Nirmal Gorana v. State Of Haryana And ORS
!"#$#%&'&() &+,!-+!(! . #"&"&(#+ /#+'0' 1"!"#!+2!(!!($"3#+' #'4($#("'
+#'#(") '(5&"!&-'(6$7%!"#6+"3#4#"&"&(#+ + 1!89!6$$-$7%!"##(#+!-6 0(8!: +##4!5!-2!(6$$-$7%!"##(#+!-6!+2!(! ;;;;
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
&("3#+#:2-#!$&(<"!'&"0!"&(93#+#"3#2!+#!""3# 7#+<#'"!+7!"&( 1"!"#!+2!(!3!'&-#$!4+#-&,&(!+2+#'4('#""3#4#"&"&( !($ '"!"#$ "3!" !-- "3# ,&<+!(" 9+5#+' &(%-0$&(< ? ,#("&(#$ &( "3# 4#"&"&( 3!7# !-+#!$2 :##( '#(" :!%5 " "3#&+ 3,#' :2 "3# !0"3+&"&#' ( @A "3!':##(0+"3#+'"!"#$"3!"!',!(2!'
$4!%5#"' !($ &( !$$&"&( BAB $+2 +!"&( 4!%5#"' 3!7# :##( $&'"+&:0"#$ &( &'"+&%" 3!88!+:2"3#!0"3+&"&#'
#!+(#$$$&"&(!-$7%!"##(#+!-!44#!+&(<+"3#1"!"# !+2!(!3!'0+"3#+'"!"#$"3!""3#23!7#("&&#$"93#-4-&(#(0,:#+'&#
@@A@@B!($@ "!''&'"!--"3#,&<+!("9+5#+'&(%!'#"3#2&($ "3#,'#-7#'&(!$&&%0-"4'&"&(+(##$!(2!''&'"!(%# 1&,&-!+ '0:,&''&( 3!' :##( ,!$# :2 "3# -#!+(#$ $$&"&(!- $7%!"##(#+!-!44#!+&(<+"3#1"!"# 0(8!: ( ! '0:,&''&( :#&(< ,!$# :2 -#!+(#$ %0('#- + "3# 4#"&"&(#+6-#!+(#$$$&"&(!-$7%!"##(#+!-!44#!+&(<+"3#1"!"# !+2!(!!($-#!+(#$$$&"&(!-$7%!"##(#+!-!44#!+&(<+"3#1"!"#
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
($ (&(#++&"+&#' " &' &(+,#$ :2 :"3 "3# -#!+(#$ $$&"&(!- $7%!"# #(#+!- "3!" "3#2 !+# '"+&%"-2 %,4-2&(< 9&"3 "3# $&+#%"&(' &''0#$ :2 "3# 104+#,# 0+" !($ !+# !-' &( "3# 4+%#'' &-&(< +#4+"' :#+# "3# 104+#,#0+"!'"3#,!""#+&'%,&(<04+3#!
(7	"3#!+#'!&$!%"'!($%&+%0,'"!(%#'!'"3#'"+!($#$ ,&<+!(" -!:0+#+' 3!7# !-+#!$2 +#!%3#$ " "3#&+ +#'4#%"&7# 3,#' !($ (#%#''!+2$&+#%"&('3!7#!-+#!$2:##(&''0#$:2"3#104+#,#0+"93&%3 !+#:#&(<%,4-&#$9&"3:2"3#1"!"#' 0(8!:!($!+2!(!!($"3!""3#2 !+#&("3#4+%#''&-&(<%,4-&!(%#+#4+"':#+#"3#104+#,#0+"69# $("&($!(2+#!'("&''0#!(20+"3#++$#+&("3#4+#'#("4#"&"&(!'"3# ,!""#+ &' !-+#!$2 '#&C#$ :2 "3# 4#= 0+" !($ &' :#&(< $#!-" 9&"3 &( !%%+$!(%#9&"3-!9 &"3 "3#'# :'#+7!"&(' !($ $&+#%"&('6 "3# 4#"&"&( '"!($' $&'4'#$
/1D 1