High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/809/1996disposed of

(O&M) Om Parkash v. State Of Punjab

2025-12-05Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja5 pages

&@ *$"&% *$"&% *$"&% *$"&% @;&%;;A. B/ @;&%;;A. B/ @;&%;;A. B/ @;&%;;A. B/ "322&# "322&# "322&# "322&#< < < <

< ::",,*#$ ::",,*#$ ::",,*#$ ::",,*#$

":&#+"#$ ":&#+"#$ ":&#+"#$ ":&#+"#$./ /

& C C C C&% &% &% &%;;A ;;A ;;A ;;A. B/ . B/ . B/ . B/

::",,*#$ ::",,*#$ ::",,*#$ ::",,*#$ ":&#+"#$ ":&#+"#$ ":&#+"#$ ":&#+"#$./ /

!""#$ !

%&! !

(#2'(:$* +5&3*$" $'"*::",,*#$D,*#+&9#"!.$'!&(6 6'/ (#)*#"'$* ++, (# #)*- EEEE . !*,/ . !*,/ . !*,/ . !*,/ 01 2+ +"$'23&44&#&!+"!

& &@;*#+ C&%;;A*!"-"

"2#6 +"32+"+ * -&$ $' $'" *::"*, '*5" *!2"# &( ($ &% 3&44&# *3?(22$2&#D9 9*!+ 2#5&,52#6 2+"#$2 23*, %*3$ *#+ ?("$2&# &% ,*9

&! $'" *7" &% -!"52$8 %*3$ *!" 4

&@;&%;;A -"2#6$*7"#%!&4 1 8 9*8&%:!""#$*::"*, 3'*,,"#6 6"'*-""#,*2+$&$'"9*!++* *$"+

;;<:* "+-8$'","*!#"+++,2$!23 3$(+6"

&'2*!:(!.'"!"2#*%$"!

!$& '"= "%"!"#3"&(!$>/ -"!"%"!!"+*$'

01 !

2"%,8$*$2#6 2#$'":!""#$3*"

,*#+4"*(!2#6*#*,2$(* *$"+ 92$'2#$'"!"5"# #(""$*$"&%52,,*6"*!2*#* "

"'2,*#+2$!23$&'2*!:(!

3* *4" $&-"*3?(2!"+5 52+"&$2%23*$2&#+*$"+ @ ;;*#+C ;;

2("+(# #+"!

"3$2&# C B A A &% $'" *#+ 3?(22$2&# 3$

@;C .%&! '&!$ $'" =@;C 3$>/ !":"3$25",8 %&!

! $'" :(-,23 :(!:&" #*4",8 %& &! 92+"#2#6 &% &'2*!:(!J*( (8*

&*+ %&,,&9"+ -8*#9*!+:*"+-8$'" *# #+3?(22$2&#&,,"3$&!.%&!'

'&!$ =$'" >/&# @;; $'"!"-8+"$"!42#2#6 6$'"4*!7"$5*,("&%$'"*3?(2 2!"+ ,*#+F C;

DJ:"!*3!"%&!3'*'2,*#+*#+ + @@:"!*3!"%&!*!

!*#2 ,*#+ 0C1 6 66!2"5"+$'"!"&% $'"*::",,*#$J,* *#+&9#"!2#5&7"+ "%"!"#3"(# #+"! "3$2&# @ &% $ $'" @;C 3$ 9'23' 3*4" $& -" :*!$,8 *,,&9"+ -8 $'" ,"*!# #"+

"%"!"#3" &(!

!$ 52+" 2$ *9*!+ +*$"+ ;

;;< 9'2," 6!*#$2#6 '24 "#'*# 3"+ 3&4:"#*$2&#F F IC CDJ:"!*3!"?(*$'" *3?(2!"+,*#+-"2+"*9*!+2#6 6*,, &$'"!$*$($&!8- -"#"%2$D2#$"!"$(#+"!$'"@;C 3$ 2 J*$2%2"+92$'$'"9*!+:*"

"+-8$'","*!#"+ "%"!"#3"& (!$ $'":!""#$*::"

"*,9"!":!"%"!!"+*$$'"2#$*#3 3"&%*::",,*#$D,*#+&9#"!*9", ,* "&% (#)*- !":&#+"#$D$*$"

0<1 4:

:(6#2#6 *%&!"*2+ 9* *!+ ,"*!#"+ 3&(#", %&! *::",,*#$D,*#+&9 9#"!(-42$$'*$$'","*!#"+

"%"!"#3"&(!$%*2,"+$&$*7"2 2#$& 3&#2+"!*$2&#$'

'"*,"2#$*#3"GHD*#+ +GHD 9'23'9"!":!&5"+ +&# !"3&!+ -8 $'" * *::",,*#$J,*#+&9#"! *#+ 9"!" & &% :"!2&+ "5"# :!2&! $& $'" +*$"

" &% 2(*#3"&%#&$2 2%23*$2&#(#+"!"3$2&#C&%$'" @;C3$2#$'"3*"2#'*#+ '" *-&5" *," +""+ + *,& :"!$*2#"+ $& $'" *4" !

!"5"#(" "$*$" &% 52,,*6" *!2* *#* *+-*$ &IA "*!#"+ 3&(#", $'( (-4 42$ $'*$ 9'2," !",82#6 (:&# *%&!"4"#$2&#"+ *,"2#$*#3" $'"4*!7"$5*,(" 9*!"?(2!"+$&-""#'*#3"+ 0A1 # $'"&$'"!'*#+ ,"*!#"+$*$"3& &(#",(-42$$'*$#&!"*&#*$ $*,, 9"!"!"3&!+"+- -8$'","*!#"+ "%"!"#3"&(!$9 9'2,""#'*#32#6$'"4*!7"$5*,("

IC CDJ:"! *3!"2#%*5&(!&%$'"*::",,*#$ $J,*#+&9#"!"$'( (-42$$ $'*$

$'"24:(6#"+)( (+64"#$9*,2*-,"$&-""$* 2+"*#+$'"9*!+:*"+-8

9*!"?(2!

!"+$&-"!"$&!"+ 0I1 '

'*5" '"*!+ ,"*!#"+ 3&(#", %&! $'" :*!$2" *#+ 6&#" $'!&(6' :*:"!-&&7*9 9",,*!"3&!+&%$'"3*"./ %2#+(-$*#3"2#$'"(-422 &# 4*+"&#-"'*,% &%$'"*::",,*#$D,*#+&9#"! 0@1 :"!(*, &% $'" !"3&!+ '&9 $'*$ %&,,&92#6 *," +""+ 9 9"!" :!&+(3"+ &# !"

"3&!+ -8 $'" *::",,*#$J,*#+&9 9#"! %&! $'" :(!:&" &% ""7 72#6 "#'*#3"4"#$ &% % 3&4:"#*$2&# -"%&!" $'" ,"*!

!#"+ "%"!"#3" &(!$ $'" +"$ *2, $'"!"&%*!""G$!* *3$"+'"!"(#+"!J G'2-2$ G'2-2$ G'2-2$ G'2-2$

*#+

*$"

*$" &$*,3&#2+"!*$2&# &$*,3&#2+"!*$2&# &$*,3&#2+"!*$2&# &$*,3&#2+"!*$2&# J:"!4*!,* # GHD +*$"+ ;;@I GHD +*$"+

A;; G +*$"+

A;;

J*!*2 '&ADD

<DJ . 4 (7'+"5 J '&ADD

<DJ 4 *!7

*,2#6'

J '&ADD

<DJ . 4 (7'+"5

I DJ *!7*' $& 2#6'/ J:"!4*!,* 7*' $& *$ '/

DJ J:"!4*!,*

I DJ *!7*' $& 2#6'/ 0;1 "

!(*,&%$'"*%&!"4"#$2&#"+*,"

"2#$*#3" '&9$'*$*,,$'"$'

'!"" *," +""+ :"!$ $*2# $& $'" *4" *+-*$ &I IA &% 52,,*6" *!2*#* "'2, * *#+ 2$!23$&'2*!

!:(!&%9'23'$'",*#+(#+"!*3?

?(22$2&#-",&#6$& (!$'"!4&!"

*,, $'"$'!""*,"+"

""+:"!$*2#$&$'"*4" "3$*#6 ,"&A&%9'23'*#*,&%,* *#+ '* -""# *3?(2!

!"+ %&! $'" :(-,23 :(!:&" #*4 4",8 %&! 92+"#2#6 &% &'2*!:

:(!J *(8* &*+# #$'"625"#%*3$ $'"*,"+""++ +*$"+ A;;.GHD /5 52+" 9'23'4*!,* &%,*#+%&!42#6:*!$&% "3$ &A2,,*& 9*&,+-8 *::",,*#$J,*#+&9 9#"!'24",%$&&#"*$ *,2#6 6'F <DJ:"!4*!,*-"2#6 62#

3,&":!&G242$8 $&$'"#&$2%23*$2&#(#+"!"3$2& &#C&%$'"@;C3$2#$'"3*"

"2# '*#+K2#$"!4& &%$24":"!2&+ #""+$&-"!",2"+ (:&# 01 2# #3"$'"!"2*$24"6*:&%*,4& $8"*!-"$9""#$'"+*$"&% *," +""++*$"+.G HD /*#++*$"&%2(*#3"&% %#&$2%23*$2&#(#+"!"3$2&#C&% @;C3$2#$'"

"3*"2#'*#+ *#*::!"32*$2&# F M:"!*##(4#""+$& &-" *9*!+"+&5"!$'

'"-*":!23":"!4*!,*+"!25"+%!

%!&4$'"*4"K9'23'$'(3&4" $&

I<DJ:"!4 4*!,*2#3"$'"*3?(22$2&#2#$'"

":!""#$3*"!",*$"$&4*,,:*!

!3", &% ,*#+ 4"*(!

!2#6 *#*, *#+ $'" *!"* %&!42#6 :*!$ &% *2+ *," + ""+ GHD / 9* *!,* * +"+(3$2&# F M 9&(,+ (%%23" *#+ $'" 4*!

!7"$ 5*,("&%$'"*3?( (2!"+,*#+$'( 3&4"$&

DJ:"!4*!,* 01 & &!"&5"!

2#$'"625"#%*3$2#3" $'"*3?(22$2&#2#$'"3*"2#'* *#+ '*-""#3*!!2"+ +&($%&!$'":(-,23:(!:&"

#* *4",8 %&!92+"#2#6&%&'2*!:

:(!J *(8* &*+ *# #+*(3'$'"!":&#+"#$+2+# #&$(%%"!*#8,&$&9*!+&:$24 4(4 ($2,2L*$2&# &% $'

'" *!"* *3?(2!"+ *#+ *,& +2 2+ #&$ 2#3(! "G:"#+2$(!" $&9* *!+ :!&52+2#6&%*++ +2$2&#*,2#%!*$!(3$(!*,*4"#2$2" ,27":*!7 6!""#-",$ !&*+* *#+ 3&44(#2$8-(2,+ +2#6"$3 #&3($$&9*!++"5",& &:4"#$3&$#""+$&-"24:&"

"+ 0 1 33 3&!+2#6,8 $'" 4*!7"$ 5*,(" % %&! $'" ,*#+ (#+"! *3?(22$2&# # 2 *""+F

DJ:"!4*!,*#*++2$2&# $'

'",*#+&9#"!'*,,*,&-""#$2$ $,"+ %&!*9*!+&%*,, $*$($&!8-"#"%2$*#+2#$"!"$* *:!&52+"+(#+"!$'":!&522&# &% $'"@;C3$.*4 4"#+"+(:$&+*$"/2#3,(+2#62#$"

"!"$&#&,*$2(4*9",, 01 &# #"?("#$,8 2# 52"9 &% $'" +2 23(2&# 4*+" '"!"2# *-&5"

*::"*,:!"%"!!"+ +*$$'"2#$*#3"&%*::",,*#$J,*# #+&9#"!2'"!"-8:*!$,8*,,&9"+ +2# $'"*%&!"*2+$"!

!4*#+$'"*::"*,%2,"+-8$'" $*$"&% (#)*-2 $'(+242"+ +

0C1 H'

'"!"5"! $'" ,*#+&9#"!./ '*D'

'*5" (#%&!$(#*$",8 "G:2!"+ 2# *::"*,./D3!&J& &-)"3$2&#./*%$"!%2,2#6$'"!"&% *#+$'","6*,'"2!'*5"#&$- ""# 24:,"*+"+ $'"8 8 '*,, -" *$ ,2-"!$8 $& ""7 "G"

"3($2&# &% $'" :!""#$ +"322&# -8 4&52#6*::!&:!

!2*$"*::,23*$2&#./-"%&!"$'","* *!#"+G"3($2#6&(!$ 0<1 ,, :"#+2#6*::,23*$2&#./ 2%*#8 '*,,*,&$*#++2:&"+&% /

/ "3"

"3"

"3"4-"!

4-"!

4-"!< < < <

$27 . . . . < H'

'"$'"!:"*72#6D!"*&#"+ " '"$'"!!":&!$*-," " D& D&