Union Of India And Other v. No. 9398 Wg Cdr Ms Randhawa And Another (Retd.)




    
    



!"#$%#%&


     

  

 ! 

  '"  ()'

% *
 *
'

*
*
 ()'

% *
+
,**

$%



& '()&*+

 & * *+ ,(   

-&. '(+#/0& +, 22222  *
'

*
*
 -%.

)/  

( "

+( 0(&** '

( 3"' #& #45 6467  8 %1!"& #.9 6%3 #0

.&*+  '&*  :

0(+  (&#'&(  ( &,    ,  #    & ;

.&*<!+.9)(0(+&, 0# '( #&.*9, 1 =4>( #& , +( (&.

'& #&"

,
 

      .#$/*$#&-  &*')('&'( ,,#',, #&.*9"

,34>@4>&"

,(

,#&    +#0   * !1!*#&#%

 &' (&( ,,

6!

=@4>0*#(&/

'& #& (&#   #  ,3      03"*   ,  (     &#    #   /&*#&,3 &( 0&

)&0&* ## ( *)3 #0&*0& '9&#( +'&,.

.9 .&*0 0



#  0 *  &""

&'    .

(&*,  ,      .3  (&  &  "

  ( #  "0"*  ,  *&)+  /   &  (  , 03"* ,  +0& & 3"*9

,, '( #&.*9)(0( 3 (&64>+( '&,#&.*9"

,&/,0( 3"*9

 &#3.* &#( +( '&,( &#.

,B

"'/ )( ,#'  ,  ( % / 9 

#0&*  :&#+  )(   (  #&.*9  , 1(&.

,#.

4>+( &#3.* &#(&'(*9.

'& # 1.9#'

,,( #&.*9,34>@4>

 (&/ ( &#* "& &#(&/ ' ('(( ,* )(( &.* &&0

@

0 + ,*&)(& / &,,0 +)( ,3 .,#.

,, ',3#&.*9)(0( &  #3 (&64>&#( &3  &.&.* ( 3*&9 &''&/& 3*&9 +( '&,#&.*9"

  &#3.* +  ( +  (  '&  ,  (  .

,  ,  #&.*9  "

      1   (  .& , ( % / 9

#0&* :&#  "+ )( +( #&.*9(&.

,#.

4>&.&.* 3*&9

!

+( ,#' 0# .&*0&.

 & #&"

/ 

,&0, ,*&)

  #.+  )(   &**9      1  )&   #+  ( #&.*9)&&  #&.

)

1@>1>+)(0(* (&64>& # 9( +.0 % / 9

#0&*:&# %&  #( #&.*9, 1&#,#( &##&.*9 4> &#,1@>1>+( 0*&3, 1)&0/ ,( '&#&.*9"

+&( # & D#&.*9,)(0(( , )&.

'0*&3 ### 8&( 3 )( ( ? #(  &# ( *90&0 #( &##&.*9#'(  #&#&"

?#'3 ,( ,#& 
 

      .#$/*$#&-   0(0& ( &#3.*

( * /&"&& 4&#6 ,( 
 

  "&!& &# $% E4 ( 0& #" #(& ,  &9  # &  (&  .

   0# #  &  (  , &""

**&F  &00 "&0  ,  3*&9  

(   (&/  ,&* #    .'     0#  &9 #03   ''

 (& (  &""

**&  )&  #  &3 ,0(&# & .9( #&9(  ,, ',30(# &

&. ,&9   0#&( 3 ,&00 "&0 ,?'

,  &""

**&    )&  03.

    (  "&  ,  (

#0&*:&#0&**, 0#&#*B( &3 03'&"(&( # & 0*#(&/

# 0 #3 #0&* 8&3& "    (  &00 "&0  ,  3*&9   +  .

7!

('( 0#''

(&&90( 0#)&0&** #,.9(

#0&*:&#*B &# &(&/

 0# #)' 03 ( 00*(&( #&.*9#  3*&9

,&0+%&""*0&,3#,

#0&*  :&#    &""&   ,3  *&  #!  , "&&'&"(6,( ",(

#0&*:&#+ )(0(&,**)$ E #!( ,&#&.*9# ( .&# (*#& )(& 8&0*9( "( 0& , G &.*9 *& #3* 6

" ,( &, &#"/+(

&0'  (9  ,&* #    0  (&  (

#0&*:&#(&#'/ &9 &"", "+"&0*&*9)( (  ,0( # & #&.*9&/&*&.* (  0#, &""

**&&( 3 ,&00 "&0 ,3*&9

(''('(( &, &#,&0(

 &0'(93 0(&0&**9"& 3"' , ?

0.& #( ",

#0&*  :&#    "

  *   @  &#    , F*  * ,&&*9

&9)&#+ 16F+( &""

**& #," 3"&# ,," 3"(,&/ &. , &9 /#  0#()(&( &""

**&)& ,, ',3I  &* # J  "* "9!H&( 3 ,&00 "&0 ,( +)**.

3 (&( &""

**&)&#"(90&*&#3 &* 0#  &  (  ,   '  (  &# &   (  ( &*(  (&  &B   "*&0  #  

( +&"

 ,*&) #.9

@!

,#&  +#0 * !1!*#&#+)( (&.

( *#(&&3 #0 "

 * #.

'& #( ,,#',,)( '&# + "

0/ ,( ,&0(&( )&/&*#& #, + #&&'( &'

,"

&&03"* , (  ,( '&'

+,,#.

,, ',33 #&.*9 )(0(&.&.* &''&/& *&9

 * /&"&& ,(  0&  "&!& &# $% E7 :9(  ,&""

&*( &""

**& !

& ( K +)( +&#/#&*+)( (& #&&'( &'

,"

&& 03"* ,(  , '&'

+,,#   .

 ,, '  ,3  3  #&.*9  )(0(   &.&.* &''&/& 3*&9 +

#.

'& #( ,,#'%,,, #&.*9  "

(  &""

**& !  (   )*# 0 #  (&+    (  .&  ,  0*&  

1 6!D5D

%! 9, , + / 3 ,#&+#& #1 6441+( &, &# ,3&# &/&*&.* *9&3 #0

 *)(/&*#& #, +&# &9  (   0& '9  ,  3 #  0  

 *  #( &./

@  (&/ ( &#* "& ( *

  #    

 &9      (  3"' ?#'3  !&##  !&#( &**( &""

&* )(0("

&( 00 ",#'%,,,( & #3 #+)(# & 0

( #3&*,( 3& )**.

&B

C!

 ,.9( '(&) **&.9( .&* '&'&"""& * ,( .

3+,&9+)(& '

'& #( 

 (&.

&.* #" &#"",*&)(&/'.

 ,#& 
 

  0&  "&!&#   0& "&!



( &'3 (&.

&

+( &. ,&9"

/ 9.

'" #( 3"' #& #45 6467  8 %1! ( .&,( ,&0    ( #  "0"*  ,  *&)+   
   

       

     

00#'*9+( )"

#3

. *
'

*
*
/  .+
,**

/ !234#$-& 

( "

&B'D & (  "&.*