+ 1+)" 9%/9+, 1+)" 9%(9:9.1+)" '%8"9%9+1+)"9+(';"(#<1+)"=98#($"#$%19./#=-%# $"#((.

#,,1-+,'()#9$#"9/9( ->#<#%9%/9+,1+)"9%(9:9.

1+)" '%8"9%9+1+)"9+(';"(#<1+)">#%#98?'1$$#(-=$"#8"9%)#, =%9*#(/:$"#$%19. -'%$ "#0%#,#+$900#9."9,/##+0%#=#%%#(/:988',#(

9%&1+(#%1+)"9+(-"9+1+)">"->#%#8-+<18$#('+(#%#8$1-+5 %#9(>1$"#8$1-+56 9+(>#%#,#+$#+8#($-'+(#%)-6:#9%,

9+($- 09:9=1+#-=@#98"9+(1+(#=9'.$$-'+(#%)-9='%$"#%0#%1-(-=5 *-+$",1*0%1,-+*#+$

$1,$"#/%1#=89,#-=$"#0%-,#8'$1-+$"9$9..$"#988',#(&-1+#( $-)#$"#% 1+ ='%$"#%9+8# -= $"#1% 8-**-+ 1+$#+$1-+ 9+( 9$$98;#( ! 9;"/1%1+)"!5'8"91+)"9+(!4-"9+1+)" 88',#( -"9+1+)"#A"-%$#("1,,-+$-/%1+)9)'+9+(;1..$"#8-*0.91+9+$09%$:

88',#(9%&1+(#%1+)"/%-')"$ /-%#)'+9+(,"-$9$!!5 9+( !4 9+( 89',#( 1+&'%1#, 9+( (1,0'$# >9, $"# -%1)1+ -= $"# -88'%%#+8#1$"9,/##+0%-&#8$#(/:$"#0%-,#8'$1-+

,*9+:9,B>1$+#,,#,>#%##A9*1+#(-+$"#,1(#-=$"# 0%-,#8'$1-+ !9;"/1%1+)">"-,',$91+#(0#..#$1+&'%1#,.-()#($"# =1%,$1+=-%*9$1-+%#0-%$ #"9,89$#)-%189..:(#0-,#($"9$909+8"9:9$>9, 8-+<#+#($-(#*9+(/98;$"#.9+()1<#+/:!"9&9+1+)"$-988',#( -"9+1+)"$-9<-1(9+:(#8%##1+9*-$-%9881(#+$8.91*,89,# '$ 988',#(-"9+1+)"9+(9%&1+(#%1+)"%#=',#($-09%$>1$"$"#.9+( + 7769$9/-'$

$"#%#>9,909+8"9:9$1+$"#("9+1-=$"#%1<9. 09%$1#, !"#+$"#$9.;,1+8-++#8$1-+>1$"$"#.9+(>#%#)-1+)-+$"#%# >9,,-*#9.$#%89$1-+/#$>##+$"#8-*0.91+9+$09%$:9+($"#988',#(09%$:

"#%#>9,9+#A8"9+)#-=/.->,/#$>##+$"#* 88',#(-"9+1+)"

9,;#("1,,-+9%&1+(#%1+)"$-/%1+)$"#%1=.#=%-*"1,"-',# !9+( "1,>1=#8.-,#($"#(--%-=$"#%--*1+>"18"988',#(9%&1+(#%1+)" #+$#%#( 88',#(9%&1+(#%1+)"=1%#(56,"-$,$"%-')"$"#>1+(->

91*1+)9$$"#8-*0.91+9+$09%$:>"18""1$!9;"/1%1+)"!5 '8"91+)"9+(!4-"9+1+)"

"#%#9=$#%988',#(-"9+1+)"%9+ 9>9:-+/-9%(1+)"1,&##0

!5'8"91+)">"-9.,-,',$91+#(0#..#$1+&'%1#,,'00-%$#( $"##<1(#+8#-=! !"9&9+1+)"9.,-8-%%-/-%9$#($"##<1(#+8# -=!9+(!5 !4-"9+1+)"-=8-'%,#$'%+#("-,$1.#$-$"# 89,#-=$"#0%-,#8'$1-+

!6% 9>9+91+3#(189. ==18#% #+#%9.-,01$9.1,9% %9(1-.-)189..: #A9*1+#( 1+&'%#( '8"9 1+)" 9+( 9;"/1% 1+)" -+

776 !7%

9*#,"1+(9.$%#9$#(!4-"9+1+)"=-%$"#=1%# 9%*1+&'%1#,"#,',$91+#(-+"1,9/(-*#+8"#,$9+(/-$"$"#'00#%.1*/,-+ 776 #9.,-8-+('8$#(-0#%9$1-+-+<#%:,9*#(9: -"9+1+)">9, (1,8"9%)#(=%-*$"#"-,01$9.-+.:-+ 776

!% 9$%93#(189. ==18#%#A9*1+#(!5'8"9 1+)"9+(=-'+($"#=-..->1+)1+&'1%#, C

& '(%)

* +

% & ' %)

. +

% & '

#9.,-*#(18-.#)9..:#A9*1+#(!9;"/1%1+)"9+( =-'+($"#=-..->1+)1+&'%1#, C .

& '

+ %

& ' %)

!% '%#," '*9%3#(189. ==18#% #+#%9.-,01$9. 1,9%#A9*1+#(!4-"9+1+)"9+(=-'+($"#=-..->1+)1+&'%1#,-+"1, 0#%,-+ C %

( !

1& ' %)

+ -

2/2

1& '

. %

1& '

/ -

1& '

4 %

1& '

!B 9&9 9*>9,$"#1+<#,$1)9$1+)-==18#%1+$"1,89,#

"#988',#("9<#,#$'090.#9$"9$1$>9,-+.:$"#8-*0.91+9+$ 09%$:>"->#%#$"#9))%#,,-%,9$$98;#( '%8"9%9+1+)"9+( 18"09. 9'% 89',1+)1+&'%1#,$-$"#*

!% 9.*#(18-.#)9..:#A9*1+#(988',#( '%8"9%9+ 1+)"9+(=-'+($"#=-..->1+)1+&'%1#,-+"1,0#%,-+ C

+44

1& '

' +

) (

' !

1& '

4 4

# 9.,- *#(18-.#)9..: #A9*1+#( ! 18"09. 9'% 9+( =-'+($"#=-..->1+)1+&'%1#,-+"#%0#%,-+ C

5/ 5/

/ )

)

' 1& '

D 5

"#$%19. -'%$"9<1+)$"-%-')".:9(<#%$#($-$"##<1(#+8#-+ %#8-%(89*#$-$"#8-+8.',1-+$"9$$"#988',#(900#..9+$-"9+1+)"1+ ='%$"#%9+8#-=$"#8-**-+1+$#+$1-+#A"-%$#("1,,-+988',#(9%&1+(#% 1+)"$-/%1+)9)'+=-%;1..1+)$"#8-*0.91+9+$09%$: 88',#(9%&1+(#% 1+)"-0#+#(=1%#=%-*1+,1(#"1,"-',#$"%-')"9>1+(->9+(*9(#9+ 9$$#*0$$-;1..!!59+(!4

8%1$189..: #A9*1+#( $"# #+$1%# #<1(#+8# -= ! !5 !49+(! "#:"9<#(#0-,#(1+-+#<-18#$"9$$"#%#>9,9.9+( (1,0'$#/#$>##+$"#988',#(09%$:9+($"#8-*0.91+9+$09%$: !4"9, $'%+#("-,$1.#$-$"#89,#-=$"#0%-,#8'$1-+ ->#<#%!!59+( !"9<#,$9$#($"9$99+8"9:9$>9,8-+<#+#(9$$"#0"1%+1 '$$"#%# >9,<1-.#+$9.$#%89$1-+/#$>##+$"#09%$1#, A8#0$!4>"-"9($'%+#( "-,$1.#$"#-$"#%*9$#%19.>1$+#,,#,+9*#.:!!59+(!"9<# 89$#)-%189..:(#0-,#($"9$988',#(9%&1+(#%1+)"-0#+#(=1%#=%-*"1,

/-%#)'+9+(89',#(0#..#$1+&'%1#,-+$"#0#%,-+-=!!59+( !4

%'# 1$ 1, !4 8"-,# +-$ $- ,'00-%$ $"# 89,# -= $"# 0%-,#8'$1-+ '$$"#1+&'%#(>1$+#,,#,+9*#.:!!59+($"##:# >1$+#,,!"9<#(#0-,#(>1$"-'$9+:$%98#-=8-+$%9(18$1-+$"9$1$>9, -+.:988',#(9%&1+(#%1+)">"--0#+#(=1%#$"%-')""1, /-%#)'+ =%-*1+,1(#"1,"-',#9+(89',#(1+&'%:$-!!59+(!4 "# 1+&'%1#,-+$"#0#%,-+-=!9+(!59%#=-'+($-/#,1*0.#1++9$'%#

'$$"#1+&'%1#,-+$"#0#%,-+-=!49%#=-'+($-/#)%1#<-',1++9$'%# 1+9,*'8"9,"#"9(,',$91+#(0#..#$1+&'%1#,+-$-+.:-+"1,8"#,$/'$9.,- -+"1,,$-*98"

+-$"#%>-%(,1$1,=-'+($"9$988',#(9%&1+(#%1+)" "9(1+=98$91*#(9$$"#8-*0.91+9+$09%$:$-89',#(#9$"

"#*#(189.#<1(#+8#(1,8',,#(9/-<#8-*0.#$#.:8-%%-/-%9$#, $"#-8'.9%$#,$1*-+:-=!!59+(! "#%#=-%#9*-=$"# 8-+,1(#%#( <1#> $"9$ $"# 0%-,#8'$1-+ "9, #,$9/.1,"#( $"9$ $"# 988',#( 9%&1+(#%1+)"-0#+#(=1%#=%-*"1, /-%#)'+9+(*9(#9+9$$#*0$$- ;1..$"#8-*0.91+9+$09%$:

-*1+) $- $"# 8"9%)# -= #A"-%$9$1-+ 9$$%1/'$#( $- 988',#( -"9+1+)"1$1,9+9(*1$$#(89,#$"9$"#>9,4:#9%,9$$"#$1*#>"#+$"# -88'%%#+8#$--;0.98# !"9,,$9$#(1+$"#=1%,$1+=-%*9$1-+%#0-%$$"9$ 988',#( -"9+ 1+)" 9,;#( "1, ,-+ $- =#$8" 9 )'+ $- #.1*1+9$# $"# 8-*0.91+9+$09%$:

+"1,#<1(#+8#!"9,(#0-,#($"9$988',#(-"9+ 1+)"#A"-%$#($"9$$"#8-*0.91+9+$09%$:,"-'.(/#$9')"$9.#,,-+=-% (#*9+(1+)/98;$"#.9+( #9.,-9,;#(988',#(9%&1+(#%1+)"$-/%1+)

$"#%1=.# !5(#0-,#($"9$988',#(-"9+1+)"9,;#("1,,-+$-/%1+)9 %1=.#$-;1..$"#8-*0.91+9+$09%$:

!9.,-,0#9;,1+9,1*1.9%<-18#

=988',#(-"9+1+)""9(/##+0%#,#+$1+$"#*1(,$-=$"# 8-*0.91+9+$09%$:$"#0#..#$,=%-*$"#)'+',#(/:988',#(9%&1+(#%1+)" >-'.("9<#9.,-=9..#+-+$"#0#%,-+-=988',#(-"9+1+)" "#%#=-%# $"#<#%:0%#,#+8#-=-"9+1+)"1+$"#*1(,$-=$"#8-*0.91+9+$09%$: >"#+)'+,"-$=1%#>9,-0#+#(/:988',#(9%&1+(#%1+)"1,=-'+($-/# (-'/$='.

"#/#+#=1$-=(-'/$>1.."9<#$-/#)1<#+$-988',#(-"9+ 1+)"

#9%+#( ,#+1-% 8-'+,#. 900#9%1+) =-% $"# 900#..9+$, >-'.( ,'/*1$$"9$$"#8-*0.91+9+$09%$:"9(+-"-',#1+$"#=1#.( "#:"9( 98$'9..:8-*#9,9))%#,,-%,$-$"# 0"1%+1 -=$"#988',#( "#%#=-%#$"# #<1(#+8#-=!4>"-$'%+#("-,$1.#>1.."9<#$-/#988#0$#( $>9, ,'/*1$$#(/:.#9%+#( 9%:9+9$"9$1=$"#8-*0.91+9+$09%$:"9( 900#9%#(9,9))%#,,-%,9$$"#0"1%+1-=$"#988',#($"#:>-'.("9<#8-*# 0%#09%#(>1$">#90-+,

+ *: 8-+,1(#%#( <1#> $"#%# 1, ,-*# ,'/,$9+8# 1+ $"# ,'/*1,,1-+*9(#/:.#9%+#( 9%:9+9 "#0%-,#8'$1-+>1$+#,,#, "9<# ,0-;#+ '+9*/1)'-',.: $"9$ $"#: "9( 8-*# $- 09%$18109$# 1+ $"# 09+8"9:9$9$$"#0"1%+1-=$"#%1<9.09%$1#,/'$'+=-%$'+9$#.:9+9.$#%89$1-+ /%-;#-'$>"18"%#,'.$#(1+$"#=1%# '%$"#%9))%#,,-%,>-'.((#=1+1$#.:

8-*#0%#09%#($-.9'+8"$"#*'%(#%-',9$$98;

"#%#1,+-*9$#%19.$-,"-> $"9$$"#0%-,#8'$1-+>1$+#,,#,>#%#9%*#(>1$"9+:>#90-+

#9%+#(,#+1-%8-'+,#.=-%$"#900#..9+$,>-'.(='%$"#%,'/*1$

%#=#%%1+)$-$"##<1(#+8#-=!49+($"#(#=#+8#0.#9,#$'0/:$"# 988',#(900#..9+$,$"9$,-*#/-(:#.,#>"-988-*09+1#($"#8-*0.91+9+$ 09%$:-0#+#(1+(1,8%1*1+9$#=1%1+)9+(9,9%#,'.$-=>"18"!!5 !4,',$91+#(1+&'%1#, #9.,-(%#>$"#9$$#+$1-+-=$"1, -'%$$-$"# #<1(#+8#-=!B>"-1+<#,$1)9$#($"#89,#9+($"#%#0-%$$-,'00-%$ "1,,'/*1,,1-+,

!B"9(+#<#%%#8-%(#(1+9+:-=$"#0%-8##(1+),8-+('8$#( /:"1*$"9$$"#%#>#%#/'..#$"-.#,-+$"#>#,$#%+,1(#-=$"#>9..-=$"# "-',#=%-*>"#%#$"#)'+,"-$=1%#>9,-0#+#(/:988',#(9%&1+(#%1+)"

$900#9%,$"9$$"#(#=#+8#"9((#<#.-0#(9,$-%:$"9$,-*#/-(:#.,#>"- 988-*09+1#($"#8-*0.91+9+$09%$:-0#+#(=1%#9=$#%!4>9,>-+-<#%$- ,0#9;1+$"#,9*#.1+#!B1,+-$,'00-,#($-,0#9;=%-*"1,*#*-%:

"#%-')",1$#0.9+(-#,+-$(1,8.-,#$"9$$"#%#>9,9+:/'..#$*9%;=-'+( -+$"#>#,$#%+>9..-=$"#"-',#-=988',#(9%&1+(#%1+)" "#%#=-%#$"# #<1(#+8#-=!B$"9$$"#%#>#%#/'..#$*9%;,-+$"#>#,$#%+>9..-=$"# "-',#988',#(9%&1+(#%1+)"1,=-'+(+-$/#.1#<9/.#

=9$9..$"#0#%,-+,>"-988-*09+1#($"#8-*0.91+9+$09%$: "9(-0#+#()'+,"-$=1%#9..-=9,'((#+$"#988',#(09%$:9.,->-'.("9<# ,'==#%#()'+,"-$1+&'%1#, "#0#%,-+,>"-988-*09+1#($"#8-*0.91+9+$ 09%$:>-'.(+-$"9<#-0#+#(=1%#91*1+)9$$"#1%->+0#%,-+,

$>9,='%$"#%,'/*1$$#($"9$8-..9%-=9/%9,1-+(9%;1+8-.-'% +-$18#(-+$"#.#=$,1(#8"#,$9+(9/(-*#+-+$"#0#%,-+-=!4-"9+ 1+)">-'.()-$-,"->$"9$$"#)'+,"-$>9,=1%#(9$98.-,#%9+)#

!4"9($'%+#("-,$1.#>1$"-'$(1,8.-,1+)$"#%9+)#9$>"18"

"# %#8#1<#( $"# 0#..#$ 1+&'%1#, '%$"#% ! >"- *#(18-.#)9..:

#A9*1+#(988',#(-"9+1+)""9,89$#)-%189..:(#0-,#(('%1+)$"#8-'%,# -=8%-,,#A9*1+9$1-+$"9$"#(1(+-$+-$18#9+:/.98;#+1+)9%-'+($"# >-'+( "# )'+ ,"-$ 1+&'%1#, >#%# 89',#( $- -"9+ 1+)" =%-* 9 8-+,1(#%9/.:.-+)(1,$9+8# +<1#>-=$"#9/-<#=1+($"9$$"#%#1,+- *#%1$1+$"#,'/*1,,1-+,*9(#/:.#9%+#(,#+1-%8-'+,#.900#9%1+)=-%$"# 900#..9+$,$"9$!4"9(%#8#1<#(8.-,#%9+)#1+&'%: 4

9,$.: 1$ >9, ,'/*1$$#( /: .#9%+#( ,#+1-% 8-'+,#. =-% $"# 900#..9+$,$"9$988',#( 9%&1+(#%1+)" "9(9..#)#(.:89',#()'+ ,"-$ 1+&'%1#, $- ! 9+( !5 !4 >"- 9..#)#(.:%#8#1<#( )%1#<-', 1+&'%1#,-+$"#<1$9.09%$,-=$"#/-(:8"-,#+-$$-,'00-%$$"#89,#-=$"# 0%-,#8'$1-+ "#%#=-%#$"#,#+$#+8#*9:/#%#('8#($-$"#0#%1-(9.%#9(: '+(#%)-+#/:"1*

!9+(!5"9<#%#8#1<#(-+.:,1*0.#0#..#$1+&'%1#, $ >9,-+.:!4>"-%#8#1<#()%1#<-',1+&'%1#,-+"1,8"#,$9+(,$-*98"

'$"#<1%$'9..:,'00-%$#($"#988',#(/:$'%+1+)"-,$1.#$-$"#89,#-=$"# 0%-,#8'$1-+ "#-88'%%#+8#"9($9;#+0.98#9/-'$:#9%,9)- 88',#( 9%&1+(#%1+)"1,+-+#-$"#%$"9+$"#,-+-=$"#/%-$"#%-=!59+( !9+($"#8-',1+/%-$"#%-=! 9+((1,0'$#1+$"#<#%:,9*# =9*1.:>9,$"#)#+#,1,-=$"#8%1*# -%9..$"#,#%#9,-+,"9<#0%-0-,#( $-%#('8#$"#,'/,$9+$1<#,#+$#+8#1*0-,#(-+988',#(9%&1+(#%1+)" =%-*6:#9%,

$-5:#9%,

=-%$"#-==#+8#'+(#%#8$1-+5

+$"#9/-<#=98$,9+(81%8'*,$9+8#,988',#(-"9+1+)"1,

98?'1$$#( -= $"# 8"9%)# '+(#% #8$1-+ 5 %#9( >1$" #8$1-+ 56

-+,#?'#+$.:$"#8-+<18$1-+9+(,#+$#+8#09,,#(/:$"#$%19. -'%$9)91+,$ 988',#(-"9+1+)",$9+(,,#$9,1(# "#900#9.?'9988',#(-"9+1+)"

1,9..->#( 1+8#900#..9+$-"9+1+)"1,-+/91."1,/91./-+(,$9+(, (1,8"9%)#(

"#8-+<18$1-+%#8-%(#( /:$"#$%19. -'%$ 9)91+,$988',#( 9%&1+(#% 1+)" '+(#% #8$1-+ 5 1, 8-+=1%*#( "# ,'/,$9+$1<# ,#+$#+8#1*0-,#(-+"1*1,%#('8#($-5:#9%,

->#<#%$"#=1+# 9>9%(#(9+($"#(#=9'.$,#+$#+8#1*0-,#(-+988',#(9%&1+(#%1+)"=-% $"#,91(-==#+8#,$9+(8-+=1%*#( 5

"#988',#(900#..9+$9%&1+(#%1+)" 1,-+/91. 1,/91.

/-+(,$9+(,89+8#..#( #,"9..,'%%#+(#%>1$"1+ (9:,=%-*$"#(9$#-= $"1,&'()#*#+$/#=-%#$"# "1#='(1819.39)1,$%9$#9$#"9/9(>"-,"9.. ,#+("1*$-&91.$-'+(#%)-$"#%#*91+1+)09%$-=$"#,#+$#+8# ="#=91.,$- ,'%%#+(#% $"# .#9%+#( "1#= '(1819. 39)1,$%9$# 9$#"9/9( ,"9.. $9;# 8-#%81<#,$#0,$-,#8'%#"1,0%#,#+8#

!1$"$"#9/-<#*-(1=189$1-+1+$"#*9$$#%-=,#+$#+8#$"# 900#9.?'99%&1+(#%1+)",$9+(,(1,*1,,#(

!4"9(8"-,#+$-,'00-%$$"#988',#("9<1+)$'%+#("-,$1.# $-$"#89,#-=$"#0%-,#8'$1-+ 88',#(9%&1+(#%1+)""9(89',#(-+.:

,1*0.#1+&'%1#,$-!9+(!5-++-+<1$9.09%$, "#988',#(09%$:9, >#.. 9, $"# 8-*0.91+9+$ 09%$: 9%# 8.-,#.: %#.9$#( $- #98" -$"#% "# -88'%%#+8#"9($9;#+0.98#9/-'$:#9%,9)- +$"#9/-<#=98$,9+(

81%8'*,$9+8#,9*-=$"#8-+,1(#%#(<1#>$"9$$"#0.#9=-%#+"9+8#*#+$-= ,#+$#+8#1,=-'+($-/#$-$9..:'+&',$1=19/.# '%$"#%1+9,*'8"9,!4"9( 8"-,#+$-,91.>1$"$"#988',#(9+(!9+(!5"9<#,',$91+#(-+.: ,1*0.#1+&'%1#,$"#?'#,$1-+-=9>9%(1+)8-*0#+,9$1-+9,,-')"$=-%1+$"# %#<1,1-+(-#,+-$9%1,# "#%#=-%#$"#%#<1,1-+=91.,9+(1$,$9+(,(1,*1,,#(

'.:

! $

'.9$1