← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8311/2019allowed

M/S P And R Infraprojects Ltd v. Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd And Others

2019-12-13Mr. Justice Deepak Sibal4 pages



       

   !"#$"%&'&() 

*+' , (# -."%!'/!$   "!&!&("          0  

 / ($!1"'  "'-($"(!'

 *)  2/*   3/

"'"(!) *  ( 4$5% !" ($ * ( 4$5% !"4#!1"-"!&!&(" * 678&! &(4$5% !"4# * 1&71 9 4$5% !"4#!1""'-($"(!'  :::::::

 3/4;

/< 1"%('!6%!&(#= 7 (%">8%9-&'&(?# !#" $, &7

%"1 (("74 >"6'"6&7$&(?4 '1 %84(! 8"4 #!6="4(! 8",  #!6=" !"', 7777&"$-!"%!&(>8#*68"& (@$"7 ."%!! !" > ' 77!!"$!!1"-"!&!&("=@!1""'-($"(!' 6(. =! !" >"- !&( /&9&!"$;#'1!4!1"- !&(< (!1&'"? $(

!1"- !&"'

"(!""$ &(! ( ?""9"(!>1&%1 %(! &("$%7 6'" 

 ' -">1&%1 $&'-6!"'

="!>""(!1"9>""!="'"!!7"$!16?1 =&! !&( 6&(?!1"%6'"#$&'%1 ?&(?!1" =5" 77!!"$>8$&'-6!"' '"="!>""(!1"- !&"'1"-"!&!&("4 #!"&(58&(?!1" #"' &$ =&! !&( %7 6'"4  >!"  !  !1"  - !&(  '""8&(?  --&(!9"(!  #  (  =&! !   1" - !&($&$(!"'-($1"-"!&!&("!1"(#&7"$ -"!&!&(="#"!1&'6! 6($""%!&(;A<#!1"=&! !&( ($(%&7& !&(%!4A;#'1!4!1" %!<'""8&(? --&(!9"(!# (=&! !16?1$"$ !"$B

C!1&'

6! --&(!"$*6'!&%"(&7  5"4 #9"6$?"#!1"6-"9"6!# ($&  '!1"'7"=&! ! 1"  -"!&!&("  #&7"$  &!'  %7 &9'  ="#"  !1"  =&! !  !  >1&%1  !1" - !&(#&7"$!1"&%6(!"1"" #!" ( --7&% !&(> '#&7"$=@!1"-"!&!&(" '""8&(?"D"9-!&(#9!1"- @9"(!# E#!1"%7 &9>1&%1> '"F6&"$!="

G H #6(&'1"$ '-"%7 6'"

;5&&&<#!1" #"' &$ ?""9"(!="!>""(!1"- !&"' 1"- !&(--'"$!1"-"!&!&("2'- @"(!1"?6($!1 !!1""F6&"9"(! !9 8"!1"$"-'&!4 '-" #"' &$%7 6'"#!1" ?""9"(!41 $=""( ?""$! ="!>""(!1"- !&"' ($!1 !!1"' 9"> ' $"!""(! ? &('!#&7&(?##&576' %7 &9' 16?1$"$ !"$ 

!1"=&! !"."%!"$!1"-"!&!&("2'

"F6"'!  ($  %%$&(?7@ $&"%!"$ !1" -"!&!&("  ! $"-'&! E #!1"  96(!

%7 &9"$=@&! 6%1$"#!1"=&! !4 7(?>&!1%7 6'"

;5&&&<#!1"

?""9"(!$ !"$

4&'%1 77"(?"$=@!1"-"!&!&("!16?1!1"-"'"(! -"!&!&((!1"?6($# =&! &("'' /" ("$%6('"7#!1"- !&"'1 5"=""(1" $ 7 6'"'

;5&&&< ($

;D5<#!1" ?""9"(!="!>""(!1"- !&"'4 >1&%1 ""7"5 (!4" $ '6($") I

;5&&&<!'1 77=" ("''"(!& 7!"9#!1&'%(! %!!1 !&($"! 5&$ #&576'%7 &9'4!1"- !@&(58&(? =&! !&('1 77'-"%&#@!1"$&'-6!"'= '"$ (# %!' ($% 7%67 !&(''! !&(?!1" 96(!6($"" %1%7 &9 ($'1 77#6(&'1 I$"-'&! !% 77J#!"(-"%"(!#!1" 96(!%7 &9"$( %1"$67" (8&(!1" ( 9"#!1"=&! !;=@1&'##&%& 7$"'&?( !&(<>1'1 778""-!1" 96(! ' $"-'&!!&77!1" ((6(%"9"(!#!1" > $(!1""5"(!# ( > $&(# 56# !1"%7 &9 (!4!1"$"-'&!'1 77=""#6($"$!1&9--!&(!!1" 96(! > $"$>&!1"'-"%!!!1" 96(!%7 &9"$ ($!1"= 7 (%"4&# (@'1 77=" ##"&!"$ ($- &$!!1"!1"- !@J I

;D5<F6"'!&("7 !&(?!!1&'%(! %!'1 77="=6?1!="#" (@&5&7 %6!>&!16!#&'!&(58&(?!1" ($%9-7"!&(?!1" =&! !&(-%""$&(?'4&#!1" &''6"&'%5""$=@!1"'%-"# =&! !&(6($"!1&'%(! %!1"-"($"(%@# =&! !&(-%""$&(?''1 77(!$&'"(!&!7"!1"(?&(""&(%1 ?"!!"9&( !" !1"%(! %! ($!9 8" 7!"( !"  (?"9"(!'#%9-7"!&(#>8J '-"%7 6'"

;5&&&< - !@'""8&(?"'76!&(# $&'-6!"!16?1 =&! !&(&'"F6&"$!'-"%&#@!1"$&'-6!"= '"$(# %!' ($% 7%67 !&('K'! !"!1" 96(!%7 &9"$=@&! ($!$"-'&! E#!1"%7 &9"$ 96(!&( '%1"$67"$= (8 &(!1"( 9"#!1"=&! !>1&'!8""-!1"' &$ 96(!&( $"-'&!!&77!1" ((6(%"9"(!#!1"> $(% '"!1"> $&'&(# 56#!1"%7 &9 (!!1" $"-'&!&'!=""#6($"$!%7 &9 (! ($&#(!4!1"' 9"&'!="##"&!"$ ($- &$ !!1"!1"- !@6%1$"-'&!&'!="9 $"! 5&$#&576'%7 &9' !!1"="1"'! #!1"- !@&(58&(?!1" =&! !&(%7 6'"

G H '-"%7 6'"

;D5<!1"&5&76!&''6?1!!="8"-! > @! $"%&$"!1"$&'-6!"'="!>""(!1"- !&"' &'&(?6!#!1" ?""9"(!="!>""(!1"9 ($>1&%1 "%5""$6($"!1" =&! !&(%7 6'" %1 77"(?"! (&$"(!&% 77@>$"$%7 6'"

;5&&&<4 ' =5"4% 9"

6-="#"!1"6-"9"6!&(



   





  !"#$%&'(('#$(!1"?6($!1 !'6%1%($&!&(> ' =&! @ ($!16'5&7 !&5"#!&%7"#!1"('!&!6!&(1"6-"9"6!4 #!"%('&$"&(?!1""7"5 (!%7 6'"'#!1" ?""9"(!="#"&!4>1&%14 ''! "$ " 7&"4>""&$"(!&% 7!!1" =5""D! %!"$%7 6'"'&(!1" ?""9"(!&(!1"-"'"(! % '"4'!6%8$>(!1"%7 6'">1&%1"F6&"$!1"$"-'&!# E#!1"%7 &9"$ 96(!=@ - !@&(58&(?!1" =&! !&(%7 6'"=@17$&(?!1"' 9"!=" =&! @ ($!16'5&7 !&5"#!&%7"#!1"('!&!6!&(1"6-"9"6!1"7$ ' 6($") IC  5&(?1" $7" ("$%6('"7#=!1- !&"'4&!>&77="'""(!1 ! 1"   E  I$"-'&! !% 77J  ="#"   - !@ % (  '6%%"''#677@ &(58"  !1" =&! !&(%7 6'"&'(!1"= '&'!1 !!1&'&'&($"! 5&$#&576' %7 &9'7 6'" B;D5<&' 7'9 !"

& 7 ($&''"!6!1""&(="7>) ID5F6"'!&("7 !&(?!!1&'%(! %!'1 77="=6?1!="#" (@%&5&7%6!>&!16!#&'!&(58&(? ($%9-7"!&(?!1" =&! !&( -%""$&(?'4&#!1"&''6"&'%5""$=@!1"'%-"# =&! !&( 6($"!1&'%(! %!1"-"($&(? =&! !&(-%""$&(?''1 77(! $&'"(!&!7"!1"(?&(""&(%1 ?"!!"9&( !"!1"%(! %! ($! 9 8" 7!"( !"  (?"9"(!'#%9-7"!&(#!

9!1&'%7 6'"4&! 7'="%9"'%7" !1 ! =&! !&(&'%('&$""$ !=" ( 7!"( !&5"$&'-6!""'76!&(-%"'' ($"(!@!!1"%&5&7%6!&' '6?1!!="! 8"( > @&#!1"$&'-6!"'="!>""(!1"- !&"' "%5""$=@ !1" =&! !&(%7 6'" ! DDD DDD DDD

C "!"&(? - !@! ( =&! !&(#9&(58&(?!1&' 7!"( !&5" $&'-6!""'76!&(-%"''=@ -"$"-'&!# E>67$$&'%6 ?"

=&! !&(4%(! @!!1"=."%!#$"%7??&(?!1"6!'@'!"94 ($ >67$"($"!1" =&! 7-%"''&("##"%!&5" ($"D-"('&5"



 77!1"'"" '('4>"'!&8"$>(%7 6'" B;5&&&<#!1"(!&%"

&(5&!&(?!"($"1&'%7 6'"="&(?'"5" =7"#9!1""'!#%7 6'" B>&77 (! ##"%!!1""9 &(&(?- !'#%7 6'" B1".6$?9"(!#!1"&?1 6!&''"! '&$" ($!1" --" 7 77>"$J ;"9-1 '&''6--7&"$< /" ("$%6('"7#!1""'-($"(!'- !&($"'(!$&'-6!"!1 ! !1"# %!'="#"!1"6-"9"6!&( 



) % '";'6- <>""

GH &$"(!&% 7!!1"# %!'#!1"% '"&(1 ($ (5&">#!1" =5"4%7 6'"

;5&&&<#!1" ?""9"(!="!>""(!1"

- !&"'$ !"$

&''!6%8$>( ($'&(%"!1&'%7 6'"&''"5" =7"#9!1" "'!#%7 6'"

&!>&77(! ##"%!!1""9 &(&(?- !'#%7 6'"

 "'67! (!7@4 !1"-"!&!&("2'%7 &9'1 77=" $.6$&% !"$6-(=@!1"=&! !>&!16!&('&'!"(%" (!1"$"-'&!# E#!1"%7 &9"$ 96(! 1"-"!&!&(&' 77>"$&(!1" =5"!"9' 

 G 3/H '1 9'1"    1"!1"'-" 8&(?+" '("$ ) "'+ 1"!1""-! =7"

)"'+