United India Insurance Company Ltd v. Simarjeet Kaur And ORS


 

      

   





 





     

  

    

 



    

 





 

   !  "##!$$"%&
'%()*"%+!  +,-#"%.  '(  "//*'!0!1  "/"'%(&  & ! "2"*11"&!13  #"((!14.& !,&,*++'1!%& $"'-(*'4)%"$ "& '%1"56,*( ,*&7& !*'4)%"$782 !*!4.'& "("2"*1!1"+,-#!%("&',% ,6  ( 9:
 &,  & !  +$"'-"%&(  "%1  6"(&!%!1  $'"4'$'&.  ;,'%&$. "%1 (!0!*"$$.)#,%& !"##!$$"%&1*'0!*"%1,2%!*,6& !,66!%1'%/0! '+$!

*'!6$. & !6"+&(,6& !+"(! "*! & "& ,%3  <&*)+= 4!"*'%/  *!/'(&*"&',%  , 

>>??  5,66!%1'%/  0! '+$!8  1*'0!%  4. *!(#,%1!%&, 
"%*#*!!&'%/ '%"*"( "%1%!/$'/!%&-"%%!*+"-! 6*,-2*,%/('1!,6& !*,"1"%1+,$$'1!1 !"1
,%2'& "%,'$&"%=!* 4!"*'%/*!/'(&*"&',%, 
3
>91*'0!%4."$1!0'%/ "%1*!()$&!1 '%-)$&'#$!'%;)*'!(&,"$1!0'%/  !2"(&"=!%&, '0'$,(#'&"$ "& '%1""%1& !*!"6&!* !2"(( '6&!1&,"@)#!*#!+'"$'&.,(#'&"$ "& '%1"4!'%/+*'&'+"$$.'%;)*!1 !2"(,#!*"&!1)#,%4)& !+,)$1%,& ()*0'0!"%1()++)-4!1&, '('%;)*'!(,%  <"&"@,(#'&"$ "& '%1"



%"++,)%&,61!"& ,6"$1!0'%/ & !+$"'-"%&(
"##!$$"%&( 6'$!1"+$"'-#!&'&',%)%1!!+&',%<<,6& !,&,* ! '+$!+&>AA"%1 +$"'-!1  "  +,-#!%("&',%  ,6 
?  $"= (  "$,%/2'&  '%&!*!(&  B  AC  #!* "%%)-

,&'+!,6& !+$"'-#!&'&',%2"((!*0!1&,& !*!(#,%1!%&( ,2!0!*  *!(#,%1!%&(  ,     51*'0!*  "%1  ,2%!*  *!(#!+&'0!$.  ,6  & ! ,66!%1'%/&*)+=8"%1*!(#,%1!%&, D5,2%!*,6,'$&"%=!*81'1%,&"##!"* "%12!*!#*,+!!1!1"/"'%(&!@
#"*&!



!(#,%1!%&, 3
%'&!1%1'"%()*"%+! ,-#"%.+,%&!(&!1 & !+$"'-4.6'$'%/2*'&&!%(&"&!-!%&"%1*"'(!1#*!$'-'%"*.,4;!+&',%(,6 -"'%&"'%"4'$'&.


"%1,%-!*'&(#$!"1!1& "&%,"++'1!%&&,,= 2'&  &*)+=  , 

>>??  "%1  #*".!1  6,*  1'(-'(("$  ,6  & !  +$"'- #!&'&',%

 !  *'4)%"$  "6&!*  "##*!+'"&'%/  & !  !0'1!%+!  ,%  *!+,*1 "$$,2!1& !+$"'-#!&'&',%"%1 !$1*!(#,%1!%&(, "%1$'"4$!&,#".

& !  +,-#!%("&',% ;,'%&$. "%1  (!0!*"$$. "%1  *!(#,%1!%& , 3
'%()*"%+!

+,-#"%.  2"(  1'*!+&!1  &,  #". & !  "2"*1!1  +,-#!%("&',%  "&  & !  6'*(& '%(&"%+!2'& "*'/ &&,*!+,0!*& !("-!6*,-*!(#,%1!%&(, "%1

!%+!& '("##!"$  !"*%!1  +,)%(!$  6,*  & !  "##!$$"%&
'%()*"%+!  +,-#"%.  "( "*/)!1& "&& !*'4)%"$2 '$!1!+'1'%/& !'(()!*!$"&'%/&,& !$'"4$'&. &,2"*1(#".-!%&,6+,-#!%("&',%&,& !+$"'-"%&( "(!**,%!,)($.1!+'1!1 "/"'%(&& !'%()*"%+!+,-#"%.4.'/%,*'%/& !+,%&*'4)&,*.%!/$'/!%+!,% & !#"*&,6& !0'+&'-2 ,2"(1*'0'%/& !,'$&"%=!* !()4-'&(& "&& !

3
,66!%1'%/0! '+$!1*'0!%4.*!(#,%1!%&, 2"(-,0'%/,%& !$!6&('1!

,6& !*,"1"%1& !,66!%1'%/0! '+$!1*'0!%4.& !0'+&'-+"-!,%& ! ,##,('&!('1!*!()$&'%/'%"++'1!%&"%11!"& ,6"$1!0'%/ %()##,*& ,6 '("*/)-!%& ! "(*!$'!1)#,%& !!%E)'*.*!#,*&4.& !5,$'+!8 @

F: &,  ()4-'&  & "&  "(  #!*  & !  *!#,*&  & !  0'+&'-  '-(!$6  2"( %!/$'/!%&'%1*'0'%/& !,'$&"%=!*& !*!6,*!& !6'%1'%/*!&)*%!14.& ! *'4)%"$'(%,&()(&"'%"4$!

#"*&6*,-& '( ! "('%0'&!1& !"&&!%&',%,6& ! ,)*&&,& !

+*,((
!@"-'%"&',%,6 F
"4 '%/ & !"$$!/!1!.!2'&%!((,6& '( "++'1!%&2 !*!'% !"1-'&&!1& "& !*!"+ !1& !(#,&"6&!*& !"++'1!%& "%1,%& "&1".'&2"("6,//.2!"& !* !"*%!1+,)%(!$ "("*/)!1& "& & !!0'1!%+!,6"4 '%/ *!$"&'%/&,"++'1!%&"%1%!/$'/!%+!,61*'0!*,6 ,66!%1'%/0! '+$!+"%%,&4!*!$'!1)#,%& !*!6,*!& !6'%1'%/1!(!*0!(&, 4!(!&"('1!

 6&!* !"*'%/$!"*%!1+,)%(!$"%1+,%('1!*'%/& !!0'1!%+!,% *!+,*1  & '( ,)*&  6'%1(  & "&  & !  !%E)'*. *!#,*&  4. & !   5,$'+!8 @

F:*!$'!1)#,%4."##!$$"%&'(%,&"+,%0'%+'%/#'!+!,6!0'1!%+! &, ,$1& "&0'+&'-"$1!0'%/ 2"(%!/$'/!%&'%1*'0'%/& !,'$&"%=!*"( 1)*'%/  & !  +,)*(!  ,6  !"*'%/  '&  '(  (&"&!1  4.  $!"*%!1  +,)%(!$  & "& +"%+!$$"&',%*!#,*&6,)%1!1,%& !("'1!%E)'*.*!#,*&2"(%,&"++!#&!14. & !"/'(&*"&!"%16)*& !*'%0!(&'/"&',%2"(,*1!*!1  !*!'(%,!0'1!%+!

,%*!+,*1&,'%1'+"&!& "&& !0! '+$!1*'0!%4."$1!0'%/ +*,((!1& ! 1'0'1!*&, '&& !,66!%1'%/0! '+$!1*'0!%4."%;'&'%/  !*!6,*!'& +"%%,&4!("'1& "&& !0'+&'-2"("$(,%!/$'/!%&'%+")('%/& !"++'1!%&

D
)*& !*"#!*)("$,6& !'-#)/%!1"2"*1( ,2(& "&& !*'4)%"$ "( +"*!6)$$.!@"-'%!1& !6"+&(!0'1!%+!,%*!+,*1"%1*'/ &$.*!&)*%!1& ! 6'%1'%/"/"'%(&& !"##!$$"%&  ,,& !*#,'%&2"("*/)!14.& !$!"*%!1+,)%(!$

!()$&"%&$.%,+"(!'(-"1!,)&6,*'%&!*6!*!%+!4.& '( ,)*& "(& !'-#)/%!1"2"*11,!(%,&()66!*6*,-"%.#!*0!*('&.

 !"##!"$'(1'(-'((!1

 )/)(&

  )$"&'

  F !& !* !#,*&"4$!

 !(:, F !& !*#!"='%/:

!"(,%!1  !(:,