High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/25192/2017allowed

Avtar Singh @ Titan v. State Of Punjab

2018-12-14Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan6 pages

*$%$%+#*, -*,..

$"$*+/#)"0 *.1+#2*#$ 3333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333 45

6$", %#&'(%$"# *$%$%+#*, -*,..

$"$*+/#)"0 *.1+#2*#$ 3333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333 4 4

"7%, %#&'

*$%$%+#*, -*,..

$"$*+/#)"0 *.1+#2*#$ 3333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333 8

",)%#2*, %#&'

*$%$%+#*, -*,..

$"$*+/#)"0 *.1+#2*#$ "$*+/2*9%.%+#: 8 : ;<

! "# $%& "'( %& ) ) )

* +%,)-,"'( %& ) ) ) . %%& "'( " * "%,#-,)"'( %& ) ) ) /)&0%)*) "'( -) % +&%#% "'( %& ) ) )

*)12 *%#+"0 #34 5 * *1%"'( -) %( 66666666 => ,

7%)(22 %,,)&4' -& ) ) %8 )# %29: 7%& ) )%'4),# *( )

% )2),

(# $ $#, 4), 4' 2 ) & ) ) )(9:

# *( )

*( ) /:

, $) ,)(* )/ ,) 8+) )( / ,

-%),$ )$) )24), %& ) ) %,,-)$ -&!

?.1*," *&"$%+#.%#$'* &+$,*9+,2*2+#$'*.$"$*7*#$+/ +#*,7@' %#&''"'"#>%$%..$"$*2$'"$+# "$ ",+#2

"7>'%.,* "$%6* +7" !".&+%#&+# '%.-*.1".9++$*,$+7**$+#*"&2%.' ")""#2'* !"./+ +!%#&'%7+#'%.7+$+,9A9 *='*# +7"

$,#*2$+!",2."$$% +"2>",#" ">"9",!".1",@*2$'*,*> '+!*6*,>'*9+ 2#+$.**$'*#70*,+/$'"$9","#2%#+#* *71+> ",)%#2*, %#&' ( %#$"> 1*$%$%+#*, %# 8 +/ 9",,A%#& " ,%// * " +#& !%$' "7%, %#&'> 1*$%$%+#*,%# 4 4+/ > ") %#&'>,0"9'"#

%#&'(% "#2",9'","# %#&'"&&%>&+$2+!#/,+7$'* ",$% !%/$9","#2+A+$"$%+.9", !".9",,A%#&"9,%9@*$0"$>" !"#$ " "!".'"6%#& " .'",1 *2&*2 +0)*9$ "#2 6$", %#&' ( %$"# '"6%#& "

!++2*#.$%9@>,2*6 %#&'"'",%"'"6%#&".1"2*"#2%$$

%#&'" .+'"6%#&".1"2*>B#%2*#$%/%*21*,.+#.9",,A%#& .'",1*2&*2!*"1+#&+$+#$'*%,6*'%9 *."#2.,,+#2*2 "7

%#&' +7" "#2 .$",$*2 0*"$%#& '%7 '*,*"/$*,> $'*.* 1*,.+#.@%2#"11*2 +7" "#2$++@'%7%#$'* '+.* +/ +0%#2 ,+," "#2 @*1$ 0*"$%#& '%7 ='*# $'* 9+71 "%#"#$,"%.*2$'*6+%9*>$'*#*%&'0+,.9"7*$'*,*"#2 +#.**%#&$'*7>"99.*21*,.+#.$',*!$'*%,!*"1+#."#2 */$

+7" $'*,* +7" !".$"@*#$+%6% +.1%$" > ",#" " !'*,* 2+9$+, ,*/*,,*2 '%7 $+ > <2'%"#"'*7+$%6*0*'%#2$'*+99,,*#9*!".$'"$ "7

+7" %.,*.%2*#$+/ ")1$ "0'""#2'*'".,*7+6*2 ,0"9'"# %#&' ( % > !"#$ %#&' ( ")% "#2 ",)%#2*, %#&'(%#$"/,+7$'*."%2 "0'"# 8 ><*",#*2 *#%+,9+#.* "11*",%#&+#0*'" /+/ 1*$%$%+#*,",)%#2*, %#&'(%#$"'"..07%$$*2$'"$$'* %#),A"$$,%0$*2$+'%7%.+#"#+#6%$" 1",$+/0+2A"#2'* '"." .+,*/*,,*2$+$'*< $+.07%$$'"$%#),A+%.

"$$,%0$*2$+'%7"#2".1*,1+.$7+,$*7,*1+,$>$'*9".*+/ 2*"$'!"./,"9$,*+# -*,$"0,""#2$'%.%#),A!".#+$ "$$,%0$*2$+'%7<*",#*2 *#%+,9+#.* /+,$'*1*$%$%+#*, '"./,$'*,.07%$$*2$'"$$!+1,+.*9$%+#!%$#*..*.>#"7* A>

@'7%#2*, %#&'C=D"#27,%#2*, %#&'C=D'"6* #+$ .11+,$*2 $'* 1,+.*9$%+# 6*,.%+# "#2 !*,* 2*9 ",*2 '+.$% *$%./,$'*,.07%$$*2$'"$$',**7+,*1,+.*9$%+# !%$#*..*.'"6*0**#*E"7%#*2".=4",)%$ %#&'"#2=

,.*!"@ %#&''"6*#+$#"7*2$'*1*$%$%+#*,!'*,*".= " %1 %#&''".+# A.$"$*2$'"$%#$"!".1,*.*#$"$$'*.1+$> !'*,*".> $'* #"7* +/ $'*1*$%$%+#*,%. ",)%#2*, %#&' ( %#$"+!*6*,>'*'"..$"$*2$'"$'*%2*#$%/%*2$'*"99.*2 1,*.*#$ %# $'* +,$ $ %. " .+ .$"$*2 $'"$ %# $'* 1+ %9* %#6*.$%&"$%+#>$'*1*$%$%+#*,!".#+$/+#21,*.*#$"$$'*.1+$ "#2'*'"22*1+.%$*2'%.,%// *%#$'*,7+,A+# 4 # ><*",#*29+#.* "11*",%#&+#0*'" / +/1*$%$%+#*, ")%'"." .+.$"$*2$'"$$'+&'

$!+ 1,+.*9$%+# !%$#*..*. '"6* 0**# 2*9 ",*2 '+.$% * "#2 1*$%$%+#*, ")%!"..'+!#'"6%#&"'"#2 * +/.1"2*<*",#*29+#.* /,$'*,",&*2$'"$$'%."99.*2!". " .+#+$1,*.*#$"$$'*1 "9*+/+99,,*#9*".'*!".8 7.

"!"A".1*,'%.9" 2*$"% ."#2'".,* %*21+#$'*.$"$. ,*1+,$/% *20A *#%+, 1*,%#$*#2*#$+/+ %9*>",#" "%# +/ !'%9'!"./% *20A$'*9+71 "%#"#$/+, /,$'*, %#6*.$%&"$%+#> !'*,*%#> %$ %. .$"$*2 $'"$ ". 1*, 9" 2*$"% .+/$'*7+0% *1'+#*+/1*$%$%+#*, '"6%#& 7+0% * +58855 '%. 1,*.*#9* %. .'+!# #*", 6% "&*'",%@*>%.$,%9$<2'%"#"/,+7 4$+4 $%." .+.$"$*2$'"$$'*!%$#*..*.=4$+= '"6*#+$ #"7*2$'*1*$%$%+#*,# 4 4 > *",#*29+#.* "11*",%#&/+,$'*1*$%$%+#*,"7%, %#&''"..07%$$*2$'"$ ".1*,-/++$"&*+/ "" %"$""#2%,"$%" "C##*E,* D>'*!".

@7."!"A/,+7$'*1 "9*+/+99,,*#9*"#2 #+.1*9%/%9,+ *%."$$,%0$*2$+'%7*E9*1$$'"$'*!".'"6%#&" .1"2**'"." .+,* %*21+#$'*.$"$*7*#$.+/=4"#2 = $+.07%$$'"$1*$%$%+#*,%.#+$#"7*2"#2,"$'*,= ,.*!"@ %#&''".2*1+.*2$'"$'%..$"$*7*#$!".,*9+,2*2 0A$'*1+ %9*#+$".1*,'%.6*,.%+#"#2,0"9'"# %#&'( % >,2*6 %#&'("'",%A">",9'","# %#&'("&&%> %$$> %#$" "#2 ",7%, %#&' !*,* #+$ %#6+ 6*2 %# $'*

7,2*,+/ +7" # 45 > *",#*2 9+#.* "11*",%#&+#0*'" /+/$'*1*$%$%+#*,6$", %#&'( %$"#'"." .+",&*2$'"$$'*,*%.#+.1*9%/%9,+ *"$$,%0$*2$+ $'*1*$%$%+#*,*E9*1$$'"$'*!".'"6%#&"2"#&F!++2*#.$%9@ "#2'*'".0**#/" .* A%71 %9"$*2%#$'%.9".*0*9".*%#"# *", %*, &+$,*&%.$*,*2"&"%#.$$'*2*9*".*2#2*, *9$%+#

>%#!'%9'>'*!"."!%$#*..#,*1 A> *",#*2 $"$* 9+#.* > +# %#.$,9$%+#. /,+7$'*#6*.$%&"$%#& //%9*, "#2 "..%.$*20A *",#*29+#.* "11*",%#&/+,$'*9+71 "%#"#$'". .07%$$*2$'"$=4'".#"7*2",)%#2*, %#&'(%#$"".

%#$">'+!*6*,>'%.%2*#$%$A%.#+$2%.1$*2"#2=" %1

%#&''".#"7*2"7%, %#&'"#2 ")%$%.

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

%#&'>!'+%."#*A*!%$#*.."#2$'*%#/+,7"#$+/$'* '".

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

+9@1.%#9* 9$+0*,> "#2"7%, %#&'"#26$", %#&'

",*%#2%9%" +9@1.%#9*",9'> $%.!+,$'#+$%9%#& '*,*$'"$%#$'*.*/+,1*$%$%+#.>/+,$'* ".$/*!2"$*.>$'* 1,+.*9$%+#%.$"@%#&$%7*$+*#"0 *$'*1+ %9*$+*E"7%#*$'* 9+71 "%#"#$,7@' %#&' "#2 +# 8> %$ !".

.07%$$*2 $'"$ $'* $,%" +,$ '". %..*2 #+#0"% "0 * !",,"#$."&"%#.$'%7"#2$'*#>+# 8>%$!".2%,*9$*2 $'"$$'* !% *#.,*$'"$$'*.$"$*7*#$+/,7@' %#&'

0*,*9+,2*2+#$'*#*E$2"$*+/'*",%#&+!*6*,>"1*,." +/ $'*+,2*,2"$*2 8 81"..*20A$'*$,%" +,$>.'+!.

$'"$$'+&'$'*.$"$*7*#$.+/",)%$ %#&'C=4D>" %1 %#&'

C=D"#2,.*!"@ %#&'C= D'"6*0**#,*9+,2*2%#$'* +,$>$'*.$"$*7*#$+/9+71 "%#"#$,7@' %#&''".#+$ 0**#,*9+,2*2.+/",>,"$'*,$'*1,+.*9$%+#'".,*G*.$*2$'* $,%" +,$$+&,"#$$%7*$+/% *"#"11 %9"$%+##2*, *9$%+# 5,"#2$'*9".*%.#+!"2)+,#*2/+, 8/+,

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

$*"2+/,*9+,2%#&.$"$*7*#$+/,7@' %#&'"#2%$7"A $"@* +#&$%7*"#2$'*1*$%$%+#*,.",*%#)2%9%" +9@1.%#9* +#&<%.

% ),# 5 (#, % & ) ) 3) ,8 #42) % #4># ,8 2 /,3) *)$%$ (2*)$% ;2,%4 ( ?%%, #&& % & (# )'

)-(, % ), 5 * (#,) #( ) 2"*:* -) , *)$%) 48, (#,&& )$ %-)( % )&# %( #,&) ) % ),, (2&,) 0# 2#1% *)$%% && 4 % ),# %) 2 % 4

( :%'% , (#, %& ) ?) %# (22 )$#& %2 ) %(() )$ % ) ( % ) & ) ) ,,-

$ )$) )24), %& ) ) )24,# #43( % 2() ) ) %) : )2(, % )( %& ) ) ), && 4

% ),# 2'&&,)( ) @2& ) 2&& ( %

$#, 4),$ %,,4((,, " &% (&8 %) 4 &,( % ), %

(( ( *9*70*,> 8 C =D