(O&M) State Of Punjab And ANR. v. Mangat Rai









 


 



 



 







 


 

 




 


  !"#$%
&'() %
%*!)(($   

 !"#$ %%  &
 '( % +++++
%*!)(($,& )  * +   % %%   $ +( *+ #"*&( ,-

%$. ++ /++( 0"*  0   1 $. %%  *+ #"*&  (  -2- 

 % $.   +  )" +&++* "+ 

1 1 +&%"*#"*&(1 +"+ + $.

( +1(  

(  -2

22%$. ! * "#$
1. + + *  " ($     %    $ +   $ +1+ %( +%.31*+ 

-2

221%  %3% ++

 *
+  ("( + "#$
1.0   1*+'%"+ & +(&

(%.'$' "$+( 1(

"%+%+1 +'+ -2

224



 1 ( *5      *+   

-,

1  1".)"($"  5" 0   +&  +"+( %*' +*

&0  6"

+ " (&&+&$77 & "
8 -%   (&% +* %("  & ++  *"  %&  +9"+.1("( :9"+.

+("$&+%  +* %*"+ . +(  ( *(%. +9"+.% 1 "%% +   1 (" +( 1 +"   1 .  +9"  " $&' &'+(4 %"$&+% .   1 (" +(  '" . +&%"*   -2

22 +&%+*% . +(&1+

(1 %$. (&%" +.  +  )" & +"  +( + % ,  #"*& +)"4 %+1%&+"('+(+ "%%  + %(+' (+  ;'+*  ("    %++  +*  &+ ( + )"1+"   *+   %3% ++

  (9" . "+ +  $. 

1+&+ $+(

+%% )"((% %% % $.% + #"*&(%$. + )"( "+ + &++(  )"     %%  1"  *"   %%  )" ' + )"+"  +*+%

  #"*& "* %% )" + % -   #"*&  ((%   )+'+  )" ( + + %% ' :9"+.

+(:+' & .*" (+% #"*& + % +*

'+("($.

"( &(       #"+(+  ("+.  ; 1"  "  *"  +&%"*  $+ %&+ #(+* % . 1("+(+% +* +" %. '$'"$+( 1(+'++ %1 *+'.+(%%"+. $+* + +* +'+1 %'++ 
" 8  "#$)+'+ '+(
" $. .+* "%#"*&

  

  "#$

 %
&'()
*&+
,
-./((+*(" +&%"*+% +*  %"+ +*" +.$. +* +'+1+ & +&%%"+ &  .+(&1+ ("&" +' 

('+5<5'+ %%%"+ & &'  &'+( )"  %+*   % +  +  %++  "%% +*+*$.  +%% )" +% #"*& 1 (.% +*'+(&"(  %  +$. &% . %#"+( $(" +&" &  ;1'  "%% ++*  + %%  )" ( + %

   1+  *  +&%"*  $+*  5 % +* +" %. 1('$'"$+(  1($+*+'+ + %+(+%  " #"+(+( 1'"% +9"$ ("+* +& +(+   : ' ("  %+ %" %%5$ (   ++*($. +%% )"+%

   #"*&  & ( $  1"+ $+*$. % +*'+(4 %% )" $ 1 +  &  "  1 ( + + 7   + "  +   +9"+.

, %(+*+&%"*: +'+1 &  1+*  +   &+   %%  )" + '+1   + $'+ (+% #"*& "  &++* % +* '+( " "

 &%'+. +$+* )" %% )" %"+ +* " +.   %  % +*  1 +   +* 1+ % .   1 (" +(  +&%+* %% % .   &'  "  % . 1("+(1" '   %+ ++"%+".+*" +++ * ++++9"+. %(+*%"$&+$. :9"+.

+( (.

#"+ (1 +( 1% $. +& +% . ( *5  (% 4 (" +%"+$.

+% . ( *5 +('   *+ + *+ +& 1   "$#(&   %(+* ("($. :9"+.

+()"  %  +  (+. 1%( +  +9"&% .+% . 1 ("+( +&%+*% .& .+ + (% + + % .    ( *5   %"+ +* " +. + 9"+  5 =&+ ++"%% +*4 %% )" "=&++*( % . $.  +9"+ % .+(  ( * %(+ +&%"* $. .+*   % .   1 (" +(   $ +%   $. %+*  % +*     &  (  + % .   1 (" +(  % +  %+ " . *  1  ("  +*" +. +   +9"+. %(+*   + . "(  %   +&%+* % . &'  &'+(+(&&" *'+. ( * &*+ +& +'+1+9"+$

 + (+("&($++*+ +("(

+&%"* ($ " 1+ $.  +*  &+% +*  $+*  ++*  + %%  )" 1+  *  +&%"*$+* " . 1 $"%(( %%(++ &+ (($ 1"+ +$+* )" +" %. 1(' $'"$+( 1()"  %  +  %+".%'+++
" 8  &+($'  +9"+ *+'(+("&($(" %+(   +&+   &'   %5&" +& & '+(  4 #"*& +"%$. %% )"+

  0
1 "% + $ "% #"*&   ;>$    "%& )" + 
"2 

  !
3%
&'/-
,
(45 : 
"2 0
1 "% 

+(+ ((1 " .= ( * '  *+ +&  +   (+("&(  ;>$    "%& )" $.  .+*"%+ +(++6
 27

"

  63
 %
&'8/
,
(..      #"+(  + % . &   !'&  "  ' *+'   %%   $ %%"+. 1("1 .

(+* +%. & "& +%#"+( " $&+ ( 

+%% )"++&%+*% . %%* +(&1+

(++'+1  +("+ &    "  ( .

+ " .= ( * ' *+

+&: *+'(+("&(

(+'. '*  + (+ &   #"*& +

  0
1 "%$. +)"#"*& ;>$  "%&)"+

 
"2 0
1
"%     (.

 #"*&   ;?$   "%& )"  

9

  



:;

#:

271%
&'/-
,
44  +
"2 <
1 "% 1" $%% +($ + '" %% "  #"*&

+ %%  )" +* +  ++* %. '  $' "$+( 1(++ :'+1 1 $+(" %% +  1 0"*& (%$.  + %% )"+  +" (9"( #"*&(%$. +  )"+4 "+ + $.

++&+ ( "* "  ,
&'%
-.&'














* 
6,+
@/!" +?













 
 % +*3  .3  %$   .3