Ashok Kumar v. Jal Guffar
1
!"#
#$%&%
'
( )
&* + ,-.!/
11#22!
"
3#/&-& !2 -44!/ 2%!& 5*!.%.
*.!6
"*#/
0#&1
6# "& '78
5 3 98
! ! "#$% &
''''' 3 98: 8
( * +(, -.
"--( /& % )/ + + /& )/ + ((0---1# *+ 23 * 1 4 + + * /&/!* /& 5
, 5 "
* / ("
-6 (22,/"
"- 5 *+ /!* + *7 8#9-%#(:"0
2 ++ ;
+&* +#< 4/**7 =#$>#-06.* +/& 7 ( * * / *4 * "6 4/& $+ / & !/# $ -9 -6 (22,?@ #:, ?@ #:9/ 4& & + &A & * $+ B/ * & * ("
-6 (22, ""
-6 (22, $$ ! 7+ -:
(- (22, C $$ !7+ -.
(- (22, (6 (- (22, C++* (" (- (22, &:- (- (22, $+ & + / / &/ +*/ 0---1# * +
:
7 ( + / &/ / ++ " + =#$>#-06.
7 "D$% & + +/# 4& +7
3 8#9-%#(:"0 / $+ * ** /&
+ / * /& *
.
8 & )/ A+ * **/**7 =#$>#-06./& 7 ( + & 5;#:+ + /&/!* 5;#0 $?@ ;#:1(
% !
5;#" + + # * &@("
-6 (22, = 4+
) )/ / ?@ (?@ :0 ?@ :,?@ :9 %A & ((0---1#++ 7 ("+ 4 & & / & *+ 23 * B
;
* A )/ + "0---1#+ * 0---1#+ @ 0----1# + * &1 (----1#+ "0---1#+ + ) + ((0---1#+ 23 B
4 5 , = +/& )/ * &A& **4 $* 5) )/ / !/#$ + *&4&& & * & & ?@ :9 (,.-#,-#",--?
#90#"2--
5E & 0---1# /++ @ * % * $$ ! 7+
5) "0---1#++ * A* ++* &/ &
5) ++ +
57 /++ * @
$ & +
E 7 "/ + /& )/ 4/ $ * &/ &@ / @ / & $ + * + * & $
5 / )/ & / + + +*
535 5 $ * )/ * */ * & ** * *4 / & 7 (" &* + * A + @
A* @ / & * & = / &?@ #:2?@ #.: + / / 4& & 4& + / & & / !
6 A/ &* +/& CF/ ! % + / / &/+ * & & *
& / & $ * / & & & / &A A/(--3 / / * + /
(( ?@ :,?@ :9 / !/#$ & + (,.-#,-#",--?
#90#"2-- * & / *+ & *+* % & 0---1#/ /
("
* & &* +
!"! !"
!
#$ %&"
!
'
( !
)"% * "
+$$, * & / & #
!/"%$-2!/& ;!/6 <= /%<- !2
#!&&#& .
- "
= &$ 5(--3 / & @ 0---1# = &$+ 50-3 @ 90--1# 50---G"0-- = $ @ 2----1# 590--H("
7
5*"0& @ (6 ) = $ 0----1# (,"----1# 52----H(6 (:
* & 4 &# &
** & /& CF/ ! %
+ / 4& A & @ * * * A * $ * & 4 5;#:/!* 5;#0 % !
5;#"+ + # * &@("
-6 (22, = 4+ $$ !7+ & / 4 * */& & * / 5?@ #(?@ #:0 ?@ #:2?@ #.. / B/ * & * ("
-6 (22, ""
-6 (22, $$ ! 7+ -:
(- (22, C $$ !7+ -.
(- (22, (6 (- (22, C++* (" (- (22, &:- (- (22,
8 (.
+/& )/ + "0---1#+ * 0---1#+ @ 0----1# + * &1 (----1#+ "0---1#+ + A & *& 4 *
* & * * / & $+ +* !/"%$-2!/& #!&&#& .1# &!"%
* 0----1#
@ "0---1# ) (----1# (----1# ! "----1# =* (0---1 = (0---1# ) (.0---1# "!2 .1# &!"%
(0
&/ !/"%$-2!/& .
- "
) = $ (,"----1# E C ₹(.0---1 ) ₹(9,0---1# (, $+ / 1!/"2= !22 ;#6 * + (, -.
"--( @
9 &/ ((0---1#₹ >:):? ) & 93 * B ?@ A */& )/ * + ** * / & /
(9 ! / * 5&
3 98
( )
-