Prem Singh v. State Of Haryana

  



          
 


! 


  "#$%#& (
) )
  *

+#"

-') * 

   +#'.$ !# $, /(

012#,)3'"

&#)*)4 2 ) ,#'# "( ,)*)5) ,6 ,7 8*,)!-$& "#7 "9 ,) /

'93, 8!-$& "# ! ,)* !##. 92 7 "8!-$& "#%$,"9# ..2 & ".#"

#,) ,)

"5 " , 8!!2)) )8 ,:

) ;;; )*)4 2 8)<=> 
 

)  '# '1#

6" ?# 3.%$,9# ,

6"9,$369= !#$$ %#,# &

6!3# "$$- !
.

&) ) , :#,

 "9# ..2 ' %$, !!

 $% $%%# &# 3 !#, *#&"

  * &"8
@

 "9# 9# ! $"# ! ., :#, &2 3'# $% "9# /

) A) $"

&#$%"9# ..2 ),)

"5 " , 8!!2)) ) ,:

8 &&#."' $"

&# $  1#9 2% $% "9# *" "# $% ,:

! '" "#' "9 " 9# 9 ' $ $1B#&"

"$"9#., :#,/ !#

"9# ..2 ) )   - #7 $% "9# .$'

$"#! 1$-#8 "9# ..2 ' 22$7#!) #6 '",: '!

,#&"#!"$/ ?# #&#'' ,:&$,,#&"

"9#9# ! $"# !., :#, &2 3'#$%"9#/

.#"

) 


 @) , :#,

 "9# .#"

 3 !#, *#&"

 A ,))) ' %$, 6, " $% ,#632 ,1 2"$"9#.#"

& '# $)
@! "#!
)C)8,#6 '"#,#!

EF !#,*#&"

'
 !8 *&"8
@8 "$2 &#*" "

* ! , ,7 8  '", &"

!)

) G# , #! *,) !-$& "# ''

'"#! 1: ,) * !##. 92 7 "8 !-$& "#&$ "# !'"9 ""9#.#"

#,9 '1## & "#!

"9#

'"

"& '# '$2#2:$ "9#1 '

" 22#6#!"$9 -#1## / !#1:9 ''$

!&$ &&3'#! )#)* B :%,$/79$/@6, /'$%$.

3/7 ',#&$-#,#! ! 79$$ 9 ' ,,#'"'" "#!"9 "9# 2$ 67 "99 '% "9#,8 )#)"9#.#"

#,9 !6$ #  /$"$,&:&2#%,$/ ,7 "$ ,7 2 "$.3,&9 '#$.

3/ !1#'

!#'"9# %$,#/# #!!

""9#,# $$"9#,/ "#, 2"$&$

#&""9# #,7 "9"9#&$// ''

$%"9#$%%# &#) C) G# , #!!!2)) )8 ,:

$ "9#$"9#,9 !&$ "# !'"9 ""9#

-$2-#!

% -#$"9#,& '#'1# ,

6 $)
A! "#!@)
)@ !#,*#&"


@ *&"8
@8 "$2 &#*" "

*

8 $)

! "#! ))@ 3 !#, *#&"


@ * &"8 $2 &# *" "

 3 ?8  $)@ ! "#!  )

)8 3 !#, /12

6 &"8 $2 &# *" "

 ,7 8  $)@@ ! "#!
)C)
C3 !#,*#&"


 *&"8$2 &#*" "

 ?'9 7 2  !  $)A ! "#! )

)
 3 !#, *#&"

 
8 C * &"8 $2 &# *" "

": ,7 8"9#,#%$,#89# $"# "2#!"$1 2) ) #,&$ ", 82# , #!&$3 '#2&$ "# !'"9 ""9#.#"

#,9 '1## &H3 ""#!

& '# $)
A! "#!@)
)@3 !#,*#&"


@ *&"8
@8 "$2 &#*" "

*

879#,# '

& '# $)

! "#!))@ !#, *#&"


@ * &"8 $2 &# *" "

 3 ?8 "9# .#"

#, 7 ' &$ - &"#! ! '# "# &#! "$ 3 !#,6$
 ! :' /., '$ /# ! %

# $% ')8 !79 &9'# "# &#9 ' 2,# !:1## 3 !#,6$ # !%

#.

!

"9#

EAF :# , ) ' ,#6 ,!'  $)@ ! "#!  )

)8 3 !#, /12

6 &"8 $2 &#*" "

 ,7 82# , #!&$3 '#2&$ "# !'"9 ""9#.#"

#,9 '1## '# "# &#!"$. :%

#$%')8 !"9#' /# 2,# !:'"

!'.

!79 2#

& '# $)@@! "#!
)C)
C3 !#,*#&"


 *&"8$2 &#*" "

 ?'9 7 2 8"9#.#"

'$ ,#632 ,1 2879 2#

& '# $)A! "#! )

)
3 !#,*#&"


8C *&"8$2 &#*" "

": ,7 "9#.#"

#,7 ',#2# '#!$ .,# ,,#'"1 2)G# , #!&$3 '#29 ',#2 #!3.$ "9#!#& $% 012#"9#*3.,#/#$3,"


  

    "$&$ "# !"9 " $%  &&3'#!'$2#2:$ "9#1 '

"7 "9$3""9# ,1#

6 :&$,,$1$, "

-#/ "#, 2

'2#6 22:3 '3'"

12#)G# , #!&$3 '#29 ' 2'$,#2 #!3.$ "9#!#& $%

012#"9#*3.,#/#$3,"

 !"#$

% & '('(      ) *8"$&$ "# !"9 "

-$2-#/#

$"9#,& '#' $ 6,$3 ! "$ !# : 6, " $% 1 2) G# , #! &$3 '#2 %3,"9#, &$ "# !' "9 " "9#

 &3'"$!: '

&# ))
8 &9 22  9 ' 1##  .,#'# "#!8 &$ &&3'#! * B : %,$/ 79$/ @ 6, /' $% $.

3/ 7 ' ,#&$-#,#!8 9 ' 2,# !: 1##  ,#2# '#! $  ,#632 , 1 2 1#'

!#' ", 2 7$32! " ?# &$ !#, 12# .#, $! $% /#"$&$ &23!#$  &&$3 "$%& ,&3/'"

&#'.,#-

6!3#"$$,$ = ,3' .

&8 "9#,#%$,#8 $ 3'#%32 .3,.$'# 7$32! 1# '#,-#! 1: ?##.

6 "9#

&3'"$!:#'.#& 22:'

&#"9#

-#'"

6 "

'&$/.2#"#) )  9 -# &$ !#,#! "9# '31/ ''

' $% 2# , #! &$3 '#2 %$, "9# . ,"

#' !.#,3'#!"9#. .#,1$$?)
) &&$,!

62:7 "9$3"#I.,#''

6 :$.

7 "9,#6 ,!"$"9#

EF /#, "'$%"9#& '#13"1:" ?

6

"$ &&$3 ""9#% &""9 " $%"9# ''$2#2:$ "9#1 '

"7 "9$3""9#,#1#

6 : &$,,$1$, "

-#/ "#, 28&$ &&3'#!* B :%,$/79$/,#&$-#,:$%@6, /'$% $.

3/7 '/ !#89 '1## ,#2# '#!$ ,#632 ,1 28

-#'"

6 "

'&$/.2#"#8 &9 22  9 ' 1##  .,#'# "#! ! &$ &23'

 $% ", 2 7$32! " ?# &$ !#, 12# .#, $! $% "

/# "$ &$ &23!# $  &&$3 " $% & ,&3/'"

&#' .,#-

6 !3# "$ $,$  = ,3' .

&8 "9# .#"

 %$, ,#632 , 1 2 ' 22$7#! ! "9# '$,!#,#!"$1#,#2# '#!$ ,#632 ,1 2!3,

6"9#.# !# &:$%"9# ", 28'31B#&""$9 '%3,

'9

61 2'3,#":1$ !'"$"9#' "

'% &"

$%"9#2# , #!  , 2$3,"3": 6 '", "#8&$ &#, #!8.,$- !#!9# $",#H3 ,#!

: $"9#,& '#) 9#.#"

#,'9 22 2'$ 1 !#1:"9#&$ !

'&$

#!

*#&"

AC<A>,)))

)

$7#-#,8 $"9

6 '" "#! 9#,#

1$-# '9 22 1# " ?#  ' #I.,#''

$%$.

$ "9#/#, "'$%"9#& '#)
   

 
) )
 + , - 49#"9#,'.# ?

6,# '$ #! (#' $ 49#"9#,,#.$," 12# (#' $