← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1272/1998allowed

Satwinder Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2019-01-09Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia13 pages



    



 !!

" #$$ #%&  '"

"!()))  

 

     



   *(  +,*  ---.,    

    

     

       

 

    !   "

#  #  --#!"

#/#%'# 01 #%2      %& 

'( )%*% )%*+ )%*, )%*- )%./ -,)-,+ ++,,++&) +--0 +--) +*%0 +*%, ,%+0)../'( +&-)%00%   &, 12 )/.,3  4 45 $     

 

 %, 0.

)..*    8  %* 0+ )../  

9    )& 0, )../   1 :

$ ;6  '

< 

 =  '

< 

%   ,   %/ 0+ )./.

="=)+ 2 $  2  86    = 

  6  "     "   

 

+ 12      

 6   7   8            "   "      %, 0.

)..*    7 8    %,       "  > 3'!"%#!"

#

&$

# #&$

,

#

&$ # #&$



!

4

!(  %, 000!>  +0 000!> (  %, 000!>  +0 000!>   )) +00!>  )& 000!>  8!?"

 )) 000!>  ), 000!> # "9  )- 000!>  %0 000!> , " =

9   12

      "" 

      %* 0+ )../  

9           )*            

"  > 3'!"%#!"

#

&$

# #&$

,

#

&$ # #&$



!

4

!(  %, 000!>  +0 000!> (  %, 000!>  +0 000!>   )) &00!>  )& 000!>  8!?"

 )) &00!>  ), 000!> # "9  )- 000!>  %0 000!> &   "     "   

9       

   &0@

 

 - ' 1 :

12  



  "" 

        )& 0, )../       1  :

     %&           "    > 3'!"%#!"

#

&$

# #&$

,

#

&$ # #&$



!

4

(

1  %& 000!>  +0 000!>   )& 000!>  )& 000!>  8!?"

 )) 000!>  ), 000!> # "9  )- 000!>  %0 000!> *   "      7 "     ( *- ** &- && &0&)    %0@"  " 9     

 

  / ""

"     =       =  

" "     

97

A  *0 000!>

98 

 /0 000!> = 12     2  "   .

        )/        "  



  = 



86 

     "  



 $   =

12   

 

97

A

98    =

  =   2    6   9      

            

"   12    

     

 0) )% ).*.)* )% )..,     B   )+3)535 

   )+  3%5      

   

         

    

    C3DC )5"   

   " 2     6 9    6 '

<       6             =    1  2

       " 9            

   2  

=  )..%>)..+ )0 B  "           "   =

                    

 = 

=    =    1  2     

=    9      

   

    " 



        " 9      "   

        C       +#56'!""#&  7&  -$ '#%  ,#!"

 84'&'

'!%%

 !##!"#!

0 -9:  $

    =  C     =      ))      "    =

  7 8     " =

971 :

 $

  DC +DC ,  9 =

   9 " 9   E+0 000!> 

"   " 

)%  

"      =  

  

         =      C " DC )%

   9     

       C "  C   %, 0& )./+    %  9           6   7   8

  

 

  =  B   =

    

 " 9    " 9   

   "   ), )-92  



B"     =   "  "    C "     B

     )./+

  "    "    

 E)%@ "

)+

    

  

 =     

=

  "   "   

  

=  2  =  )./.  



"                B   = "   

      

  =    

"          "        "     &@               

 "   C    F '%#!"# 4#%#& $# '!,';'

"7& #;

& < #''6#!< #' #

%#!"#!

= ))1>2->:0 

), 



     

9       

   "  )& 

               

1 :   

"      9  =  ).*.   2)0 =   

%/ 0+ )./.

"           "     B  

     DC )- DC ).           "    "     DC )%    

7 8 "      

           =

          " 

 C   !'!!"'#6&#'!"

$#%-'!5 1)):2 -:9> 

  "        =        "  

=  B ##!#&&1"

#"2<?, 6&';# #% #"

&

4&'!5!" <#! %$;

!

4

'

? &1))2@- @   >   

               

    

     



 

   

  

  !"

       

     #  $      $ $  $ 

     

      

 

   

  !%        

     &  

 



           # !  "

          $                   # 

    



 

    

 

   

    !

%       



$     

 



  '!(      

     



   $ 



 



  

          #  !(   

  

     

    

   $

  

 

#     

 !        ) 

 $    # 

               *             

    

$           ) 

$  

  

 

     

+, +     !-

    

 $     

'     $   

$    

 

   )    )   !.

)- B     

       "                8 "     =    9  DC )%     C "

)*  

"        

     

  DC )%    %9 %, 0& )./+

 C     2     %/ 0+ )./.

)/ '

"  "  A>) 



 

    =   

   " 9 "

   1 %9    = " = A>% 

(   "        

      9    "

9

    ).

     C "  

" 9    2   "  2   "   

    =  "      

=%9  " 9   B 9  "   C " 

9  =      

 

 "   

 ==   =       9 ,/ 000!>

,0@

   9%/ /00!>   2 %, 0& )./+

   

-=      "   C   *#!A34;#

&7&- #

#?#!#

& )12 1'6'%2:0    

=

"    " E&@  &=  %/ /00!>

  9+- *&- .)3

+-*&*!> 5

   &@  =     " 

 C     1&4$#2 

  "        = &@ $   

  >

!/      

    

      

         

    

        

        !  (             

     

     $    $    $   

    )!"



     $   

 $    

 $ 

 

    

 

       

!(       

    

               

 

  ,01

201        !"



'





  $   $

    

 

   

           

    1 +1   

!  3         

    

       *

        !  3                

 *   01

21



 

   $    

        21

4!21

!

3         

        

 

            

  !5  

      

    

  

   

 $    

!. %0

 =        )* 000!>            ?")& 000!>  # "9 %+ 000!>  7 8

   %)   "            

9    " =    



  =   

 

 

C &0@        " =   

    

    !"#

 " $%&' (  

  ) (*   +*     * &  ,--  ' .  /,& 0    

1*' ( * &,-' & /2$&' (* +*"

 & * #   * 

 )#   +*  3  '   -/$&      ' (  * +* "

 &   * # 

  *    * &  ,-,  

       "#

 " %%2&1*  +* *

 1*' (  * &,-2

    !

"#

 " /,4 * 5

' (,,2 ' ./% 

   6"*  +*

 ' (67""8 -$ %%

   =            

     

 

9     " 9 

     

          "  "    "          =  

9      " ""  7 8 &0@

 

" 

  

    "    =   %+               

      " A>)      > C"     

9 8 

A 

97

A

9 7

A  1   1   

9   8 9 6  8  2  "   " = 

1 :

"   =  



%,

"  

   =

  "" =  " =  ).*.)./.



       "   C  + ,#'!12<?, &7&

&+1))>2>-  B-$ '#%,#!" 84'&'

'! '

7&3#'5/"##!"

&= ))1:2-)  " =   

  $       =

 DC )-DC ).  

=     = 

=  )..,>)..&   C  &-=      ,

  2   

" 9      , $

    7"     ( *-

** &- && &0&) 

 %0@"  

     " 

   %& " 9   

 > 7  

!(

 +- *&*!>   )* 000!>  8!?"

 )& 000!> # "9  %+ 000!> %-  =      "

= =     =   1--.,2   )0)   

5  *

 6 7*

5 8 6 7*