High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/30358/2012allowed

Gurcharan @ Charan Singh And ORS v. Gurdev Singh And ANR

2018-05-02Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan11 pages

!"# $#%&'&()

) * + , -,, .

" #

$% &'(

((

"& ))))) ' * # ( #( $%%+ ,-.+,../ ( 0

( -2, 34+ 4.5 %32 %3/

6 7 -8%9898:98:9 (

(; &8 9 %/2/8 <=%9 ## %4.4,.%,8 <=,9 7 &## ( #( $%>#(

(#( 7 (( &( "&

! 7 ((

( (; &?%2.+,../ &2# 7!

7(( / #&

# # & (( #&'#

@ # '&!7(( "#

7' ( (&''

0; 'A "

; ; ';'

A ;6;" ! A;; ' B ;; B &C A'A D7 ; ;A D7 1; A

(

(7 7

# 7

& # $ #( ( 7

#( (7

#7 > ! #( 7((& ! ((' '&'#( '

(( !7' ( #7 *&'& # # ;#7 ( & 7 7 ! 7

(,-.+,../ ; #( ( # ' <# #( @% D&

@,B

@- (

!= (

( != ; ( ##

%4.4,.%, (

&( -2, 34+ 4.5 %32 %3/ 6 7 -8%989 8<98<9 ( (; &8

9 %/2/ %%.+,.%,8 9

##7 ,5.%,.%5 (( .2.+,../ ;

( '

* #( 7(( ## %4.4,.%, ?,+./,.%, 7 ( # ( 7 "&'

&' # (( ( 4E'

( &( 8 <=%97#( 7(( >!7&(

> ; '

&( # ' D( # (

#$ %&

7 ( & '

# #( >!7( =&( ( *('

( (

#( 7 $, #( 7& # & 7 (( 7 7## #(

( &#

## ('

( 7

$#& (( & ##& # ' (( ! (!! ; (F # ##( %4.+,../8 <=-9 A?

( (( ( !&'#( =

#'(& $%->% $,,7#' 7! # @ (' # 7 ((

(# -!( $2-6

#( # />%.#(

$,,>%2&( &'' 7 ( & ! (( ( &'#( =

#('

; #( 7

&'(( '##&

( <&

( #( #(

( # " 8 <=59%5.+,../ #('

$ #(

(

&#&' '

& #!

##( 8(

9( < (7

( $- ( 7 %4.+,../ 8- 9 #( 7(( '

( < &# # ' (

(( + "&

(( ##D %/5%'

#( =

# (# $,,>>%->%83=.9 ( 7 ((7 &' ((=#= (# F '?

# %/.3,.%. 7 ((&' ((#' .5.+,.%% ' (( (

( &# 7 #& ' $#& (( & ' 7 !

( ( (( ( (> # G # (' #(

(

#( 7 #(

# ((

( &#

#( 7# #(

7 # ( ((' <# # ( &' #( ( # ' A &# #( ((' &

( ( '7 (( 7 #( # 7##(( (

( 8!

9 #&

( ( '

!&()(* #* *(!+),!* (# 7

0 AG&( # (

-8%98<9 * ##&

> ; '' (('

( # 7 # ( #( &( (7 &( 7; " # AG&(

# =

! "#$"%$

(

)

" $

(

)

& ,

D( ((

- .

/ !* (# 1!2(*!"

/& / !* (

$% /0 34

# %.

/ 7 # ( 7 &!&' 6 ('

( $%>#( &#

(&'#( 7 " #

1 %,.,,.%%' # ( !G:G ( $2 " #7

( B ( 8- 9 # ( (

< (7 # (

8 9 D ( $%>#( &# #( ('&* H6$33

.%.2,../

335 33+ %32 %3/ 6

7 7

#( 8 < =-9 6 &# #( 7(( 7 7 7 @, @- ('&#( # &(

" # 6('

( &# #'! (7 #7#&'#( 7(&'#( #( 7((

#( (( #

( &# ( >%,.,,.%% ('

7 #' #' <

('&! (

( 6

((7 = 89&( #( 8 <=%9 7

(( ' 77>&#( # & (( #7#( ; #( ( ( & >!7#( &( ( ' &( ( ' 6&(&' .

5#6 #( %0 & '

(( #( # ( &(&* 8&9 ; #(

#( (

$#& (( &

#' '7 ( (#' (( ( #'( 7 7

#' 7! 7( & (( #@ # &' (6 &'

#( 7 (7 & &7 #'

( + "& (( ##D 89?%/.3,.%.

((=#= (#F ' ?

# =

2 77( # ( (( 7( (

( &' #( & (# F ' # .5.+,.%% <

' (

# # (' #( (( ( 7 # 896 ($%>#(

( # " - ( '7 #( #''

# " 8- 9

# ( #( ( ' " #%,.,,.%%

( $52%%+.+,../ 7 77

!(7&

(

< (7; ( (

(('# ! < (7 7

& $%

" ## & ( &' ! <

(7 89 ( #( ( # '! ( &' (( 7 (7' #'

# (( (# 7

(

=&(# 9I7 # ( 8 <=%9( 8 <<=59

(&' ( (#( #

(#( &'

#( $- ( 7 7

( %+.+,../7 8- 9 ( 7 # ((# #( 7(( '%4.+,../ ( $, #( 7 7 " <' ,-.+,../(

(( %2.+,../ # 7 ( &!7((&'"#

!7' (( !( (&'& #

# ('##& # " ; #( #

(

#( 9I7 ##

-2, 34+ 4.5 %32 %3/ 6 # ( ## ( 7 (( " # ('

##& 7 'D&( ' $7 <# &'#( (( ( # A?

!7( 7 (7 #( 7<# #(

896 & $#& ((

# (( (( #'! (7#( ( (

( #( # #(

((##&

#' #( # 6 7 # ((7 ;

#( & $%%+ ,-.+,../ ( 0

18 <=%9 ## %4.4,.%,8 <=,9&'

* -,, .

A#( @!

> J @&( J