High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1198/1998allowed

Reshmi v. State Of Haryana

2025-09-17Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja8 pages

56'('(%$ 56'('(%$ 56'('(%$ 56'('(%$ ,'% ,'% ,'% ,'%

: $1&&%1'%/1,% $1&&%1'%/1,% $1&&%1'%/1,% $1&&%1'%/1,% %166& %166& %166& %166&

= = = = =F 22%33,&'

22%33,&'

22%33,&' ".

". %2&/%&'

%2&/%&'

%2&/%&'9: $%%&'

!" # !" # !" # !" # (60,+6&8((,*(,&./01 ()#*+,$#(*--,$./01 1,'% 1,'% ,$+,&2$%%'#,*$./01,'% '(%,22%33,&'43,&/5&%$ -(6&,(,6&..,$?,& &, ,&76'6&8(./01,'% " $%2&/%&'=6&

EEEE .9$,3:

.9$,3:

# # # # ; < 6/ /%'(61++&$/%$.,-*&1( = %8*3,$6$'22%,3./%'

,63 5(61(,$%860 0%&6&'(% '&'% '(67*/8 8+%&'.,$%-%6&8/%16/%/,,33 ,22%,3 (,0% ,$ $6%& *' 1++& ,1>*66'6 &45,$/ 6&0306&8 1++& , ,1' ,&/ >*%'6&

3,5 $ '(% ,)% -$%06'?.

. ,1' ,$% -%6&8 ',)%& $+

: ;=< ? 5,? 2$%%&',22%,3.1(,33%&8 8%(,-%%&3,6/''(%5,$//, ,'%/ = =

2, %/-?'(%3%,$&%///36'$61'

'*/8%.,8,/($69(%$%6&, '%$' -% $% %$$%/,'(%@ % %$%&1%*$'A:.5(%$%-?%

%$%&1%%'6'6& 63%/*&/%$%1'

'6&

'(%",&/ 1>*66'6&1'.

B9 $($'

'@'(%

B1'A:,''(%6&',&1% %

'(%3,&/5&%$9

:5,2,$'3?,335%/5(63%8$,& &'6&8'(%+'(%-%&% 6' %&(,& 1%/ +,$)%' 0,3*% G G =.F

4J 2%$ ,1$% $ 8,6$ 6$ +*+)6& 3,&/ -%6/% ,5,$/ /6&8

B1' ','*'$?-%&% 6'

'46&'%$%',2$06/%/*&/%$'(% ;H< $ 6% 3?','6&8.6&'(%2$%%&'1,% %.3,&/+%,*$6&8 ,1$%9HF

68(, = 65 ,: 6'*,'%/ 56'(6& '(% $%0%&* *% %','% 0633,8% *I,(,/5 ,3,. %(63((,1(($ $,*36.1,+%'-%,1>*6$%/06/% '6 61,'6&/,'%/ H

, =

H6*% %/*&/%$%1'6&BCD

B1'$%2%1'60%3? $23,&','

'6& 6&0633,8% *I, ,(,/5,3,. 335%/-?,&5,$ $/2,%/-?'(%",&/1>*66'

'6& 33%1'$ 9 ($' @'(% "A: & =

BM ,%6&8 '(% +,$)%' 0, ,3*% GB F4J2%$ ,1$% $,6$ *+)6&3,&/,&/ /=B $23,&',3 &8 56'(,33'(%$', ,'*'$?-%&% 6',2$06/%/*&/% %$'(%

B1' ;B< ( (% ,22%33,&'9:J3,&/5&%$9:. %% %36&8 /6,'6 6%/ 56'( '(% 5, ,$/.

63%/-7%1'6&2 2%'6'6&*&/%$%1'6&

B1'.23%,/6&8'(,'6+63,$) )6&/ 3,&/ 5, ,1 1>*6$%/ -? ?/%3 $7%1' %2 2,$'+%&' $ 6' 2$7%1' 6& 0633 ,8% (*/),3,&,&/ %8*+2*$5(61(,$%6'*,'%/& &%,$0633,8% *I,(,/5,3,,&/ "'(%$%6&(,/ /,5,$/%/1+2%&,'6&

4J2%$,1$% ;B < 2 & &'61%. $%2&/%&'J','% 1& &'%'%/ '(% ,+% 5(63% *-+6''

'6&8 '(,',5,$/+,/% %-?3%,$&%/33%1'$5,,11 $/6&8''(%$,'%2$%0,636&8,' %'-%/6+6%/ '6+% &'6 61,'

'6&,&/'(*.'(%,+%5,36,-3 ;F< & & '(% -,6 23%,/6&8 '(% 2,$'6%. '(% 3356&8 6*% 5 5%$%

$,+%/-?'(%3% %,$&%/% %$%&1%*$' $1&6 6/%$,'6& J K

(,'5,'(%+,$)%'0,3*% 6*,&1% &'6 61,'6&*&/% 1'.

BL '(%,1>*6$%/3,&/,''(%'6+% %$%1'6&B '(%",&/1>*66'

'6&

(%'(%$'(%2%'6'6&%$6%&'6 '$%%L 6&5(,',+*&'L 6'3%/',&?1+2%&,'6& $,&?

? H

(%'(%$'(%2%'6'6&%$6,3 (6(,$% $'(%,1>*66'6& %&'6'3%/'1+2%&,'6&,2%$ (,+3,'3,&/L $ B %36% O ;D< & $/%$ ' 2$0% '(%6$ 1,%. '( (% ,22%33,&' %N,+6&%/ 56'&% % 6&13*/6&8 J &,+%3? (,88* ,+. J=J *$,& (,&/. #,&*&8. ,&/

JB ,+ ",3 ,&/ '

'%&/%$%/ /1*+%&' 6% ,3% / %%/ N J . NJ= ,&/ N JH $%2%1'60%3?2 22%33,&',3'%&/%$%/6&%06/%& &1%126% ,3%/%%/NJD, 126% 5,$/ /NJ 'NJ D%',63

$%3%0,&'5,$/NJ .NJ

' NJ =,$%%N'$ $,1'%/(%$%*&/%$ $$% %$%&1% J N(6-6' *$2 % 6'6& %,$ 5,$/ 633,8% # "

%3%1'$61 #6&/ ",&/ $61% ',3 ,1>*66 NJ ?/$% $7%1'

NJ ?/$% $7%1'

%/(,$ ,&7,$ H

4J 2%$,1$%

,$,&6 J %3%1'$61 1'

%8*+2*$ H

1$%

=#J

(,(6 F

4 =B

4J $*1'6& ,/ $+ ,6$

*+)6& J NJ &'$

%8*+2*$ F

4J H 4J

$, # +,632 NJ ?/$% ,/' 32*$ ,$,&6 %3%1'$61 1'

J %8*+2*$ %3%1'$61 ,6$

*+)6& = 4J

,6$

*+)6& = 4J

J $7%1'

NJ = ?/$% 1'

J %8*+2*$ $7%1'

;D < & '(% '(%$ (,&/. '(% $%2&/%& &' %N,+6&%/ &% ,$%( #*+ +,$. %+,$1,'6&* *2%$06$. $+'(%

61% ,+*&,,8,$,&/'%&/% %$%/ 126% ,3%/% %%/NJ 'NJB

;

< '

'%$ ,22$%16,'6&8 '(% %06/%&1% 3%/ -? '(% 2,$'6%. '(% 3%,$& &%/ % %$%&1%(%3/ '(,',3%/%%/NJ='N JD5(61(5%$%$%36%/*2&-? ,22%33,&' 1*3/ / &' $+ -,6 $ /%'%$+6&6 6&8 2$61% '(% 3,&/ , '(% , ,+% 2%$',6&%/'+, ,332,$1%3 3,&/*$'(%$.'(% ,3%/%%/NJ 'NJB5 5%$% $%7%1'%/-?'(%3 3%,$&%/% %$%&1%*$'&'(%8 8$*&/'(,'&%6'(%$'(%0%&/$ &$ '(% 0%&/%%

'(%% ,3% /%%/ 5%$% %N,+ +6&%/ ' 2$0% '(% '$,&,1'6 & 5%0%$. '(% 3% %,$&%/ % %$%&1% *$' %&(,&1 1%/ '(% 1+2%&,'6& ' =F

4J 2%$,1$% $8,6$ $+*+)6&3,&/ 88 8$6%0%/ '(% , $%+%&'6&% %/ 5,$/ /,'%/ = =

. 2$%%&'%8*3,$ $6$'22%,39:5%$% 63% %/-?'(%,22%33,&'43,&/5&%$ , 5%33,-?'(%'

','% ;

< +2 2*8&6&8 '(% , $%+%&'6&%/ 5,$/. 3%,$&%/ 1*&%3 ,22%33,&'43,&/5 5&%$ *-+6' '(,' '(% 3%,$&%/ / % %$%&1% *$' 5(63% +,) )6&8 ,%+%&' + +,$)%'0,3*%. ,63%/'$%3?*2& &'(%5,$/NJ ,&/NJ

' NJ =2,%/ -?'(%"5(61(5%$%$%3,'6&8 8',1>*66'6& 3,&/2%$',6&6&8 8' $%0%&*% %','% 633,8% %/(,$ ,&/%8* *+2*$ "%,$&%/1*&%3 26&' *' '(,' -'( '(% $%0%&*% %','% ,$% ,-*''6&8 8 '(% $%0%&*% %','% 633 ,8%

*I,(,/5,3, 5(61( '(% 2$%%&' ,1>*66'6 & 2$1%%/6&8 $%3,'% ' % '

(* *-+6' '(,' 5( (63% $%3?6&8 *2& '(% 5,$/ NJ 5(%$%-?. '(% +,$)%' 0, ,3*% 56'($%2%1''/ /,'% '6 61,'6&/,'%/

=6*%/*&/%$%1'6&B

B1'5,, %%/,F

$(,(63,&/,&/H 4J2%$, ,1$%

$ ,$,&6 3,&/ /. '(% ,%+%&' (*3/ (,0% - -%%& +,/% 6& '(% 2$%%&' 1,% -? 8$,&'6&8,22$2 $6,'%%1,3,'6&'(%$%*2& $'( (%2%$6/ /6

%$%&1%-%'5%%&

'5 &'6 61,'6&

& 6%

= ,&/ H

% '(* *-+6' '(,' 5 5,$/ 2,%/-?'(%3% ,$&%/% %$%&1%*$'5,36,-3 3%'-%+/6 6%/,11$/6&83? ;

< & '(%'(%$(,&/.3%,$&%/1*&% %3 $$%2&/%&'J','%*-+6''

'(,' &1% '(% ,3% / /%%/ NJ ' NJB $%3,'6& &8 ' '(% ,+% $%0%&*% %','% 6% 633,8% *I,(, ,/5,3, 5%$% 2$/*1%/ & $%1$ $/ -? '(% $%2&/%&'. '(% 5, ,$/ NJ ,&/N J 'NJ =5(61(5%$%2,% %/-?'(%",&/5%$%$%3,'6&8 8' '(% ,1>*66'6& /6

%$%&' $%0%&*% %','% 5% %$% &' ' -% $%36%/ *2& "%,$& &%/ ','% 1*&%3 *

*$'(%$ 26&' *' '(,' '(% ,3% 6&',&1% NJ ' NJB 5 5%$% /61,$/%/-?'(% %3%,$&%/% %$%&1%*$'&3?

$'(%$%,&'(,''(%0%&/$, 0%&/%%'(%$%

5%$%&'%N,+6&%/&'(6$%8 8,$/(%*-+6''(,',2%$%1'

'6& F J

B1'.'(%1%$'6 6%/126% '( (%,3%6&',&1%NJ 'N JB 5%$%'-%$%36%/ /*2&,2,$' ,/+66-3%%06/ /%&1% ;

< "%, ,$&%/','%1*&%3,3*-+6'

''(,',2%$,3%/%%/NJ ' NJB.'(%,3% 2$61% '(%,1>*6$%/3,&/,& '(%/,'% &'6 61,'6&5,,$* *&/ H

4J ' B D4J 5(%$%,. '(% " (,/ ,3$%,/? ,5,$/%/ +,$)%' 0,3*% G B F4J2%$,1$ $% $,6$ *+)6&3,&/,&/ =B $23,&'%'

(* *-+6''(,'5 5,$/2,%/-?3%,$&%/% %$%&1 1%*$'5,36,-3%'-%%', 6/% 5,'-%$%'$%/ ,&/'(,' " ;

< ( (,0% (%,$/ 3%,$&%/ 1*&%3 '(% 2,$'6% ,&/ 8&% '($*8( 2,2%$ -)

6&/ *-',&1% 6& '(% *-+ +66& +,/% & -%(,3 ,22%33,&'9:43,&/ /5&%$9: ; < %$ $*,3 $%1$/(5'(,''(% ,3%6&',&1%2$0%/&$%1$/ /-? '(%$%2&/%&' 6&'(% $+ NJ 'N JB$%3,'%/''(%$%0%&*%%','% % 0633,8% *I,(, /5,3, ,&/ '(% (68(%' ,3% 2$61 1% 2%$ ,1$% 5, B D4J 2%$ , ,1$%

9NJB: *$'(

(%$. 2%$*,3 5,$/ /,'%/ =

B 2,%/ -? '(% " 6& %N%$16% 25 5%$*&/%$%1'6&

B1'.(5'(,''(%+,$)%'0, ,3*% '(%,1>*6$%/3 3,&/5,,%%/GB F4J2% %$,1$% $,6$ *+)6&3,&/5( (63% $%3?6&8 *2& 1 33%1'$ $,'% '(% ,$%, (*. &1% '(% ,3% 6&',&1%. NJ ' NJB 5%$% %N N%1*'%/ $ '(% 3%$ 0,3*% '( (,& '(% 133%1'$ $,'% '(% , ,$%, 1&1%$&%/M '(% ,+% 5%$% &' ' -% '%$+% %/ , -&, 6/% '$,&,1'6& , ,11$/6&83?&' '-%$%36%/*2& $'(%2*$2 % ,%+%&' +,$)%'0,3*% %6& $%3,'6&''(%2$ $%%&',1>*66'6& ; =< *$ $'(%$. & 6&'$*1'6& $+

1%$ 1&1%$&%/. 5( 6 2$%%&' 6&J 2%$&. 6' (, & &' -%%& /62*'%/ -? '(% 3%,$& &%/ ','% 1*&%3 '(,' '(% $%0%& &*% %','% 0633,8 8% %/(,$ ,&/ *I,(,/5,3, , ,$% ,/76&6&8 ,&/ ,-*''6&8 (% ,1>*66'6& 6& '(% 2$%%&' 1,% $%3,'% ' '(% $%0%&*% %','% 0633 ,8%

*I,(,/5,3, (% ,22%33,&'43,&/5&%$ (,0% % 23,1%/ & $%1$/ NJ 6% 5,$//,'%/

'(%",&/1>*66'6 6&33%1'$.*-361 $)9C C: %2,$'+%&'.+ +-,3,6'?2,%/6&%N%$16% 25%$*&/%$%1'6&

B1'56'($ $%2%1'''(%,1>*6$%/3,&/ $ $+6&82,$' '(%$%0%&*%%','% % 0633,8% %/(,$ $ ,6/ 3,&/ 5, *8(' ' -% % ,1>*6$%/ 06/% '6 61,'6& /, ,'%/ D

6* *%/ *&/%$ %1'6& B '(%

B 1' ,&/ '(% +,$)%' 0,3*% 5 5, ,%%/GH H.

$,&7,$#,/6+ +3,&/ ; H< & *1( 16$1*+',&1%. '(% $%0%&* *% %','% 0633,8% %/(,$ ,

*I,(,/5,3, - -%6&8 ,/76&6&8 ,&/ ,-*''6&8. '

'(% /%'%$+6&,'6& +,$)%' 0, ,3*% +,/% -? '(% "

,&/ 1>*66'6& 33%1'$ 56'( ( $%2%1' ' '(% $%0%&*% %','% % 0633,8%%/(,$ $6&$%3,'6&''(%-681(*&) 3, ,&/+%,*$6&8H

#,&,3 , ,$3,. ,1>*6$%/06/% '6 61,'6&/,'%/= D

6 *%/*&/%$ %1'6& B

1'-%6&8$%3%0,

,&',&/2$N6+,'%6&'%$+ '6+ +%2%$6/.5,'-%$%36%/*2& && 06%5 '(% ,1 1' '(,' '(%$% 5, , /6

%$%&1% ,$*&/ = +&'( -%'5%%& '6 61,'6&/,'% %/= D

6*%/*&/%$%1'

'6&B

B1'6&$%3,'6& &' 5,$/NJ , ,&/'(%'6 61,'6&/,'%/ H

6*%/*&/%$%1'6&B

B1'6&'(% %2$%%&',1>*66'6&M5(63%23,1 16&8$%36,&1%*2&%(3,/ %(3,/ %(3,/ %(3,/,+, ,+, ,+, ,+, '(%$0,$?, '(%$0,$?, '(%$0,$?, '(%$0,$?, ,&,$-,&%0%32+%&'*'($6 ,&,$-,&%0%32+%&'*'($6 ,&,$-,&%0%32+%&'*'($6 ,&,$-,&%0%32+%&'*'($6 6'?,&/'(%$.= B9 B:

6'?,&/'(%$.= B9 B:

., 1*+*3,'60% 6&1$ $%,% G P 2%$ ,&&*+ &%%/ ' -% ,5,$/%/ 6& ,0*$ 3,&/5&%$ $'

'(%2%$6/ /6

%$%&1%-%'5%%& &'(%'5&'6 61,'6&(%$%3%0 0,&' 2,$,8$,2( F F '(%,6/7*/8+%&'6$%2$/* *1%/(%$%*&/%$ J K F F ' 6 ,3 %06/%&' $+ '(% 3,5 $% %$$%/ ' (%$%6&,-0% '(, ,' , 1*+ +*3,'60%6&1$%,% ' F2%$1% %&'2%$?%,$6&'(%+,$)%'0,3*%

3,&/ &/+,?-%,11%2'%/*&3%'(%','% %,8%&16%$,1>*6$6&8,*'($6'?2$ $0% '(% (%$56%O ; B< 11 1$/6&83?. '(% +,$)%' 0,3*% 6& '(% 2$%%&' 1,% 6 ,% %/ GH

4J2% %$,1$% $'(%,1>*6$%/3,&/.,3 &856'(,33'(%$','*'$?-%&% % 6' ,3&8 56'( 6&'%$ $%' , 2$06/%/ *&/%$ '(% 2$0 066& '(%

B 1' 9,+%&/ /%/ *2' /,'%: (% % 3,&/5&%$ (,33 ,3 -% %&'6 6'3%/ $ 3,'6*+ G H P -%6 6/% ,5,$/ 6&'%$% ''(%$%*2&,5%33 ; F< & &%>*%&'3?. 6& 06%5 '(% /6 61*6& +,/% (%$%6& ,-0%. ,22%,3 2$% %$$% %/ ,' '(% 6&',&1% ,22%33,&'9 9:J3,&/5&%$9: ,$% (%$%-? 2,$ $'3? ,335%/6&'(%, , $%,6/'%$+,&/'(%,22%,3

63%/-?'(%','% ,$?,&,, ,$%. '(*/6+6%/ ; D< *$ $'(%$. 6& 1,% *& $'*& &,'% /%+6% ,&? ,22%33,&'43,&/ 5&%$. 6 '(% 3%8,3 (%6$J3%8,3 3 $%2$%%&','60%9: (,0% &' - %%& -$*8('&$%1 $/.'(%?(,33-%%&'6'3%/ 6&8%N%+2'6&,22361,'6&6&'( (%6$

5&&,+%-%6&

&83%8,3(%6$$3%8,3$%2$%%&'

,'60% '(%/%1%,%/3,&/5&% %$M *-7%1'' 1* *$%,&?'%',+%&',$?/1*+%&' 1$%,'%/-?'(%/%1%,%/ ;

< 33 2%&/6&8,22361,'6&9:.6 ,&?. (,33,3',&//62%/ # : # : # : # : %2'%+-%$ %2'%+-%$ %2'%+-%$ %2'%+-%$

....= '6)4%756&/%$ 9 9 9 9 =F =F =F =F

(

( (%'(%$2%,)6&84$%,&%/ % (%'(%$$%2$',-3% % 4 4 $ ,%*+-%$ J B

= J B

H J

B J

F J BHJ

D J BBJ

JHBB J

JHBF J

JHF

JHF J

= JHF J

H J

B J=F FJ

F J=F DJ

D J=F

J=F

J=F J

JHDDDJ

= JHDD J

== JHDD J

=H JHDD J

=B JHD

=F JHD J

=D JHD =J

: %2'%+-%$ %2'%+-%$ %2'%+-%$ %2'%+-%$

....= '6)4%756&/%$ # : # : # : # : 9 9 9 9 =F =F =F =F