High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7152/2026dismissed

Bant Singh Through Lrs v. Financial Commissioner Punjab And Others

2026-04-09Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger5 pages

"#$ '$()*)%+

, ,

"+# -)+./

*)+($ '$($"*$' #/0%1./ 2*

,,,,,,$#)#)%+$0 3$0*1*

1+7"8 %#/$0*

,,,,,, $*9%+'$+#* :2 ,

- - 0$*$+# 0,

8/)*/$;

-)+.4"6

'<%("#$ 9$#)#)%+$0,

0, )05"47)# -)+./ )="+"6 -$+)%0

1+7"8,

, , - 6

, 0">$0 1+'$0

0#)(4$* %+*#)#1#)%+ +')"6 )+#$0 "4)"6 )**1"+($ +"#10$ ($0#)%0"0) *$##)+.

"*)'$

, ,

6 9"**$'

*# 0"'$6 $/"4 @"4"+

*/%0# %44$(#%0:6 =/$0$8> %87$(#)%+* *185)##$'

00":

')*5)**$'

00":

*"+(#)%+$',

&10#/$0 90">$0 *$##)+.

"*)'$ A, ,

6 9"**$'

%44$(#%0(15

6 "0+"4"

*/%0# :%44$(#%0:6 =/$0$8>

, ,

6 9"**$'

')*5)**$',

+%#/$0 90">$0 *$##)+.

"*)'$ A, ,

B6 9"**$'

"#)"4"

)<)*)%+6 "#)"4"

*/%0# : )<)*)%+"4 %55)**)%+$0: , B,

6 9"**$'

%55)**)%+$0

99$"4*6 1+7"8

*/%0# %55)**)%+$0:6 =/$0$8> 0$<)*)%+ 9$#)#)%+*6 90$&$00$'

00":6 ')*5)**$'6 0$*9$(#)<$4>, , 0)$&4>6 0$*9%+'$+#* %, *%1./# 4"+'

5$"*10)+.

"04"6 *)#1"#$'

"# <)44".$ /"1/"+ @$ @"4"+6 $/*)4 )*#0)(# "0+"4"6 <)'$ "994)("#)%+

, , "&%0$*")'

:00":

("5$ "990%<$'6 <)'$ A, A,

9"**$'

%44$(#%0, $#)#)%+$0 (4")5* 4"+'

$?#$+# "04"D /$ *")'

"0$"6 <)'$ #=% *"4$ '$$'* , ,,

6 0$*9$(#)<$4>D /%=$<$06 +%# .)<$+ '1$ */"0$, ,

$$4)+.

"..0)$<$'

:00":6 90$&$00$'

8$&%0$ %44$(#%06 ("5$ ')*5)**$'6 <)'$ , ,

,A -#)44 "..0)$<$'6 90$&$00$'

0$<)*)%+

A 8$&%0$

/%=$<$06 '10)+.

9$+'$+(> "&%0$*")'

0$<)*)%+ 9$#)#)%+6 00":

("5$ 90%9%*$'

*185)##$'

%87$(#)%+* , ,

D /%=$<$06

*"5$ ')*5)**$'

<)'$

, ,

$$4)+.

"..0)$<$'

, ,

6 90$&$00$'

8$&%0$ %44$(#%06 ')*5)**$'6 <)'$ A, ,

, -#)44 "..0)$<$'6 90$&$00$'

0$<)*)%+ 8$&%0$ )<)*)%+"4 %55)**)%+$0D /%=$<$06 *"5$ ')*5)**$'6 <)'$ A, ,

/$0$"&#$06 *$(%+'

0$<)*)%+

A 8$&%0$

%55)**)%+$0,

, # #0"+*9)0$* 8%#/ 0$<)*)%+ 9$#)#)%+*6

),$, A

A6 ("5$ ')*5)**$'6 <)'$ (%55%+ , B,

A, "&%0$5$+#)%+$'

()0(15*#"+($*6 *$$;)+.

0$4)$& *6 +%#)($'

/$0$)+"8%<$,

, $"0',

, /$ %+4> "0.15$+# 0")*$'

(%1+*$4 /$ "04"

"0$"6 <)'$ *"4$ '$$'* , ,,

6 0$*9$(#)<$4>D /%=$<$06 "44%##$'

%+4> A "04"6 #/$0$8> ("1*)+.

'$&)()$+(>

"04"6 =)#/%1# "+> 8"*)*,

, 10)+.

(%10*$ /$"0)+.

9$#)#)%+6 *9$()&)( F1$0> 0")*$'

(%1+*$4 =/"# ;/$="#6 9$0 :00":,

, 0$*9%+*$ *")'

F1$0>6 (%1+*$4 &")04> *#"#$'

0$(%0'$'

:00":

%+4> $?#$+# "04", /$0$&%0$6 %+($ 4"+'

&%1+'

%+4> "04"

&)+"4 9"0#)#)%+6 '1$ */"0$ "44%("#$'

/)5D "((%0')+.4>6 +% &"14# ("+ &%1+'

=)#/ *"5$,

# &10#/$0 *9$()&)("44> "*;$'

&0%5 (%1+*$4 =/$#/$0 $<$0 4")'

"+> (/"44$+.$ $+#0)$* 0$(%0'$'

0$<$+1$ 0$(%0'

%0 (/"44$+.$'

"04"

&)4)+.

*1)# 0$."0',

, 0$*9%+*$ *")'

F1$0>6 (%1+*$4 &")04> *#"#$'

#)44 '"#$6 +%# "+> *1)# $)#/$0 (/"44$+.)+.

$+#0)$* 0$<$+1$ 0$(%0'

%0 (/"44$+.)+.

'$#$05)+$'

0$<$+1$ "1#/%0)#)$*6 =/)4$ 90$9"0)+.

:00":,

B, 2$"0+$'

=/)4$ 0$7$(#)+.

(4")5 9$#)#)%+$06 0$#10+$'

*9$()&)( &)+')+.

9$0 0$(%0'*6 4"+'

&0%5 (%*/"0$0*6 =/% *%4'

5%0$ #/"+ #/$)0 0$(%0'$'

*/"0$6 #/$0$&%0$6 ("++%# (4")5 "+> 4"+'

8$>%+'

=/"# <$+'%0 $+#)#4$'

9$0 0$<$+1$ 0$(%0'*,

# &10#/$0 %8*$0<$'

%55)**)%+$0 "40$"'> 9%**$**)%+ 4"+'

5%0$ #/"+ "(#1"4 */"0$ 4"+'

"+'6 #/$0$&%0$6 #/$0$ +% $00%0 00":,

B, 2$"0+$'

(%1+*$4 &")4$'

')*4%'.$ "&%0$*")'

%8*$0<"#)%+*

%55)**)%+$0,

, @$$9)+.

<)$= "8%<$ ')*(1**)%+6 *$$ +% (%59$44)+.

0$"*%+*6 5"> ="00"+# )+#$0&$0$+($ #/)* %10# 90$*$+# 90%($$')+.*,

, $*14#"+#4>6 &")4* *"5$ "((%0')+.4>6 ')*5)**$',

, $+')+.

"994)("#)%+

*6 )& "+>6 */"44 *#"+'

(4%*$',

, ,

*7;* /$#/$0 *9$";)+.0$"*%+$'

!$*

% /$#/$0 0$9%0#"84$ !$*