Hardev Singh Sodhi v. State Of Punjab And Others
"#$%&&%'
#$#($) "#$*%&%'
+,#-"
"#$&%&%'
. /0
% 1 2
!"
# !
!
$
% & ''''
2
3% ( ) "
" *"&+
$ ,-.
$ !
%
! //01//, % 2 3
" ! 4
/(((/5(6*
78((+ "
"
"
(,(5/5(9*
786+ $5(50/5(: ;(5-/5(- !
< " $ $
" (9.!
$
$ / ) ! "
! ! " !
!3& $ = ! & $ &$ !>
!
5(50/55(?
" ! <2 @ 6/ 5950/55: ! :0, :09 :,( 2% " ! & @ , A #
"
) # " !
! ! B ! ( % A $ !
! !/;59/5(/
$ $ 5/" - 55518
$ $ 50 $ ) $ ! !/;59/5(/ B A !
! !
" ((5;/5(:*
78 -+ ; = 8$ !
! ! " $ $ ! ;55-/5(: *
7 80+ "
!
! $ !
! ! ) "!
%
%?@ (/5,( /5(:*
+
! " !
! " % $ (/5//5(- "!4 $ !
$ ! :0,
4 2% !
! ! :09 :,( 2% " $ "
5/
/5 55518 " 3$ : ) ?
$ " % $ /6((/5(,*
78,+
8
! "# $%& '( )
* +
"" ! "# % , - %& '(
'
. (
/ &
#""001
2 '.
!"##$%&' ("(
!
3! "!
- , 4
-
5 6
. !
#! "# 7( * % , - "" ! "#8
9 /
7
:
& 9 ! "# $%& '( )
5
/ %
.
(
7
;
.
< = 6 " 1 " 0! "! $;
. < > '.) 6 " 3 3 0! "! $
> ) %
. "! !! " %& '(0 '
;
. < (
7
/
#1? '
#13 #?" '
;
. < ! /
*
#13 #?" '
"!
'
%
"0 3 + )"
* +
@ 6
#
/
+
' '
# /
<
"" ! "#
#13 #?" '
6 "
5 & (
/
! "# $%& '( ) .
A 8 - ! @ (
(,5,/5(9*
78/+
;(5-/5(:
8
5
!0""! "? %B '.
%
B
5 =A'9 " ! "# % 6 $%6:;%B >C;4%) A "? ?! "3 D E ; A E '
A '.8
0 ) $ /;5,/5(9
"$ !
C $% 7
!05 !
$;55-/5(:
;(5-/5(- ) " !! @ ( (,(5/5(9*
786+
! ;(5-/5(-*!
$ 05
!+) !
!
8 D? 5 2 -' 6 " 1" ! "
= * A '
$; )
' A 6"?7! 7! " (!''7!7"
"0""! "#
& 1 3 5
& = * A '
2
*
2
' A = * A '
" ! "
% 6 A "?" ! "3 7( % > D E '. B ; A '
A 8 , ! !
(,5,/5(9*
78/+ (,(5/5(9*
786+"
5 $ ! 5659/5(6
" @ ( /(((/5(6*
78((+ " (,(5/5(9*
786+ " ! $5(50/5(: ;(5-/5(-
$
! C
"
3
C) $
! (,5;/5/(*
78(/+ "
/(((/5(6
" ! ! (/5-/5//*
78:+ "
9
/(((/5(6*
7 8((+ ) ! $
$ *+
(/ " $ ! "
8 & $ &
E(/E E(9.
6 -: 99918 ;556/5(- (,5;/5/( 0 ;6 ,,-18 6 -6 0:(18 A ! $ ( 59 5/918 ;556/5(- /956/5/5 0- 99518 5 69 9/518
1 5(5,/5(- (,5(/5/51 ; 0( -;918 , /; 5,-18 (;5:/5/( , 55 55518 (5-/5(- ) - 99 55518 9 9/ 55518 ) /0 :; -;018 6 " # G !
$ &$ & $ @ ( /
"
!
"
$
! A $$ ! &$ A A "
! $
3
" " "
C $ %
*, - .)$/$%"' (&)
$5(50/5(: ;(5-/5(- $ $ $ !
"
3
(5 A
!
$ (,5,/5(9 *
7 8/+ (,(5/5(9 *
786+ ! !
" ! $5(50/5(:
;(5-/5(-
" (,(5/5(9 " $
*!! !+ /(((/5(6 *
78((+"
$5(50/5(: ;(5-/5(- $ !! !!
" ! $ ! C
"
3
C"
! ! " "
$
" " !
" ! $ "
"!
!"
" $"
! ! $
* ! $ *+ " " "
< %
*
!.
)$$0%1'
&2/ %
3 ."#)&%)1'**%'1(( (( ' !
$ ! $ $
$ $5(50/5(: ;(5-/5(-
" ! ! $"
%
%
$ !!
$ (/ 2 !
!
(; ) 4 $ ! "
" ! $5(50/5(: ;(5-/5(-
$ *+
H (: ) !
"
!3 & $ = ! & $ &$ !> 5(50/55(?
" ! <2@ 6/5950/55: ! :0, :09 :,(2%"
& ! & @ , A #
"
# " !
! ! B ! ( % A $ !
! !/;59/5(/ $ )
$ !
! ! /;59/5(/ B A
!
! !" ((5;/5(:
*
78-+ (- !
! " $ $ ! ;55-/5(: *
7 80+ "
! $ !
! ! ) "!
$ %
%?@ (/5,( /5(:*
+2 $ "
" % $ (/5//5(- " !4 ! :0, 2% !
! ! :09 :,( 2%"$ "
) "
$ " " " % $ /6((/5(, *
7 8,+
$ " !
!
"
" B A
" ! ! "
&& !
$ 2" "
4
$
;55-/5(:*
78-+ $"
! !
$
"
!
$
(0 ! @ (
(,5,/5(9*
78/+
;(5-/5(:) $ /;5,/5(9 $5(50/5(: ;(5-/5(- "$ !
$ C $ % $ $ 7 05)
" !! @ ( (,(5/5(9 *
786+ " ! ;(5-/5(-*!
$ 05 !+ !
(,5,/5(9*
7 8/+ (,(5/5(9 *
7 86+ "
$ ! 5659/5(6
" @ ( /(((/5(6*
78((+ " (,(5/5(9 *
7 86+ " ! $ 5(50/5(: ;(5-/5(- ! C
"
3
C ) $ ! (,5;/5/(*
78(/+ "
/(((/5(6
" !
&
! (/5-/5// *
78:+
! (, ) %?@ (;-/; /5(/ *
+3
"
!
!
"
! (05/(660 (,5(/55() "
" " % 5((//5(/ $ $ %?@ ,/;; /5(5
! /-5-/5((*
7 8(+A A $ " $ (:5(/5(: *
7 8;+ (056/5(:
*
78:+ (9 ! " " ! ;55-/5(- (,5,/5(9 *
7 8/+ (,(5/5(9 *
7 86+
" (,(5/5(9*
786+ " !! ! /(((/5(6*
78 ((+ ! ! "
$ " ! ! ! $
% 4 , 3 5 6
."#"&7 33)&"2/ "
!! !!
"
! ) $ ! $ %
% 8 7 1#&2 "##0 3
3
)( #$ "#)#9:4 -
3:!
&4 7 6
. "#"( 7 33 )#&111 5 !
5 6 ."#"(7 33)#22$" (6 < ! $ ! $ !
!
!" B A ((5;/5(: " $ $ ! ! $ !" ! % B A $ (/5//5(- "
"
" $
$ " %
/6((/5(, " ! !
$ ! (,5,/5(9 *
78/+ (,(5/5(9*
786+ "
! !
$5(50/5(: ;(5-/5(-< $ " /5/51/5/(
/5 ) C $% *4 - ."#)(%1' 0#& !
"
3
C"
!"
$ 2 $ " $ !!
! $ "
!
$ "
!$ $ $""
) $ C $%
"&
& % 3 76 ,
.
"#)$%)' (/ "
8 "" 9 ,
.
F %& ; <
: ! " $ ) 5 ? # + %;
! " !0 #
G * F . +( "!
&
< E 9 C< =* ' ! ?$!) 5 ? ? + $! ?) 1
!#
* 8
$#)
+( HH I
5
/
* * * /
/
/
.
'
.
(( 5 * 8
5 &
&' 8 %
.
. "
;
/ + "
I * 8 *
5 * 8
* 6
" "!
( " 3"00?
.
6 8 "! 5 F %& /
G * F
*
% F %& ,
.
/ 8 /( ) $! $ %
% ;
3 .
"#"#%"' ()/ // < 4 , 3 5 6
."#"&7 33)&"2/9 8 7 1#&2 "##0 3
3 )( #$ "#)#9:4 -
3:! 76
."#"(7 33)#&111 5 !
5
& 6 ."#"(7 33)#22$"
!! !!
" ! /; < %
*
!.)$$0%1'
&2/ "
$ " ) $ 8 3 B
' ; %
&
%& 4 ' 62 $)
&& && && &&8 /: $
3
. "#)&%)1' ** %' 1(( %
$ " $ "
"
! ) $ 8 && && && && 5 .
2
&5
$ )
8 /- #
" ! ! " ") $
/(((/5(6*
78((+ " ! $ 5(50/5(: ;(5-/5(-
" ,.
$
$ $ " ! $ 5(56/5(- * $ $ $ + ! $ ) ! ! "
5;$ $ ! ! !
*%&%'
* 2
+ ?
3
1 I1@ ?
I1@