Mangtu v. The State Of Haryana
!" =.+,+,") =.+,+,") =.+,+,") =.+,+,")
!+"
!+"
!+"
!+"
) 9 **" +"4 !"
9 **" +"4 !"
9 **" +"4 !"
9 **" +"4 !"
" ..*%
" ..*%
" ..*%
" ..*%
B
> # # # # $ $ $ $ 66"11!*+ 66"11!*+ 66"11!*+ 66"11!*+ "6*4"*+ "6*4"*+ "6*4"*+ "6*4"*+ % % % % )""*+% )
) & '$($ & '$($ & '$($ & '$($ ""6!C):")/4: !+" +,"!66"11!*+ -,.*!,!.*/ /!)0!* *! DDDD /)!1 /)!1 /)!1 /)!1 ($ ($ ($ ($ 2 3 #.4 4"+,. 55*)4")/+,"6)""
"*+!66"!1-"!).*7
/
/ / / / 8/ 9/
!*4
!)"-".*74" .4"4! !11 +,""!66"!1,!
!:"!)."*;+ 55*! <;
;..+.*!*4.*:1:".4"*+. !1 !
! + !*4 <;"+.* 1!= ) +," !C" -)":.+0 / ! + !)" -".*7 +!C"* )5
3
0 =!0 6)""*+!66"!1/ ,!11"*7 7",!-""*1!.4++,"=!)44!
!+"4
>
6! "4-0+,"1"!)*"4441 .+). + ;47"/!).4!-!4,")".*!
+")+ -" "
")"* ";)+@ )"
"))"4!+,"? 2 3 ) ."
10 +!+.*7/ .* +," 6)""*+ !
!"/ 1!*4 5"!;).*7 B 9 !
)" .+;!+"4 =.+,.* +," )":"*;" "+!+" :.11!7" !*4C1!/ !4-!+ 8/ ", ,.1 !+,.*/ .+).
+ !).4!-!4/ !5" + -" !
<;.)"4 :.4" +.
. !+.* 4!
!+"4
A
A!*4
A
>.;"4;*4")$" +. *B> +,"'!*4 <;..+ +.* +/ 9 B ) ,)++,"? 9 B +@/)"6" +.:
:"10 )+,"6;-1. 6;)6"*!5 5"10
) *+); +.* * !-!1;.*)G=!)4;*4 4")$" +.* B += =! 6!"4 -0 +," '
'!*4 <;..+.* 11" +) ) ) ,)+ ?+," '@ * 8 >
>/ =,")"-05!)C"+ +:!1;" +,"! <;.)"41!*4=!
!!""4JAB/B89FH6")!
! )"
) ,!,.1!*4/ A /
FH6")! )" )!)5+ 1!*4!*4 /9A/
FH6")! )"
!.) ;5C.* 1!
!*4 !1*7 =.+, !11+,") +!+;+ )0 -"*"
.+ !*4 .*+")"+6):.4 4"4 ;*4")+," 9 B + 2B3
. !+. ."4 =.+, =!)4 6!"4 -0 '/ 4=*") .*:C"4 "
")"* " ;
;*4") $" +.* 9 +," 9 B +/ =,. , =")" 4. 5."4 -0 +," 1"!)*"4 "
")"* * " ;)+ :.4" .+ 4" ..* 4!
!+"4
>
77 7).":"4+,")" /+,"6)""*+!66 6"!1=")"6)"
"))"4!++,".*+!
* " !*4=*") !66"11!*+F1 2A3 56 6;7*.*7 !
)"!.4 =!
!)4/ 1"!)*"4 ;*"1
4=*") ;-5.+ +,!+ +," 1"!) )*"4 "
")"* " ;)+ ="*+ =) *7 ,!:.*74. !)4"
4+,"!1"4""44!+"4 9
9>IH :.4"=,. , 5!)1!
! 1!*4 =! 14
) A/
FH =.+, +," -!" 6). " B
FH 6") !
)" '"!)*"4 ;*"1 1 ;)+,");-5.++,!+* "+," !1".*+!* "6")+!.*.*7++,"!
!5" :")0 )":"*;" "
+!+" :.11!7" !*4C1! =! !:!.1!-1"/ +," 1"!)*"4 "
")"
* " ;)+;7,++, ,!:"+!C"*.*+ *.4")!+.*+,"
"!5" )+,"6;)6" !" .*7 +,"5!)C"+:!1;"
".*+," !".*,!*4 2A '"!
!)*"4 ;*"1!16.*+;++,!
!+ )+,"+.5"7!6-"+=""*+," !1" .*+!* "4!+"4 9
9>IH +.11+,"4!+"
" .;!* " *+.
. !+.*;* *4") $" +.* B +, ," 9 B + .* +," !" .* , ,!*4/ +," !66"11!*+F1!*4=*"
) =")""*+.+1"4 )!=!)4 ;.+!-1"!66)" .!+.* *"+,;/;-5.++,!++,"5!) )C"+ :!1;"=!)"<;.) )"4+-""*,!* "4.* !:;) + +,"!66"11!*+H1!*4=*")
2>3 * +,"+,"),!*4/1"!)*"4$+!+" ;*"1;-5.++,!++,")"=! * .11"7!1.+0)6"):
:").+0=.+,+,"4" ..*6!"4 -0+,"1"!)*"4"
")"* ";)+
,!:.*74. !)4"4 4+,"!1".*+!* "4!+"4 9
9>IH !+,"!5"6")+!.* *"4 +5")"10 !
!)1! 1!*4/=,")"!+,"! <;.)"4 41!*4=!5"!;).*7 B 9! )"
" 2> 3 '"!
!)*"4 $+!+" ;*"1
;)+,") ;-5.+ +,!+ 4=*") !.1"4+61! "*)"
)4!*0":.4"* "!+ !11
!*0C.*4 !66) )" .!+.*:")+,"1!*4:!1;"4;) ).*7+,".*+"):"*.*76").4-"+= +,")"1."4;6* !1".*+!* "!*4+,"4!+" * *+.
. !+.*;*4")$" +.*B B + .* +, ," !" .* ,!*4 " +,;/ *+"*4 +,!+ ! ="11H)"!*"4 !
!*4 K;+.
."4=!)4 =!6!"4-0+,"1"!)*"4"
") )"* ";)+!
+")4;" *.4")!+ +.* +," 61"!4.*7 7 !*4 +," ":.4"* " !:!.1!-1"
" * )" )4/ =,. , !11 * .*+") ")"* " )4.*710/ 6)!0") . 5!4" 4.5.!1 +," 6)""*+ !66"!
!1 6)"
"))"4!++,".
.*+!* " +,"!66"11!*+F1!*4 =*") 283 , ,!:" ,"!)4 1"!)*"4 ;*"1 +," 6!)+." !*4 7*" +,);7, 6!6")-C!= ="11!)" )4 +," !" .*4;-+!* ".*+,";-5..
* 5!4"*-",!1 +,"!66"11!*+F1!*4=*") 293 * +," 6)""*+ !"/ 1!*4 5"!;) ).*7 B 9 ! )" )5.*7 6!)+ )":"*;" "+!+" :.11!7" !*4C1!/ !4-!+ + 8/ ",.1 !+,.*/ .+ +). + !).4!-!4 =!
! ! <;.)"4 * )4") + ;66)+ +,".) 1!.5/ 4=*")6)4; "4!*46):"4 *)" )4+," ")+.
."4 60 !1" 4""4 4!+"4 9
9> IH !7!.*+ =,.
, 5!)1! 1!*4 =! 14
A/
FH =.+ +, +," -!" 6). " B
FH 6") ! )" ,;/ .* +")5 $" +.*A H
B +/+,"!.4!1"4""4 4IH =!)"<;.)"4+-"+!C C"* .*+ *.4")!+. *!!:!1.46." " ":.4"* "
3 45 5.++"410/+,"!1""I"561!)4!+"
"4 9
9>IH 6")+!.* + 5!11 6!) "1
1!*4 5"!;).*7 5!)1! !*4 56!)!+.:" 1 !+.* +," 1!
!*4
)5.*76!)+
+,"!.4!1""I"561!):.LH!H:
:.L+,"! <;.)"41!*4,!*+- "+!-1.,"4*)"
" )4=":")/+!C.*7.*+! ;*++," ! ++,!++,"6)""*+!66 6"!1 . !7!.*+ 4"+"
)5.*!+.*F)"H!"5"*+ 5!
!)C"+ :!1;" +," ! <;.)"4 1!
!*4
)5.*76!)+
!)":"*;""+!+"!*4*+ !* *0+=*) .+0/+,"!1""I"56 61!) 4!+"4 9
9> IH *""4 + -" +!C"* .*+ ! ;*+ -0 !6610.*7 ;.+!
!-1" 4"4; +.**+,"
"-!"6). "6")! )"4").:"4 )5 5.+ ).7,+106.*+"4;+-01"!)*"4$ $+!+" ;*"1/*":.4"* ",!- 1"4-0+,"!66"1 11!*+F1!*4=*")+"+!-1., ,!*0C.*4 !66)" .!+.*+=!
!)4 5!)C"+ :!1;" +," ! <;.)"4 1!*4 )5.*7 6!)+ )":"*;" "+!+" :.11 !7" !*4C1! )+, ,"+.5"7!6-"+=""*+,"!1""I I"561!)4!+"4 9
9>I H ;6++,"4!+"
*+.
. !+.*;*4")$" +.*B + +," 9 B +.*+," !".*,!
!*4/ ! ; , * !66)" .!+.* *""4 + -"
" 7)!*+"4 .*
!:;) 4=*") =":")/ *.4").* *7 +," ! + +,!+ +," !1" "I"56 61!) 6")+!.*+!5 5!116!) "1 1!*45"!;).*7 5!)1!!*4 56!)!+.:"1 !+.* * +,"1!*4+,")".* :.LH!H:.L+,"! <;.)"41!*4,! *+-""*"+!-1.,"4*)" )4 4/! ;.+!-1" 4"4; + +.* J 9 M *""4 + -" !
!661."4 :") +," -!" 6). "
B
FH6 6")! )"4").:"4 )5+,"!.4 !1""I"561!)!*4+,"5!)C"+:!
!1;" +,"! <;.)"41 1!*4+,;/ 5"+9/
FH6")! )" 2 3 * +," 7.:"* ! + .* " +," ! <;.
..+.* .* +," !" .* ,!*4 = =! !))."4;+ )+ +,"6;-1. 6;)6"*!5"10E ) *+); +.* !-!1;.*)G G! ; ,/+,")"6* *4"*+*".+,");
")"4!*01 +=!)46+.5;5;+.1.L!+.* !)"! ! <;.)"4 *) 4.4 .* ;) "I6"*4.+;)" + +=!)4 6):.4.*7 !44.+. *!1
.* )!+); +;)!1 !
!5"*.+."/ +,; * ;+ +=!)4 4":"165"*+ + *""4 + -" .56"4 )4.*710/ +," 5!)C"+ :!1;"
) +," 1!*4 ;*4") ! <;..+.* * . !""4J 9/
FH6")! )"!*+," 4!+" *+.
. !+.*;*4")$" +. *B B + +*!44.+.*/+,"1!*4=*"), ,!11!1-""*+.+1"4 )!=!)4
!11 +!+;+)0 -"*"
.
+ !*4 .*+")"+!6):.4"4 ;*4 4")+," 6):..* +," 9 B + !5"*4"4;6+ 4!+","1!*4=*"),!11!1 -""*+.+1"4 )1!+.;5J
M -".4"!=!)4
.*+")"++,")";6* 2 3 * *"<;"*+10/ .* :."= +," 4. ;.*5!4" ,")".* !-:"/!11 !66"!1 6)"
"))"
"4 !+ +," .*+!* " !66"11!*+ H1!*4=*") !)" ,")"-0 6!) )+10 !11="4.*+,"!
)"!.4+")5 2 B3 N, ,")":") +," 1!*4=*") ,!F, ,!:" ;* )+;*!+"10 "I6.)"4 .* !66"!1F )H -K" +.*!
+") .1.*7+,")" !*4+,"1"7!1,".),!:"*+- .561"!4"4/ +,"0 0 ,!11 -" !+ 1.-")+0 + ""C "I"
" ;+.* +," 6)""*+ 4" ..* -0 5:.*7!66)6) ).!+"!661. !+.*-"
)"+,"1"!
!)*"4I" ;+.*7;)+ 2 A3 11 6"*4.*7!661. !+.*/.
!*0/ ,!11!1+!*44.6"4 2 >3 6 6,+ 60 +,.)4")-"61!
"4*+," .1" +,") **"
+"4 !" ($ ($ ($ ($ 6).1
////
>
>
>
> +.C N, N, ,"+,")6"!C.*7F)"!*"4
" ,"+,"))"6)+!-1"
" F F