← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/802/2026dismissed

Harnek Singh v. D.M. Cum-Appellate Tribunal Sri Muktsar Sahib And Others

2026-03-24Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi,Mr. Justice Parmod Goyal7 pages

 







  



!"#

$%&' !#/0

%()*)&+,!#1!#/

 22%+$  -   

!!

    

     



    

%*2&+3%+$ *  .   



 

  

.  

) 1#  -( " 



    2      "       

 

!" "# &

"3 (   "$    #  !" !   #   

'%4 9 % % %!  !4 " 5 "

         & & "3"#  ((  6   ""    

' !  & & "36    

' 

 "

 & " 3 7#8



  (   "

) "   3-" 

, *       +

, -"./  !" "      "      0"   !  " 

,-" !  :  # 

!!



#$         &  "3  (  (   

'&% %! #$ ! '

 ("

   "

!" ;

2# """ "      !    %  "3     

'%%%!      % "3 "##""#(   6 "$ #" 

,-"  < =  "

&   "3 #          " " " ##  

'&% %! !& "3 #"      %#"   &  "3  !" "   (  "$ & "3" 

,-" :  0#" "( (  ! 4" "# & "3(# 

>( ! " 

,-" 1 .#  2# " 

$   ! 6 ""  #   , " 

,-"%

!1! 

         

  

 



 

    

 !   

   

 " 



   #    

      

 

$$    

    

       $

    



   





$     

   $





 

$$  

   

   

       $    

$$  



 

 

   $  

 $ 

 



"

       



 

   

 



  

"

        

 " 



   

 



 

 "

     



   "  %   "  

 



     

 

 "

 &   



    $

 " 

 "

   '



    ( 

$  

"   

   )*$  '

 

 +, ?

 - " 

,-"!

 !   ( " 

,-"   (              "3          "

         !  ( " #   "

   ( "#   

 =#    4"# "     "    4#   #      

     

     

!

 "!  " (

" 

,-"  (   3  #   (  # ( "

  "   ( " 

!,!

,-"   ! "

   " '  (    (   @(

;  < , 4#% - .

$   $

 

       /    $  

  

   

 

 

 "

   $    

    

      $

 

  )  

"

     012



0     $     "



   &

  $     



 !

   

  $   

  $$    

   * 

 "  )

 " 

#      

  "

  

    $







3

$$

'

 

/  & 





   $   

 $  

   

 $



 *  

#      +

  



   

 $ 

   )  

     $   

 $

 # 

       &    $ $     

  $$         (  

 

    



 

0      $         

    

       '/   

 /     



  $ 

5"

.

   

 



$$ 65 





    

 $ $$



"

       0 12 

  

 0     $ $$

   017



5"

.





   

  $ 

     /  

116!    



$$

   ,

A  $        !     !   (#  "3 $"     ( "

% "3   !("  !6#

" 

,-" "

#!

"(" "



-4# 1 .#  

   #  

    $  .#   %#"  "3    ""  

!4! 6   ""( ("

("   "3"

" 2# " " ("% "3   "

"   !    #   #" ! 6  ( #  (  "

  

B   "    6  !"     !   " % %! "3 :#"!$(!  +".(" */

,-" !" %  $ , $

"

 " 

  " '"



 $  %, '

- #!

 !%%! " "! #" "# "3 ;

=  +(." */

,-" !"% " $ ,  $ "$



 $$



    

$

     %, < -  (!

 !7(8!

# " "3 !  #     "3.  !   "3 2"

""%%! "

( (!

!/!

:06 !" "

 ! ""

" 

,-"  "# "36(" %%!    2 #   "    

, -" "   $(! ( 

,-" %% ! "

( 7"8 7(8 (  (   "       "3 "   "    $  0"(   %%! " ! "3 (  % %!0"( 1"  "  " !      '

;

    )": !" "3!  , =   1 . #    2   

%&    #        ' ( 

 " )* +,      $"  -

  "  %%! ##   "

(" "  "3! %%!

 A"     "   #  # C #" D "-" 

<* +CD-" 

<./  ( %%! "

 ""##  #   $(!( (  CD-" 

<   %%!     "    7"8 ! "

, -"       # #        : (    4#      . / 0%

!5! 

  * 

 "    # 

$ " $  

   " 

"





  "       " 

 

 "



      

      $

 

 



$ 



 $ "

   

 



$ !$$  " 

 /  .

 ! 116 

     "

  

  $$ 

 



   " $ 

   "

 

 



$   

   "

8 9:!11+  $



#   



8$ 

"

      "

$ $ " $ 

$  "

 





   

 

 $



 

 

 8!; ) 1  $   $

 )3$$  

 

 

9: ! 11+     "

   $ "



       <

 $ " $

       $ 

 5 

"



  

 

    



 

 



$     

   

$

*  

 "  

   "

      

/ .

!116, ?

5"

   $(!4#   . / 0" "#%%!  # 

9(!  ""#" #

 

            ( ( " !    # 

" 

#

#" "    





 





;% '%

E     

$F G