High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/2335/2000disposed of

Laxmi v. State Of Haryana

2025-11-12Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja3 pages

($"&% ($"&% ($"&% ($"&%

=&% &% &% &% >>>

>>>

>>>2 F3 2 F3 2 F3 2 F3 "6//&# "6//&# "6//&# "6//&#

> =

))"**(#$ ))"**(#$ ))"**(#$ ))"**(#$

")&#,"#$ ")&#,"#$ ")&#,"#$ ")&#,"#$23

& >?B >?B >?B >?B&% &% &% &% >>

>>2 F3 2 F3 2 F3 2 F3

))"**(#$ ))"**(#$ ))"**(#$ ))"**(#$

")&#,"#$ ")&#,"#$ ")&#,"#$ ")&#,"#$23

& >?A >?A >?A >?A&% &% &% &% >>

>>2 F3 2 F3 2 F3 2 F3

G G G G))"**(#$ ))"**(#$ ))"**(#$ ))"**(#$

")&#,"#$ ")&#,"#$ ")&#,"#$ ")&#,"#$23

!""#$ !

%&! !

9,'/!<<(!-(*0,;&6($" $'"())"**(#$+*(#,&-#"! .'/#('(/#00(!1(# #( CCCC 02 !(*3 02 !(*3 02 !(*3 02 !(*3

45 /, ," $'/ 6&77&# &!,"!0 $'" ( (%&!"7"#$/&#", ())"(* (!" ."

"/#< ,"6/,", ( $'" (7" '(;" (!/"# &9$ &% 6&7 77&# (689//$/&#+-(!, /#;&*;

;/#< /,"#$/6(*%(6$( (#,89"$/&#&%*(- &!$'"(:

:"&%.!";/$10%(6$(!"."/#<$(:

:"#

=&% >>> %!&7

5 1 -(1 &% )!""#$ ())"(*230 6'(* **"#<" '( .""# *(/, $& $'" - -(!, ,($", >?>@ )(", .1 $'" *"(!#", ,, ,* /$!/6$ 9,<"0 9!<(&# 2# #&- 9!9<!(73 2'"

"!"/#(%$"! $& ." !"%"!!", ( $ $'" D "%"!"#6" &9!$E30 -'"!"

".1

"%"!"#6" "$/$/ /&#%/*",9#,"!"6$/&#A&%$'

'"(#,689//$/&#6$0A@2 2%&!

'&!$D$'"A@ 6$E3($$'"/#$(#6"&%$'"*(# ,&-#"!-(,/7/", (!(<!( ()' &=$&B."/#< <!"*";(#$(!""H$!(6$",'"!"9#,"

"!J I= $ / )"!$/#"#$ $& 7"#$/&# '"!"

!" $'($ (** $'" (.&;" $/$*", !"%"!"# #6" /#/$ $/(**1-"!"6&#&*/,($",-/$' ("#&

@&%?$/$*",(( (*./! /#< #<' $($" .1 71 , )!","6 6"&! /," &!,"! ,($", ?=A (#, !"9 9*$(#$*16&#&*/,($",/9"-"!"( (*&%!(7",/#$'"(/,6("-'/6' ' (!" (9 9#,"!J K'($-($'"7(!:"$;( (*9"&%$'"(689/!",*(#,($$'"$/7"

7"&% #&$/%/6($/&#9#,"!"6@&%$'"

"6$L

"*/"% &- -";"!0&#@0/$-()&/#$",& &9$$'($(**$'"(.&;"$/$*",!"%"!"# #6" ,& #&$."*&#<$&$'"(7"#&$/%/6($/& &#(#,(-(!,(&%$'"(/,6 6(" #&

@+?$/$*",((*./!/#<' $($"'"!"%&!"0(%$"!<&/#<$'!&9 &9<' $'" %/*"0/$-(%&9#,$'($$'"(.&;"$ $/$*",!"%"!"#6"-"!"#&$&%$'"( (7" #&$/ $/%/6($/&# (#, (-(!, ( &% $'" (%& &!"(/, 6(" '"!"%&!"0 (** $'" (.

.&;" $/$*"

", 6(" -"!" ,"6&#&*/,($", %!&7 7 $'" (/, 6(" #&

@+? (#, -"!

!" !"6&#&*/,($", -/$' 7(/# 6(" #& &% ? $/$*", (

/ '(#"$6$($"$/%9!$'"!)"!

!$/"#$$&7"#$/&#'"!"$'($&# @

0 2-'

'"# $'" (.&;" $/$*", !"%"!"#6" -"!" 6&#&*/,($", -/$' (" &

@+? $/$*", ( (*./! /#<' $($" %!&7 -'/6' $'"" - -"!" ,&6 6&#&*/,($", ( ,/69", (.&;"0 $ $'" ";/,"#6" &% $'" )"$/$/&#"! /# $'" )!" ""#$6("-(6*&",.16&9!$&!, ,"!."6(9"$'")"$/$/&#"!,/,#&$* *"(, (#1 1";/,"#6",")/$"(;(/*/#<#97."!

!&%&))&!$9#/$/"/#6*9,/#<&%*($ &#" (#, ,$'"6("-(%/H",%&!!")&#,"#$ #$ ";/,"#6"%&!@&#-'/6', ,($"0 , (*&6*&",";/,"#6"&#."'( (*%&%$'"!")&#,"#$J$($" ? '(;" <&#" $'!&9<')*"(,/#< <0/9"(#,!"6&!,(;(/*(.*"&# %/*" (#, ,'(;",&9#"*%&!$'")"$/$/&# #"!(-"**(, %&!$'"$ $($" 1 1%/#,/#<&#/9"%!(7",/# 6("#&

@+?$/$*",((*./!/# /#<' $($"(!"(9#,"!J B ,/69", (.&;"0 /#6" $'"

'"!" / #& ";/,"#6" &# ."'(*% &% % $'" )"$/ $/$/&#"!!"<(!,/#<7(!:"$;(*9"&% %$'"(689/!",*(#,(96''(;"

"#& &$'"

'"!&)$/&#.9$$&'&*,$'($7(!:"$;( (*9"&%$'"(689/!",*(#,-($'"( (7"

( -( (-(!,", .1 $'" (#, 68 689//$/&# &**"6$&! &# $'" ,($" " &% #&$/ $/%/6($/&#9#,"!"6@&%$'"6$N 4 5 ( (;/#<'"(!,*"(!#",6&9#"*%&! $'")(!$/"(#,9)&#)"!9(*&% $'" !"6&!,0/$/())( (!"#$$'($$'"())"**(#$J*(#,&- -#"!-"!"#";"!(%%&!,",9%%/6/ /"#$ &))&!$9#/$1$&) )!&;"$'"/!6*(/7$&-(!,<!(#$ $&%M9$0%(/!(#,"89/$(.*"7(!

!:"$ ;(*9"(<(/#$6& &7)9*&!1(689//$/&#&%$'"/!*(# #, 4@5 # 96'6/!697$(#6"0$'"/7)9<# #",-(!,,($",>?>@)( ", .1$'"*"(!#",

"%"!"#6"&9!$/'"!".1"$(/ /,"(#,.&$'$'")(!$/"(!",/!"6 6$", $&())"(!/#J)"!

!&#&!$'!&9<'$'"/!6&9#"*."

"%&!"$'"*"(!#", "%"!"#6"&9 9!$J 697J,,*/$!

!/6$9,<"09!9<!(7&# A > ="(!#", "%"!"#6"&9!

!$/ !"89"$",$&,"6 6/,"$'"!"%"!"#6"(%!"'(%$"!(%% %&!,/#<$'!"""%%"6$/;"&))&!$9#/ $/" $&"(6'&%$'")( (!$/"&($&6&#6*9,"$'"/!";/ ,"#6"/#9))&!$&%$'"/!!")"6$ $/;" 6*(/7+6&9#$"!J6 6*(/7 4=5 # $'" -(:" &% $'" %(6$ $'($ ( (689//$/&# /# $'" )!""#$ 6("

"23 6&77"#6",;/, "&$/%/6($/&#,($", B>@BA /9",9#,"!"6$/&#@&%$'"( (#, 689//$/&# 6$ $0 A@ (#, $'" ())"**(#$+*(#, &-#"! (!" $/** (-(/$/#< "%%"6$ $/;" (,M9,/6($/&#&% $'"/!!/<'$0$'"*"(!#", "%"!"# #6"&9!$/!"89"$",$&"H)", ,/$" $'")!&6"",/#< (#,6&#6*9,"$'"(7")!"%"!(.

.*1-/$'/#/H7&#$'%!&7$'", ,($" &%())"(!(#6"&% %$'")(!$/"66&!,/#<*10(**$'"

"())"(*$(#,,/)&",&% 4?5

"# #,/#<())*/6($/&#230/%(#10'(** *(*&$(#,,/)&",&%

3 &;"7."!

&;"7."!

0000

$/: 2 2 2 2

> =

> = K'

'"$'"!)"(:/#<+!"(&#", " '"$'"!!")&!$(.*" " +& +&