High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/88/1996dismissed

(O&M) Joginder Singh v. State Of Punjab

2026-02-25Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja3 pages

20.

.:77/*

.:77/*& & &&& && && && ! ! ! ! " " " " ! ! ! !

==.552/0 ==.552/0 ==.552/0 ==.552/0 ## ## ## ## $# %!!

# $# %!!

# # # # # .=/8./0 .=/8./0 .=/8./0 .=/8./0 & ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

==.552/0 ==.552/0 ==.552/0 ==.552/0 " " " " ! ! ! !

## ## ## ## $# %!!

# $# %!!

# # # # # .=/8./0 .=/8./0 .=/8./0 .=/8./0 ' # # # #

==.552/0 ==.552/0 ==.552/0 ==.552/0 " " " " ! ! ! !

## ## ## ## $# %!!

# $# %!!

# # # # # .=/8./0 .=/8./0 .=/8./0 .=/8./0 (

#)!

! ! ! !

==.552/0 ==.552/0 ==.552/0 ==.552/0 " " " " ! ! ! !

## ## ## ## $# %!!

# $# %!!

# # # # # .=/8./0 .=/8./0 .=/8./0 .=/8./0 * * * * -../0*

- + #!,! + #!,! + #!,! + #!,! 1023214-$89:20. ,4567/8.-,24-$89:20.2/8 ;<712!8$89:20. 8 03.2==.552/0>52/86/.- 4/?2/.302$885$4/ /?2< DDDD $-25 $-25 $-25 $-25 ,! ,! ,! ,! @ A "78 8.037:;;/-8.-$03.2 -.

.;./07/.8.B452-7-0==.

25$ 2-.<.7/B8.:78.

.8225503.2==.25329.2-7./ /40 :;;/2:C47707/>6 62-8

7/9597/B 78./07 7:25 2:0 2/8 C4.07/ 526 - 03. 21. <-.970E$ 2:0 2-. ;

<.7/B021./ -;

@&A

E 62E =-../0 2==.25$ :325 55./B. 32 <../ 5278 0 03. 6 62-8 820.8& F

=2.8<E03.5.2-/.8885

70-7:048B.$2072523.-.7/2 0.

-0 3.G.

.-./:.4-0H <.-.

.--.8203 @'A - 7.

5E 0207/B$ 7/ 03. =-../0 :2 2.$ 52/8 ;.24-7/B ' F 2:

:-. 70420.867037/0 03.-.9./4..020. 97552B. 320-7.$.3752?=4-2$:2;.0 <. 2:C47-.8978. 07 7:207/820.8((

2/ /8& (

74.84/8.-!.:07 / ( 03.#2/ /8:C47707/:0$

( -3 -003.G

(:0H-.=.:079.5E$

03. =4<57: =4- -=.$ /2;.5E$ - K:/0-4:07 07/ 03. 2/47 2/25 7 7/- 70-7<40-EI I 62-84/8.-!.:07/

03.

(:062=2.8<E03.#2 2/8 :C47707/5 5.:0- -3-0G03.#H/ '

-9254. 52/8#2 20.- /24==5.;./ 02-E62-8820.8&

6 6703-.=.:0003.B-2/0 82;2 2B. /2::4/0 .

.9.-2/:.003.52/862=2.8 8M& L 03.;2-1.09254. 03. 2:C47-.852/8

.3-70E=. -03.5.

09.-52/ /82:-03.;7/-2/8&L 03. ;2-1.0=-7:.

03.52/82=.-03.-7B7/2526 62-8 -25503.-0E=. 52/8 5.

0 9.-<E.9.-2/:

:./03.03.-78. 03.:2/25 7.062-897552B.78. @(A BB B-7.9.8 03.-. $ 03. 2==.552/0 0>52/86/.- 75.8 <?.:07 / 4/8.-!.:07/

03.

(:0637:3:2;.

.0<.87=.8 <E03.5.2-/ /.8 .

.-./:.4-0 0978.62-8820.8& F

3.-.5.92/0=2-2B-2=3 & - -; 03.62-87.J0 0-2:0.803.-.

-;*N K & /03.-.450$03.=.0707/.-7/2 25503.2 -.;./07/.8://.:0.85 52/8 -.

.-./:.2-.262-8.803.:;=./2 207/ -03..9.-2/:. 52/820 0 03. -20.

. L 03.;2-1.09254. 03 3.52/8.9.-.852/8$ 2557/B2:- 03. :2/ /25262E -;03.97552B.2<287$2/ /8M&L 03.;2-1.09254.

03.

52/8 /8 -.9.-.852/8 2557/B/03.9 97552B.78.4=003.2-.2 2:-. . 52/8 /8I @ A 3 329. 3.2-8 5.2-/.8 :4/.5 03. =2-07. 2/8 B/. 03-4B3 03. =2=.-<126 6.552-.:-8 03.:2. @ A = =.-425 03. 62-8 2 6.55 2 03. -.:-8 -.

5.:0.8 0320 03. 2==.552/0>52/8 86/.-329.<../4702<5E: ;=./20.822B27/003.82;2 2B. 062-8.9.-2/ /:. 03.7-52/83587/B/2::

:4/0 2:C47707/7/32/8:2-- -7.8 40 - 03. =4< <57: =4-=.$ /2;.5E$ - :/0- -4:07/ 03. 2/47 2/25 7 7/- 70-7<40-E 3.62-8=2.8<E03.5.2-/ /.8.

.-./:.4-07<2.84= =/ =-=.- 2==-.:72 207/ 03. =5.287/B 2/8 .978 8./:. 292752<5. / -.:-8 2/8 03. 2;.$034:255 -/7/0.- .-./:.B27/003 3..9.-2/:. 52/83587/B$ 03. 2==.552/0>52/8 86/.-329.25-.28E<../B- -2/0.8 L 03.;2-1.09254.

. 03.52/8 2557/B 2:-03.:2/252/8&L 03.

.;2-1.09254. -03.2:C47-.852 2/8

2557/B/03.9 97552B.78.4=003.2-.2 9.2:-.;20.-725.978./:. 32 <../-.57.84=/ /0.02<573032003.2==.552/0 >52/86/.-2-../0705.8 -2 2/E

4-03.-./32/:.;

;./0062-803.82;2B. .9 9.-2/:. @FA /9 97.6 2<9.$ 7/87/B/755.B2 2570E-=.-9.-70E670303. 7/87/ /B -.:-8.8<E03.

.5.2-/.8.

.-./:.4-0$03.7 7;=4B/.8262-8$034:255 - / 7/0.- .-./:.55 503.2==.2502/887;7.8 @ A ./ /87/B2==57:207/$7 2/E3255 2502/887=.8 ,! ,! ,! ,! .<- .<- .<- .<-42-E 42-E 42-E 42-E& & $$$$& 071 )3 )3 3.03.-=.217/B>-.2/.8

. 3.03.--.=-02<5.

. > >