Manpreet Singh v. State Of Punjab


  

 
  
 
  

  !"#"$%&''



  



 

    



 %
 ()*'

+ *+ ** ) ****   

 

 







 + $,

-.,/"01 '23 04 !



 #$%&&    

 

'()!%* !+!!,-,! !. /,%)0   !%,/,-* 



!%11 

  

"'

 2# 0  

) "

    '( 2
  

 

   !"!#$


         



!

"  "

"

  # 

 $%&'


 "

)#

 %*+&'


  ,



 +-'


.



%/0$'

(1# . " # 2   3-$-*4%  3 
.   (   

 5.

 +-'

!

" "  

"

#"  (  ( ""

   " 22)

   .  ! " "67-05



" ("+800. 2"

.

. ." "3

"

 1."

 

 "5 !

 1 

7 " 2"

#"



 9     )

 

 ":

):

,



- 2 -

 .

   7 " 2" :

)"

 :

"

     .

 

 "

.

 7 (

7 " 2"

  3 ( 

    :





  

 "   

   

 5

 7 " 2" ;



 (



) "(



.""

" 

  2 



 "2)  6-$ 4$0* :

)  3  " 3 < #

)

 

"

"!

  "

#



 !

5



2)   (#"



9  

!

" .3

"

  ""



"2)

2  

6%&+&:

) 5=7! "2   "

""2)

..

" 

) (

 ( 

 

  .

 "  " !

 ( 

  !

"  

"   )

.

 ( #

 ""!" 3

 #"



 :

"



3 ( 

 (#

2

#

2!

"  2"(

)

 

".""

"

  

  , (

 " 2..

""   2 



2"

%$7 2"6  "

2  

"3

"

 1."

 

 "5 !

 1 

" 2" 

 #"



 9        )

 

 "  :

) :

,

   .

   7 " 2" :

)"

 :

"

     .

  

 " 

.

   7 (

 7 " 2"

  3 ( 

    :





  

 "   

   

 5

 7 " 2" ;

 ( 

  .



 %/0$'


( "

.((

. > , 3   

     

   

 4 54  4       5    5 4

6 44 75

!+--7 5 8 7   

   ) 92+.2%.-* 5  

   8  

  )92#!2:2,$,#5

5  

- 3 - 4

"

  

 5 ;  < 5     4 =   

> 5    5 4 5 ;  <                  7      

  #,)0   $ 3       4 8  

 

5  

    

5

     7

 

4 2 2 5& 87

5 ?@(0

5     4

         5

& 87

  75   4

5  5 6 44 79       4       -,-#,-,# 5

 7    85 

 ,4#8 !, 4 4 #



   8

&   



&22!#*+.2,-,$  ,1-$,-,$"

 





 

 4 8 ,4#8       

A

  %&'()%("

*   % + ,- . //

 

 

      4     2B2        $*  )0   . 9          



- 4 - 6.

 8   5    84 

4   8 "

  

      5  

<      8   

 &  (     8  8   

      

 8

  4    5

   

8  <  

  4

    C"

8 8   8     8(    8   8 88 8 5

   

       8       



    5   8    4  

8           4 8    4   <     4 D  4    8

 



4 5        

   ;

 C     4  4   74

   87  8 (    

    

    6  8  8

  4  8 

     4 8  8  8   7  4(5

  4 4        8    

 8       4 

 84   4     * (  

&    

8  4   $*)0   

4  

   4    

 

- 5 -  5

   

7 4 88 4



"

8    $* )0  

55

2 ?@+*  2 " ( 2

<

(

( AB%C "!

""



"

 2



 "
  
 .

2  %4*+B&%4*C A? C# 2

 ( 

" 2" (2

< ( D B(C  22 

 2

 ( +@ 2

 2"

 %4  2"

 &  2"

 &*

   2

# #

 2..2

 

"E   (      (

  !

(

 AB C"( 22"  (  

 "

" "  "    2   

 B

C ! " ( 2 2"  "



 " 2"      " " "   



( #

" "  " "2

" "  " ) "2..

"

 2!  (

B&C

.

   

  (

 2  

 2  B(C  ( 2"

B%C 

"" .



"
 
 .

2  %4*+B&%4*C

" !" .(



2 

(

E> 1       

    8  $* )0

    < 2

       $.)0

  8   8    8 5

C   8 8

  $.)0    ?+$ ."

  2  (  .  "

"AB%C

 2"

 

  2 

 "  2" ! 2   

- 6 - 2  ( . "

"" 22

"2" ." F " 22. "

"(" " (  2"

22 "#" 2"" "

2. "

"!

" 2""" 2"2  



" "2"

 GF

A  "  2"

 ?2  (  .  "

">

2  

" ."

) !    2"

( 

  " ( #  2" B&C"" 2"

 2" 

"(#  !  " 2" ( # " " F " (

  

("

" .  ! " F "  "

(   ( 



2( (

">  9   C8  

8   

      8       





2

6 8

8 

   

    

4 4  4      4  

4

 

     4      

  8 4    4 5

  48 4    5  8   4  

 

   8

      % ( 5 2   8       4 

  8     6 4 4 7 8  7

 8 

    4  8

 

   

  

8        

 5

    28

   #,  )0    7   5

 

- 7 -  

8      84      7  6     4    4 

&  

   8   !++- ?

4 758  7

88     6 4   5   7 5     

 8  8        

45   7( 5   

    

   

  8   48  !-

    7     8  

 &  (8    5

     

 

  5  '

3  5  !! 9  

  8 5

    !, 95 8   4

    

  C   8    -$-#,-,# HH  2+ $,

-.,/"04

.,/

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No