← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/999/1996disposed of

Ram Piari And ORS. v. State Of Punjab & Others

2023-11-23Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja8 pages





 ! "#$ %  $ &'& $ $(()*&

*'*&

 +!(( ,,-- . !/012/3-- , * 

 

 +!((  ,,-- . !/012/3-- , & 

*' 

 #1/+  ,,-- . !/012/3-- , 4 

*  

 2+#+$5( ,,-- . !/012/3-- , 6 **78 

 2+#+$5( ,,-- . !/012/3-- ,

 7 

 2 !/01/3-- /,/  ,,-- . +!(( , 7  8 

 2 !/01 ,,-- . 2+#+$5( ,

8   

 !/012/3--  ,,-- . 2+#+$5( ,   4*' 

 2 !/01/3--9 /,/  ,,-- . 2++!(( ,

' 

 

 !/012/3--9 /,/  ,,-- . #1/+  ,

 7&8  7

 !+  ,,-- . 2 !/01 ,

)

  

 

            



  

 !

"

####   



 $%& '  

  (  ))) %%%) %%*+ %%*% **,- %.%,%.%-%.%)%.*+%.%/%))/012 3 ( %,4-%)),012 3

 "       5            

  ( "6     "    (  )))  %))/ 012 3

$*& 76  6   03      "      +- +* %))/ "6 8     0 "    9  : ;3 "6         = %-> 5   %-). 0   "   9 %-). ;3         /++++<@  A++++<@   = "    6"  " %-).  ( %,4-%)),   %+ +4 %)),"6 :  $4& 76  "6        '

   B=

 B   =      0    =3      " 5    %* +4 %))*   .%-)."6 *, +, %))*  / B    *+ +.

%)).  "6> 5 :

!



!   

 0   "   9 >:;3 "6     



@ :;( < =/((;- > - ""  ..  %+ 

*.+++<@   %4*  %/      /  %4 

*++++<@ C $.& D   %-* 

      5       

  03 " 

6EB(FG    

 

!



!  "G   

$A& (

     %-%-).=     B :  +- +* %))/ 

=  ?

/++++<@  A++++<@  =   "      6 "<  "   %-).   D (  %,4-  %)),        %+ +4 %)), "6 

: 



 $/&



     

 =

 <    

  +- +* %))/<%+ +4 %)), "6 :   

    !

" 6    

03 $,& >   03        +* *+%-     

 

    9!!"  #$%&'%(!)"*+* %, "

 

6       '

   B=

 B 

         

5       +/ +% %))*<4+ +% %))*  6         6     

     03<     

   '

 B=

 B   =      0    =3     

5  "5   %* +4 %))*  $-& 1            "

        6 "6 :    6"



  6     +- +* %))/ %+ +4 %)),"

   "6>:"      " "   

 :       +* *+%-     

 

    9!!"#$%&'%(!)"*+* %,   6 

=                  '

   B=

 B 

       5       +/ +% %))*<4+ +% %))*

@       

  

! " # $$



%&   

"  ' ( $$

   )

') $ 



 *% 

+  * ,  !- %  &.)/* , --!%  01 )+* ,  !!%  2'' ,  !!%3 $)& D                   "=          D   "     "



"   $%+&   ' +* *+%-   %, -*   0  3  :    =        ? )+./*<@  2''   %+++++<@   D    5      4)

 ! "   ? )+./*<@ 

"6:   +* *+%-  (         

         +/ +% %))*<4+ +% %))*  "   " "6 = 

  %+++++<@   2''     $%%& H 6  !

"   %)4+            6   "  "

      

 

 *A)  "       @  ./  **"*  %(  5 6   7  )

 

 ' )  )$   

  ' '  )"''')   

'8"''$  9'

 

 5  %$

: 

 % +$$) 7) 7 :  %" 7  ) + ! &'

!  )  9'  )   

 $$   ") $8 :  '%8)

;'0)  )

$ 

 <   ' )   '   7 ' )  ))  8 ' ''':  ''%")"

9') )) +'  

 8)&'  '+ )6  

$&'   &'  9' "

 

'8 ' 8!'

' '8 3 (   

 "          2''     

 D"  =&'



              2''     "   

 6    "    +* *+%-

  %,-* 0 

$%*&  (     "6I;"G:  0% !!" %($*!, 1"+"23"%! 2!,% +*  #% $4) 5 !)"*

 6.     6      "6     @  9'=

2

 '

$ 

')  "'+>9'

!"' '

8 '"'

'  " ' 8 $  )') ' ) 8'')$   9'   '

 

    '  "   '

8 $  $ 8 +  '7 7 '

'   9'+  ) ' " ' 8'= 

2

"'')'

  9'=

2

 '

$ ''

 )$  '+  ' "  $%4& D "   

     '

 B=

B 

    0  =3    +/ +% %))* 4+ +% %))*  6  ? )+./*<@  =    



  47) 6       %+++++<@ "      6 "<  "   %-).   6      +* *+%-

     %, -*   0  :5 6 "6    

"6    

$%.&    6   

;

 " 5+1*&9*'*& " $

+ J = <  K< J " K<