Jaspal Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others
!"!
#$ %&%
'( $ #)*+
'% ,"
!
%-%-.
/.0
!"
#$# !
%" &
'
! ! !(%) ***
%-%-.
/.0
% + , ! -./ ( ( 0" ! 123 ( ( " 4 5 6-6+/6/-7 8 9+6:4 ! (%) ;
"
4 $$ ! ! <);12 /16//6+1 ! #" ! 16/ 1-) (7 8 9+: / = ! $ <) !"
>
$# !$ $4
$
$ !"9
! " "
" ""#
$ %&
'" !
( ) !* + ,, ! - . / ," !0 ,, * 1 *1&
2" "
1 "3--&,!
,"!,
&
*1 " // ,4"-
// , . "* - "5 , "&
# 1
30 & "1*1& "+ !
) " * !
" !
1
-!*
+ -
!
- . " ,
!
*
" - ,!
* + 1 " ! 2"
/ ,", ! - . ," ! * ! 2" // , 4"-
"* - // , .
, " 4"- ,""!""
** * 0,",! *!
1 " "," !0, , * -1& - * !4"- - "1
,!* + - " #! *6 " - - # ,- "1 * ! - . & "-
0 "4"- "35!
$!,
" !1"0 1 , " &" 2"1&+! "*&
*!
"* - // ,4"- // , . *! " ,
& " + " !"
" 11 ", ""!
" 78! "- "" ## 1 1 !* &"# , !" - "1 !* + "*
1
1/
+* # ""* 1 !- "1,1"
1/+ 9 1 = ! 8 ! !" !) ,$ "
!
! ) 7($: &) ) !
! ($ ; " " !$ "! ! ?$4 ! +31( ( 8 9/:" $
!$ ""
! !4 !! (' (%) 4 )
!4 , ( 9.@119/6+1 A
""4 (
+B6@/6+-7 8 91: " (%) -
(%)! ! " !!! ! $ ! ! ! " ! " !!4 $# "
!
"4
>
!
" 4 !!
>
! 16B) (, 4 (%)" 7 8 9-:;" " ! ), !"(%) $<) $! (%) $!
9 ! 16B) ( "
!$!
9 ! 16/) (;" ! (%) +@+//6/+ 7 8 92: " ! " 4 ! ! !4;" 84++ 4 !$ $ ! ! 1+2( ( $$ !! "
!
""4 ,( @ = ! $ !$ 0 ! $ <) !$ !
!!! ! !"4 !!
>
$#"
4>" $ ! ! 1+2 ( ( !$ !4" $ ! "
4" "
$ ! $#" "
>
" !' ! $ $ !, $ $ "$4 !$ $ 7 8 9++: 4" 5$ 4 !$ "
), !"(%)
!4 " ! !! ! " ! C (%) "!! $= ! $ !$ " ! !!! !" 4(%) ! ! !!!4
!4 "
"!9 A:
!"" $;
"(
5 * * " 4"- #
1 " * ", , 1 <7 /
; - %=
,$
;> 7 ?,11 # <@( + *." - 1
11
1A - )@ 5 ( ( *"B !
,C1
", 1# " * * " 4"-
> 5 5 ( ( 1 " * " , 1 $
;> /7 ?1 # +,& 5 $
;> /@@$
;> @@(?1 # 0 D A$
;
> /$
;> /(? 1 # %&B A
$
;> / > ? 1 # "- A + "
#" # "11 "4"- ,"
@( + *." !
- 9 B = ! $ (%) !$ $ "
!
4 !$ !! !) ! 4 " //6//6+1 4 ! "
!
!$ $ $ !! ! +666 /16//6+1 ,
! !$
! " ">" !$ D9+ +60+616 /16//6+1 ! 4$! $ 5" $$
$ # !! 4 !
>" (%) !$ !!
!! ! " "!4(%)9
"" 1 " * .
""
. !"" $;" * - " 1 1 - " "" # (> 5 ( ( . 1
"" * . # * E>>>7/78@ * - . # &C "- "
6C
* . " 1- 1
" ," " - 5" 0 $ " 1 ; - %=
+
"
"1 . 6 ,!
" - 1
!
" 5- 0* "1;
#" "5- 0 # - 1
!
0 5
,
- .
!
",
" 4", % *
,*
* " 1;
#" * 0 4", 0# # 1# 1
"
5- 0
4", 0
" 1-
","
5- 0* - "
! "
* "1+
,
"
- .
!
0 " #" 1- " ,"
" , - . * " 1 ", !"" $;
2" *
" , 1
"(("1 "," 1#*!
5 * E7@ / 77 0 5
5 1#1
5 * E>8/8888 - 0 " 1
" ,
1# 1 * -
," , 1/
,5
$ !
1 # "1
+
, ( 1# 1
" " D - F
!
,
1 1 %
3 3 !$ ! //6//6+1" ! /16//6+1" " 4(%)4 9 A+ "
!"" $;
" * # " ( 1 " * + " # , ,11 # " "1 1" -
. <@8 + *." + " ", !"" * ," , 1"<7 /
; - %=
, $
;> 7 1 # " 1","
-
E 5 8 5 ( (
- ,1 -
1#1
""" ,* #+"$;
" , E 5 ( ( 1# 1
"*
"5 * E>>>7/8E@ +* # !""1"+ " "1 - . + * ." ! (:
"!
*
, (
# ( - E 5 ( (
, 1#1
"*
" * !
"" 1 " * .
""
. !"" $;" * - " 1 1 - " "" # (>
5 ( ( . 1
"" * . # * E>>>7/78@ * - . #&C "- "
6C * .
1- 1
"," " - 5" 0 $ " 1 ; - %=
+ "
"1 . 6,!
" - 1
!
" 5- 0 * " 1 ; #" 2"5- 0 # - 1
!
0
5
, - .
!
",
" 4",
% * ,*
* " 1 ; #" * 04",
0 # # 1# 1
"
5- 0 4", 0
" 1-
","
5- 0* - "
! "
* "1+
,
"
- . 3
"" 1 !"" #$;"" #
+ #" " - . @( + *." !
(
!
,""1 * 1 #" , 1 1
+
* 5 ( (* . * ,
6
"" !"" #$;"",
"
" ,"""," 0
5
, ," "
( (* "1
,*!1
*! - 5 #" 4", 0 "
*! ""3 . = ! $ $! ! ! " $4 " !!! !C "
! " ! ! "
>
$# !9!! " 4
4" 4 " $ 9 9" ! "$4 ! ! ! " $$ ! 4$ 2 = ! "" 4 > E$( $A
!"# $$% "
$ $! !$$ !!! "
" ! ! 1+2( (, 8! $ !"9 A8@+ "
-- 1 - #" " 1 (E $
$ " B !" * " "
1- "-1#+- , 1 (E$
$1 * C 1" ! *"" #1 1 *
1 ""-- 1 1 " B !"1 1 " "
* # - " "11 "
, ""* $ 1 / " ! - " , *11 - 13 A 8 , 1 (E$ $""1 ! C !- , " *C 1""- ! ! "1"", 1 1 "1" 1""
,
" *C 1"*1 "5"
"" "4 " - " - " ! " * ! 1
16 !, " 1 #1 11 ""- "
#1 *
1 " 1- , " * C 1" 1" 1# + "
, !- 11"" *"* "
#1 *
1 1"" ! " # 1 ""/C
B " 1" #1 - ** !
"1 - 1!+"" *-- " ,1"
- 11" " C 1"
1 * " ""
1 C #1 " * , 1 #1 *"1 " 1""
1 1 "
C 1"- , 1 (E$
$1 (E$
$- - " - # 2-- "
#1 ! - " * 11 " "
1 !
12"1
, "2
,1 " 1- " 1 * ,11 "+ , " " 2
,1 " 1 - " 1 * 1 #12+ "
"1 -
1 1 1 (E$
$
! - "
11 "3 6 ! " !
! ! (%) $ " ! ! !4 ! " "
3/4$4 >
$# !! " 9 9"
!!$4 !$ C " " !!! ! "! " " " >
!! $4 $#
! '" ""
$' $# !
4! C " $ # !$$! >
!
$#C ! " ! !
!" ! !$ $4 ! ! ++ ) ! ! !4F" ! +/ , > E$( $$G ! "
!
! ! &+2( (4 ( $ &'(
) * + $,"- " ../
! "9 A+- 1- " ," "1 (E $ $ !*" "" ) 61
1 (E $
$",
"
", 1" "
*1 "1
" *
"1 !- " * 11 " *
1 ,
11 "- " "
$ """
!" - 1" #1 1- " ", # *
!"11 "" 1 "
#" 1- " #
!
*:"11 " * 1 " 1 " * 1 *+ 1 1&" 1"- " 1- " ""
11 " ! *"" #1 1*
*"" "# * 1 "
1" !
*1 " " 1 " 1 1 " 1" ! 1 " #1 1+- , 1 1 (E $
$"
1
# *! - " 1 1 : ""- - " *"" 1 "*!- 1"
& - " 1 1 " "1 - " 2!- " *11 "2 11
1 (E C1 "
" - 11 " , " *
"*!- 1 1 E $ "
* " , 1 1 " 1 " ! *" * 1+" C- "" 1
!1 # "!- " , " *
!*!$ # !- - " 1" 1 - #" & 1 (E?A 1
! " ," # - " " , # * -- *! - 1 #" * " , #1 " ,
# #
11 "*
$ $ 1 "C- "" , *- -
1 1 -- 1
, 11 " *! 1 "
1 " #"6
1 0#1
1 - " *, ! 11-1 ""
1 #"6
1 ! "
""
1 #" 6
1 " * "
#- - " 1 (E, *
" 9 +1 > E$( $
" " 5 $ " ! 1+2( ( ! 4" "
!
$" ( ! 4 " $ !!$ ! !
!$$ !$"
!
$ " !! "
"4 4 !! ,(C ( 8! "! 4! 1+2( (
!$!
!4 4 $ ! !$ ! $! "
$$ 4 "4 !
! C ( !! ! $ $! ! !
!! "
$$ C !
" 8! 4 !$ +- ) ! 4 " 4 $ !!4 !$ " 4 4), 4) 7($: "4(%)%
! "
!
!! ! 4' ! $ " !" ! ! " $$ >
$# !; 4 " !!! ! "
! ' ! < " 4 ! 9 9" $# !! "
"$4 ! ! " $ "
!
" !9!!C "
D9+ !$ $ "
!
"4 !! ! $ !4 )" ! ! !!!4 !C $"! !4 ! "
!
! !$!4 !$ , ( $ "
$$ ! 1+2( (C (
1 !! " ! ! ! 8! !
8 4" ! 1+2( ( +@ ,(" 4
! !$ $
" !9 !! $ # >
G !
!>
!! >" $4 ,(4!$4 ' $ !) ! " 9 9"
! ! ! " $$ $ # ! >
$ !!C ! "! ! " " !!! ! +B , " 4 ( $ 6-6+/6/- 7 8 9+6: 4 ! (%) ;
%-%-567 /-61/6/B " ' 0 H0; H0;