High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2397/2001disposed of

(O&M) State Of Haryana v. Suman Lata And Others

2015-05-06Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Garg9 pages

!" #"$%&%' ( ( )! !" *+ ' ,,"-- '! ."*&/& )0!)/0 '1 ! '#!2"*& "&,'#"'!&

)! !" *+ ' '#!2"*& ,,"-- '! ."*&/& )0!)2 '!%".% '#!2"*& "&,'#"'!& !"#$% &'() %*+'

32"!2"*",*!"*& 1$ -"4&, ,"*&0 +5" --4"#! &""!2"6/#70"'!8 +"& 5"*"

"**"#!!2"",*!"*&*'!8+"& 32"!2"*!2"6/#70"'!&2/-#5"*",*!"#%'!2"%7"&!8+"& *"&"'!9)2*% /* . '& -:: *+ ' *!2" ,,"-- '!

&%' 5!2 ,," -& )2*%) '6%. 55%:#.$ !" **"&,'#"'! %' 5!2 ,," -& )2*% *! ,)%'72:#.$ !" *;<56"$!*& *+'

,& +!2%&$00'6/#70"'!%'!"'#!#%&,&"

!%!-"# &)! !" *+ ' ."*&/&)0!)/0 '1 ! '# !2"*& '# =

!%!-"# &)! !" *+ '

."*&/& )0!)2 '!%".% '# !2"*& '#*&&56"$!%'& (<

,*"

"**"#5+*"&,'#"'!& '#*$'."'%"'$" $!& *"5"%'7 ! >"' *0

!%!-"# & )! !" *+ '

."*&/&)0!)/0 '1 ! '#!2"*& )! !" *+ ' '#"'"* - ' 7"*: *+ ' #4 +&:

2 '#%7 *22 ."#%*"$!"#&

'#& =

7 %'&!!2" 4 *## !"#

, &&"#5+)2*% ) # ':!2"!2"'-" *'"# !*$$%#"'!&- %0&*%5/' -:2! >.%#"

42%$2!2"$- %0,"!%!%'&2 ." 5""', *!-+ $$",!"#7* '!%'7 &/0

&?:= :

@< -'74%!2%'!"*"&!A B,"* ''/0%'*"&,"$! #" !2 % )%'72 '#&(:

@<4"*"7* '!"#%'*"&,"$! #" !2 C%-")%'72 *%"

-+&! !"#)/0 '1 ! 4%#4 '#2"*$2%-#*"'2 ." %-"# $- %0 ,"!%!%' $- %0%'7 $0,"'& !%' ! !2" !/'" &?:

@< %'

*"&,"$! #" !2 %)%'72%' 0!*."2%$/- * $$%#"'!!%&,-" #"# !2 ! %)%'72 -'74%!2C%-")%'722 2 -4 &7%'7 *02! >! 2 '#%7 *2%'2%& */!% *5" *%'7*"7%&!* !%'<@ ( ?!

5/! ,042"'!2"+*" $2"#'" *!2"!/*'%'7 )"$!* !%,-%'

2! > 2 '#%7 *2 #: 5/&5" *%'7*"7%&!* !%' < @

5"%'7#*%."'5+ 01 -*"&,'#"'!* &2-+ '#'"7-%7"'! '# ! ."*+2%72&,""#$ 0" *0!2",,&%!"#%*"$!%'%": *02 '#%7 *2&%#"

'## &2"# 7 %'&!!2" */!% * !"*$0%'7'!2"4*'7&%#" % )%'724 &#*%.%'7!2"$ *'%!&$**"$!&%#" !2"* # !&-4&,""#2"

%0, $! $$%#"'!4 &&&!*'7!2 !!2" */!%$ *"'! '7-"#/'#"*'" !2 !2"

"'#%'75/&42%$2#* 77"#!2" */!% *! #%&! '$" 5/! , $"& %)%'72 -'7<4%!2C%-")%'72!2"!2"*$$/, '!& !2" */!%$ * &/&! %'"# 7*%"./& 0/-!%,-" %'6/*%"& ' !2"%* ,"*&' !2 !2"

%'6/*"#@$$/, '!& !2" */!% *4"*"! >"'/!5+!2", &&"*&<5+"4%!2 !2"%'!"'!%'!& ."!2"%*-%."&5/!5!2 !2"0&/$$/05"#!!2"%*%'6/*%"& !!2"&,!2"#*%."* !2"

"'#%'75/& -"# 4 + *0!2"&,!! >%'7 !2"5"'"

%! !2"$*4#2" $$%#"'!4 &$ /&"##/"!!2"&-"* &2 '# '"7-%7"'!#*%.%'7 *"&,'#"'!"&,'#"'!#%#'!5-4!2" 2*' '* --4"#!2"!*

%$*/-"& E 7%*)%'72&' ) '!>2)%'72 *"&%#"'! D )"$!* E/*/>&2"!* -#7"#!2" ? !%&,-" #"#!2 ! %)%'72 7"#??+" *&4 & 6/'%*"'7%'""* %' *+ ' )! !"<,"* !%.","; '>-!#)"$!* :2 '#%7 *2 '# 4 &#* 4%'70'!2-+& - *+ &: ( @< ,,*;%0 !"-+ !%& /*!2"* ,-" #"#!2 !$- %0 '!&%'$/**"#";,"'#%!/*" & :

@<'!* '&,*! !%'

#" #5#+ '#'2%&- &!*%!"&2"#"$" &"#4 &2 .%'75*%72! /!/*"

,*&,"$!/& ,*0!%'%'2%&&"*.%$"$ *""* '#2%&& - *+ !!2"!%0"

2%&*"!%*"0"'!4 &5/'#!5"0*"!2 '&(:

@<,"*0'!2 ( '!2"*$- %0,"!%!%'4 &#%*"$!"#5+)0!)2 '!%".% '# '!2"*%'*"&,"$! #" !2 C%-")%'722 2 -,-" #%'7!2"& 0" $!& 2 !$- %0,"!%!%'4 &, *!-+ $$",!"# '# &/0 &(:

@<4 & 7* '!"#!!2"$- %0 '!& D "&,'#"'! %-"# &", * !" 4*%!!"' &! !"0"'! ! >%'7 ,*"-%0%' *+56"$!%' ''<6%'#"* '"$"&& *+, *!%"&!2 !'&/* '$"

$0, '+4%!242%$2!2" */!% *5" *%'7*"7%&!* !%'<@ ( ?

2 &'!5""'%0,-" #"# &, *!+ 2"#*%."* !2" */!%$ *4 &'!

2-#%'7 '+. -%##*%.%'7-%$"'$"'0"*%!&:%!%&,-" #"#!2 !'

01 -*"&,'#"'!4 &#*%."* 5/&5" *%'7*"7%&!* !%'<

D:5"%'7#*%."' *0E -> !"-2% */!% *4 &5"%'7#*%."'

* &2-+ '#'"7-%7"'!-+ '#4%!2/!5&"*.%'7!*

%$*/-"& ! ."*+2%72 &,""# '# $$%#"'!2 &$$/**"#'!2 ! $$/'! &#*%."* 0 */!%$ * $/-#'!$'!*-!2"."2%$-"

"&,'#"'!2 & %-"#!2"4*%!!"'&! !"0"'!'!2"& 0"

-%'"& = "&,'#"'!?'&/* '$"0, '+2 &! >"'!2",*"-%0%' *+ 56"$!%'&!2 !$- %0,"!%!%'& *"%'$0,-"!":. 7/" '##'!#%&$-&" '+ $ /&" $!%' 7 %'&! !2" '&4"*%'7 *"&,'#"'! 2" #*%."*

"'#%'7."2%$-"4 &'!2-#%'7 . -%##*%.%'7-%$"'$" '# &&/$2 '&/* '$"0, '+4 &'!-% 5-"

*"6%'#"*4 & %-"#--4%'7%&&/"&4"*" * 0"#9< 32"!2"*,*"&"'! $$%#"'!%&!2"/!$0" * &2 '# '"7-%7"'!#*%.%'7 *"&,'#"'! 01 -42%-" #*%.%'75/&5" *%'7< @

*/'# (,0'" *)"$!*!/*'%'7 !%,-%:%'42%$2 %)%'72 '#C%-")%'72#%"#8 %&&/"%&,*."#%'

%*0 !%.":!42 ! 0/'! '# '# *0420!2","!%!%'"*& *""'!%!-"#!*"$."*8 32"!2"**"&,'#"'!4 &2-#%'7 . -%##*%.%'7 -%$"'$"'!2"# !" $$%#"'!8 ? "-%"

1" *'"#*%5/' -*"!/*'"# %'#%'7'%&&/"%' ./*

!2"$- %0 '!&42"*" &'%&&/" %!4 &2"-#!2 !*"&,'#"'!?%&'! -% 5-"!, +!2" 0/'! '# &&/$2%&&/" 4 &#"$%#"# $$*#%'7-+ ""-%'7#%&& !%& %"#4%!2!2"4 *## !"# ( ?)! !"

*+ ' 2 &#%*"$!"#

'# =

4%!2 ,* +"* * 5&-.%'7!2")! !" *+ ' !, +!2" 0/'! '#

( 2-#%'7!2 !'&/* '$"0, '+%&-% 5-"!, +!2" 0/'! 4"."*:)0!)2 '!%".% '#!2"*&$- %0 '!&,*" "**"#*&& 56"$!%'& (<

%' =

*"'2 '$"0"'!

$0,"'& !%' 2 ."2" *#-" '"#$/'&"- *!2", *!%"& '#2 ."7'"

!2*/72!2"*"$*#& !2"$ &"4%!2!2"%* 5-" &&%&! '$" ? 2" %*&!$'!*."*&+*"F/%*"&!5"*"&-."#%'!2",*"&"'!-%& %&42"!2"*!2" %'#%'7 !2"*%5/' -!2 !'&/* '$"0, '+%&'!-% 5-" &! '#&!2"!"&! -"7 -&$*/!%'+2" '&4"*!!2 !F/"&!%'%&%''"7 !%." !%&&"!!-"#- 4!2 !'&/* '$"0, '+$ ' .%#!2"-% 5%-%!+'-+%'$ &" %!%& 5-"!,*."!2"#*%.%'7-%$"'$"4 & >" '# *%.-/& '#!2 !!2"

4'"*2 &'!";"*$%&"#*" &' 5-"$ *"'!2%&$ &"!2" ,,"-- '!& *"!2" )! !" *+ ' '# *+ ' #4 +&:2 '#%7 *2''*0 -,* $!%$": !2")! !"."*'0"'!7%."&"0,-+0"'!!!2"#*%."* !"*& !%& +%'7!2 !

,"*&'@#*%."*%&2-#%'7 . -%##*%.%'7-%$"'$" 2" *%5/' -: %'!2" ,*"&"'!$ &"2 &7%."'0/$2%0,*! '$"!!2"&! !"0"'! #*%."*!!2"

"$!!2 !2"%& ?+" *& 7"'!2"5 &%& $ -$/- !%':!2"*%5/' - *" $2"#!!2"$'$-/&%'!2 !#*%."* !2"

"'#%'7."2%$-"4 & +" *& 7" !!2"!%0" %'$%#"'! '# &&/$2-%$"'&"$/-#'!5"%&&/"#! 2%0# !" 5%*!2$"*!% %$ !"2 &5""',*#/$"#'!2"*"$*#2"'/& -%"&2" .%-+/,'!2"'&/* '$"0, '+!,*."!2 !#*%.%'7-%$"'&"

!2"#*%."*

"'#%'7."2%$-"4 & >"2"%'&/* '$"$0, '+2 &'!

&/00'"# '+*"$*# *0!2"-%$"'&%'7 /!2*%!+ *042"*" *> #*%.%'7-%$"'&"4 &%&&/"#2"#*%."* !2"

"'#%'7."2%$-"2 &&! !"# !2 !,*".%/&-+2"4 &4*>%'7%'"5*/7 *2&& 0 '# &&/$2/'#"* !2"&"$%*$/0&! '$"&:!2"%&&/ '$" #*%.%'75+!2"& %#-%$"'&%'7 /!2*%!+

$ ''!5"& %#!5"&/&,%$%/&1" *'"#*%5/' -%'%!&%0,/7'"#4 *# 2 &0"'!%'"#!2 !%'-%$"'$" *>!2"*"%&'"'#*&"0"'!!2 !-%$"'$"

%&. -%# *,-+%'7, &&"'7"*0!*."2%$-") %# %'#%'7& *"!2"*"&/-!

0%&*" #%'7!2"".%#"'$"*0!2","*/& - *>:%!%&*"." -"#!2 !

#*%.%'7-%$"'&" *2" .+, &&"'7"*& !*G"2%$-"&2 &5""'!%$>0 *>"# 2"& %#-%$"'&"2 &5""'*"'"4"#'/05"* !%0"&):!2" ,,"-- '!&$/-# '!.%&/ -%H"!2 !& %#-%$"'&"4 & *7"#'"2"/--"'$2 /!2*%!+

!2%&/*!%'- .$/+/*.01 2

34 3/-4256 2"-#!2 !42"*"#*%."*#%#'!

,&&"&&*"F/%&%!"-%$"'$" 0!*$+$-"5/!4 &#*%.%'7!"0,:'&/* '$" 0, '+ %& -% 5-" ! , + $0,"'& !%' % !2" #*%.%'7 0"!2# '# 0"$2 '%&0 5!2!2"."2%$-"& *42%$2-%$"'$"4 &5! %'"# '#!2"'"

42%$24 &5"%'7#*%."':4 &!2"& 0"):%'!2"&"$%*$/0&! '$"&:!2"

%'#%'7 *%5/' -!!2""

"$!!2 ! 01 -#*%."**"&,'#"'!4 & '!2-#%'7. -%##*%.%'7-%$"'&" !!2"!%0" $$%#"'!&! '#&*"."*&"# '# &! '#& '&4"*"# 7 %'&!!2" !%' -'&/* '$"0, '+2"$'&"F/"'$" *"."*& - %'#%'7'!2"& %#%&&/"%&!2 !'&/* '$"0, '+%&6%'!-+ -% 5-"!, +!2" 4 *#"# 0/'!%'5!2!2"$ &"& '# &&/$25!2 ,," -& &! '# $$",!"#5+2-#%'7!2 !'&/* '$"0, '+%&2"-#6%'!-+ '# &"."* --+-% 5-" -'74%!2!2" ,,"-- '!,,"-- '!&2 ."&/50%!!"#!2 ! 0/'! $0,"'& !%' 4 *#"#5+*%5/' -%'5!2!2"$ &"&2 ."5""' , %#):!2" ,,"-- '!& *"2"-#"'!%!-"#!%'#"0'% +5+!2"'&/* '$"

0, '+ ( 2" $- %0 '!& )2 '!% ".% '# !2"*& 2 ." %-"# $*&&<

56"$!%'& * "'2 '$"0"'! $0,"'& !%' C%-" )%'72 #"$" &"# ,*"#"$"&&*<%'<%'!"*"&! )2 '!%".%2 &#%"# !!2" 7" (? &,"*!2"

%'#%'7 !2"*%5/' -2"0'!2-+#","'#"'$+ C%-")%'722 &5""'

! >"' &&D

@<,"*0'!2 '#0/-!%,-%"* 2 &5""' ,,-%"# 2"

0/'! $0,"'& !%'$ -$/- !"#4 &&(:

@< &D

;;

D 1" *'"# $/'&"- * !2" $*&&<56"$!*& 2 & &/50%!!"# !2 ! %'$0" C%-")%'72 &,"**"!/*': $$*#%'7!#$/0"'!;3<?@4 & &:=:?D @<,"* ''/0!%&&/50%!!"#!2 !$- %0 '!& *"!4%''/05"* @ *# 0/'!$ '5"#"#/$!"#%'*"&,"$! ,"*&' -";,"'&"&2" /!/*"

,*&,"$!/&2 & -&'!5""'! >"'%'! $$/'!%'.%"4 /!2*%!+ 1 1/ (5112 3 4 3/-4 257 2"0/-!%,-%"* ,,-%$ 5-" !!2" 7" (? &,"* (0(- 801"3.24,%&!%& /*!2"*&/50%!!"#!2 !' 0/'!%'

*"&,"$! -&& $'&*!%/0 '#-&& -." '#

"$!%' 2 &5""'

--4"#!%& /*!2"*&/50%!!"#!2 !' 0/'!%'*"&,"$! ";,"'&"&'- &!

*%!"& '#!* '&,*! !%'2 &5""' --4"#):!2"& %# 0/'!5" -& --4"#%'.%"4 /!2*%!+ 11"3.242"*%5/' -2 & '!! >"'%'! $$/'!!2"%'$0">"",%'7%'.%"4!2"& - *+$"*!% %$ !" /'&"- *!2"'&/* '$"0, '+ &4"-- &)! !"$/'&"-2 ." &/,,*!"#!2" 4 *#, &&"#5+!2"*%5/' -2"7*&&& - *+2 &5""' &24' & & := @<,"*0'!2 & %& ".%#"'! *0 & - *+$"*!% %$ !"

;3?@42"*" &!2" %'$0"! ;2 &5""'#"#/$!"#!!2"";!"'!

@<4"."*:%'*"!/*' ''";"#!!2%&#$/0"'!:!2"%'$0" !2"

#"$" &"# *!2"+" *

2 &5""'&24' &&:= :

(@</!

= !2"& %# 0/'!!2"%'$0"! ;, + 5-"2 &5""'&24' &&:= @<):

!2"7*&&%'$0" !"*#"#/$!%'7%'$0"! ;$0"&!&: :

@<2"

$- %0 '!& *"!4%''/05"*):@ *# 0/'!2 &!5"#"#/$!"#%'*"&,"$! ,"*&' - ";,"'&"& ): !2" 0/'! +" *-+ #","'#"'$+ $0"& ! &:=:?@<,"*+" * 1" *'"# $/'&"- *!2" ,,"-- '!& 2 & &/50%!!"#!2 !!2"

/!/*",*&,"$!/&!!2"";!"'! (B5"! >"'%'! $$/'!%'.%"4

/!2*%!+ 11"3.244"."*:$ &" !2" ,,"-- '!&%& $."*"#5+ /!2*%!+(0(-801/9-1)2 2

3 4 3/-477, *"-%"#/,'5+!2"

-" *'"#$/'&"- *!2" ,,"-- '!&'!2"& %# /!2*%!+%!2 &5""'2"-#!2 !

/!/*",*&,"$!/&2 &!5"$'&%#"*"#'-+/,!!2" 7" ( +" *&):' 0/'! * /!/*",*&,"$!/&$ '5"7%."''!2" $!& !2",*"&"'!$ &" 2"0/-!%,-%"* !!2" 7" (?: $$*#%'7! (0(-80 1"3.24, %&):5+ ,,-+%'7!2"& %#0/-!%,-%"*!2" 0/'!

$0,"'& !%'$0"&!&:

:(D@< = 2"$*&&<56"$!*&<$- %0 '!& *" -&2"-#"'!%!-"#!$- %0 0/'!%'*"&,"$! ";,"'&"&'- &!*%!"&:!* '&,*! !%' #" #5#+:-&& $'&*!%/0 '#-&& -." '#

"$!%'>"",%'7%'.%"4 ,*%$"%'#";

!2"+" *

): &/0 &(:

@<&! '#& --4"#%'*"&,"$!

";,"'&"&'- &!*%!"& '#!* '&,*! !%'"!$'!2"*&/0 & (:

@< &! '#& --4"#%'*"&,"$! -&& $'&*!%/0 '#&/0 & (:

@< &! '#& --4"#' $$/'! -." '#

"$!%' ): %' !2%& 0 ''"* !2" $*&&<56"$!*&<$- %0 '!& *" 2"-#

"'!%!-"#!$- %0& :=?:(D@<%' --42%$2&2 --$ **+%'!"*"&!A IB ,"* ''/0 *0!2"# !" $- %0,"!%!%'5"

*"!2"*%5/' -!%--!2"# !"

*" -%H !%' '!2"0 ''"*%'#%$ !"# 5.":!2",*"&"'!$*&&<56"$!%'& &! '##%&,&"# $$*#%'7-+ $,+ !2%&6/#70"'!5"&"'!!!2"!*% -/*! *&!*%$!

$0,-% '$" 3*+'

4 &'9:% ; <, /