Subhash Chander v. Davinder Singh And ORS




   

 


 

 !!"#$#%&'  ()*+$++%,!- +-).+/ $               00!11% 
2 ( (            3#%,!-(#%.+ -$      !$0%,!% $  & 4/

 (
(5/

  

      

 



 !

   "#$  % &  666
(5/
7  / '

 



 
  









 
 




  


  











 


!"#$!#$%%&#

'#
#
( 
) 

 


*




+#,



 

*






+#-


(
(
.
 #


-#
#
(
.
 






+#-#
/









+#-
 $$#!$#'!$%



$0#!$#'!$%
 
 

*







 89
 
* 






(
(
.
 
 


*
  
'$#!$#'!$%



 
  #
1 
 
*


*

 
*
 


* 















(
(
.
 



*


 

*




 










+#
-#

(






 

$%%&
 





'!!$
 
2






 


 
#



*



+#
-

 34


 

 
  


 







+#,
2
 
* 
 

 #
"#
5
 







*


5

*







0'




 






0!

 





0!



  
 

*


 
 #
5
 










*






 







2


 

$%%&4%%


$%%%4'!!!
 

*





 06!!!  


 6'-,!74
 





 *




 

*
+#-,

-6



 

 



&!!!!!74
##

'#0


$!!8









*
  
 







*

0
9
 



3 

0!!!!74





*






*#
5
 






  


 




   



*


$!!8



 











 

 

* 
 : 



#

5
 


 8:9




*



:  


 





 ##






*
 




*


 
*

 


 


  

*
 

 #
;





  
#
0#
2
 



   


 


  #
,#
   






*







 #

1



















 
 
 
 



 




1 
<


 


 

<.2(









1 
)




  

 




 #
 




 



2

(


2 
 
= 
> 
+
) 




  

 #





0



 
 #









?3#<4$-$
  

*
+#-,


 





$!!8






* 

 

 


 
 
 
*
*

   

 




  #




 

<@46
)#
(


.


A


) 
<.2(
#



<@4$!
( 




>
<.2(


 


 





* 
 

)$
 

* 


 





  



:


 












 

 




  
 


 
















* 
*


 

 89

 
*


















*

 

 


 


*#

*






 
 







 
 *   #
























  

 #



6#
)

*










$!#!0#'!!6
 
 
59

 #

(







$!!8













*




* 








 
 











*

 









 

 






*



*




  







 




 




*

*

#
0!!!!74





*





*#
2 
 



 

  

 
*












 
 







*


$!!8








*







*#





 

 


2 
3
 

9
$%%&4$%%%


$%%%4'!!!
 

*





06!!!74

6'-,!74
##
?3#$-!


?3#
$'%
 #


&#
5
 


 

*

*

 

 

*





0!




5

*







0'
#


  

3

 



*

   
  
  





*



5#


 8;9



1 9 

(


(-12!-<2$!1+# -%$0- -0%,% +!-7':

 #3#1 ==




*
*
0$

00
  

$$

  #


*
  

$$


 





*


 #
%#












3
 
$!8

 
  





3
 
 






  


 



 
 
*
+#,$





1 9 

(


 #%1
%$)-%"!<0%>/#<# !,3$ -%>(! +# %, +!-$7=  #3#1 '



 
*
+#$0



1 9 

(






 

  









0'


*



 #



*





 



$!8

 
  






3
 
 


 



 #
$!#



 
 

 








 







 





*
 
*






*















3 #
$$#
   





 





 




* 
 




*
$!!8










 





*



#










!"#$!#$%%&


$!#!0#'!!6#

2
( 
=9













 


 
 


  
1 9 

(





*




 89




  


 

 
 
B 





-!!!!!74








*

 

*

 
 






*




  



 



  

 








 #

$'#














 






* 






 
 

 #











 



( 
=9

 #

1 




 


 

$!#!0#'!!6
##
 
%'
 
 

!!!!!74

  


 








*#
+

 






*#



 












 


*










 
 

##

!"#$!#$%%&

$!#!0#'!!6


















*#

$-#
 





 

 
 
 


#




 



*
 















 






$!!!74

 


 
 

#


*





 



%'!!!74

 






!"#$!#$%%&
 


 

##
$!#!0#'!!6#







 



  
*







3 #

2

  
 



((((()# !

 !

      

 8=9
  $    * + '( (, -((.$ !  !


'((((()#   /!  & 
'((((()#  !

       / 0  
-,((()#!

    $"#
1 9 

(






  !   " #
$
 



 


 


 

608










  
  





 



*




*


  

 





-!!!!!74

 








3


#
2


 










 




* 
 

 

 

 












%'
 

!"#$!#$%%&
 
$!#!0#'!!6



#

2

  
2

 





'!!!!!74





 



 






3


#

$0#


*


 *





  

59



 


 




 C
(-  !, <)%  $$!$$!, *> -#*)%1 #%
 <)%  $$!$$!, *> +#$ )- #%
  '
$ 
.- "()# 


.- "()# 

1


'(23.- ")# .- "()#4.- ")#3.5,5")# 6
 


'' -

 8?9
,
%     

    0&
0!!!!

6%0%,743$$D&6000,74
-,(((()#  - 7   - 7

 5-((()# 8   -,((()#  - 7 1 /' 7    .      
, 7
, 7
"   

          

     9
8 
&!!!!!74
'$%'00,74
'"

 &         0 

 * + !

 
-'5-,,")#    
9((((()# !

0&  80  !:52   !     ;

 

&  &  $ % &  / 0& &  

 !
 & < * + 

'.

 &    !  !

   (

(6 -(('  0&  % 80   7 /  0 (5/
  %)->7'      
0$ = 7)  >) 
= 0 >) 

 8'9