High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/24995/2015allowed

Balbir Singh v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2015-11-27Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain3 pages

"#$%$ &' (")*"+ ,-

.*$+ /$&01 22222222"!$!$ &"+ 3"+%4% /! !"

4&5 * &6 !1"+% 222222"%7 &6"&!% '

8 9 /2 / /

+"%"&!

+"%"&!'

+2 & 5 /1 +) - 6( # !"

+2 / &5""( /1 +) - 6( # !"

+ !1" 7"!$!$ &"+2 +2 2/2 /":1 &-

4&5 *2 ;;;;;

;;;;;

- 2 /

- 2 "!$!$ &"+ 1 % $."6 !1$% 7"!$!$ & 4&6"+ /"#!$ & <

!1" 6"

+$)$& . + #"64+"- ,=

+ >4 %1$&0

6 !"6 2

=- 4&6"+ /"#!$ &% ==- <?- ?- =

!1" &6$ & "& . 6"- <?

+ %1 +!- +"0$%!"+"6 !

.$#" /! !$ & / 6 + )+$!% +- $%!+$#!

)+$!% + $!@ &6 ..

&%">4"&!$ . 7+ #""6$&0% +$%$&0 !1"+"

)- & !1" * %$%

)$%"2 9" +&"6 # 4&%".

+ !1" 7"!$!$ &"+ 1 % %4*)$!!"6 !1 ! 7 +!$"% 1 (" )$# *.@ %"!!."6 !1"$+ 6$%74!"2 3$6"

+6"+ 6 !"6 =2 <2

- .. > 0$%!+ !"A!+$ .

4+! B % 6$+"#!"6 !

+"# +6 !1" %! !")"&!%

!1" 7 +!$"% &6 %"&6 $!% +"7 +! B$!1 +"0 +6 !

0"&4$&"&"%%

!1" # )$%"

"#!"6 *"!B""& !1" 7 +!$"%2 & 74+%4 &#" !

!1" % $6 +6"+- !1" 0$%!+ !"

!"+ +"# +6$&0 !1" %! !")"&!%

!1" 7 +!$"% 1 % +"7 +!"6 !1 ! !1"

)$%" "

"#!"6 *"!B""& !1" 7 +!$"% B % 0"&4$&"-

( .4&! +$.@ &6 4!

+"" B$..

!1" 7 +!$"%2

% 7"+ !1" 4..

"&#1 5460)"&!

!1$% 4+! $& C4.B$&6"+ /$&01 &6 !1"+% (%2 /! !"

4&5 *-

, = C4.B$&6"+ /$&01 &6 !1"+% (%2 /! !"

4&5 *-

, = C4.B$&6"+ /$&01 &6 !1"+% (%2 /! !"

4&5 *-

, = C4.B$&6"+ /$&01 &6 !1"+% (%2 /! !"

4&5 *-

, = +$)$& .

- +$)$& .

- $01 4+! 1 % 7 B"+ 4&6"+ /"#!$ & < +222 !

B !1" # )7 4&6$&0

& &# )7 4&6 *."

"&#"

&6 >4 %1 !1" 7+ %"#4!$ & B1"+" !1" $01 4+!

".! !1 ! !1"

% )" B % +">4$+"6 !

7+"("&! !1" *4%"

!1" 7+ #"%%

&@ 4+!

+ !

!1"+B$%" %"#4+" !1" "&6%

54%!$#"2 1$% 7 B"+

>4 %1$&0 $% & ! # & $&"6 !

) !+$) &$ . 6$%74!"% .

&"2 &8*." !1"

7"D 4+! $& !1" # %"

$ & /$&01 (%2 $ & /$&01 (%2 $ & /$&01 (%2 $ & /$&01 (%2 /! !"

4&5 * &6 & !1"+ /! !"

4&5 * &6 & !1"+

+.2 =

+.2 =- 1 % 1".6 % 4&6"+' E,2 1" 7 %$!$ & !1 ! ")"+0"% ) !1" * ("

6$%#4%%$ & # & *" %4)) +$%"6 !14%' !1" 7 B"+

!1"

$01 4+! $& >4 %1$&0 #+$)$& . 7+ #""6$&0 +

+ # )7. $&! $& "D"+#$%"

$!% $&1"+"&! 54+$%6$#!$ & $% 6$%!$&#! &6 6$

"+"&!

) !1" 7 B"+ 0$("& !

#+$)$& . # 4+!

+ # )7 4&6$&0 !1"

"&#"% 4&6"+ /"#!$ & =

!1" 6"2 &1"+"&! 7 B"+ $%

B$6"

7."&$!46" B$!1 & %! !4!

+@ .$)$! !$ & *4! $! 1 % !

"D"+#$%"6 $& ## +6 B$!1 !1" 04$6".$&" "&0+ !"6 $& %4#1 7 B"+ ($FG $ !

%"#4+" !1" "&6%

54%!$#"

+ $$ !

7+"("&! *4%"

!1" 7+ #"%%

&@ 4+!2 & B1 !

# %"% 7 B"+ !

>4 %1 !1" #+$)$& . 7+ #""6$&0 )7. $&!

+ 22 ) @ *" "D"+#$%"6 B1"+" !1"

"&6"+ &6 ($#!$) 1 (" %"!!."6 !1"$+ 6$%74!" B 4.6 6"7"&6 & !1"

#!% &6 #$+#4)%! &#"%

" #1 # %"

&6 & # !"0 +@ # & *" 7+"%#+$*"62 B"("+- *"

"D"+#$%"

%4#1 7 B"+- !1" $01 4+! )4%! 1 ("

64" +"0 +6 !

!1" & !4+" &6 0+ ($!@

!1" #+$)"2 "$& 4% &6 %"+$ 4%

"&#"%

)"&! . 6"7+ ($!@

"&#"% .$:" )4+6"+- + 7"- 6 # $!@- "!#2 # && ! *"

$!!$&0.@ >4 %1"6 "("& !1 401 !1" ($#!$) + ($#!$)H%

)$.@ &6 !1"

"&6"+ 1 (" %"!!."6 !1" 6$%74!"2 /4#1

"&#"% +" & ! 7+$( !" $& & !4+" &6 1 ("

%"+$ 4% $)7 #!

& % #$"!@2 /$)$. +.@- &@ # )$%"

*"!B""& !1" ($#!$) &6

"&6"+ $& +". !$ & !

!1"

"&#"% 4&6"+ %7"#$ . %! !4!"% .$:" +"("&!$ &

++47!$ & #!

+ !1"

"&#"% # ))$!!"6 *@ 74*.$# %"+( &!% B1$." B +:$&0 $& !1 ! # 7 #$!@ "!#G # && !

7+ ($6"

+ &@ * %$%

+ >4 %1$&0 #+$)$& .

7+ #""6$&0% $&( .($&0 %4#1

"&#"%2 4! !1" #+$)$& .

# %"% 1 ($&0 ("+B1".)$&0.@ &6 7+"6 )$& !$&0.@

= #$($.

. ( 4+ %! &6 & 6$

"+"&!

!$&0

+ !1"

74+7 %"%

>4 %1$&0- 7 +!$#4. +.@ !1"

"&#"% +$%$&0 ) # ))"+#$ .- $& &#$ .- )"+# &!$."- #$($.- 7 +!&"+%1$7 + %4#1 .$:" !+ &% #!$ &% + !1"

"&#"% +$%$&0 4!

) !+$) &@ +". !$&0 !

B+@- "!#2 !1"

)$.@ 6$%74!"% B1"+" !1" B+ &0 $% * %$# ..@ 7+$( !"

+ 7"+% & . $& & !4+" &6 !1" 7 +!$"% 1 ("

+"% .("6 !1"$+ "&!$+" 6$%74!"2 & !1$% # !"0 +@

# %"%- $01 4+! ) @ >4 %1 #+$)$& . 7+ #""6$&0% $

$& $!% ($"B- *"# 4%"

!1" # )$%" *"!B""& !1"

"&6"+ &6 ($#!$)- !1" 7 %%$*$.$!@

&($#!$ & $% +") !" &6 *." : &6 # &!$&4 !$ &

#+$)$& . # %"

4.6 74! ##4%"6 !

0+" !

77+"%%$ & &6 7+"546$#"

&6 "D!+")" $&54%!$#" B 4.6 *" # 4%"6 !

1$) *@ & !

>4 %1$&0 !1" #+$)$& . # %" 6"%7$!"

4.. &6 # )7."!"

%"!!.")"&! &6 # )$%" B$!1 !1" ($#!$)2 & !1"+ +6%- !1" $01 4+! )4%! # &%$6"+ B1"!1"+ $!

4.6 *" 4& $+ + # &!+ +@ !

!1" $&!"+"%!

54%!$#"

&!$&4" B$!1 !1" #+$)$& . 7+ #""6$&0 &!$&4 !$ &

!1" #+$)$& . 7+ #""6$&0 B 4.6 ! &! ) 4&! !

*4%"

7+ #"%%

. B 6"%7$!"

%"!!.")"&! &6 # )$%" *"!B""& !1" ($#!$) &6 B+ &06 "+ &6 B1"!1"+ !

%"#4+" !1" "&6%

54%!$#"- $! $% 77+ 7+$ !" !1 ! #+$)$& . # %" $% 74! !

& "&6 &6 $ !1" &%B"+ !

!1" * (" >4"%!$ &% $% $&

$+) !$("- !1" $01 4+! %1 .. *" B".. B$!1$& $!% 54+$%6$#!$ & !

>4 %1 !1" #+$)$& . 7+ #""6$&02I /$&#" !1" 7 +!$"% 1 (" ++$("6 ! # )$%" &6 1 (" 6"#$6"6 !

.$(" $& 7" #"- & 4%"

4. 74+7 %" B 4.6 *"

%"+("6 $& ..

B$&0 !1" #+$)$& . 7+ #""6$&0% !

&!$&4"2

## +6$&0.@- !1$% 7"!$!$ & $% ..

B"62 6 !"6 2

=- 4&6"+ /"#!$ &% ==- <?- ?- = - +"0$%!"+"6 ! .$#" /! !$ & / 6 + )+$!% +- $%!+$#!

)+$!% + $!@ &6 .. !1" # &%">4"&!$ . 7+ #""6$&0%- +$%$&0 !1"+"

)- +" >4 %1"62 /

(")*"+ ,-

) 1 ($+