Som Nath And ORS. v. State Of Punjab And ANR.
-1-
!"# !$% "#&'(
)))&"*"* $&'(
+&'(,(
"!"& - ,$.!/ !$% "#&'(
)))&(0 $%&$"(
') ) !'"*1,2!'(
&"!*2(
!
!
"
#! #!
!!
# ! $
3
45 )
% & '()) #* ! ') +, #, -*.#%
'- #* / ! $ 000 6 )
% #!
1!/! / %
#!2
!"3)$ #
4(!3%/% , - $ # 5
! 2
! 1
2
-2- ! * #
$ #
2 #
(!! ! ! ! ! "3) !
$6 ) 7
$,$8 9
: !
$(414 ;6
2 5 / # 5 ! !)##64*!< ! # )##64 < !# ,$
$, / 8 9 $ ,
!
!)##64 ;: #)##64 1 #) ##64 ; #)##64 ; )#:#64 ; !
< # !!< ! < 3 !
# ,$!< ! # <!!
< < : = #
!!!,
)
# ,$! #
-3- !!! !#
< ! #
!
< #
< +
> !!
#
#
#
! ! !
3 !
2 #
#
!!! !
# *! ! "3)#
! *! ! ! #
/ / !!
+
2
!
"3)? ::#
! #
! / #
3
!
! # $ ,$ , / #!#
2 $ 3!
"3)
!
: < $ $ ! *
# !<)##64
-4- !< !
!< #
2 <
! ! $ + ! !! ! ,
) #5 ! !!# $ !
3!
! $ + : ! !< ! #
! ! 3 !# $ 1 +
!!
!!
! !
$ 5
!
$ ! !!! # !
: / @ 8@- 9#5 $,$ !
)#:#64 $3 / /
!
!
#
!
#
$
#
!!
-5- 3
! !!
4(3%/
!
! ! ! ' 4< !
! !
!! !
A # $
!
!
3
!
$ < !< ! ! $ !#
!
$
!
!! *
#
"3)
2
!
2 :
# ,
#
! $#
4(3%/ !
"3)
3 !
$
! )#:#64
< # # # !
!
< 3 !
-6- ! / ! ! #!# /
<
1 /%/!
$
!
< ! 3
2
< ! $ ! <
1/%/ !
! 2
"3) '
!
$6
: / ! / @ 8@ - 9#
$,$!
)#:#64 $#
!
!! 3
/ / !
!
"3)!#
1 /
; * #
!
+ !/ B
1/%/
-7- !"#
! =
, /
!! = /
! < !
1/%/#= / < C
!# != / !
! !
#
!!/ + !!
/#
<
! ! / =
, /
! !
<!
1 !/%/
!! / !
!! !/ *
# =
, / !! !
1/%/
<
!! !
#
# ! # !!
C# !
<
!
< + !
<!
&4 D89
"3 ! ) # ! + !
! 4 !! + E
-889
"3 ! ) #! #
"3) C
!! #
!
!4 !
89!/<
!' !, 89! /E 9
"3)
! ! !! + E 89
"3)
C
!!
4 C
!! #
!! !'
89 !/E 89
"3)
!
!!
!
E 89 <
! ! !/ *8
9
!
6 ! / *#
!!4 ! !
E 8:9
! ! 6
4
! +
4 F
-9- ! =
, / 8 9 !
!
3 !
" #$%
&'
# =
, /
!= /
1!/
<
! !
!! / !
# #= / 2
#
!!! 3 ( # ) *!
# $%+
&&# =
, /
+ ! )! !
,) ) *!
- .$ %%
% # =
, / != / 2
"3)# <!
# !! ! !
!!
!/ !
<
! CE 89 !
89
!! / )! !
/ ) # ) * #0
- .%+&
+&&$ =
, / <
1!/%/#= / < !
+
-10-
!
2
1 -! 2- )# !
2 %3
$=
, / #
B8 9# !2
!
#
!! !+
C ! !4 ! '
!* !
<! 3!
!! ! C + # = / 2 <! 4 / )"4 -5- !
2 %
0 ) #*</ /
<
1!/%/ 2
"3) ! C
!! G!
!
! C
!!
$
+ ! !!!
, 4(!3%/
#
# !
! <!
!! !
!
-11- !3%/
#
!
!, !3%/
2 >!! !
!3%/!
&
* #&'& (# ,2% /& -'!,%,2&$"
'
%*(# $&("
*$%,1& &$"
- !
0&'( $ /7 %&1&*8*$9 #* :
**
! #& 0&'( $ ( %&1&*8&% (# ,2% /& *$%,1&% "
%&2*8&'
!$7 0' 0&'"7 "
!$7 0&'( $6 '
"
1 $(&$"
"#!"
!$7 0&'( $ (#!22 '&"!*$ !$7 0' 0&'"7:
'
/ #& 0&'( $( ( %&1&*8&% (# ,2% /& *$"&$"* $!227
*$%,1&% "
% '
*"
"
% !$7"#*$9 ;#*1# #& ; ,2%
$ "
% '
*"
*- #& ;&'& $ "
( %&1&*8&%:
!$%
*** $ 1!(&( 1 8&'&% /7
** / "#& !1"
'
*((* $
(# ,2% /& $& ;#*1# 1!,(&( '
*( 2*<&27 "
1!,(& %! !9&
'
#!'
"
"#& 0&'( $ *$%,1&% *$ / %76 *$%6
'&0,"!"* $ '
0' 0&'"7)
"
#
! ! !!
!3%/!
&
* #&!"*$9:
**
*(# $&("
*$%,1& &$"
"
%&2*8&'
0' 0&'"7 '
"
!<&6 !2"&'
'
%&("' 7 !$7 8!2,!/2& (&1,'*"7 '
!$7"#*$9 ;#*1# *( (&!2&% '
(*9$&% '
*( 1!0!/2& -
/&*$9 1 $8&'"&% *$"
8!2,!/2& (&1,'*"76 !$%
*** &$( '&!
- "#& !11,(&% !"
"#& "* & - !<*$9 "#&
*$%,1& &$") 3 ! !! !
# !
!
+ !
-12- ,
# ! ! +
: >
! !
!
#/ !
!
$
! ! * #
: < $,$ $ ! 2 % $ ! < !
4< !
2 ! !
3
, ! # ! $6 ! $ , $ !
)#:#64 $6
: / ! / @ 8@- 9#5 !
/ / !
!
!
!
1 *!
!"3)
!
-13- $ <
!! !
< !
$ ! # ! ! ! !
!!
4 (3%/#
! # 2 $ ; * #
!
! =
, / 26.#-7.. ).!
2 " ) #
# $ &
'
#
< DF
! !!% *#
! !< ! ! ! =
, / <
! < +
)! !
! =
, / 2 #4. ) # !
) # $%%3
'
# #
! !
!
3 !
!
!#!!
:#1#;3%/ , # (
-147) !
) 8 ) 7 -9: ) # $ (22/ 3%% #5)## %%+.
)* - 7 -9: ) ##"#"3)
2
!
!
#!
#
! ! /
# ! #
< ! 5+ # 7 + = / ( ; <== 8* )!
: " # $ ) ) )) /%%& % #5)## +%%
!
!! #
!
3
!
! 2 * 7 += / ;1/)"!
: " # $ ) ) )) /%%+%+#5)## %% #
#
# 2
!
! #
! ! !
!
-15- !! A !
"3) # !
! !!
4(3%/ $
#
!!
/ /
!
! !
!! !
#
2 $ #
2 7
#/ !
*
#
"3)$
4(3%/% , - $#5 #
1
2
!# 2 2 $
=) >) $ %& ' (% $)* ' (%