Gobinder Singh v. State Of Haryana And Others
CWP-7900-2022
! "
"#
$ %&$ '( ' ) ***** ! "#$%&'&(&) *+& ," !& &#$%&) ) &-&& ..... ( ' )+ , -./ % $((" , $ "% & /010% (
&(," &$&2+% 3" +$%$2&* ,,+)" "& &
&+" " 4$ 5& 4$ 2&
&(6"&2,," +
"& " 37( & &
& + - " &% , +$ & "& & " 2*& % " 3&
" ,,+ , + -) &+"7$2& " 3&
* 3" & +"&( " * %% 8911901 1'':; & 1<0/01/3"6-",223(+"&( 3+*-
!
" # "
$% &' ( "# "
) *% "
$ $% %$$ + * *% , -" % .
/
+ 0 *
$
+*%*
"
'
/
+ *% *
1
0
(
*%* $ % %
2 $ " # "
$
# % % % 3- . 4 *% "% -# % 5 * . 6
(
%
%
" # "
- $
"
7 4 .
8 4 *% "% -
.6
= =
+
"&" & +"&(3& $ &&62&(& "
2("," 2 $2 & ($2& & 322& "++$2&
$ 6- " *% & 3"+" " 3& >$
,%" $ & &$62+ +$(&$62+ +$)""& 6?% * ,+& & 01000= ,%",$+ & "@(*% 2& A
+, $2B, CC& $2< , CCC," +" $2,4 ,4*2+ $)180/ ,$"+ "&" &3""%&3& 2 6,"
&2 4*2 '$ ( :
* ;) &+"7$2&) " "& &+$&22- &
&&+& , " ,& 6"&2,, " & , &-&& "$(" " + 422+ 6$ + " 3& "&*(&- $+ ,%" % &* +&-," &% &
&6"&2,,"5& +>$ ,,+)"+)" $$ & &
&&+ " 6"&2, ,$" + "& " ,,+ , " 5(&2 %%6&+ & % &* +&- *% ,
&-&&) 5&3 D 5( 2&* &% "&
$ & 4+$2& 6&( !% 1/< 1B<E & 00B01< &6$ " + $ 6 ,223 ,
$&+ , $+ , ,+ &22 4$ & + 5*2) (" 4$96$&2:
;94%%
:
;96& & $ % 4$" &%?&+ & $ "9 &
$
+%4 * : (- .
*
- .:
- . " *
B
) 2 %
0
# %
% %
$ 4 ; * <
$4 ; *<
% 3 3
&' =(
%
1
+% 4 * : (- .: *
- .:
- . $ " *
% #4 >
+$ < $ ( %$ %
# %
%
0
%
$ %
4 ;*<
? B $6% "&*3," + &76-"4", ! * & 1B0B01<& ++$2& 6-"&6* & %%
& 00B01<)" $+ , "+& & $62+?
& 6
$ 6-" % &* &%& "&" +& ) " % &* &%"&
$ &- $+" $+ "
E
" ,,+ , " + -) &+"7$2& &
&&+& , "+& 6"&2,,5& +>$ ,,+
$6% "&3"
& ("&, & & "&*(6&76-"
" 2-,2 & 322& $("+$ ," &%&2 >$-)
+,+ , ( 3"
+ &% 3& + 6- "
>$-,,+" "& 6,$ ">$-6 6&+" , &- $+ ($ 2 +
$ 6- " % &* &%"+% &$"- +
"& "&6 +,&-
+,+ $+ 6-"+% &$"-" % &* +&- &
&&+ , " ,,+ , " 5& +>$ 422+:% 3" ,%",,+,"5& +>$ 422+"& +&+ ",,+," +-"
6, &
&6$ " ,&+ *2* "$ ;) "
+$2 "&* &%&22- + &(& " 3" &+ & " +
$ * %% & 00B01<
,+ &2 %& "
+,+&*% 2& 6-" " 2-"+"&( " * $ "%$ $2," &-&& 4*2 *+ :$ "%&
&2;) $2 )01<"2*&?&+ ," 2- & <1001/)&
"$
( % 4 +$ < + 6 0
# %
% *% * # %
1
/
$
$
@
< # %
%
(
% +$< &' 6 !
8 4 +$ + % < + 6 $
% "
$ &' .
-.
+ 64 -.
A *
3 - 3 !. -.
# % 0
+ 6 4 (
% + 6
% "
# %
4 +$ + % /
' 3)) 3
-*
.
1 6' .
> (
%
1
+% 4 * : (- .:*
- .
- . $ " *
% # 4
> $ $
!
# % 4 1
# %
$
4
63 BCCD226
B CCC222 A
" * *% !
( % + 0 *
-
/
. + ( *
8
$
$
-
/
.
2
# %
$ $
+ 0 *
-
/
. $ $
( %
, $ D
"
4%" D
"
4E D
"
4E " D
"
4E
"
4 < E D
"
4 / D
"
4 699 % D
"
4D
"
4"$D
"
4 8 F
8
"% E + *% , -" % . G + 0 *
-
/
. + (* %
% $ %
+0 *
-
/
. ) (
+ *% *
+ 0 *
-
/
. 1 %
8 8 F
8
% (*
$ $
*%* %
3F
8
/ 3F 8 F
8 3F) 8 F
8-1 6'
6'3.%$+0 *
$
1 G
1
8 %
-1 6')6'
.
88 F
8 1 $%
"
4 + *% * $
88 F
8%$
/
+ 0 *
$ 1 4
%
$
# %
B +( *
1 %
8-1 6'86' .
%
( 0
:
/
+0 *
%
$
D
:
8: 8 8' 8
8
!!'
!3
8
)F'
3
) 3'
) ) F
8
3 '
8 8 3'
8 )
FF'
!
)!'
)! F
88' 88
8
!8'
!
8
F8'
F
) '
) F F
F'
8
!F'
3F
8
F)'
)!
'
)!! F
883' 88)
8
3)'
8
F!'
F3
)!3'
)!) F
)'
8
3!'
33
8
F'
F
)!
'
)!8 F
8 ' 8
8
!)'
!
8
8 !
F'
!!
)! '
)!F F
-1 6'F
6'
.
( %
%
G
$
0
"
% ' :+ 0 *
( BD2226' * *% % !
4 $% $ :6
/ '
+ 0 *
<
%
5% :+0 *
-
/
. %$
0
( 50$ +
4
" "
G " <
/
$
"
D G 4$0 % 0 &' +
8- .
8- * .
- . F
- .
# %
+B -$
H 5
4. $
$
9
%
1
!
10
" # " $ %&
'()*%& E
,(" &%)2& 4$ 2+
"&& $ &2 ,"&, & >$++2&2- &62 " "&" "& &7&22 & >$&
3"" +2 F" , & &%&6$ "(( + ( & &7&
&
+2$ (,
$&+ , $+ & , $6%
,"
)"3*)
+)" +&"2 2&62,"2&
& 2&?- "3 " &,"5& +>$ ,,+)&+"7$2&,2(,"3
&% & 2 " G$+ &
2+&)
" %& , +*-6(% 6-" A62 ("4$ &2 $6% 6- "+$ 2," "&&," &
(,& , &$ >$) &+*2% +22&$ &
&23& , 6$" &%3& %
& 2&+7( % &2 $6% "& *$&22- " & 4*2 $ 3&
%
* G$ (% & + & =01101/ & * "
$6 >$ 4*2 &
&2 &(& " &6* G$ (% & + 3& &2
%
)"3*)" &$ "&, 73" < ,$" +
"& & " ,+& & 01000=)" "& &2& -6?% ,% ,%&+, ,$+
+, $2B, CC& $2<, CCC , " +" $2 , " 4 , 4*2 + $) 180/) "+) "
+&6"2 2&62,,&2$&
&&+6"&2,, "5& +>$ ,,+ "& *"%2-&($ "&" >$- ,,+ &7 + & "
+,+ ,+ &7 6- "
11
& "& $ " +"&( "&* 6 * 3"$ + (&- , ( & 3"& $+ 9(*% "& 6 *2& 6- " + "& " &6 + , "
&,&2( &62 " +& &6$" 6( 62(& &
&&+ 6"&2, , " 5& +>$ ,,+)*"&6 +,&- $+ "&*(6
$ 6-" % &* &%)"+&6&,&$2,"&*(,&2 &
&&+ 6"&2, , " 5& +>$ 422+ 2(" , "
+,+ $+
$ 6- "
& ++$2& * %%
& 00B01<"5&3& 5( 2&* &%
,+ ,$" %& " , ( + 6- "
>$-,,+"+"&(" &% ?&+ & $ +&,& ( )
$ %
0
% %
I % 2
%
%
0
'' ( 0
$ $
1 0
9
29
%
0
( $
$
$
2
0 0
2
'
1 $ 1 >2 ;+ 4
A26
" / "
4 % % *
F 8>
$ $
$ 2
0
0
2
'1 $ 1 >* % % J>
$ $
$
4 ;+ 4
A26
" / " 2
B 9
0
$ $ >
B
0
+ * 0 %$ * "
0
$ + * 0
% %
(
$
> 2 %
1=
0
% 4 $%
%
$ $ 0
4 $ 2
4 $ $ 0
: $
( 0
0 $
+ 0 *
- /
. ) 2:2 I :
- I
.
/
-*
.
+$ "
# %
4:
4 :
9 29
0 *%*
*% , -" % , % .
% :
# % 2 # %
"
# % -$
0 $ : . :
# % "
4 $
0
# %
%
1B
*%* $ 0 1
% %
2 $ 1 0 # %
% * *% F
4 # % B :B
"
4 *
%
, % $
+$
"
4 2 0 :
) 51 :
%
* "
# % 4
,
:* "
# % 4 $
%
2
%
*% * '
/
-+ 0 *
. $ $
* "
# % 4 $ * "
# % 4
,
$ 0 $
0
'
1 " 9 69 #
0
$ 1 > "
51 :
51 :
J>
$ $
$ :
1E 2
:
:
$ :
"
$%
*
+$
'
"
# % # %
% %
$$
$ $ $
% %
2
"
G 2
D:
G G
) "
* !
" * %
% %
-
% % * E"6(* D:
< # D
6 - . 6", !3
( %
$ $
'1
$
0 $ :
2
%
0
%
0 $ $
:% 2%
$
/
3
5%
1< $
A I %
%
0 %
B
% 0
5% %
$$ :9
%
% $
%
9 % 0 2 %
0
%
0 2 / + "& & $ &2 , " &, & , ( +2&2-
"3 "& >$- ,,+ "& * ( " >$ , "
6( 62(& $ " &$ &- " *% $+ 9
$ 6- " +% &$"- &
&&+ & +
& $% "&" 6(&* 2& & (( " ,+& & 01000= +
"& & +"&( +&6"2 "&*6 * &(& & 2>$% 2- 22- " 6& , &- 2&+$& " ,+ +"&( >$ 6 &62 " 6- " +$( &% & " +& ) " ( ,,+ ,&2 2& &- * + &62 " " +"&( 6- ,( &- $+ 9,,+ %& &( "
1 &
&&+ 6"&2, , " 5& +>$ 422+ " &2
+$
"$%$ 2 6-" %&(",,+ , " 5& +>$ 422+
$ $+ & ,2 3
&%" $& 2-"&
2+&,&% $2(+ " +"&( "& 6 "2 6 * +G+$ & $% & 3"$ * %&7( & ,+ " $+
$ 6- " *%"&6 +," %&-6$ 6( +"&( 6-"
&)"+"&(&(& " +$2 "&*6 & 6 * ,$"+
"&"&, & &
+ 3 $ &(& $( " &( , + "3 +&$ +) "3*) 3"$ + (" &%)"%&G $ "%,
&(,"+% 3"+$%$2&*,,+"& 6% " 8 5& 4$ 2&
&( 6"&2,, " ,$"
$6% "&+& ," ,$" (" ,%"!% :1;90191< & 110801
$ 6- " + , +$) &-&& &22 + - ,,
&% ",,+"&"5&3,,+ &>$ &
&*, $+ "&* 6 +* ,% " ++ &% , &
&&+9 ,+," & +& "&,,+&2 + &(& ?
&" & %% ?&+ & $ < /
- .:
8:
8 F
8
1/ "9 & '
* "
4
*%
===== $ B : # % -
.
: "'%
"
4
*%
"
4
% "
4 *% " : *%
: *% 6% :51
%
%
%
:
1'
%
( +$ : # %
%
4"
*
:
"
% $
4
18
$
(
$
% %$ '
$
4 1'
$
$
(
*6 10 $6% "&& $ &2," &%+2&2- "3 "&"
"& &$"-&
&&+6"&2,,"
$( " 2*& % & "& &
+* + "& 6
$ * ,,+ & 110801&
&
$+
+)" +&6"2 66&+",&- $+ "& "&*6
$ 6-"+% &$"- 11 5& $- *+& &2) &-&&) "3*) +
"&" &%"& ,223 " + $ +6 $ " &-&&4*2 *+ :$ "%&
&2; $2 )01<&
$-,"&("& 6(& " "& &2 6 (& &
$-2& " * +6,">$-,,+3"
$6% & 3"+""+"&( 3 * &(& " $6% "& * "&,) " + - , " +"&( " & " >$- 3 &2 $2- * $ " (& &% 2
0
$- , "% 2,4 >$"+ ," + "3 +&$ +) " ,2 "
3& &2 (& &
$-,"&(6$"+" &
&&+ +
"& " + $ & +% 2& $ " &-&& 4*2 *+ :$ "%&
&2; $2 )01<"& 6,$22-+% 2 3"& "& " +"&( &(& " &6$ "&*( &
&&+ 6"&2,,"
5& +>$ 422+ &
322 &62 " ) $2( & , +*- &(& " 2&,, 6( &- 3&
&
)"3*)
$",&+"&&(& "% ,?
&& % , &$ >$(& ,&*$," 2&,, ) " +*2 $) & % +22&$ +*2 &
&2 3& &2 , 6- "
&%& " &%3& %
)"3*)+
"&" &3& & 3"" " 4*2 $ 3& *$&22- %
6- " G$ (% & + & =01101/ 6- " 4$ ,
&2 4*2 '$ (:
* ;)&+"7$2&& &2 &6$" $6 >$ &$ , "&
&26-" 2&,, 1
+
"&& & $2,"2&?-& (2(+ "3 6- " ) " 2&,, $ $2- +" "% 2* & " + ,
&?+">$6-&("&%$& "&&2
&++$," "& 6 $,, 6- "
& +
"& "
$ "%,
&(,"+% "23 & $(" 2+- "& 6 "3 " " & $ "%
* 6, 3"
1 1= ) "3*)
$ " ,&+ "& * ,,+
& 110801) "
+* + 3
$ &22 + - 9
&2 +- &
&&22+&
+*,
+,+ $+ "&*( 6 +* 6- " % &*
+& 1B " &($% "& 6 & 6"&2, , &- , "
& &-G$ (%+ 1E "&*"& 2& 4$ 2&
&(6"&2,," & & "&* ( "$(" " +$% &
3" " 3""&62&
&+ 1<
$ 2-) & %% , +"&( "& 6 * $ "
," &
&&+6"&2,,"5& +>$ ,,+ 1E 4*2 $ "& "& 6 , 6- " 5& 3 2&,, &(& " +*- +:
; 6- " ,,+ 6- " 5& +>$ ,,+ &2
$"&" "& &
&&+ 6"&2,," &, &-&&"$(""422+& 3& "
+* & , "&( 3" " &(& " 5& +>$ 422+3 &
"$ &+& 3"" "& &6 ,%" + ( &
& ," &6$ &
&&+ 6"&2, , " 5& +>$ ,,+ + $+ "& 6 +* 6-"%&
& , $+",,+*"$("%$2 22 "& 6 6-" "
+% 2 $+ & ,2 2-" &2 &2,",&+"&& + "& 6
&7 6- " 4", ! , " & , &-&& 1B0B01< :++$2& * %% & 00B01<; %& &( "& " ,,+ , " +- "&22&
&&+6"&2,,&- &% " &6 + , $+ ,% " % &* &% " &2 "( &*&2&62 + $+ $( " +$ ,
+ ( 6, " >$- ,,+ "& &-
+,+ $+ "& 6
$ 6-",,+,"5& +>$ ,,+6-" & , " &% +(",,+, +-)&+"7$2& &
&&+ 6"&2, , " 5& +>$ ,,+ 4&) "
+,++& "&",,+,"422+"& &2 ,3& 2 " ,,+ , " 5& +>$ ,,+ " ,,+ "& "- "$2
, "%&,& 6"&2,,"422+& 322* +"& 6&
$+ 6-"
6,">$-,,+"&&-
+,+
$+ "& 6
$ 6-",,+,"5& +>$ ,,+&
&&+"6"&2,&-&% "& 6%& 6- " & ,,+ $+ " ,2 2- $") "
&2&2 "
+,+&*%%& 6-" " 2-"& 3& ,2 "+"&("&$%$ 2 3 6-"%",,+ ,"5& +>$ ,,+),2 2-2-" 2&6$&2 "&
2+& 7(%2, 1 "(*$
$ ,&+$&2++$% &+ )3$2 "&* 6G$ , " &,"
?
+"
& + - &*2 6- " +
$ >$& +&$ &
= ,,+* **
"&*&2& -6&76-"% F"
, ( &% + 1/ "+& ," ,$"&$(% 6-",&+"& 110801)" &%,5&3& '$ + $+ ",,+, " +-&
&&+3"
& (+ ,&- $+ ,% " & % &* &% +) " + +%%$+& &2* %% & 00B01< &
* $2 * & 110801 + 6- " % " &, & & 110801 "& 6 ++$2& ) " , &$ >$ "& &2& - 6
&
)"+) "3$2 6&% + $+"3 " & , " &
& 3"$ $+ $+" +2&,+& 2-
$
"+& ," "&
$&+, $+"+2&,+&) "3& $ &$"-+% +&
&&+"&6 + , &- $+ "&*(6
$ 6- " % &* &% "2&?-),&-) "$ " &,"5& +>$ ,,+& " &," 3" "3 $ 2(+& "& &
& 6"&2,," &, &-&&"$(""422+ 18 322 2 2&3"&"6$ &62 "" +"&(2 " % &* &%& " &% 6 * 6- + 62 & 6G+* * + * ,% & $ &2 , " +2 ,+"&( &%,&22(& "&" ,+, &- $+ 9 "&"& 6%& 6-" (,,+6, ">$-,,+,3"+"" 3& 6&+""
B &%+&&76, , 32&
&3&-&&2(- +G+$ & (&2F &
$% &6$ " ,$+ 6
+"&( " %&- 6$ &%&2 + ( 6
+"&( 6-" &%& "&6 +,&- $+ 9,,+ 6( *2& ) " +& 6 "2 ($2- , "&*( +%% &-*2& ,%&+,&-
+,+ $-3"+"" 3& & ,% 0 &2 * ,% & $ &2 , " >$- "& & , ( "& 6 $ 6- " >$- ,,+ 6- 6 *( "& ?
+ ,% " *% 2& &
& 6"&2, , " (*%)"3*""& +*2-,&2 ,",+&
& 01000= ?% ( "% ,% ,%( ,$+ & & *
2& & 322 & " %% & 00B01< 3"+" "6 * " *%2& ,%(&
&&+?+ ,3" $+ " (& "&*
$ 6-" % &* &%"$ , "& ", ( + &(& " 6-">$-,,+ $,, ,% &
+&,"& % &* $+ 9
$ 6-" +% &$"- 1 >$- ,,+ &
& +"&( &+ %+"&+&22- & 3" ?
+ &
2- & % &&2% ",&+ & * +6$("6,"%& "&,
$6%" & 3""&+"&(9&22(& &
* ,%& 6G+* + & , " %&&2 2&+ 6, "% 4+2$
E
&36-">$-,,+ "$2 %,%&&&2+ &, " %&&2 & G$ $ + , & $- & $% , 6&+"", ,& >$-,,++&6 (& 6-"4$ 3"", ( &6& $ ? & 2*&%&&2& 3" " ++2$ & 6& $ + & , %&&2 $+ 9
$ 6- " *% "& 6 "2 6- "
A62 $ %4$"%&,-+
.
/ 0
1'*234/&$&*)33"&"* &-*&2$,"%&&2%$ 6 $+""&3$2 &%$($2,"% 2-
+,+"&( 3& ,$""2 "%&,-1
$
5 " $ !
6"
1'*244/$*72,"&"++2$ &>$- %$ 6 6& ? & 2*& %&&2 $ &2 , " "3 "& ,"%&&26,& +
&
$% 3"+" & 6$ ,%"*% $")" "(+ +& +"+ & 6-" & "&*$&22-"4*2 $ %
& *"&
&2&(& " &%"& 6 %
=
,&& "+,"
&"&" & *%"& $,, &2
, &++$," &
&( 6, "
&2 4*2 '$ ( :
* ;) &+"7$2& & & , &$ >$"&*(6 &
), "&"&6* & &($% 6,,%"2
$,, 6-"
&), &-) &++$,& , &$ >$(& 6-"4$6$
< 3& &++$,3(,$2 6$ %,"?+
&%$6-",,+ ,"5& +>$ ,,+" , ($62+ +$+&6 "2 2&62,"+ >$&22
, "&%&-"&*6 $,, " %&-
62- , $( 6$ % , " +% &2 ",,+,"5& +>$ ,,+& ,)& & +& +& ( $2,&-&+ ,%
& +%%
+%% 6-" ,,+,"5& +>$ 95& +>$ 422+)&-2
& ?+">$ +&$ )+*-, $+"2
$
6,,+ ,% "(,,+&2& ,%" +$(9 , ( &% B 2"$(" &2-)" ("4$3$2 & &4$, &
&2&(& & &
6-" $ "(&$"-)"3*)3"
$+" ,% ( $ "% 6& $ &
+&," * + & + & , " $+ 9,,+
$ 6- "(*%) $+"& , $ "%+&&23&- 6, 3" 6-" ("4$?+ , 3 ,G$ +&2*3 E " A62 $ %4$"%&,8 1 & .&&/ & )99:%:/$$32;)"& "2 "&*"$("" (" 4$ &+$,&
&2&(& &%&2>$- & "$2 &2-,$2
" "$( + $&2% -)&
"+7 "+ ++,"+$ , 2(+" &* &&
& $ (
$
;
$
$
$
2 %$ $
K
% 4 + % * - F3 . EG
!&- F38. 56 -*.L $
(
9 %$
'
) (
:
A
1
2
$
< " & + &6*) , "& " & /010 % ( $ "% ,
&( , " &$&2 +% 3"+$%$2&*,,+ &
6-"
&24", +&-*,
&-&& 6& $ 6G+* + & , 3 &
$ ""
& +-,,&$2) & ,&7( &+&(& "& % &*,,+3"3& &2&
& +" ,,&-?
2&&" & 2 6( 6-" " % $( "+6& & 2&626 &
/ " 3 ..2 ,( ' )/ +"
"# D " H""
&7(9&
9 H"" &62 9