Ravi Sarangal v. The Revenue Secretary, And Others
-1-
!"!
#$%&%
!"
#$
'$ ()'
% *' *) %
&'
() ((*(+, # #
---
' *)+%, )- '
# .*.
( # $
/+ 0
$( 2* $/ #$ (2 (###(
/3(+ $#(3(+ (/ (*( * 11/(+ 1 /(* 3(+
.((3 .3'
'
# ( $ /#(+ .1 33'
! 4(
$ 33($3 /.(*. ''5'
! 1+$ 4 (3
$1/'
! (##(/.$ (+
$3() 6(+ (*(
$#(3(+ #/$*'
6(+ )$ 3 $ $($ ''7
$/$ #$ /.(*. 4++ /3 4(8 #9
#3'
6(+ )$ $ $($ '' $/$ $/#+(8
(.8 /3#+ $#(3(+ #/$* 4. . 3.'
:8
11/ )$ # $($ 7'' ;($ .3 (++
/.(*'
#(3(+ 3 33 3 <' '
-2-
#9 #3 4( 2# (+$ /)'
6(+ )$ $ $($
'' $$ # (+$ /) /$ #9 #3
( # .+$ <' ''
1 #3 # .1
33 /3 (;
4( .+$ ='''
(##)$
#9 #3 ( .1 33'
1. (##)$ .
#3 ( /#(+ .1 33 7''='
! $ (
/#(+ .1 33 7''='
<'
# 4. # # 63 . 4(
+(# . #( ++ 4( 3#+/($ $#(3(+ #/$*'
/($
#((6+ 3(+ + .3'
! .( *. +) 4.
1++ $*8'
! 4(
#3$ ( # . 8'
)+8 #>$/$ . /('
.
.+$ $/ #$ * /3(+ /( ( $#(3(+
#/$* (*( * 11/'
='
# 4.
#/ $#(3(+ #/$*
(##(/.$ (+
$3() 6(+ 4./.
3 3 #($
3 $ . 1()'
:8
11/ 63$ . #
7'''
! 4( 1++8 ;($ .(1 #3$ #
.1 33 ( 4++ ( /#(+ .1 33'
! /+(3*
$#(3(+ #/$* 3(++8 .(($ .3'
! 4( ( 1(+ ++
4( 3#+/($ ( 6. #)( #$'
?'
/+(3 # $) 6 >/$ 3 .(
*$'
# (##(/.$ (+
$3() 6(+ 4./.
#($ 3+#+ $'
! $$ (2 1 (8 +1 ( *. . 61
6(+'
! 4( ;($ * 1. #3 4.( .(
-3-
1+$ ( # (1 4 8( . 3'
: ($ .3 ( #+8 $#$ : 1(/'
'
4(2 (6) $/ 1$*, .
/$$ # # $) 6 $3$ (//$*+8
$3$'
'
$* &/'
(##+/(@A, 1 (8, .(++ (+ ($ $#$ 1'
,' *)- %&%
B
.. #(2*0($ C0
.. #(6+
C0