← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8176/2019dismissed

Jagdish Singh And ORS v. The Chandigarh Administration And ORS

2022-10-18Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal7 pages

  

               

! "# $%&'(( 

"%&%)&* $%&'((  

   

 "!

#$%& '" 

 (

!!

 %"

" !

      +  +,) 

 "!

#$%& '" 

 (

!!

 %"

" !

  ' +,

( --   , "

" !-   , (.

/ ( 1!" 

 ',    / ( 1!"

 !" *"!

! *"!

 ( . "!/  !

  ". 3    , 45./ ( 1!" 

  60 ""! +,/ ( 1!"/

 "

" !

  !

! *"!

88888 -   ,.(    '" *"!

"

 !9

0

"1!

!5 :",!

,. ;

 !"

*,*

"/ .

0" 2""

,"

5" < , " !"

 !,"

(

. 

"/ , *.

/ 

 '" .

" 3

  *"

< 5"  6!

**" !! !"

3"" "9!"

) !

)" !

)" "3 !")

3"" *"

1 3"  </ 1 *5

   "9"

( "9," < = "" 3 .

1"

..""

.5/ !" *"!

!!"

*5  !" "  1"

"" 6 !" 5" /

)"

!" .

3"" 1 1".."

1!

3 1.." "

 7< !

!."



   #  

 (

!!

"1!"

1  '"

)" 3""

<   

0 < 3

."

25 !" 

"/ , *. 

/ 

 !!

 !!

"

 !" 1 1"..!

" 3 2" ) !9

2" *") !!"

)>" "*"

" !!

"  !!"" !

2" 1

!,!"

 

,!" 1!

3 !>"

  .

5"   /  1 )),

3

,"

!" !9

!! !9

2" ..

!!"

! , $!"

!"

!! !" .

""

2" *") !!"

*"!" !"

 !9

.5

  !" < )  '" *"!

/ 11

.5/

,2) !!"

 "*"

" !!

/ 1 *5 ( "9," / !

!" .

1. ")2"

.

)" !  /  1 )),

3

,"

*"!

!!

 !! !" , *. 

/ 

 

.0"

! !

! !

$!"

  !!   !!"" 3

!,!"

)"  "3 * 15 '

3

..

3"

25 1 )),

 

1 "

"" 1" 3 " !

!" ! ""!

?" ". @

!" , *. 

/ 

 ".

 "

.0  !

," 3 ! !" ..

!)" !

!9

"9

 !")

,2A"1! !

"0

!.5 "" (11

.5/ 1

" ! 3

")  5

) !"

, 1"

!" ."!!"  3 1 $,1!

2" "

!"

 < *"1!

!" !9

."

,2)

" !B, "!>  '"

" , " 1.." "

!" *"

" !

3 ! *"!

=" "

".

 !" *"!

,"

!! 11

!" "1!

7<

!" , A2 , *. 

(1!/   

"9!"



 ""

!" "

""

!" (1!/ !"

, *. ?

0" )" ! 0"

,2A"1! !

!" *

!" (1!

%,."

/ %",.!

:5"=3 " !"", " "1!

<  !""

*,.!"

!!  "" )5 2" 1"

  .

" !

,1 !"

)5 2"

9"

25 !" 

" 3 ! !"

 1!

 %!"

0" 2""

9"

25 !" ?" ". @

, *. 

/ 



! ""!

 ".

 

"0

" !

) 1 )),

 

)" 0" 2"" 1 )), 1!"

 !,"

!" (

.

"66

 ', / !"

%"

.,!

,!

A,

1!

)),

  ( "9," 

..". '"

)" )5/ 11

.5/ 2" C, =" "

".

 !" "

" !

,2) !!"

!!

A,

1!

9 !"

"" .

! !" , *. 

/ 

 !, / !"

)*, "

%"

.,!

1 ! 2" !")"

2" 3 ,!

A,

1!

', / !"

*,!" "0 .0"



!"*"!!

"1!

<

!" (1! '"

)"

"*

,1"

2".

 " 5 "

"" 1"-

 7 /01( -23&45)" . *%&$252%&!. $)"452%&. !)!6 &!2%&. " #%*452%&. 5*(.%782* &! !4&$9"255 &6 ":2!!2%&!(  " "0"

*

(1!

  5 25".3 ) " !"", " !!  .

1" 1"

  3 !!" *")

)5 2"  !"

  5 *,*

"/ ,1 .

3 !!" *")

.. 2"

 "

25 !" 

 25 !"

1" ")* 3""

 ! !"

)" , " !

(1!

 !" 25".3

" !"",  25  5 

1" ,!

25 !"

,1

1"

2".

..

*"1

 5 !" )!!" "C, *"1

"  5 *

(1!

  5 *

 5 25".3 ) " !"", "  !"

!"  ! !""

2 !" *,*

"  !" *"



 5

 3

 !"

1 "

! 1!

 1

/

 5/ ,2A"1! !

 !"

  !" )" 

!" *"

 !"

D 

" !"

""/

 5/ *

 !" .

1" 1"

 3 !!" *")

 $91"*! 

!"3

" *

(1!

  5 25".3 ) !"", "/

 "0"5 ,1 .

1" 1"

 3 !!" *")

"" )5 2"

1"

!

,1 !"  )5 ) !

)" !

)" 2"

9"

25 !"

" 3 ! !"

 1!

,1 ""

..

2" *52." 25 !" *"

) !" .

1" 1"

 3 !!" *")

 !"

< 0" 

!"3

" *

(1!

  5 25".3 ) !"", "  5 .

1" 1"

 3 !!" *")

 !"

" !

(1!

 5 25".3 ) " !"", " )5 !  5 !

)" 2"

*"

 "0 >"

25 !" 

 25 !"

1" 25 3 ! 3  !"

/

!

!!

!  2""

"1,"

25 !"  !"" ! ,

"*"

" !!

,

 5

! 1!

 1

  2""

"

 "0 25 !"  !""/

!"  !""  2""

1!"

 !" 1 !0" !

 5

!" *

(1!

 5 25".3 ) " !"", " ".!

 !

 5 )!!"

 3 1 !"

1" 1"

 *")

2""  !"

- 

!!  2"

" )>   5

*"

 "0

"

2."

** !, !5

2" 

!"  !""

!" .

 !"

3 !!" *")

3 1, " 35

! 2"

*"

"0 >"

2 "0"5 ,1 .. 1  2

!!")" !

!" "

*"

 "0

!" .

1" 1"

 !" 3 !!" *")

7 "  5 ,1 .

1" 1"

 3 !!" *")

*"

"0 >"

 3" !" *"

 3 1 !"

)" 3  !"

"9* / !"  !""

../

 .. *,*

(1!

  5 25".3 " !"", "/ !"

"")"

2" 3 ,!  .

1" 1"

 3 !!"

*")

, !

,1 !

)"  *"

 "0 >  !"

1" 1"

 3 !!" *")

 , !

. !" .

1" 1"

 3 !!"

*")

" "3"

 $0"5  !""

 5 .

1" 1"

 3 !!" *")

 !"

" !

(1!

.. ! .. "

2." !

)"

/ 3 ."

,1 .

1" 1"

3 !!" *")

")

1"

"C, 25 !" 

 !" ,!

!5 25 3 ! 3  !"

/ *

,1"

,1 .

1" 1"

3 !!" *")

E ,2 "1!



!" 

")" !

*

!!"

!!  1" 1"

.. 2"

 "

25 !" 

 

1" ")* 3""

!" (1!B:5"=3 " !"", "/  25  

1" ,!

F"

25 !"

"B(,!

F"

1" ,2 "1!

 *"

1 !! !"

  1" 1"

"" )5 2"

9"

25 !" 

" 3 ! !"

 1!

 '" .

1" 1" 1 2" 1 1".."

*"

,2 "1!

< 25 !" 

"B(,!

F"

1"/

/ !" 

1"

!

!!  !")B1

!" .

1" 1"  2""

"

,

2"" *1!

B.

1" 1""  2"" 1 1!"

 0

.!

 !"

*

!" (1!

 :5"=3 " !"", " ,2 "1!

*

 1

"C," 1"

*"

B1 1"..!

!" .

1" 1" 

,2 "1!

 )>"

1,)2" ! ,* !" .

"" !

*

,1" !" .

1" 1"

") 6!

*,!" !! , *. ?

0" )" ! 0"

 "1!

<

3"

!" 

)>"

:5"=3

,2 "1!

   ,!

F"

)

25".3

 5 )!!" *"1!

1 !" (1! )>"

*"1

1 *

 

*"1

1 25".3 0" 2"" 2 ,! !

,! "

9!

1" 1"

""

 !9

 $0" !

,/ !"

25".3 )5 ! 0" 2""

)"

/ !" A,

1!

 !" *,*

,2!"

.5 0"

! !" 

 ', / 3"!" !" 

** 0"

!" !"

!" !"5 " "1 ))"

25 !" 

!"3

"/ !" %"

.,!

 1 ! 2" ".

2" 3 ,!

A,

1!

 ,

1!

0"

25 0 !,"

!!,!" 

! 25 0 !,"

) "

  1! 6 !"*"!

 "1!

< 

!" (1! 

,"

!"

25 ." "

".

 !" *"!

)*.5 !! !"

0"

!"

A,

1!

)*.5 2"1, " !"

" 

! ) "  "1 ))"

!

 1!

 ,1 

 

!"*"!!

2" 2 , !"*"!!

,.!

2 ,

!5 1 ! 2" 

*!"

6 0 "3

2 0"/ !" 3 ! *"!

0"

)" !  "

"

 )

1".. "

**.

 /

 5/ .

( * *5

" 2" *.1"

." 

"1!"

1 "   -   ,    ((   %) ""*  "!" *">  B "

G"

"!" %"* !2."

G"