← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7571/2020allowed

Himanshu Kukkar And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2021-04-06Mr. Justice Rajbir Sehrawat28 pages



        

    !"#$

%& '()*+$,-,..)/ #$0/+  0#'#'*0/+ 10/+,+ #)#0 ,*2)3 #$0/+  0+4*50*#+  !  6%

         



    

       

      !

  "#  

 $       % & '( 

   & /)7 '

)      #*#    +'

,- +,+, ./ 0&1   /       

           % &  '( .

    1           ,+ '+ +,'( ./ 0+1     2   23 % '&4'  +,'5                    + )     6      "   

  6               0

  " )    "          7 

 8

  9       &'

'+ +,'+ 

    "   7  

 8

 #  



"  *    #     #   

"          ,( ''

+,'+   )     % & '(

     7



          " 6  7  +,':

   

   #    7



            !     " 7

8

  & 8 +'

,5 +,'4    0   "           7

8

 ) !  * "   # !  #  "    ;   "  +5 '+ +,'4 )   #      #23% '&4' +,'523% 5+,& +,'5 )

"  #  ##         "   

" #    #  "  

  7

8

 #   #   "   *    < =      "    >       "             "              6   !    "    #   #"

    )        !#" ? ,+ '+ +,'( "           *  =    2   



          

    

 



  

     

                   !"

   # $%##

&

             

    !   '    

     

       ( )      

        

  

   )       

 

!



!



    

   * * +        

         

 )     )

  ,     

'  - 

  

     , 

    !

, .!



         

  &

 )                           

   

   

 & '  /     

)      

            

   

  

           0    

 

 

       

    )      )

      



    

  )    *-  .!



*



 )

                     

    

       * **    

    )   *  - 

 

   

 !



 

  (1$             2   3

!              )   

)    *4

                                    )    )   )   )    &

 

 

!



  & )  

 +        ( ( ) * :

>          2        0   "    "     ## "

     < #   # # " "  "           7  

 8

      0   "   0 " - ) *"        #     "         #  @/   7



 "  *      "  7  

 8

   ) /         #   "    )   #   

"     /    0A0                    



" 7

8

 

  "    "

      /    #       #      " 7

8

  

 +,'&6 +,'&6$+,'& "+,'& >          "  

 7 +,':

="

#6

/#     0A0                )    #       "  7  

 8

  

           "      "  =        3  #   "

#    

     <    "  

 "      7

8

        "          #      "  

  "    "

  

 / 6* <6     

" 

                  !  

         "  =    0    #        "#     !  

    > #            " 7

8

        "       "  B#@ "     

 7

8

   "

         "

       "B "

 @ "

      

 # 7 +,':                    > "             #    

   "            <       <  "                 C   #     "      

    "

        "

     "     =     0                 

   >   "             0  #       "      "

     =#2 6 * "               

"        "    

  "     "

         "              "  6     )   

"    #                   "  #       )#   *   "             "        =  "

#  *    # 

  !      

 8        #     "       "               # )" "

  

    =# 2   ) =# 2        

"  "       =  "            % & '( < #       < D   ! 2  .   "" 2  1<'((:   #    

               "                    

              "      #

  #   #

 " =         "   "  7

8

 ) #""          "

       8           

   B#@ "      

 "  

=   #  "     

 " >            #    #          "

    =#2 "

  <

 "  

" #  #"           

#      % & 

  '(  "          "    

     =#2  #       #    *          3 

  #    7

8

  "  /       7 

8

 )  ** /    #      "    )        *#     /           7  

8

          =# 2                 7  

 8

   )     #  "#       "     0   "  

  "   "   "  +,'& )  " * * /    +,'(  2   *   "         /       7

8

 ( =#     #    2             "  <     2        23% '&4' +,'523% 5+,& +,'5*   "#                  )   "#  <           # > 

      <   

   "    ) "    

,*2)3 5)*5 ,447'0+ 7)++ 0/8'90 ,70+&:;;

 /// /// /// ;

0#$5  )44'*#(0*# )*5 <,)7''9)#'* = .'1 

 "       "   "  

/BE@   .+1 %    

        *   /   

/BE@   .&1  

 "      "  "   0"0"        "       "  # 

.:1 3         

 #      " "   

 .-1 %      

 "  # ! ##          *       ! ## 

        "     "   " "  " :

/3)#'*  0(30/+  0/8'90 =.'1  

   "                 



 "          

  F   .1      

 "          ##         6 .1   

 "    

     *   # 

  

 "   "        

 #            

 6 .1     

 # 

 "             

   

   "

          "   

  #   "   6  .1         /# / "   #          

         .+1 >         

 #       #  

                     "  /"    



 /#   "    

 "  " F .1  

      

 "     "     

 "       

 " 6 .1     F .1  "  "  6 .1    "     "   "       

 "  " .&1     ) 

      

. (    & 

 )



  . (              

  

 

 

      ' (             

             

 

        ' (    

    ) 

                 *

 ()   &  

  )

   

   

     

  

)      !

 . (  

  



  )        

            

        

              ' ( !       )    

 

  

  

   !        )     ). (5            )   !     

  !

  

 *     

      6-

  

 )  

 

  

 )    )     

 

    

 5   

 )    )      0      

            



  ) !  ) 

   )0     !                 

      )  

          7  

   



) 

)  ) 5        

          0 

    !   

              

     

 



 )  



 )          0 

 5        

          !

 

 0  

  )          

  0       

)   )     

     !

   0          5     

   )   

    



)    



58 (    )     )     

 )

    )       

' ()  )   ) 

)

  )   )   ' (    

   )    )     



 )        

  



   )        

  

        '

 ( 

 )    )       

 



)        

    )     )  



 

     

     

     

 

 



   

    )        

          

    

      ) 

)

 

 ) *  

    )         )



)    



 

  

    &

  

   

  

 

 * 

,*2)3'8'7 0/8'90+ 0*0/)7)*59((**5'#'*+  0/8'90 ,70+&::>    /3)#'*?.'1 

        "         

  >        

 "     

      0

 .1      

 "          ##         6 .1   

 "    

 * #

 

 "   "        

 #            

 6 .1     

 # 

 "             

 6 .1         /# / "  #              .+1>     

 #            #   

             "  /"        <   /#    "   

 "  " 0 .1  

      

 "          "       

 "        

 " 6

 .1   

  0 .1  "  "  6 .1    "     "   "  

 "  " .&1 8 "

       

 #  " F .1          F .1  "  "    

 "  "    "

  

 

          "6 .1      "

  

             "6 .1                  " /"       <F .1       

   

 "   

   "   "   "

  "  "    



 " " " 6 .1 /                  /         0.'1          # /    /    ; 0*'/'#@?)   

  

   " #                  

 "   !             

 "        "   /  " "  "    

 #   !  "/"" "  "      

 "      "   "    2"" E "            "   !       /          "     2"" E

  "   " "  !             /     !                     #

!         /  !   "                     "



  "     "  0 .1  

   

 "    

  6 .1  

  "   

    6 .1   

  "           " #      

 "  "     "    6 .1      

     

" 

         "#    # #      #  #    

 " 6    " 

   #   

 "      #         "        

#  #0!?     

   

 "   # 

  #    #

 "  ',         <    

 "        7  

 8

    " #    "    6       

"             )

 "  " "     

 "    " !   "   

  )                     

      

"         ) "

        # 

     "    

        /#         "     

   "

    "   "    

      6      #  )

 #  /     "/""     8#        

  "

    "  "  

  "       

 "   "     "

                   " 2 "  "   

 "  "  

   "

    6    

     "    "     

       

           

      "  #                )   "   < 

    ""

 

      "       #  

   #         #

 " ) 

*    2""    2  <   '((:

  G  <  %    B  

   B @ H   B @     "       #  

   #         #

 " @   =   2""    2  <  B  @   

"    B  @ 8   <     ''

>      <    0  "   *  /   

      #    ) /          

 "      "  B @    "

      "   <   @B@ "

  2""   2  <   '((:         "              #; 

 # )  "

   *  /   

       "   <    2""    2  <   >           

  6          6   /       "       =    "

        

C   /         "

           "   *    " "  

 " =    #     "             "   

C        " *#          #     "

    "

 "           

          % & '(              # =#2  ,+ '+ +,'(./ 0+1     #  "     #       "  "      "

     / * <   

"         0        #    " #       ?

      )      "    % &  '(      #         '+ )                

" B "

 @         " #  # "    

  "    

  "

     G  "

       " # 

  =           #     "    #

 "       "       "

      =         !   " #  

 "  ', ,+ +,':

=       #        =  

  #"          !     "

    )#"   "        " # "

  

" ) "B "

 @   #        " B @B@

 "         #  "    

 "      B#@  =  " 

 

 "#   !  ) "B#@         " 

 " >       

     

 "  *  8     "B @B

 #@B  #@         

 "   *  )   "  

 /   #    

  36  "B#@    "    

   

# *"     #  #  #

   "

   )  #   "B#@    B#@

 " 

    "

    " "#  

 "   =  "" 6   " B#@        B @ B  @ B

 #@  @6  " B "

 @        B " @  )

 "     B#@ 

    # #  

 "      6 

  B "

 @"

  # #  )

 "    

 "      

 "      

 "   "   

 #   "  

  "   6  # 

 " 6" ## 8    B "

 @

 "  #

 "    " "    " >   

   #

     

 "      B "

 @  # 

   B " @     "

       "   "  

   

    "       " =  "B "

 @"

      "B " @B  @ "

  " B @B@B  @   )  ""     <##    7

8

    #     

#  "   B "

 @    "  " @          < ##   

          "   B  @   B " @    "

>  #   

 "          #  #  " #  "

    "     )

            "                    "  <

  

 " )       "          #          "     < 

     0  "   #         "             =# 2    "       

    "  

 "   ) "    

  "#      "   B " @     "         #   )                 

"    # )    0#     6      B "

 @     "     )           7

8

 "  0   "   +,'&       "        '&    "  #"   #    

     ', ,+ +,':    

 "     

  

    #

 B#@ ) "      

 "                 #      /        #               

 "       "  "           ## "  "      )    " #  "  * "  "

   "               

 "     "        *  "

    ) #   

 "            

   B "

 @  "    #  "

   ) #      

  #  B " @          "     



        7  

 8

 "  B "

 @  B " @    ':

 #    0          "       6            6    "

    #      "   * "    

< >    #                "#

            ""      8        "    "

    " 

    

        <        

     6#      

       )   /"

         "  "

     

"  )   "      "

             /     "

      *      =                     

     /     "

    

  <       0   " #             "

    

6 #   '-

      

             < ''   

  " <<D 2""  2 < = %  *   

 B#@  #  

) %    /         B @               "   

  " < % /B @B @ 2"" 2 <'((:  =  "           B @  @   <      # "  #   B "

 @   =      " B "

 @  "

 #  *  " B " @  B  @      "B#@B@B @ = 2 



            #     

  6      6 "   "

 

  6   #  " "       

 "     % & '(                   '4  #       #       #     "          #    / 6     #/      7

 8

   /     /        =#2 6     / *  " 

  7I

 8

  /  

    7

8

 2    #"       #"    

  )     #     "  ! #  

"  

  "   "

   &     7

8

 )

        =#2   )     "             7  



               >     

 "       B@      B/ @6 "

 #       >           "   #            7

8

  )     

 

  #      

) 7

8

    0# #          7  

 8

   )    /  #  7 

  

 8

       /         7

8

6  /   "       *  /   &  /   

    7

8

 =     #    #          "               "       

"             #   # 

   # )          #  7

8

 "    "      #   " "       '5 >               0                 6  #  " "     "         6    #     % & '( "       " 'D 8#

'( >               )         0  *        % & '(* )  0    

    6 0 "#          % & '(      "  

 "         "  "        

   "#$

%&