← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/1912/2024dismissed

Brij Mohan Gupta v. Manoj Kumar And Another

2024-08-28Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl14 pages

 

          

 

 

 !

"#$#%&  '('( )#* +, % -.

(((

# #% ) / )$-$ + %* 0-1 ) %!

, ) ((((( $.%!

$ + &  23 +( 4

 / 04  

   

/ 04  36 ( 3

 

 ! " #"$"#  %&

'() &* + ,"(, -*  ,   .+               / +01 02 31'

 ++

 . +  4

5  4

'

6                     54

(  74

8*   /

 .  +9  0" : 2 4  0 0" 0 0;

2 $ ""

.

  .                           #   $     "       # 

 "5 "#/

 .

 <

  #   #"() &* +/ .

#  # # () * .

    +"    #    # .

+" +   1%          "  .    +  0 $   =#      0 $     " !.



"   +   #0 $ =# >0 $     #)              0 $   =#     .   #  =       ,     ".  #    #+ ?# # # !.

     +"  "  # 0" 4

5

(  7  4

8*  +""

" # !.

  %3

 #"

"

  .= .0 $ =#   0 $=# +?? ? .

  "

 @

%3

 # .

+ 0;@  ,  +  + ?      ! #  3  3 9. +"  +/ .  ? "     "  +     +   '%

'

 

"  4

..

 .

#    &

-

 . #() *

 . #  ?+

.

 ## + ?+0 $=# . .

 +    0 $ =#   %<

%%<.= ..

  "

 + # 

"  .

 ?+.

   .

 ?+0 $=#  # 

 A .

    ?. #.

  < . #.

    0 $=#  .= .

 +           #   .                   " .

   #  #

 =  ".     " ?"   #.

""  2  4 < . # +.           

     

    

     !        

       "

#$                  

    



  

 



  



   



  

  

    !  



"    



       " 

" 

    

!                               

        

   %         &     '(                          #  



      $         

%& $" '   $ !  

(% 

%  )  *    $     $    

     )    

      

  *  +

,         *      

 *  !  $

     "

 

*  + +  



"    "       *   

7    $ *       

*          

, *            *

    *        -

  $"#  '% %'

< (   # '% %&

'*    "





+

"

) .   @32 '  +

 #.

. .

 " #+  

 .  #   %

%'

%   .    4 B     #  +$ +  

 ?# /#

 "# '

%<

'



  

 ? #   ..

<

  $"#  %&

'

  . " 



     ##    +   "   '

& #."

  '      

    .+// 0 '       

     .+// 1 '        .+/2

8 3 '      

           .+/2 4 '            (+/2 5 6 - !4

.  

"

  :" ."

 .+    (* -   4

    "           ) #  #      A >= #A (*

(9)  % 9) 

*..  #  A >= #A   .  +   . ? +   +    .

   .

#   (* 9)   9) <    9) 3  .  .       )  %%3."  + #

$=# . 

 #..+"+

! .

+  "

 ?

 "+.

+    4

               .

   +   +  

9  (* 2.

# +   ) # 

..

) # -:

  #" ) #  

 A >= #A  (* !.

+     +    4

                  +  "=  +   .

.   ,   #    

  "

.  =    #                  %3

 .

     9   

 " . ?+ ?# .    < %'

%%3(9) <*  

%%3 (9) 3*.

$ .

    ."9"     ?.

+  !.

+  

  ?     ? #=  / ""+ ? ##  !.

+ . #..  9) 9) 3 " .

 # .

#++

'    " #?."  !.

+    .

   

(*

     ?   =    .

(* :   + + / + #  #.  .

   #..

     

@ + .

+  .

  .

    +"

+

 .=  <

!4 '& B. + .   "

 

C!4 1 ".

 0102 31' .

"       ##  !  %&

'. +"+ "+  4

.  +  +  

A  +# 

     ) # :

$=# .. .

#/  .

#/ /#+"    :

. +""+  +.  7$  

   0        7     $   8   0430

      &  

            &  "  9  : 

" $ 

  

 * 

' $                    ;    ":2 :   $   8  $  

                 

*

**   " 

  

*  $    &       

  

    $     

 $   

  *&2     

 ,

 

     %            *&2     

    %  %    $* $

 

- 

*   



             * $   ,'.  -  

*        

 

 

     

 / A  +# +  + #$"#  +

   +  +  +#

         +? ".  .  +##+   6  '% %B

&   # +#  



 +# . +"+   "#4

   "

  +.+"

  +     

 ) #   #      A >= #A   

  #   ) # 

  (9)  % 9) 

*. .. .

 +  A >= #   "       #  A >= #A .

  +.+"

     +     .

  +  9"  . (9) 9) < 9) 3*.   %%3 .)

 +

  +  . #%<

%%< +.+ "

  (9) 9) 3*." +

" .9"   " .   #    +"+  #   ..

  A >= #        + +#)    ..   

  "5" + ?# "+ ? "+$+    



'

 . .  # 

  + ?+

 

  #   . # 

. + +  . #

 ?      0 $=# + .= .

 +     # #, . +/ .  # +   #  # # ".=  "#

  ?##  + = 

   ? %<

%%<     +  +" #   , .   / "  4

   %3

 +  )"          % %3

 

   .    +       A > = #A .

    ".+.  ".?  +  %%< .

       .  .

    )           /       +    #        

.

     ?

#=  .

... # /""+ ? "+$+ 

  "       . . +

&

 "# +  +  ##  ) # :

  ! #  .

 . + !) #    

$  =#                    

%3

#"

"  .=  +??     ? .

   "

" #   #  #   

%3

 0;@0 

 ,    ##,      #  .          9)  %    9) 

 !   ) #    9) B9)  ' 9)  &D9)  B

)  9)  1 9)    ) 9)  <  9)  3 + + +# 9)   9) & !.

 ) #    " 

"  4

..

"

 "  .                9      +   ) # ..

""+        .

 "

  )         +0 $ =# .

" 9  #"9) - + ++ +   + +   # "+#"/ "+#  $ =# " :

)    ## # " ! # 

+#  #.

$=# . " . #"$"# . +   ?"  # ." .+



!  #      ++ 

..

"  

=". +    #                 #"       %&

'

() &* + ,"(, - *, "

     +"#+#  " #  / 04  3  -:-$ '6    8 : 5 ?"E F : +E F