← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1401/1996disposed of

(O&M) Baljit Kaur And ORS. v. Yadvindra Public School, Patiala & ORS.

2018-05-01Mr. Justice Arun Monga13 pages





          !" # $

$%$$$ &  ''() * + ,-./0*10 $$$22,, 30/ 4540 /6,%1,! ,10/71 02,*10 $$$ 24 "$

$%$$$ '8 ''() * +

-4.1*10 $$$22,, 30/ 4540 /6,%1,!10/71 02,*10 $$$ 24 9$ $:$ $$ # &"#) * + ,-./0 $$$ 0 30/

/-6 065,2;/10 ! ,*10 $$$ 24  !"#$%&' ()%)(*$

0

0$3<%71!45*

$%/<1;=!45!

0122,, %$ &  ''(* 0120:

$ # &"#$

0$0/4,!45*

0$01!45!

0122,, %$ '8 ''($

0$ $%$.1,!%045=1

0$%051 ,<450 $

0$./,42%=,!45!

0024$ *"$ 0$ /.$%<1!45*

0$%60%$.0!45!

0024$9$ >>>>>

+

)(*$,& 1  040    ;  1,,  42    =  7/,0  %4 22,$ & 4 '8 ''(45,:0 $ # & "#!=11!54040449$&$" #!=04046774=1

%$ &  ''(01;2,011/0!5404044 "$ $"'24:

$ # &"#!04041=02 6104=1 %$ &  ''(!1=02,</20 1071050 5,544,$

%$ & 4 '8 ''( 1  1  7/,0  %4  22,  15  0  /    1 404045,%/$ #' '##,46 ; 8# 2,  7  4540  /6,  %1,!  ,  4  77 ;;<720;-/!=11=4046 10, /0!6/05046 1?=022,,/04:

$ # & "#  1  6  ,4  6  ,-  ./0!  =1    ,  2,  4  /71 20;=140=1/01,,771040@$ " 44 '$'$"#  24  6  1    0!  /-6  06  ,7  * 5,2;/10 ! ,=1,@0712=0/40% &() +)6+ /-6 7,4= ,745,2;!

''8)010A ''8B+$ 10;4/=,46 12,71 44!1005$0;0070/7000 4/062/,4,=/,212,501;0<4 12,!/43,,7%1670,10! 1,40 0,120;1/;601/146 0/4    1  ,4  0  1  ,  ;0  1  8C(  0  4  1

-

2146//!,74,4$4@44 10    42  1;  4  /      0    ,  1  / 0;4  =1  10  0D/      /  00  =   44$ 10;4/=46 1446

,7  =0  ;    1  20;  1  1  /  =  ,6,    6 4;4/0/45/0122,,E2,! 0!144=0C0=021,4;/07 8' <,!/4=1105/,;5,,710$1,4= ;00/11,6/,47!6/0001 10!10//,4604!0!144=000 7 106/5  ,41212,= ,44$ %120=050!10,/00;41 ,,=7/ A $     



                    

   

         



!

    



     

  

 



  "



 

     #!





   

$         %!

   







&    ' !

   





 





"

   

   

 ' !





       

 ' (!

)  !* /22010!12,@;4 -40%71 220540;! /2,;;! , :E !=12054



12,@$ !1/ ;%021%1670,10! :E"!

1/0/ ; :E9!=1424112,140/41 1/01,( 0! -4.1 :&!=14241;,0 ,4?,%71 :E8$ 11014!44@;4 0;%71 ;0%71! %/204:E !=120541 D/1,45444"$ $ '8(@$ $, 205444 F$'$ '8(@$"!=04449 $ "$ '8#@$9 4-;6401 0 '##E#'@$&$ 1615460/71004!10,/0 4041/40041440;4271;0; 1/,4120;114444610< 21D/04= 6<1 0 '8#$22,20004 14471-/47;44010,/014 6,,=46 1?=022,,/0$= 7/,0%422, 0;4156,46 12,$

0$3<%714 $%/<1;=!45!,04 /,220761,122,, %$ &  ''(4

0$0/  4,!  0207  1  22,,    %  $ '8    ''( /6;4 1  2, 15 6 6,  2051 ,7 4  ,4 2  50  1  /  2020 $  1  ?=0  22,,  /0  20,

,,=4122,6 207122,$(! F! #! "'!&!8F!8#!&F!&#!8!8 48"1@1021=   1    2,  @$GC"  4  @$GC9!  @2    4/  /0    ,=$ =50!1102,15,66,2051,74 ,42$1; 10;4=15

.

6104$1700 10E@; /04$147=024/222014/;0

54$14670,, 20541,,12,=0 212020 4144,4<2 42D/$10201?,;;0=<1 4 146416<=12,4!100!/,4 6,<407070,2012,;465$ 1?=022,,/0444/154,,4004 =1/77 0!100!10=22,;4! 1/!1-/47;440/6,1 ,=4,6, 6E4$ 22,!$$!  $#&(E"" =,4 0 ;2,4;  %$ &  ''($2/0/1 /4!  0$ /240  .1,!

 ,04  %0  45  14  2/   22061, !=10024$ 4"067 02046  0$./,42%=,4024$96 0$ /.$ %<145$1 /6;4120620;40 121C11466,/,,,1, 704,74,42$1?=022,,/0 4-/44122,6 <71?,;;04 /4112,!000465!=0, 24 704,60 421;@24//0,=$7 12,!146</40%&() +)6+ ''8! =101 0140404015414040 /401,,71;2 7=02!

 4!1/!/0741/004;,122,$



151041,04/,0120!22041 2206<415=112C0@2046 1?=0 22,,/0020, ,7,4-/444,,0

004/07124 122,! 0$.$%$70!45 =224?,;;0=14075020 6/  1  @    1  1/    1  42/4  2,$  1  ?, ;;05412475102012,$(! F! #!"'!&!8F!8#!&F!&#!8!8 48", 14621 2020 !  =10  1  0;7  2,  =0    /4    6   2$;

5=!14710,/075716,<  =1/4507120,=14004,1, ,,=12!=1100220,=$1/0 =,510;411024=0 157 ,$20157,12020 !16 ,74,42!<1-/$1,==10704 -/5/0120!=116/4,74,4 2!,70 

 5=10444/,,4/ 1H6,%/20;/0  /0 2 34$5655 637 2 34$5

89,+  : 01 <605 !207021#4 "041/ +,!

-

      - 

 "

       

     



 

       

 





  

 



  

    .  

!/  "

 "    "    





        . 



 

      "

 

    !-  





 



 

  

  "

0  "



:

   .  "1

 . "



"

     



 "







 !  2   "  "

               

    



  

$ 

     "

 

  .

 "



"

  0     

 





      "

3   $ "      40

   





 



    !-        0



    





 

       !5 "   



 "

  

!2"



     

     

    

0"  





 

 0

    

  0

0

  0         

 0      $   

 0"   "

         "!-     0





  

0$  

"     6   "

! 7 !

2      

               '



 8 

 

 '

  

 / !

!/   ' /  0/    / !/-) 7::/   %7,  

;

 

<   )  5  9 !      /  $   !/-)7:: <   .  #,   

        

  

   0  

 



&      "

   



0         





   

 !

 ! '

   

 / !=        

  

$   "

0

          0'



 8  > ? 

  "



     

&

 

$   



   

        

      . 

  



 "





;

=   =!- <   )  5  =  0  

 ; 



         .



$   0"

      0   

"



      ;  "

     "          

$   



  

  06      "

 . "







=  



$   

 "   



  





  

 

 " 



 





  





$    !

2 

     "!- @ .

 8 "



/ !9 !A   >    / !/-)7:78

#,   '



  8   .   8 "  0  ;!  3  

5   "

40   

  

      



$   

    !- " 



  "



 "





 

   





 "



     

         "          !       "

 "  . !2> ? .6      !B  "  

    "          "    



   0     0  

 

 

  

 !8 "

       0" 

   $ 

   .   6     

    



   

   !* ;15=122,,E2,$(! F! #!"'!&! 8F!8#!&F!&#!8!8 48"1462$1-/47;4 401?=022,,/064/22201 0201?,;;0671,/04,=4 1;4,,0 000,,=110,; 2050 6,7;0;402110054$

/,, !1-/47;4401?=022,,



/0/21,4$22,44;4$ 0;/;4/,111/0!=1, 4;7122,!1470410; $10; 5EE5 122,,E2,!=1146/42!454$ =50!14007,7,2004046 1 ?=022,,/05EE51200004101,,0; $ 5,:0 $ # &"#

011,,74104044 '$'$"#)@/0

E" +246 1 0! /-6 06 ,7*5,2; /10 ! ,)010A B+120;11!54, 4444F$8$ '')@/0 E +!2/014,4;/079671 4 6=!/4=11643,,7%1670,10! 1,  4  0  ,$ 10 2  ,4 ;/07  9  671 /4    1  ;  5,,7  =  2/014  0    40  

$#!CE540704,44448$&$ '' )@/0 E"+$10 =/6=,,=1,0;04,0=, /41;120$

/-6  /7!  =  *  /0  ,7  20; ,,74, ,;41D/041,42012050=1, ?4D/6 20;/,77144"#$'$ '(# /40%&04=1% F)&+1$1= 1,,746 1,4=054:

$9(" 'F $3404044 ""$ $ 'F !10;4=0D/146 1/0 41;/45/01%=,,4$ /-6 50;157,4D/01,4!75 44



02    ,4  ;/07  &8(  <,  '  ;0,  ;207    .10 $8CC C&) 8'E(+48CCF)E8+$.10$80 $$80004 164)=1?,?<0+15,,7;/076/'<,$ !  10  =    4  07047  1  ,4!  =11  = 2/014/.10$8$ 4540 /6,%1,)010A %B+,41,4

545 44;465!67=01,4 2120$120,7=18F1020 ,45,%/$ #' '##!=11=404"'$ $ '' !6/1 22, 20004  6  1   %  =  ,,=4   20$  1  20  = 024$&F1-/47;1?=022,,/0$=50! 0  10  20  14  ,4  7/,0  %4  22,    1  /0! =100; =704$ 1;;! 4,;2400   1  2    1  20!  7  10!  061-  %71!

,=  %71!  06  ./0  4  1/240  %71    ,  5,  %/ $"#F ''8<74,0420;-/$10, /0  704  1  ;200  -/!  6/    22,  1  ;  = ;44$5, 5$8FF# '''=20004601/0 45404044 $ "$""!1;=,,=4!=106 1040 44,0/47! ,=E44110,/0 004!6/4/07124 %/$ #' '##!,

/6;422, &$ $"804;01,4 1 =0/06/14 1,4$14;0=4  "8$"$"8 4 7  &$&$"F$  204;0 020 44 "8$"$"8!14;00/4&8<, (;0,@0=11



$  1    ,4  0  6-  7  1  020    1 4;00!6/421! ,202/,, @4710 0012120$   9$'$"8!  01 4;0 =  4/4 6  1 ./7  4  1    ,,0     04  /6;4  020   "$ $"8  54  @/0  E $  57  44  =1  1 0;4020! ,220142/ ;;0!

,$3404044"$9$"(!2,4;0;;= /4!=114/414;0 &$&$"F)@/0 9+$120=454=140=1/0 /4!

100!1;==140=9 $ $"F$120,71 =105444 #$#$"#,,7/21022060 1    0    "#$#$"#$  ,4  02,  =  ,4  60  1 /10 !6/1 0241;2/74040!=11 /6,1 ,=0212,42/ =0544!100!

1040/,415624/40 %&() +)6+ ''8120510;4 ,0, 577094 ;5120;$ 10;4=021646 07 20,;0 6-$=,,7411010146 //10421/,4$10/=176 4 1010$0=140=,1/! 0E45 204771010!,/4712045 220/ 107=2054410;4010! =12024152047!=115/,, /,;4 20/7504012/0#$'$"#!

+

/6D/, 0,4 '$'$"#)@/0 E +$

$%/<1;=!450 0$3<%71!,04 /,0120/6;41024$",4< 401,04 5,/=2474 7/,0%4 22,!=11=2471/0! 14,04 6704$

24$"20/;411,442/6,74  =1/ 6454$51D/,=5,54$ 10/;!1/=00D/0460;46 707 220/ 20,4544!1/!/0741/00 7E41;2/74040$

0$ /240  .1,!  ,04  %0  /,  4  6

0$%051 ,<!45!0207 /6;411=0 240564;4!0!120/,42051,  1 0;4 2020 $ 15  44 4   00

20/;20/1420 404;,1=02$ 151041,04/,0120!22041 2206<415=11004;01/6;  0$3<%71$ 12012,40045 44!=11 07044/;$1 0/;;0, 42047 /4010;42051!0!=1/77

04=1101201466,20510,6 =00$1D/=1070410;71/ /;;0 2047;6464/2-/47;04046

1%7,11/0  <71 (71765= %#,;+

7>7 +

-

/10/;!1 0=0D/040; 1/6 047220/ 120,4541 D/,=5,54$ 012/02,;7,!120  ,= 60,7415,/0$1 0= 2054<4070471,12020 $1040 60107=107041,12020 4!100!

1;/6,1 ,=4106 D/14$1 ;00;4024$"441050 01 @24/, 26,00;71/6 0475 220/120!04=1,=$ ,,1!/ED/7046 1/004046 ;4$@2411201,1,,45/0 4, 142,1204760024$"$ :110;4605!1=024 424$ 4,+;

  )(*$

/59 &'20% *9895?7 @5

 A5@

*989 83 A5@