Sandeep Singh v. State Of Punjab
"#$ $%&'&()* +"(,$$-+&(./0+(1 $#&#&($2 3$2'1'
+#"#$ 1(4"5 $'-(,$(# *6
"78&(,$2+&(./0"..1 $#&#&($2 3$2'1'
+#"#$ 1(4"5 $'-(,$(#
2$'$(#) 2 ++&,/129"-&79/"((":
,;%"#$ 229+/"(41:
,;%"#$ 2#/$-$#&#&($2' '"2-2$$#9#/8"7:: 1(4"5 <<< /&' 2,$2 '/"77 ,&'-'$
+"(,$$-+&(./0+(13'+#"#$ 1(4"5!"(, *6
"78&(,$2+&(./0"..13'+#"#$ 1(4"5!"'5#/#/$'$-$#&#&('
/";$5$$( &7$,1(,$2+$%#&( = 2 '$$>&(.#/$5$($ &# 2$.17"25"&7 -$(,&(.#2&"7##/$-$#&#&($2'&(%"'$ ,"#$,*1(,$2 '$%#&('=:=:=: 6:
:2$.&'#$2$,"# 7&%$+#"#&(:"/"8 ?"7":&'#2&%# "@&7>" 1('$7 2#/$-"2#&$'/";$5$$(/$"2,
%"A$#5$2$.&'#$2$,(#/$'#"#$A$(# "(4&#+&(./&( 2$7"#&(#"(%%122$(%$#/"##>-7"%$(* A-7"&("(# "''$2#$,#/"#124"(#+&(./8"'/&'B1(.$252#/$2"(,/&A"(>8"'"
2&$(,'-$2-2'$%1#&(;$2'&(:?"@&2+&(./"(, "4"1'$,#$C#2# A($B 2A;$/&%7$'%A&(. 2A#/$2#8('"(,/&A"(>:8/8"'"
2A$2 2$'&,$(# #/$ &%>1- (&(1'$,#54$%#'1%/"%#&;&#B
77$."#&('"2$#/"# (* "2-2$$# +&(./ 0"22B%"77$, 1- 124"(#+&(./"(,"'>$,/&A"'"7'/&A"(>#%A$##/$ "2A/1'$ ($+/&;D"7,""(,8/$2$A&#,"&$($-/$8 +/&;D"7,"
817,"##$A-## "%&7&#"#$"%A-2A&'$5$#8$$(?"@&2"(, "4"(#/$ ($/"(,"(,/&A"(>(#/$#/$2A-7"&("(#/"'"''$2#$,#/"#/&A "(>"(,124"(#-2%$$,$,&("(((;";$/&%7$"(,#/$%A-7"&("(# /&A'$7 "7(.8&#//&'A"#$2("71(%7$"'-"7+&(./0/7""(,4"B 91A"2 778$,&("&''"($22"(%"2/&A"(>"(,124"(#/";&(. 2$"%/$,#/$ "2A/1'$8$2$"##"%>$,521#"77B5B"2-2$$#+&(./0"22B:
"4":?"@&2+&(./: ",/$B+/"A0 ",/&B":17"5&":$;$(,$20 "2&:
3&%>B "(,&#:+&A2"(://"441:"--B"(,E#/$21(&,$(#& &$,-$2'(':
8/8$2$"72$",B-2$'$(#+-$%& &%"77$."#&('"2$#/"#"2-2$$#+&(./0 "22B:?"@&2+&(./: "4""(,17"5&""A-1#"#$,"77#/$ 127&A5' /&A "(>5$&(."2A$,8&#/"(, 124"(#+&(./&$52#/$2 #/$ %A-7"&("(#8"'"7'"''"17#$,"(,/&'2&./#/"(,8"'%/--$,
"(,/$ 8"'&( 7&%#$,#/$2&(412&$'"'8$77/&A"(>"(,124"(#8$2$#/$(#">$( #&;&7'-&#"7:5/"2"(,"
#$2/";&(.5$$(",A&(&'#$2$, &2'#"&,8$2$ #">$(#A"(,$$-'-&#"7:A2&#'"2/&A"(>,&$,(#/$'"A$;$2B ,"#$:8/$2$"'124"(#+&(./8"'",A&##$,#A"(,$$-'-&#"7:A2&#'"2 +"(,$$-+&(./0+(1&$-$#&#&($2&(
8"' "22$'#$, ( * "(, "78&(,$2 +&(./ 0 "..1 &$ -$#&#&($2&( *6 8"'"22$'#$,(=* 1('$7"--$"2&(. 2#/$-$#&#&($2'&(#/$'$#8%(($%#$, -$#&#&('817,"2.1$#/"##/$("A$' #/$#8-$#&#&($2'/$2$&(,(# $;$( &(,"A$(#&( &(#/$ "' -$2&(&#&"7 ;$2'&( 2$%2,$, #/$ %A-7"&("(# "(4&#+&(.//$ &("7&(;$'#&."#&(2$-2#-7"%$,(2$%2,"#
= (($C12$-=/"'"7'5$$(",;$2#$,##%(#$(,#/"#4"B91A"2'(
"A91A"2:8/8"''#"#$,#5$"($B$8&#($''##/$%%122$(%$/"' A",$"'#"#$A$(##/"#+"(,$$-+&(./0+(1"(, "78&(,$2+&(./0 "..1&$#8-$#&#&($2'/$2$&(8$2$$A-7B$$'&(#/$7&F12;$(,' +/&;
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
5$&(."2A$,8&#/5&.
"(,/";&(.%"1'$,#/$"A-1#"#&('
#/$ 127&A5' /&A"(>(#/$,$-'&#&( 124"(#+&(./: ?
#/$2$&'(;$2#"%#E&(412B"##2&51#$,##/$-2$'$(#-$#&#&($2'(#/$-$2'( /&A"(> '&(%$,$%$"'$,! (' "2"'"A-1#"#&( #/$2&./#/"(, 124"(#+&(./&'
%(%$2($,:#/$'"A$&''-$%& &%"77B"##2&51#$,#"2-2$$#+&(./0"22B 8/&7$//"4410".."04"B "7/",%"1./#/7, #/$2&./#"2A /&'12#/"'5$$("--2&'$,#/"#&(#/$#2&"7#/"#/"'$('1$,: 1# 6=-2'$%1#&(8&#($''$' /";$5$$($C"A&($,#&77,"#$ /$#2&"7:"''1%/:817,#">$#&A$#%(%71,$
#.$'8&#/1#'"B&(.#/"##/$&(%&,$(#&' "($C#2$A$7B521#"7 "##"%>7"1(%/$,1-(/&A"(> '&(%$,$%$"'$,!"(,124"(#+&(./ 8$;$2:"'-$2;$2'&( A"#$2&"78&#($''&$ "(4&#+&(./:
52#/$2 124"(#+&(./"(,8/8"'#/$%A-7"&("(#"'"7'124"(# +&(.//&A'$7 :8/"72$",B'#"(,'$C"A&($,5$ 2$#/$2&"712#"' ? :(&(412B&'"##2&51#$,##/$-2$'$(#-$#&#&($2'(#/$-$2'( /&A "(> ,$%$"'$,! #&'"7'#/$%(#$(#&(2"&'$,5B%1('$7"--$"2&(. 2#/$ -$#&#&($2'#/"#$;$(#/1./#/$&(&#&"7;$2'&(8"'&(2$7"#&(##/$#"7>'
"%A-2A&'$#5$/$7,"##/$ "2A/1'$ +/&;D"7,"51##/$2$"
#$2 "("##$A-#/"'5$$(A",$#%/"(.$#/$;$2'&("(,'/8#/$%%122$(%$# 5$"#"7&F12;$(, +/&;D"7,""(,&('1%/-2%$''#/$-2$'$(##8 -$#&#&($2'&(#/$%"-"%&#B $A-7B$$' #/$7&F12;$(,'"2$'1./##5$ &A-7&%"#$, ?&#/1#A">&(."(B5'$2;"#&('(A$2&#':&(;&$8 #/$ ,&'%1''&("5;$"(,>$$-&(.&(;&$8#/$7$(.#/ &(%"2%$2"#&(&$
A2$#/"(GB$"2'"72$",B'1
$2$,5B#/$-$#&#&($2':#/$B"2$/$7, $(#$,##/$5$($ &# 5"&7%%2,&(.7B:#/$-2$'$(#-$#&#&(&'"778$,
$#&#&($2'5$$(7"2.$,(5"&7'154$%##'"#&' "%#&( 2&"712#E1#B ".&'#2"#$: "@&7>"
$#&#&(',&'-'$,
71%>B ?/$#/$2'-$">&(.E2$"'($,) $'
?/$#/$2 $-2#"57$)