← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/27046/2018dismissed

Gaurav Gupta v. Joginder Goel And ANR

2018-11-13Mr. Justice Girish Agnihotri6 pages

 

     

    

 

  !" ###$""  %& & '

(

) "*   ###&!

"&  

    +++++ $&" !,') - " "*!""      .*!"" *&)!&"!""  /" $  &""( & "* ! ( 1 2-3  $4 5*6"* !)" /" &



1

 78$)6 "*!""  !)"(&""*&!

"&5&&&&6) *' )(&"" 9"*) /))6  "* : (" "   2-3  $4 *& )&   ! (  5*6 "* &  !""  ) 6 "* !""  (&" "*  & 1 !&& 6 ) (&"" 5&&&&6)-" )/&& &' ( 9"*) 7)6&"" !""    !"2*"" & !)"4 * )   !)" (&" &!

"&     '

(

) :9 2*"" &"* &45"*



"*))(" &"*""* &!"6&, 5"

!)" "*)&"  6&.*!*5 "* !)"5&)) & *)! "* !)" (*&))&&- & &"*!*5  &  7 "* "*  & & "

 !!)6   !) "&  ;<- 5* (&""  5& ) "  "* /""  ;6 .*  & ))  "* !)""

:

"*"*& &&&.* &*&"""*""*6 * ! *&  !) " " /"

 

 9  ,&*"   ()6  "* !)"(&

="

"* &&*&&*"

"*3""  >7)9 ),! & *" * :),! *(

> &* 5*&&" "*&*5&"

(6"* & .*

") "&* ;<-!) "&"?)) &""/&"* &!!) "*!) ""*  )&  ;

"*  & 5"* )  &* &"""    "* 6(( " &(),*@ & "* !"3" "*" "*& *@ &  "

  ( "

 ;<-   ?))  " "  )"&  "* & 5 "

  "  "

5* "* &")"&  "* !) " 5 ) .*  !)"   " &6&* &"6.* !)"7)9 &,"* & !"6 ""*&"" & !) "9  ,&*";

"* &!"6,!"

)(("*"" "*!"3" !*,;

)" "* !)"  "

 , 5 "*" "*  & *  " ! *& 6 !) " " 9  ,&*"   "* (   )  &!6 ( &

= !)" A 0    &    : 9   "

 "* !)" "

 &"")  "&  )   "* !) " " ?))  ( 



*@      "  &

= "

!)" ;

  5*"*&*@ 5&!&"6"* !)"*& , "

"*&5&&*   " & " &

1 .* !)"!! *"* &!& & 5* &&  *"

!6"*& ") (5"*&"""  "&)  "* !) ""9  ,&*".*" - ( &"  !)" "   "*  "   "

 , 5 "*"  &   *& )  !)"  /"     "* ( ") 8&" "& -"

  6 & &("**@ " &""

"* &!& & ) &("*& 5"*"*!!)"   ;<-!) ""?)) .* &  !)" 5& &"   @ 6  /"    $ 5*"*?@ 6A!

""*""*!"&* "6 "&" 5"** "*- & *!

&"" 65"* ;<- /&"*    !"

 ""*  *& "* '(&* !"   " !   6   " "

 &* 5 "*"  65&" ))6(6"* ! *& ;<-!) ".* & "5& "*""*!"&)(5"** "*! !"6 &&& &*("*! "& " ))6 B*) &&&( "*  !)"  ! (

1 )") "*& &&        



        

 

     

 

   

            

    

  

 



   



 

     

     

!

  "

     # $%&  !

  ' ( " )**+,+-



. ., -/0*, - 

!

 1 2 #  3  )**/,0-. ., -405, -      

  



       

  

 

    

             

       

    

  

      

                  

 

     

   

  6  

    

 

 6    C .*  & 1 !&& 6 ) ") "5&*))(6"*!""  "*& 6 "

 ""* &  !""  5& )&  &&& 6 ) -" ) /&& & ' ( 9"*)! (: (""  8"&"*& &"& !)"*&)"*!&" !""  D &) "* !)"*&( "*""* "& ) 5 * &  & &"  "* ) & 5)) &   "6     .*  !)" *& &")&*     & (&" "*  & .*  ""  & 6 "*  !)" "*" "*  &*)) *"

:

"*"* &&& ! *&(!) "&*& 5 ()6&)6"* "&) 5.* &* " ),&(*@ & "*( "*""**@ & @ "

("

;<-"& "?));

5* !)" &, "*  &  " "* &"" &  !) " " 9  ,&*" 5**"*6*!!) ""&!"*""* &* "! *&6



!) ""9  ,&*" "*( ) &!6 *( &

= !)" ; *&  "*  " "*"  &   * )&  )  !)" /"   "*( ")8&" "&-"

(&" "* !)""*" !)"

!)"5&@ "" "* *(&(&"*6)' )(&""&")&& 9"*) : (""

  2-3 $ 4 .*!" &

=!

&"5"*"*;(* "D56& B)E  & 6"*& " "    *& !  6) &) "* !)" "

5**&",   ;( * )  &)   "*  !)"

 "*&  " &"*""* !)"*&)"

! "*" 65&("

"*  & " "* " 5* "* !) " " 9  ,&*" 5& !!) ?

"*5&  "* "" 5& &"   @ 6 & !   /"    $  5* " 5& !

" "*" "* !"& *  "6 "&" & 5"** "*"&  "  "6&! " !)"*& ) .* ( "  )  &)   "* !""  "*"   !)" /"   "*( ")8&" "&-"

)6  &   !)"

 5*  5& 6 &   & *&  @ "" "**((&"*: (""

   2-3 $ & ")"*&"*"&  &  5* 5& !)" "*  * ) "

 !  "*" "* *@  5& &&   &*(   )())6 3&"( ))"6 "*  "* & : ("  "*

 

& &"""&"*""*""*!"& ) "6"&" & .*   "*&  " & "*" "*  !)" *& ) "

 , " 

 &(&""* &5** )5""*&  ( "* & .* &  "*  "& ) 5 * (*")6 ) "

 &   "*  & - ()6 "*!&"!"" (  6"

& &&&     

  !"#$    F( "" B*"*&!,(=&   F& B*"*!

")