← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR(F)/180/2019dismissed

Ranjit Singh v. Shagun And ANR.

2025-05-02Ms. Justice Kirti Singh8 pages

CRR(F)-180-2019 (O&M) 1 

        

    

 !"#$%$ &'()()

        

       '  *+ ,( ,- ,  

   

 !"

# 

!" # " 

$% & !"

#  ''''' - ,.( / 0 

 !   ( #    )**+   (& ,  - .,& %  

    "   #%%/(&

#  ***01.  "/ /  # !#   2# # " #  "

     .

  (/    

.# / ,.

 3*+++ 4 #  /,"

    /  (    )*3***

  ***3 .

. , (/  ",/ #

#.

"/ #,   %%   ( ,# #     ,  % (,/ !  )**+



"#  ***01.   " # !#  !(& . 

 "%(&#,    3 5 " ,# "   /##  ,#".

&/

& # (,"

6

CRR(F)-180-2019 (O&M) 2 (.     ! ""

  /,,

 #

"   "    %%   (  #,   ( ,# #   

./##    / " ( #"..  ( ! (/   /(&/  (

/, & 7***01 /##8",!

,8 

, /,

"

#

,,8 #", 9(.  ".,

"# .      " (  ,,&  &   .  # 7***01

"9/!# "# !    %% ! ( , &"/ !, (&, - .,& %/,  .  # !#  ) 

 , " ,#    

 (. , - .,&% 

        

  . .

" #  ***01  .   "   # ! #    9 (.    !    %%/  "

 .(/ " ( #"..##"(/  

/#  /! ".,&/.#  "..

 ! ,,/ 

.  "& &, " ,,# "/,&( " #, - .,&% " #,#.

  %%6# !   !  .! (,

..!

(,&

 ,.,& :! .

(#./" /  , &#  ***01.   9 !

,(. .

(&, " ,#  

"

CRR(F)-180-2019 (O&M) 3 ;

( "

( 

 

"         

 ",   "   !



"& "" ## ,#.

   ..



"

#,( ,

".("

  ! 

       /          %  <  " "  .

" "  /, (  ,!   ,, ! ( !   %%   /"  ! & 

 " , "  /. ",

  #.     !  # "    %% / 

" . #" , "

" /. ",

    /" , # ,, /   " 

, / # ", =3> #"(& ",3+#%  #6   7 1?2 "#9 @(,.%   

   

?"- .

2!  #,,/

     

  

 

 

   !  "  !! 

! 



   #$ A /1?2 "#9 @(,.%  

 

    !"  #  $  $  

  ?"- B

   #,,/

% # 

   

     

   !

  

   #               ! !

  # 

  #   

  

CRR(F)-180-2019 (O&M) 4

   

           !!  #    #         

   

      

     !  #           $ +

( "!,,   "!(& !    !  . .

   

 " . #.

. ,  0 "

 .

  ,#0.,#  ! ##"  #     ,

##  

"# ##,  *

 !

, ", .

 . ",,& (    " 

" , "!   "

 "    #  %  ! <

.#

"/" 

#  .# ", #<  <

.#

".( # (,

 ,"  ! ""     

,  ! "" " #  / 8. #   . .

" (    ,&8 !



   #/" ,##  &  < "& #   . .

,,/

"    ( . (&& "

# 

", (  (, , ,## 

(,".#  C, , /#.

"&

/ ?( "#9 @(,.% %" & '

&  &

(    $ ,  /   "  # .  <

. #

#,,/ "  

CRR(F)-180-2019 (O&M) 5 )* 

+  ' "#      

  () *   #

    #  &   

#+ ,

   "-  )!

,,-"!

 +  



    

       

      

   

 !        !    # !.!  /0   /1        

!% - 23#

    !  !  # 

          #  

 

 /  #   # !       #    4

 - 23 ! 

    

 

      4

 5 23        

 / 4 !          #   4  

  .

/  )

0 +   +  0    +  6  &7  "

"""""   !  

       !

     

       

    

 .! /0  /1     !    

!

CRR(F)-180-2019 (O&M) 6 2+  





- & 1!!

 +  .

 4   !   

       8   

    ("""   ,        #   &   

  !&   

!

  / #  !   !              



&+& +  .



 % 8        #  #   

     ()"*

 

2

+ 324 +! 

  + 9 .

 /&                  !    :+ ;1 + <95  '293 0*+ 5 :  !  

        !      !   

        !   :

9'#=>>"?   ,# *;* *;.

!    . /  "   . ( /   #   . #  ".. ! (/ "    # #.

"#,  %%6" #          ".,& /  . #    "  .#,

   ! # .

"  "  .! # .

"  

CRR(F)-180-2019 (O&M) 7 "  %% 7*A

8

8)/"

  # ".#! / ,( "#  ,  - .,& % -  (     #  .   )**+ (&, - .,&% 

.

 !  %(,/ ,&" .

 ,, "(#  .#"  #

" %   (!      .       :! . !"

 #   ". /   (  , 

)****01. 6 !/# .

"  # "    ".,/.

"  ,      *;* *;  ,  - .,& % 

  .

"D  ***01 / ", #  5 " ,#  ( (, "



& !&    .   /" / 

  # " (&  %  ,&

"/" ( "    ,,, #"   /,("  . #"  ##

,.

" "" ,&  .( (##

&. 3

  . " 0,# 

 (&  % !  ** *+

!

"



, - .,&% "   "   #      8,&

 

""

"/, / )   (! 

(!  ,, ( "   (

8  #    (&  % ,  .

&  "   ,  , %(,/""/ , / . ",& ""

"/, /

CRR(F)-180-2019 (O&M) 8      .",,

 => #

& , 

=> #  - ,   ()() 

  C

0   E0 C  (,   E0