Naveen Kumar And Others v. Central Administrative Tribunal And Others



 






 



  




!

"#$#%&
'

('


 


  '''  )  
 
   



 
'  

*& +,
*'
) 
) 

*)  +,
*'
) 
)-
-*
.*  

  ! "# $%&'( $ )' * ' "  $ '"+$ )'*'%
', %- ...

 

 

    

 ++  / ' '%% %,001,023 45"627* %89  +$

( $/ 89('#** '*)%89 * ' ++ '6 ('#*+

(') '%% %020:,02;45"6;7* % 
'<-3 ,02-% *' ') 

/  (

% '$/ % )"("'"/  + 89' *

+') 9 #%9

8+"%+ /="

 '%% %2>0>,02>  '% %  2<,30:,02-  '+%          * ' 

8+  )' "+ & ( %'%% %2302,0,045"6,7

%     (  **+ ' 
'  302<<<,021     
'  30::,02>   

')' ))('  # &89  *'%%"  ('#**'(% ',001,023$ % %

  (' '') + %('"+)' * '  * ' &) +% 
'<-3'),02-8)'  %# +$  

  (  )'  "+ '  ')    & (       ('# 

5  * #  /    9  /  /'

(' "'"+9    ( "

+%

+9  /   /'   )'     *   # 9  9  "( '% %010>,02-2-0>,02-/ "%89  +'

% ') 

( 

5$ 
/  + 6*'% 
'  ;  %   ++      ) '##  '')('#

5

('! +')('#

5''

#*+'9( "

+%

+9/ /' )'"+ /'  )" * 9/ # %)'"+ & (



8+& *' 

% 

+  **+ '  /   ++'/%  89     +  89  

%="

     8'&6# '%  #*"%  "( '  % % 010>,02-2-0>,02-* %89  +'

%')

(

5 '%%   #' '') *'(')(' '') (+

#') & ()'# % ') '%

020:,02;45"6;7 '

@  *'%)

+%'('#*+9/    8'&'% %020:,02;$'#* '
'::'),02>/  "%89  ' 
' (  /   "%  '     *'%  '  230;,02> *+9('#*+

(*'/ "8# %89 *'%'2<0>,02>      (+

$' (' '$  )'"%  '  8  '6 ((* 8+     9  / 

8+  )'

 "+ ' *

'%% %2>0>,02>45"637/ % '*+ (%'('% %% +%'("#'"**'  (+

#)'"+ '& % (**+ '
'<0<'),02>/  

)" *+    (+

# /'+98A(%  #  ) ++9( #"*)'  8)'  +' ,001,02345"627/  ('#** % %

)"("'"  +  ') '%% %2>0>,02>  '%% % 2<,30:,02-$/ 89 (+

'$'(' '$/ A(%    8  )'"%  '  8 

8+  )'  "+ '  ')    & ( 89/ +' &' *

+')  #%9 ="

  #*"%'% '

 '  +'  *'

%  '"        *'% ++% '%* %89  %020:,02;45"6 ;7* % 
'<,<'),02-89) @
'22:,'),023 

%  /   * '  /   /  % /  89   *'% & % '%  % % ,>01,02:45"62>7

+ 89') + & /* '8)'   + '"*# % /  % +') / '89 '8&   /'"+%8'*' *'%'

('"'  #%  # 98

8+' # (('% (/  + / ('

 %  * '/

%)' *'%'

) + & / '8)'  +8"/ '"( */

$* ') +%
'2<<<'),021* )' % ' ' *'%'('#*+9/    # &89 ('"+)'  *'%%"  ('#**'(% ',001,02345"6 27'6(' % (+

& (    '  %        *'%  %  & "

++9



((*% ) (  9 &* % '%% %2>0>,02>/'+9 8"  +$/ +*   '%% %,001,02345"627$ %'

  '(' ' 

% %89   +& %'%% %2302,0,045" 6,789'8&    '*)%89 * '/

# "')*'(')+ / %/  ')*( '" #') '"'')
,0$0006)' 8"  *'(')+ / %# +  '"/ +'

#*'% '%* %89  %,001,02345" 627 %2302,0,045"6,7 &8 

+%89 * ' /'

  (' '') + %('"+)' * ' & %'%% %020:,02;45"6;7$''+9  + *'(%%' %="

   #*"%'%% %012-0>,02- ,,0>,02-8" +'*'(%%'% ( *'%' #'  *'()'"+ '') & (') * ' (+

#') '8 ('&%89  "( '')  *'%    /++       & '"  A"%#  * %  89     'B8+ "*#  '"  %  '   '"  ('"+%  '  &  8  A(%   $  )'$  /  '%% %020:,02;45"6;7 '  8  ('#*+ %  /   89     *'%$  '%  % %  ,001,023 45"  627  * %  89      +  %# +      ('#*  * '  *)%  89     * '  %        # 

)"("'"( '"

    + '"+% &*'(%%'( ++ "*'     *'%  )'  '6('#*+

(  ')     '%  * %  89   

+   8) ') "+ '') & (')  '          '+9   )'# +  '%  /   * %  89    *'%8"  + %# +$/ +*    

'%  % %  ,001,023  45"  627$  %  *'(%%  '   /'

"#* '  / '+9 % ')'(' '') (+

#') ' % *'% %$ )'$*'(%%'(' %  (+

%)'"% #

8+ %'%% %2>0>,02>  '%% %2<,30:,02- $ "$ ('%  '%8  & '+ '') '%* %89 

%020:,02;45"6;7( '"

  % '%% %2302,0,045"6,7* % 89    + %# + A(     (**+ *)%89 * '$('"+)' * '    ' %) +% 

 +  ') ) (  '% %,001,02345"627/ ' ('' (/   % '

"%  89     +      

+  **+ '  *)%  89    ' 9 %'+9'"  #*+# '')  #/ &89 ('"+)' *'%%"  *%(9')  ('#**'(%  $ "$('%   #*"%'%( ' "

%%&'8 % 0'

('  "8#  '# %89 + %('"+ )' * '$/%'') 9'"%' )/    #*"% '% '

*" +') '%% %020:,02;45"6;7* % 89  + 
'<,<6 6,02-$/ *)%89 * '$/'"+%#

  **  ''%)' "+ '') & (') * '/ * % 

%*'(%%' "% '' *'%'

 *'( )'(' '') (+

& (  +  ') * ( *++%89  'B8+"*#'"

% ' '"

    **   )'#     

%  '%$     *'(  )' (' '8

%$/ ( $ %# %+9$ *'%%

 
'%'"8 *'% &( ++% 

%'%% % 020:,02;89) @
'22:,'),0238"#( ++ ') 

%'%/'"+%'$ 9# $% '%$/ (  &8 %89  +$ '* &"+ 9% ) ("#  / /  % /& %'%% %,>01,02:45"62>7 '

% *" %$ )'$ ( ++' 

%'%'' / %' '#

#"( ') % ))(

 9( $ *( &') ) (  / 8*)%89 *'%$  +$ +(' '#* '
'::'),02>/ ( / *)%89 '$*'(%%'%( %  #& %'%% %,001,023 45"627  + %  +9

 '(' ' '% %020:,02;45"6;7* % 
'<,< ,02-'('# ' ('(+" '  % ' "%89  + %8%"+9 ('#*+ %/  89('  (+

')  & ($/  ")'" +9$ 9/)'"%'8

8+ %'%% %2>0>2,02>  '%% %2<,30:,02-$/ *+ (%'('%/  *+9('#*+

(*'% %2<0>,02> 

+   +9 +%  ('#** 8%%

)"("'" % %+ 89' *

+') 9#%9

8+  "%  + /  ="

    '%  / (  %  8  * %  89    *'%

 +  ') 

%'% 8* %',001,023 45"627$ / ''(( '' * ') * &

%)'#'  9 8)')   (**+ '
' 302<<<,021 % ''$' *+  %"  *%(9')  ('#** '$  #/ &89 ('"+)' *'% )'

('  (+

'%*   8 '%% % 2>0>,02> %2<,30:,02-* %89  *'% 

$ )'$  +98% %89     +  %# +$  

  (  '  2302,0,0 45"6,78 # "')*'(')+ / %)'/  ')  *( '" #') '"

'

& /')  8'&$/%'') 9'"%' )   '% #*"%'% * %89  &

%,001,02345"627 %2302,0,045"6,7

%$ )'$%  */ ' 1) 

*) 2 




1)-
-*
.*2  3
4

*A 5

6
$7

8#%9:6

$% !&  $: 5

6
 76

;<

 $: