Vijay Pal v. State Of Haryana & ORS
!"#" $%&&
% '( & )
*
!
"
# $ !
"
%! & '
()
'
'
*
* +& +
,-*
. (/012 3 45
6( *6(7 . 8"
9 .
9:'
(-,
*, *660
,(/ ,*6 ,;-,0( < (*6) : .
(-;62 3 :
45 "
.
*
"
!
# & "
= "
<
"
"" ) < < <
= = " ) " !" " "
-2- #. & . " + =""
>
" "
1 66 666?) *6 6;
*661 "" ) " =
"" " "
< ) ),& & - $. .., ## # / 0 ,# $#
# $!
" $ ) $!
" $
- 1$ 2 #&3 (
= ?
# < 6, *667 1 66 666?) *
?
# < *667 1 66 666?)
?
# < (, *667 1 66 666?) ,
?
# < (, *667 1 66 666?)
@ =?
# # < 6, 6( *66;
7 66 666?) ;
:<?
.
# < (0 6( *66;
7 66 666?)
' # ?
A
# < (- 6( *66;
7 66 666?) -
?
# < (- 6( *66;
7 66 666?) /
8#<?
$. # < 6( *66;
7 66 666?) (6
?
< # < 6( *66;
7 66 666?) ((
?
$ # < *66;
7 66 666?) (*
=< <?
# < (/ 6;
*661 1 66 666?) (1
?
' # < (( 6- *66, 1 66 666?) (,
. ?
<
# < ** 6- *661 1 66 666?) (7
?
A" # < *6 6;
*661 1 66 666?) (;
= ?
<2# <5 (1 6- *661 * 66 666?) (0
#?
$. # < *1 6* *667 * 76 666?) (-
A ?
# < (, 6- *661 * 76 666?) + <
"" ) !
+
< "
" @
= "!
! "
= < B
< =
>
9:
)"
"
!
" " )
((
@ = =
-3- 8#< ' #
:<
0""
=< = # .
.
< @
<" +.
!
6;
*6(,
" 1(( <
" # & : = <" < . 8"
!
6;
6- *6(,
"" 1(1
" <
$
"" < + "" " 1(( : "
< <"< . 8"
*6 (( *6(,
C " <
. 8"
!
(;(
#
& "
= "
(-""
=
! =
<
+
"
)
# & < *1 6/ *6(1
+ :!
@"
2
:
5
" )
-4-
A . 8"
!
""
!
) =
"
. = "
) <
A . 8"
)
C(
# &
(-"" . = "
)
" "
A . 8"
""
C(
# & " )
""
=
! "
. = "
)
<"< "
=) =) =)D =)% =)1 =))- =)(* =)(7
=)*6 =)*7 =)*/
,
+
"
6( *6(7
C)(
# & < )
!
< <
<
> +
"
E! <" .
!
6;
*6(, "
1((
" # & : = "
< !
6;
6- *6(, "
: = <
-5- !
*6 (( *6(, + .
"
! <
" " 1(( + .
<<
- <
B
+
-
) C)(
# &
. =< ) " "
<
" "
. 8"
"
1(( <
0"" < <
" )
"
+
+
"
'
"
<!
+
"
'
( '
*
!"
;
: '
(
6( *6(7 . 8"
C)(
# & . =
"
) !
+
!
8
+
:!
.
!
-6- -
.
C)(
# & < " ) "
!
<
+
<!
" "
< " .
!
6;
*6(, " 1((
< " # & : = < !
*6 (( *6(, E!
"
1((
: =
< + .
! " " 1((
< "
" 1((
"
" + .
<
- <
B
+
- "
< "
C)(
# & " ) "
. =
+
"
:
.
"
"
!
4
! "# $ %&'())*!
'+,- - %-')**.
.
/ 0 / %&())&(.1))22
-7- $30 3 , 4 )!2!252 #67 " / 4 /
@
1((
"<
"
< "
"
" "
+
.
) C)(
# &
""
=
"
. =
" "
) C)(
# &
. =
" "
"
" +
! < "
) C)(
# &
. =<
" "
<
" )
<
+
(6
: " (-
"
!
=
=
"
@
= "!
! "
= < B
< =
+ "
" )
(( 0
-8-
@
< " .
!
6;
*6(, + > " 1((
"# & : =
" <"<
6;
6- *6(, C " <
!
6( *6(7
C)(
# & "
= " <
.
= @"
< <
)
(-""
! . = @"
)
<"< "
=) =) =)D =)% =)1 =)- =) (* =)(7 =)*6 =)*7 =)*/ ((
+ !"
!"
! <
6;
*6(,"
6;
6- *6(, " 1((
.
"# & : =
1((
"
" " )
<" <
!
" C(
# &
-9- " C)/ :!
@"
"
9
<
-
"
F
<"< "
9
!
! "
"" "
" 1(( !
(*
+
4,"
5 , 1,
) ##" $'.
G::: 4,"
5 6 ,, $ # #7 8"# ,
#'
)H3 # #"$#
. $ 0 5"!
, 0 , ' ) H3 # #"$#
. / ,9"# / $ $0 5"!
, 0 , '.
G:G4,"
5 )1- - $# # #7 8"# ,
#' .
GG3)1-- ,7,"
5#' .
GG: ! !
"
**7)*10 < .
*16 ""
"
!"
**/ 8
B
< *1(2(5
.
B 8
= " *11 2(5 < ""
">
*1* "
"
!
*1-)*,1
< "
-10- *,*2(5 . ""
"
!"
"" *,(
B
< *,*215 .
B
= " *,1
"
"" 1(1 "" "
)*,,)*76
.
"
< "
*,,
. < < )"
< "
""
= "
*,0
"
"" 1(1 "" "
*7()*7/
"
< *;6)*;,
"
*7,2(5 <""
!"
"" *7*
*71
=
"
"" = "
-11- +
! >
:
55#1!/ ;".
$!
40, .1!
.' "" (1 '
!
>
:
55#1!/ ;".
$!
<0, .1!
.<
"" < <0, .1!
.<"
!
"
"" <
" < <0, .1!
.<
<
"" <
2
8 9 ,4 0 :-')*. 8 9 7 :-')*.) 5
(,
! "
.
.
!
"
< " "" <"
"
*16
" "
"
<
& *11215 : ""
"
"
<
8 "
"" !
"
*,*2*5
"
<
*,12*5
-12- ""
"
"
<
" )
"
""
!
"
" < *,,2*5
.
"
<
*,0 =
! *,1 . "
< )"
< "
2
5
""
= "
" *7,2*5
= " ""
<
! ""
B 47'
4#/ 55'<" !
<
(7
: "
<> "
) 25 : "" "
" < < " " " " " "
""
< I
-1325 :
"
"
?
" "
?
"
< "
"
" "
" <
"
"
?
"
=
)"
"
= >
="
"
"
I 25 :
"
< !
"
!
"
""
) "
"
"
="
<
< B" " "
"!
" I (;
+
! <""
"
"
""
""
= "
<
"
>
<
" >
(012*5
" ""
-14-
1(1 <
"
"
<
(0
+
!
!
< "
< : "
) .
: <" < 3 , !
## -0 500
, $!
'
! !"
! !
"
;(
.
< "
"
".
"
"
.
;*2(5
!
"
"
"
&
= "
" !
;*2*5
"
" !
!
"
;*215 <
!
> ! "
"=
"
;1
!"
"
"
;, <
"
"
!
!
"
< < <
> ! "
"=
-15-
"
;7 : !"
"
"
;* ;1 ;, ! "
B "
"
<"
J
= " > = "
!
!"
"
;; <
"
!
!"
&
"
"
<""
J" "
!
;*
> ;/2(5
!
<
<
"
!
"
< " = ;/ 2*5 < "= <
=
!
!
"
!
+ ! !
<
!
"
"
;*
-16- (-
) .
:: <" < 4 , !
## -0 5/ , .1!
" $ /"$8#' = ! "
/(2(5
!
< .
!
>
".
"
< "
>
"
(/
:"
!
-025
< "
!
" <"
"
< < "
!
!
""
"
< B" "
) .
:
!
< ! !
"
062(5 < .
< "
".
062*5
"<
"
""
<"
0(2(5
-17- .
< "
< "
< "
"
"
<
"
<
<
= " " "
"
0*2(5
<
"
"
J "<
"
"
!
"
07
-( <
*6
(0, :
<"! "
"
< "
> <
"
"
"
"
" ! "
"" !
"
"
<
<" <
<
<"
< <"
!
<
"
"
.
8 "
<"
B
< <"
<
(07 6 :
"
" !
-18-
(07 :
<
!
"
" ! "
!
<
<"
< <"
!
<
J
"
!
.
8 "
<
<"
B
< <"
<
+
(0,(07 :
)"
F )"
+ (0, :
8"
< (07 :
<" "
! .
GG:
.
8"
(/72(525
="
F"
(0,(07
:
" " "
"
" B"
< " !
" !
<
!
:! < (/72(525
"
>
"
"
*(
""
"
1,/
!
<
1,/
< "
-19-
. .
< ">
<" .
>
!
B" " ".
<
<
8
"
"
B"
" "
<
""
! 1,7 1,;
176
.
!
)
"
<
! <
.
"
"
< B"
"
"
<
<" <
<"
B
"
" <
= F"
! <" <
B"
**
"
" ! (0,(07 :
"
1,/176
"
> )"
-20- ! "
"
*1
K ! . "
"
@"
?
" "
?
" < "
"
<"
!
) <
< ""
"
!
(;;
:
" !
<<
"
! <
" ! = < <
<<"
"
"" !
" = <
= < " "
<
<"
< <
:
(;; :
!
"
<
=
"
"
L4!
"
"
= < < < = < =
"
L "
(;;
:
)"
"
"
@"
?@"
"
?
" < "
"
<
(;; :
+ (;; :
)"
F )"
8"
( " +
.
"
"
-21- < > "
)"
"
< !"
< " "
?
""
" "
"
"
<
" "
?
"<
""
=
""
"
?
" *,
"
1,6 .
(/72(525
(/1
(/;2
"!
5 (// *66 *67
*((2
"!
**- ,;1 ,0( ,07,0; :
" "
"
" <"
!
"
"
!
>
> 1,6
(;; (0, (07 :
:! < *669 ! ""
8"
<
< :" ) "
""
"
< " -0
:" """ "
" " "
-* . ""
" " -1 :" 9:<
-22- (0,) :
<
""
*7
!
< " !
!
.
"
"
!"
< " "
@"
?@" "
?
" < "
"
*;
:
!
< " "? "
<
"
@"
.
!
< "
<" 8"
"
"
"< :
"
"
B "
"
"
< < "
>
< "" <
< "= 9B " "
"
< = "
< "
"
" !
< "= +
!
"
< =
+ 8
-23- " F <
?< <
.
@" !
?
"
@"
<
?<
!
"= !
!
?
<
<
!
>
= +
"
"
)
"
< ) "
!
!
!" "" "
< =<""
= <
<
<
!
"
= <
+
!
" "
) "
)
" ""
" !
" ">
"" "= B"
""
< "
" " >
""
+
"
"
"
""
"
"" "
"
+
=
"
!
"
<
"!
'
<
!
" "
9 = "
!
+
-24- "
!
C
!
4
;
, 3 0 %&())&(* < "
< = " "" .
)"
"
:
"
"
"
B ""
!
>
" <
"
?
"
"
. "" */,
!
<
"
""
! */;
+
=
" ""
B "
< " +
" "
" "
"! 4
) <# 99 # 9&(% &() ) &9(*J!
!
3 +4!
"=
4
= 0 $3 3 4 4% &(*
"
"
!
-25-
"
4
>3 3 ,&(%&( ) ) &(.5 :"
.
<
!"
!"
?
<
"
< !"
)
"
<"
= " "
"
"
!"
?
+ !
B !
<"
*0
D <" <
" "
J<
!
" "" <
""
"" *-
: ! 7? 9 ; ':-')*36
3*
" *(
!
B"
""
"
<
" < :/3 >
/ 4 : $2 : %&**().* 4
" < ! "
M M
"
<"
B
" *(
: :-,3) -3 9 ) 7
-26- :**&() ) &(.5 4
<
" *(
: !
!
>
"
"
"
B
*/
:
""
!"
""
""
"
:' @- 9 ;
%&())&( 4
!
N ""
"
" " *( $ ""
"
!
"
!
= )"
<
"
<
>"= : < = "
!
A<
:$ ?3 9 /0 3 ?3 :&**(*% 4
!
!"
"
"
" "
:
<
. "
<
= < "
!"
"
1( : A /,,3 7 ?3 :&(% .&() ) &(55 4
!
)
-27- !
# "
$ # $ % #
!
# &
'
#
#
(
( )
#
# *
)
+
! )
(
# +
,
# !
-$
. % # /
'
# /
# !
01 # (
#
-28-
2 ,
# #
#
3 1*
: / 3 0 , < !
&( % &() ) &(. 4
!
) 4 #
(
#
(1
#
(
3
: ""
!
=<" <
F =" )
<
B +
""
"
""
"
"<
"
"? "
!
!
:
!
= "
"
"" !"
"? "
1,
: !
9
?
<%*.&("B 5$! " .
<
" ">
""
"!
"
!
!
"
"
< <
!
>
"
-29- ) !"
)
!
=
<
"" "
"
"
"
< "< <
<
"
:> 3 87 * "<B 32 *: $ >
<
< < "
> ) "
""
<
=
<" 8"
"
C
" 4
8
# .
>
<
+ < " .
" "
"
"!
<
< I:
) "
= "
=
< < 9 "
<
"
<
"
:"
.
" "
"
:" " <
< <
< <
" + <
!
"
C
-30-
"
< = "= "
1;
: ?3 0- 9&?3 (%* "B 4 & .
!
"
<
8"@"
"!
" !
" ""
"< :
8"@"
"
<
" + "
<
"
" ""
" <
" "
= !
"
"
" < !
" <
"
=
<
: ,9 $ 3:**!
* 4 .
"
""
">
""
: !
: **5&''(!
/ , .
!
!"
"
"!
"
"
" <
: !
9 $3:** &''(!
4 .
"
<
"
"
<
" "
-311-
:/ 0 3 , %&( ))&(.* 4 " .
!
" "
"
"!
< <
! << = 4 " .
$ 0 / ) 9
*
&8D!( 4 1/
:
!
"
@"
""
!
?
.
"
<
B "
<
<
"
"
E!
<
"
"
?
"
!
"
!
?
"
"
"!
= "
"!
"
"
""
"
<" = "
!
" "
+
"" "
<
< < .
"
" "
" C : " "
"
!
<
:
-32- "" ?
<
" ? " < "
"
!
< <
" "
+
"
< <
" "
> "" "
"
: .
"
"
"
""
= "
"
"
< " "
E!
"" " " <
?
"
"
<
""
" " <
"
" "
< " " "
"
,6
:! < " <
>
) 25 : "" "
"
"
" " "
-33- "" < "
" " < " " "
!
"
25 : "
"
?
" "
?
"
< "
"
"
=
"
"
?
" >
"
"
"
"
"
?
"
=
)"
"
= >
= "
"
"
25 : "
< " " < <
"
!
=
"
<
B"
" "
"!
" "
"
+ "" <
?
"
"
<
"" + " " <
-34- " "
< " " "
!
"
,(
: " . 8"
" !
6;
*6(, " 1((
.
"# & : = !
6;
6- *6(, :
" "
" =
"
"
"
< < < "
"
!
:
<
.
> "
" "
"" <
"
"
6( *6(7 . 8"
" 1((
+ > <" <
! < <"
<
)
" 1((
,*
1((
) <
) 1
,
(
"(
( 2
(
-35- "(
# 3 ,1
: ?
44= " 63 B '" &5( 3 .&36 3( N
F ! 1(( ) 5 6
7 7 77! ,
,
89
89(
89 "( :
)
#
(
!
( ( !
(
# #
(
) )
; # <<
# )
(
#
(
,
=
,
! << (
7 ,
7!
-36- ( #
# 3 ,,
: !
; ' % **&())&( < !
4
< " 1(( . (/01
" " ,7
)
= 4 4 84 224 0 # %***&())&(55 N
B "
< =
< B "
+ !
"" "
"
" '
" "
: <
"
!
<
!
" =
+ ! 4
) 5!
(
#
(
<< <0* . 1
$1
,
>
$ " )
)
1
)
:
;?
) (
-37-
-
"
!
) 1
#
@
= # A ! 8
9
B M:
" . .
< " )
"
" "
.
! "
B "
>
"
"
<"< "
"" "
""
O ,;
: A /,,3 7 ?3 :&(% .&() ) &(55 N
!
) C5
(
D
)
!
(
7 7
) 6
& '
3 ,0
: ) E9 $ % &() ) &(. N
" '
*1
" "
-38- <"
= < " 1(( . <" ) C/
<< &
<;. 1
B 9 6
) E6
<<
# E 9 (
<< &
#
# 9 !
#
( "( 9 ( << &
#
#
9 (
)
(
#
# 9
( #
9
(
(
# 9 # << &
# 9
#
#
#9 .(
(
-39-
)
)9
!
#
(
9
9 ( ) )
9 << &
)
# (
3 ,-
: !7 C $ 0 %5&5() ) &(. < N
"
"
" < "
** <
" ,/
: " <
!
"
"
!
"
< " !
"
"
# & " =
-40-
<
$
=!
# &
"
!
"
"
<
# &
"
"
+
<
B <
= =)
=) =)D =)% =)1 =)- =)(* =)(7
=)*6 =)*7 =)*/ :
<
C)(
# & " C)/
!
"
" "
"
"" <
"
! "
"
< :!
@"
" < >
"
< < :!
@"
"
<
"
"
=
:# 0 F 8 9 3 ,:&B= 5&(( 4
!
< ) 7*!
D
, 2
&
> 0 9 !
: **&( ))&(.%&**&((
-410 ! E98 9 $ :***&( ))&(.%&***&(.(
, (
2
#
5 1 )$ E99 $ 8 :**&())&(5%&**&5((
) ? # " - 0 9 $< 0 8 : &( )) &(%&&(97 7(
:/ 30 , <9 !
:&(%&( ) ) &(. 4
!
) <0
)
(
<< <0*. 1
& :
#
.
#
,
) #
3 7*
+ "
:!
@"
"
" C)(
# & "
= " <
.
-42-
= @"
< <
"
)
(-""
!
. =
@"
)
<"< "
=)
=) =)D =)% =)1 =)(* =)(7 =)*6
=)*7 =)*/ " " "
" K ):: 1((
. 8"
" )
" "
+ 1(( " " "
!
"
"
"" 9 " ):: 1(( < <
<
"" <" ""
"
"" <" .
<
" 1(( ):: : !
6( *6(7 . 8"
1(( "
< ! <
6;
*6(, "
6;
6- *6(, " 1((
"
-43- # & : =
A . 8"
1(( )::
# & "
= . =
"
) ! : "
"" "
"
"
F ""
- '
"
< "
"" C(
# &
.
""
=
"
<" !
. = @"
)
<"<
"" @"
) "
9 "" ""
: ! "# $ %&5()) * 4
> 9: 72*5 72(52 5 "
(/,0
"
"
< &
(1 : !
'+,- - %-')**. 4
!"
(;( :
72*5 < 72(525 "
(/,0
"
!
-44-
<
"
"
!
!
>
"
1(( .
! <"
=
"
"
"
:/0 / % &())&(. < < " 1((
" <
! " ! <
" "
'))22 $30 3 , 4 " 1(( .
"
1* !
"
" ! )!2!252 #67 " / 4 " 1(( < 1((
. "
"
! < "
@ ! " !
"
""
"
! < P "
1(( .
<
! < " <"
O "! <
< <
4
-45-
:! < "
"" "
"
<" >
<" !
.
"
7,
:
<
"
> " ,-*
"
:
!
"
"" <
" <
(012*5
:
<
. 8"
" ""
! < */,
. <" ) *5
6
4 43 8<9 6
8C9
F 89 6
,
B &
,
3 . 8"
:!
"
"" "
" . 8"
<""
"
""
C(
# &
-46-
< ""
?
1(12525 "
"" <
< ?
9 7;
""
<
<
"
""
8"@"
K + . "
$
2"
"5 . 8" "
"
< " "
" P.
"
< .
O
? "
" "
4 . 8 "
> 2
* 3 && #
C
=? % ?'
C
% ?'