High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/894/1997disposed of

Smt. Ranjana Gupta v. State Of Haryana

2025-11-26Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja4 pages

+)'

':>">(#

':>">(#67 67

6B6 6B6 6B6 6B6A !"

!" ,,'--+() ,,'--+() ,,'--+() ,,'--+() '",(/'() '",(/'() '",(/'() '",(/'()" # # # # &'"'()# ( & $ % $ % $ % $ % 1 1 1 1 (' &)*'+,,'--+().-+(/0('& +?/>"*+(:*+(/+2//- 2+&5+(+ FFFF 2&+- 2&+- 2&+- 2&+- 1 1 1 1

5 0+5 ,&'"'()+,,'+-2:*+--'(?

?'*+"8''(-+>/))*'0+&//+ +)'/

7 ,+""

"'/ 85 )*' -'+&('/ >")&>:) ;

;/?'2 +&>/+8+/ *'&'>(+ )'& ) 8' &'

'&&'/+")*'9 '

'&'(:';&)<20*'&'85'

'&'(:'')>)>( >-'/;(/'& ':) )>(

)*'%+(/ :=;>">)>(:)2 &"*&) )9)*' :)<+))*'>(")+(:'

' )*'-+(/0('&0 0+",+&)-5+--0'/0*>-'?&+()>( ?8'('

>) '(*+(:'/E+&H')D+ +-;' @ " AB.C ,'& & "=;+&' 5+&/ =;+ )*' +:=;>&'/ / -+(/ 8'">/'" +0+&/ ")+);) )&5 8'('

>)".>()'&'") +",&D>/'/;(/'&)*' :) 364 & >'

-5")+)>(?2>()*',&'"'():+"'2 2-+(/E'+";&>(? 7+:&'"">);+ +)'/ 0>)*>()*'&'D'( (;''")+)' D>--+?'*+&"+()-52 +/8+")

2'*">- +--+8*?+ +&*2

>")&>:)+&>/+8 8+/2:+E')8'+:=;>&'/D>/' )> >:+)>("/+)'/67B 6+ +(/

B7 >"";'

'/;(/'& ':)>(" 7 )*'

:)&'",':)>D'-5 &)*',;8 8->: ,;&,"' (+E'-5 5 & )*' /'D'-,E'() +(/ ;)>-> >G+)>( -+(/ +" (/;")&>+- & &'+2 ':)&CA2 +&>/ /+8+/2 --0'/ 85 +( 0+&/ ,+""'/ 85 )*' %+(/ :=;>">) )>(

--':)& & "

"*&) 9)*' %< ( 7B7 A2 )*'&'85 /')'&E>(>(? )*' E+& &H') D+-;' )*'+:=;

;>&'/-+(/@" 2BB2BBB.C,'&+ +:&' 34 ?

??&>'D'/)*'&' 2)*'+,,'--+()C-+ +(/0('&>(DH'/'

'&'(:';( (/'& ':)>( ) :)2 0*>:* :+E' ) 8' ,+&)-5 +--0'/ 85 )*' -'+&( ('/ '

'&'(:' ;& &) D>/' >)" +0+&/ /+)'/ 72 0*>-' ?&+()>(? '(*+( :'/ :E,'("+)>(@ @" AB.C,'&"=;+&'5+&/=;+ )*'+:=;>&'/-+(/8'">/'"+0+&/ / +--)*'&")+);)& &58'('

>)".>()'&'")>(*'& +D;& ;(/'&)*' :)

"C"+)>"

>'/0>)*)*'0+&/,+""'

'/85)*'-'+&('/'

'&'(:' ;&)2 -+(/0('& )*',&'"'()+,,'

'+-0+",&'

'&&'/+))*'>(")+(:' 4 (' +,,'+&" ( 8'*+- )*' +,,'--+()C-+(/0('& *+D' *'

'+&/ -'+&('/ )+)': ;("'-+(/?(')*&;?*)*',+, ,'&8H+"0'--+"&':&/" :+"' 3A4 , ,'&;"+- )*'&':&/"*0")*+) ))*'-'+&('/'

'&'(:';&)0* *>-' +0+&/>(? 8'('

>) E+&H') D+-;' @ " AB.C C ,'& "=;+&' 5+&/ &'->'/ ;,( ,&'D>;"0+&/ /.I;/?E'()/+)'/67B AJ JC6&'-+)>(?)+:=;>">)>( -+ +(/

&)*'">E>-+&, ,;&,"'>' &)*'/'D'-,E'() +(/;)>->G+)>( -+(/+"(/;") )&>+- &'+>( ':)&CA A+&>/+8+/C +--+8*?+&*:()& --'/+&'+ 374 )* *+"()8''(/>",;)'/85-'+&('

'/ )+)':;("'-)*+)+""'""E'() ) E+&H') D+-;' @ @ " AB.C ,'& "=;+&' 5+&/ E+ +/' D>/' 0+&/ /+)'/ 67B

A JC60+"-+ +)'&'(*+(:'/.+-)'&'/)" 7A.

.C,'&"=;+&'5+&/85)*>";&) )>( 667 AD>/'/':>">(/+)'/ B 66BB '-'D+(),+&+?&+,*)*'& &' >"'J)&+:)'/*'&'

';(/'&#C K()*>"D>'0 )*'E+))'&2* -/+(//':>/')*+))*'E+&H')D+-;'

;' -+(/>(=;'")>(()*'/+)' )*'

*'()> >:+)>(0+"" 7A.C,'&"=;

;+&' 5+&/ &/+(/)*'-+(/0('&""*+--8''() ()>)-'/))*':E,'("+)>(+))*>"& &+)'

,+ +&) &E )*>"2 )*' -+(/ 0('&" +& &' +-" '()>)-'/ ) )*' )*'& ")+);) ;)&5 8'( ('

>)" ;(/'& ':)>( 6 C +(/ / 6 )*' :) *'5 "*+-- +-" 8' '()> )>)-'/)"-+)>;E+))*'&+)' BL L*' >(/>(? )*' >")&>:);/?'

'( >"";

;' +&'E/> >'/))*>"'J)'( ()("'=;'()-52)*'+,,'+-" >-'/ /85 )+)' +&' *'&'85 />"E>""'/ +(/ / )*' +,,'+-" )*' -+(/ 0('&" +&' +-- 0'/>(,+&)>()*'->?*) )*'8"

"'&D+)>("+(/>(/>:+)>(?>D'(+8 D' *'

'&' "*+-- 8' ( &/'& +" ) :")" >( +(5 )*' +,,'+-" *' '(*+( (:'/ :E E,'("+)>("*+--8',+>/85)*' )+) +)' +&5+(+0>)*>()*&''E()*" M ;& &)*'&2 ,'&;"+- )*' &':&/ "*0" )*+) )*' + &'E'()>( ('/ +""'""E'()E+/ /'85)*>";&)>(667 7 A)*;?*&'-+)'/)"+ +E' ,;&,"'+(/ )*'"+E'&'D'(;''")+)'2*0'D D'&)> >:+)>(;(/'& ':)>(

:) >( ( )*' "+>/ :+"' 0+" >"";'/ ( 6 67 0*'&'+" >( )*',&'"

"'() :+"'2)> >:+)> (;(/'& ':)>( )*' :)0+">"";'/(67B " ";:*:(">/'&>(?

?)*' +:))*+))*'-+(/;(/'&+:= =;>">)>( &E'/,+&) +&>/+8 8+/C

+--+8*?+&*:( ()&--'/+&'+2+:;E;-+)>D''":+ +-+)>(@ 6L(''/")8'+,,- ->'/

&)*')>E'?+, ,8')0''()*')0()> >:+)>(" >' &E67 )67B

6 D'&)*'8+"', ,&>:' " 7A.C,'&"=;+&'5+& &/0*>:*:E'")"6ABA.C ,'& "=;+&'5+&/ 34 ::

:&/>(?-52 )*' E+&H') D+-;'

& )*' -+(/ ;(/'& +:=;>">)>( ( >" +""'""'/@"6 6ABA.C,'&"=;+&'5+&/(+// />)>(2)*'-+(/0('&"*+--+-" 8' '()>)-'/ &+0+ &/ +--)*'&")+);)&58'('

>)"

"+(/>()'&'")+",&D>/'/;(/'& ,&D>">(" )* *' :)+E'(/'/;,))/ /+)'*'-+(/0('&"*+--+-" 8' '()>)-'/ &"-+) )>;E@BL8'">/'"+0+&/ >( ()'&'"))*'&';,(+"0'-- 3 4 ( ("'=;'()-52 >( D>'0 )*' /> >":;"">( E+/' *'&'>( +8D'2 ,&'"'() +,,'+- , ,&'

'&&'/ +) )*' >(")+(:' +,, ,'--+()C-+(/0('& >" *'&'85 ,+ &)-5 +--0'/>()*'+

&'"+>/)'&E"

B4 N* *'&'D'& )*' -+(/0('&" *+".* *+D' ;( &);(+)'-5 'J,>&'/ >( +,,'+-".:&""C 8I':)>("+ )'& >->(?)*'&' +(/)*'-'?+-*'>&"*+D'()8 ''( >E,-'+/'/2 )*'5 5 "*+-- 8' +) ->8'&)5 ) "''H 'J'

':;)>( )*' ,&'"'() /':>">( 85 ED>(?+,,&,& &>+)'+,,->:+)>("8'

&')*'-'+ +&('/J':;)>(?;&)

-- ,'(/>(?+,,->:+)>("2> +(52"

"*+--+-"")+(//>","'/ 64 '?

?>")&5 >" />&':)'/ ) "'(/ + :'

'&)> >'/ :,5 )*>" &/'& ) +,,'--+() 1 1 1 1 D'E8'& D'E8'& D'E8'& D'E8'&67 6722226 )>H 6B6A 6B6A 6B6A 6B6A N* N* *')*'&",'+H>(?.&'+"('/

*')*'&&',&)+8-'

". ".