High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4779/2002disposed of

Veer Singh v. State Of Haryana

2015-01-28Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi8 pages

! "# $ %

%& '

( ")*+ *(,)** !-!.

(!,!

(1 "2 (!

3# 3# 3# 3# 4-35- 4-35- 4-35- 4-35- ( # 3(

/ ")*627

3( 7 "2 0622 027

06 (1 5 6+( 0.

5 6+( 0.

* 6 9 29

( ")*6 ! "

),0 ( !

0 * ") ") :,2);

"2 2

,<(2 "

2%& =%

0! :,2);

"22

-9 (//

9* <1!,

" 9 * "!

0 (

;

(1 ":,"

" 9 2 (

! "

2:,2

( ),0 ( !

! /(

001 2; !"2, 9 00 ,0 2, 1

% %

% %%%

(;%>%%%

"9* ** !2 !; !!

(;!

69* ,/"*

((

/, 1"!/

( 0 0 6 !

") 6 !

( ( *

09 01

"2 2 !; !!

(; !

// "( *,;,0

* ( 2 !,!/ "! " 2,( ") 2

"?, (1

9 !(2 <

!!,* "2" * ") < 9*

( ;,"

* 0(

21 <

" / 26 9* 0

( 2

: " ")2, 19 !(2 <

B "22, 17 ( ! "

16 /0

( /(

( 2, 1 9 %=$%

= 9*

( 7 0 , ! 2 ;/,)" ") (2 ( 2

,/ ( "

0 00 !(2 (2

2%=$%

= !!

/, 1"!/

( 0 0 6 !

( ") !

06 ",00 "2 7 2 "2 0 < !

@ " )(,"2! 2 "/ )( /*!>+ . >+A. 5(

22 "1 ") 0 ;

"2* ") ")

< 0 1 !, /

B ")

7 0,( 2":,( !2 "

!, 6 ( <:

"! 9

" ,!

" * ( !

// 0 ") !, " * !

"2, " ! !

2 ")!

!6 009 ") !!, 2#@ % 5*

( ( 2

"2 %$%

= !!

! "2>(

01 !

@ " )(,"2!;

!, !"

(;C > 5*

7 0,( !":,( !2 "

* !!, C 5*

!" ,!

/( !, C & 5*

! // 0 ") * !!,

** !9"

"2"2, C = 5*

( !, /0

! 0 <

29 *!/

(20

2,"!

"29

!! !

7 (2

2 ,"!

)(

" ")(,"2>+ .

2,( ") ( 2

6* !!

( ,!01 00 2;

2 "!/

0<, " ) 7 " !,<! !

2 ,"!

"( !/"!

(;

")(,"2>+ .

6( ! " (( !/"2 ")/ )( /* 9(

B,/

!,<! !

2,(

"! "/ ( 2 %

% $%

9 !/ 7 2 (

!,(1',* ( >2

" ! !

6 0

2 ,"!

"2!

"?, (1 /(

2 ")! 9 "2,

*, 1 ")

"?, (1/(

2 ")!,0; "

2 "

!! ") (;!

" 9* * (

!,(1 * " ( / !,<! !

2 " (,;!

!6 0

2 ,"!

(

"2!

00 "

"2/,(/!

!6 "?, (19 !"2,

*, 1 ")!,<! !

2,"!

!,/" ! " "4<0 ,/(

"2 " 3 ,0"

*"1 3 ,0"

*"1'! '! '! '!*

023 "

!- 2 " (6 *

023 "

!- 2 " (6 *

023 "

!- 2 " (6 *

023 "

!- 2 " (6 %

%%%= %

%%%= (( !,/" ! " "4<0

,/( "2 "

3 !*

3 !* '! '! '! '!* "2( <* " * "2( <* " * "2( <* " * "2( <* " % $>+>.>$ % $>+>.>$ % $>+>.>$ % $>+>.>$

2,"!

!"/ )( /*! >% "2> ! " "4<0 ,/( "2 " 3 ,04! +!,/( . 3 ,04! +!,/( . 3 ,04! +!,/( . 3 ,04! +!,/( .

9* !( /(2, 09#@ D* ,"2

0 )* !6 "0,2 ") )*

,"2 (( % "!

"( ! *,;

( )* " !,(( ;/01

* /(7 ! "

(/ ,<! !

009

,0 !"01 "!,( !""@7 0

( )* 0

;/01

!"9*1 * !,( "

!* '* (<* "6+% $>.>>> #+% $>.> >$ # % $>$ >!

(,B29" ,0

9* */(7 2 (/ "; "

;,"

!,<! !

009 ;/01

2,"2 !,!/ "! "* !2 ! "9 009 2 " B (<* ,0 <*

0 "B 7( ! 2 ")

(6+% $=.>%>%#+% $=.

% & #% $=%%=$ !* 02 "

" ;/01

,02 "

"2 2

2 ")!" 0!

( ") ,!

2<1 ""@/ ,<! !

009 <1,02 " ,"2

:,("

1 1 (;* !*;

0 /(

2 ")!6 ( "0,2 ") 9*0 /(

2 ")!9,02!

"27

2 (

* !/,(/!

6( 0!/0

(0 (2 ! "

"* "!*1 ; !!*( 7 7

3 2*1 ( !*6 +% >.%=&=#% >%%$> > * ?, "9*

!,"

)

E0 (02 02! /

"?, (1/(

2 ")!

" ""@/ ,<! !

009 "

"?, (1

(6<, /!

01(

)*,( "2* 0!<

2 <

,! "

! " 2 !/,

,<! !

009 !" 2,( ")

0/(

2 ")!9

(")"

6/ ,0 (01 !" !,))

2<1

"1 (!,(

2 ,"!

( !

*,)*

!!, !!, % 9 ! 2 9 * ( (2

!,!

< 0 1 (! 2

"2 %$%

= "

)(,"2!;

001)(,"2>+ .1

,<(2 "

2 2"

09 2;

( -

2,"!

(* 7 ")<

-9 (//

,( 2 2 " //(

;

( " ((

(!/

0 ; -

2,"!

"2!

!;2

<1 @ 1 7 2 ( 2

2 %$%

= ( 2, ")

/," !*;

**02 ") "( * ,;,0

0 001,"!,!

2,( ") ( 26 9*

! *

"9 00 ,001 (;2, 16

! 00 "29 !,"2 () ")

69 !"

"?, (1/(

2 ")!< !" "/

<19 !/(

(;/

") "

"?, (1

2,"!

!!,

( ") (;;

7 2

;* 0 - "

2>% %

69*

"3 000 *

B * !"

"2 2<10

2,"!

0 *,)*",;< !,<!

0?, "! 0 9*

)(,"2!

061

2,"!

@ "2(

09;

2?,

9"01#@ D5*

( /," !*;

;/!

2 " < ! !

0/(

2 ")!2,( ") ( 2 "! "

*, !,<! !

! 0 ,"!,!

"20 <

@ F

2,"!

0!!,<;

?, 0 9( @ 2<10

2,"!

2,( ")

( ") ! "01!,<!

0?, 0 9 9* * ( !

! ( "! 2

" "2

" ( !,<!

0 9 ( !

("! 2

" " "!

2,"!

! "

" 3 ,04! +!,/( .

3 ,04! +!,/( .

3 ,04! +!,/( .9

<1 0

2-9 //

<, !2 !

"), !* 2" )(,"2

"/( !,<;

2( (2 ") 0;

" 3 3 3 3 ,04! +!,/( .

,04! +!,/( .

,04! +!,/( . 0 "?, 2/( 2:,(";

"2 * ,(" !* ;

2:,(";

"29 !/(

A@/

<, "!

6"!,*(

( ! 2 ")

(

2! < "

)( (;

")(,"2>+ . 7 0, 69 !" !/

0012 2 " ") !/

7 ") 2 002,( ") ( 2 "! " !2

" 2;

2 ! < ") ;

( ( (2

2,( ") ( 2

!,!/ "! " "29 !!

2"01"

!! ")

009!

!""@;/0

(,0 ?, ( ")/ !,<! !

7 ,"2 ( !,!/ "! " "

! ""@;/0 *

(1( ?, ( 0 96 9,027

2 ")!

,0; "

") " / !! ") ( * ,0 ( ?, ( ") !,<! !

! " B

/ ") 9 * /( " /0

"!*( "

2 "( % "!

"2 !" /

0/0

" ( !;

"?, (1

(/ !,<! !

2, 1 <,"2 ;

!,<! !

(,;!

!( :

/ (,!

0 2 ! " "4<0 ,/( ,(

(2 "

( 01 " !

")@ (

*, !,<! !

( !(

! /0 "

(1, 1 / !! !*(2 (!

B ") "

(9 (6 "/ )( /*>= ! "

"4<0 ,/( ,( " 3 ,04! +!,/( .

3 ,04! +!,/( .

3 ,04! +!,/( .6

"4<0 ,/( ,( "2

B ") "

,0 (,;!

001 7 "),"2 ()"

)"1 ",;< 1

(!(

(;2 (

") !* "?, (1

"2(2 2( @ "!

0")9 ((

(! )

"! " 0")9 *!

)( /*>= 22 ! " !( /(2, 09#@ D" ,0 ( (,;!

! 6!/

7 ")( (2

!,"2 () ")

* ! )"1! "

6% $&2

7 ")<

( ; "

0 ,( " % $ 6 9 9,02 " 2 (

"1 !*

0 "?, (1 < "!

* ; "

! * !* 00<

*@ *" /!

"2!* 00 0!<

((

(! (16 )

(9 00

"! " 00* !(

69 * " *(

*! * 9,02 0!<

* !!

9* * !?,

!!%&6

H@F " "!

2 /!

" !

"?, (1,0; "

") "/ !! ") 02

9 *, !,<! !

"22

"),"2 (!,!/ "! "< !< ")!

( ,!01 006 2;

2 "*!/

"2,"2 () ")

! ;

<, ! ;

<1 !

" ") (

!,(1

!! ")

(;!

00 "

"2/,(/!

!6"

! / 2 2,( ") "2, "?, (1 /(

2 ")! "!

016 "7 9 0 9(

(( <7

!,<!

0?, 0 9 0(

21!

"2! "!9

7,(

" ,0 ( (,;!

001

7 ")2 22,( ") "1

060

7 ")< * "2* !9 296 (! ;/! ")/," !*;

**02 ") "( !/ !!

6 !

( ") !

2%$%

@ "!

!* 02

00"!

"!, ")

0")9 * "

I=J/ "",;9

0 ;2, 00

(!,<!

0?, 0 9* !<

"/( !!

"(* "1 (),;

! !,0

016

0 !

:,2);

!/ !!

!< 09

@ "!

016

!, '

( ")* !2

(;! !;

<7 ", $6

%& ", $6

%& +5-.

+5-.