Pankaj Chandgothia v. Chandigarh Administration And ORS.




   
   
 

!"#$#%&'&()  !(+!,-!($."-&!  / #"&"&(#0  1#0'2' -!($&.!0-$3&(&'"0!"&(!($"-#0'    #'4($#("'
 


  
 
 


 

  

0#'#(") 0 !(+!,-!($."-&!5$6%!"#4#"&"&(#0&(4#0'( 0 !(+!,!&(5707"!($&(.2('#80 (&(#00&"095 -!($&.!0- ::::   
 

 &"- "-# %('#("  "-# 4#"&"&(#0 !($ "-# 8#!0(#$ 7#(&0 7"!($&(.2('#8!44#!0&(.0"-#0#'4($#("'5"-#3!""#0&';#&(."!+#(24 !($-#!0$6&!6&$#%(#0#(%&(. #;#<44'"=!0#  -&'4#"&"&(;9=!942;8&%&("#0#'"8&"&.!"&(&'!.!&('""-# 0$#0 $!"#$ >   4!''#$ ;9 "-# 0#'4($#("!2"-0&"&#' =-#0#;9 "-# 0#'4($#("!2"-0&"&#'-!6#&''2#$%#0"!&($&0#%"&('0#8!"&(."0#8!<!"&(&( ##' " ;# %-!0.#$ ;9 "-# 40&6!"# #$2%!"&(!8 &('"&"2"&(' =&"- 20"-#0 '"&428!"&( 0#.!0$&(. $#4'&"  ## !"#0 "-# $!"# 40#'%0&;#$ !($ "-# %('#?2#(%#'"-#0#
"&''2;3&""#$"-!" (&(#00&"095-!($&.!0--!' 40#6&2'89'"!"#$"-!"(#3("-"&3#=28$;#.&6#(""-#4!0#("'@'"2$#("' "$#4'&""-###'0"-#3("-'40&8!($!95 !

"#0"-#'%-8' 0#4#( =#6#05 '2;'#?2#("89 ;9 "-# 0#6&'#$ .2&$#8&(#'@0$#0 $!"#$ >  &"&'(='"!"#$"-!""-#8!'"$!"#"$#4'&""-#"2&"&(##'0"-# 3("-'40&8!($!95 =28$;#A>  !($(8!"###=28$ ;#%-!0.#$
"&''2;3&""#$"-!"%20"!&8&(."-#4#0&$0$#4'&"&(."-###' 0 "-# 3("-'  40&8 !($ !95   &' !.!&('" "-# &("#0#'"  "-# 4!0#("'@'"2$#("' =- !0# !%&(. $&&%28"9 &( $#4'&"&(. "-# ## ( A>  (!





#!0(#$ 7#(&0 7"!($&(. 2('#8 !44#!0&(. 0 (&( #00&"095-!($&.!0-'2;3&"'"-!"&("-#0#6&'#$0$#0''#6#0!80#8&#'-!6# ;##(.0!("#$""-#4!0#("'@'"2$#("'!($2($#04!0!.0!4-C"-#'!&$0$#0 &"-!'20"-#0;##(%8!0&&#$"-!"&(%!'#!(94!0#("!&8'"$#4'&""-###&( "&3# !($ &' &($&(. &" $&&%28" " $ '5 "-#9 3!9 !440!%- "-# '%-8 !2"-0&"&#' 0 0#8!<!"&( !($ "-#&0 0#?2#'" '-!88 ;# %('&$#0#$ ( %!'# " %!'#;!'&'!($&("-#3#!(=-&8#"-#(!3#"-#'"2$#("'-!88(";#'"02%+ 03"-#0#%0$(0"-#'"2$#("=28$;#$#40&6#$(8&(#"#!%-&(.( !%%2("((4!93#("## 
"&'20"-#04&("#$2""-!""-#4#"&"&(&(?2#'"&(&'!;'82"#89 .#(#0!8!($6!.

2#!'(4!0"&%28!0&('"!(%#-!0$'-&4-!';##(4&("#$2"
"&';02.-"""-#("&%#"-&'20""-!"&('&3&8!0 
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

# ;9 "-#
($#4#($#(" 7%-8' ''%&!"&(5 -!($&.!

#.$ !($"-#0'67"!"# 2(,!;!($"-#0'&(&6&80&"

#"&"&(EC B &(=-&%-%#0"!&(&("#0&30$#0'-!6#;##(4!''#$ ;9"-&'20"(  3!+&(.!(&("#0&3!00!(.#3#("!($"-#0#!"#0 8&'"&(."-#%!'#(> 
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

1
7F    
  7