High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/323/2022dismissed

Amir Nazir v. National Investigation Agency

2023-02-15Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Ms. Justice Harpreet Kaur Jeewan16 pages

% &'% ( ( ()' &'%( (

)

! " "#

! ! ! "!

$ %%%%% ( (+ ,+-+./+0

'( ) #

"'**+# ,'**+- # .

/ " !! " '0 *1 '*''"2 &

2 !3$4(# '*(4

! +1/. +,/ / ",

2" 34#544' '* (' '*(+ !

('*$" ('(" ('( " (''"1*5"0*6"'*( 3" !

(6"(+"'*"'17

(465 # ,(465 - !

1" 6

!& " (4*+ : (61 (0 *4 '*(+ !

; (" / " #

2 &

$1&

' <

& .

/ 2

# #

: $( ! = $' 2 # #

> # ! ? " / () *4 '*(+ 2

2 2 # 2 &

# < &

(4 *+ '*(4 2 ">

2 # ##

#& @

1 3

! >

$&>

2 2 2 2 $( $'2

& ? # &

#2 "; 2"/ AB /AB <

/ 2&

C< D

2 2

& C< D

# &

" " #

>2 ! ? " / () *4 '*(+ & : $("! =$'"# $ ) 7 $0 #

2 /

*6 *1 '*(4 # 2 2 2" "

Page No.2

2 2 E

# !

& " '*(+ !

('( 3 # ! !

('( 3 F 2 2

2# &

G ##

(+# (465 ) # #

2 G

! " 2 2 & # E 2$7 $H EH " # " 2 ##

'*# (465&2 &

< #

& "'*(+ 2 2 E

# " 2

'*( 3 &

2 0 < # (* (* '*(4 $ C,+2 6 ! +.. 2, +7 8 2/

2, +""! !/ 9(:2 #5,+ 2/ 2,"/8/ +."

:/+"6 -/2, 6 ! "

+""!

!; ,8+ %/ 4 !.+8 +7/ %/ 4 %/:!+ % ,+..+ -+ 2/:!+0 88 +81+ 4 % ,+8+ +81+ %/ 4 </.. ++++ , -+ 2/:!+ + +/= ,8+ %/ +./+ +,/= 4 !.+8 +7/ %/ 4 /.. ++++ +.0 -+ 2/:!+ >/ " "+? 2 "+6 !2 2, !

.+-;!. +"2//2/ 76 "+!/ 92,@:.

/ 2,:!7./":.+"/ 2 "+! 2,"/8/ +./ 2/8/+2/

2 2, :!7./"0"+!/ 99/ ! / A!/02,76"+!/ 92,+8+92 :!7./": :260 2,! "

88/22 2, ;; " !4 # 0 2, +8 / "

/1+7.762,/"

!2 Page No.3

.6 6 ! 2, +;

+/ 2, +""! 76 "+!/ 9 @:.

2, :!7./" :.+" +228:2 2 -+9 -+ +9+/ 22, 2 ; /+/ (:2 #5 ,!"

88/22 2, ;; "!4## "

/1+7.762,/"

!2 ,/.60 6 ! 2, +;

+/ 2, +""! "

:/ !/ 92,:/ (:2 #5+.

9-/2,6 !"

+""! >/ " "+? 2 "

88/2 "2+/ ;; " +9+/ 2 2, 2+2 2,76 "

88/22 2, ;; " ## "

/1+7.762,/"

!2 : "& : ! =2 #

2# #< <

& !

'*(+ 2

2 2 E # < ##

@('' 3 &

& :# " # & :

! = ()@*4@'*(+(4 )0 /

< <

? /

& G

< ##

@1*5 3" &

& !9 # & :

! = &

# ! ? ()@*4@'*(+ (4 )0 &

< ##

@)'5 3" &

& : " # & :

! = ()@*4@'*(+(4 )0 &

<<"

& < ##

@0*6 3" &

& : " # & :

! = ()@*4@'*(+(4 )0

! ? " /

& & Page No.4

# &

< ##

@ 1 & < 89

!& (4*+ < &

& : " # & :

! = ()@*4@'*(+ (4 )0

#<<

! ? /..;H & G

2 < ##

@(6/ &<

(465 < &

!2,0 2,+2 6 ! +.. 2, 2, +""! !/ 9 (:2 #5 ,+ 2 / 2, "/8/ +. "

:/+"6 -/2, 6 ! "

+""!

!; ,8+ %/ 4 !.+8 +7/ %/ 4 %/:!+ % ,+..+ -+ 2/:!+0 88 +81+ 4 % ,+8+ +81+ %/ 4 </.. ++++ , -+ 2/:!+ + +/= ,8+ %/ +./+ +,/= 4 !.+8 +7/ %/ 2/ /.. ++++ +.0 -+ 2/:!+ >/ " "+? 2 "+6 !2 2, !

.+-;!. +"2//2/ 76 "+!/ 92,@:.

/ 2,:!7./":.+"/ 2 "+! 2,"/8/ +./ 2/8/+2/

2 2, :!7./"0"+!/ 99/ ! / A!/ 2,76 "+!/ 9 2, +8+9 2 :!7./" : :260 2,!"

88/222, ;; "!4#5,

.+-;!."2//2/ > 2/

? "2 #3B , +8 / "

/1+7. 76 2,/ "

!2,02,+26 !+..2,2,+""!!/ 9(:2#5 -;

2 7+"2/887 ;+2 /29+ 9 + ,+1-+2!./ -,/", / / . / 2, 2 /2 +"2 ,! "

88/22 2, ;; " !4 ,

.+-;!. "2//2/ > 2/

? "2 #3B , +8 / "

/1+7. 762,/"

!2,02,+27 2,2,+""! +1/.+,/ / ",

+ (,+,/C!6

8/ (:2 #5+2+.+ ,+-;

2 7 / 2, !

+!2, /1 :

; / /2 .! >?+:"/+.9@:.

/!72+ ";

"+!/ 92, 8+ 2!"2/

-,/", -+ +/ 76 6 ! "

+""! 8/+1/%/ ,!"

88/222, ;; "!4>#?, Page No.5

.+-;!. "2//2/ > 2/

? "2 #3B , +8 / "

/1+7.762,/"

!2,02,+26 !+..2,2,+""!!/ 92,:/ (: #5,+2 66 !8 7/.:,

+ (%( -,/", - 7/ 9 ! 76 6 ! ;

8+=/ 9 "

+2/

-/2,6 !"

+""!02,!-"

2+/ / 9/ "/8/ +2/ 9 / " +9+/ 2 ! + !", ,+ "+! 2, /+::++ " ;2,/ "2,!"

88/222, ;; " !4# ,+8/"

/1+7.762,/"

!2 ,76/"22,+26 !+""!72/762,/ !2

2,+7 +/",+9 & 2! E

/ "" G&" !!" (* (* '*(4D 6 "

; /+< * +A70#>?( B#

0 # 2

) # 2

> "

102

# 5+ 2

(2+2 ; *+.+ < + ;0 >##?# ( B5D

)1;0# (4652

5 3

2 # & 2 2 $(& 2

'1 *0 '*(+') *+ '*(+2

2 /AB 2

< 2 ##5

'* !

! H " " # #

# # 2

2 $( 2 Page No.6

# $)2 & # H &

;$64@(" &

"& #

2 & &G #

H " "

93 ;+ (/ 9, (2+2 ;+8/. +!0>#?D(#&

2 & & !

'0# 8

"(+5' 2" "

;

!2 (465 " # " 2 &

& &

? " & 2 # & 2

2 $( $'"2 2

/ 2 &

"2 "

"> I >I> $6 J> I J> $5

# &

2 EH 3 #

2 '6 *0 '*(62 $( G EH

2# G& # ! $6 & # & $ $'2 2 G EH

# &

# $' #

;#2 $6 ; &

*4 *4 '*(+ 2 ! @ Page No.7

# # & 2 G&! &2 2 H 2" " >& 2

/ &

& /AB H #

2 $) $ 0 ? 3 2>"/ (1 *4 '*(+ "

2 ! " ? (4 )0 () *4 '*(+ 2 # "

2 # 4 2" "& C< D &

& 2 " "

>2 & 2

$( $' $+2

') (' '*(+ ') *0 '*(4 2

2 " " 2 &

; >. 2

2 &

2 G &

2 3 &

G ! # G& &

& &

! ! H H " ? " / 2

G #

& (* < #!

)1;0# (465 # & # &

(51 3 3

2 # < 2&G # &+2/

+. 2/9+2/

9 "6 < E+,

,8+ (,+, )+2+./&0 >#3?$(# "2

## Page No.8

# ? ;

! ! " &(!,*/+<

; /+&0>#?D(BD& 2 &

93 &

& # # # 4"40"***@$ # "2 & & # 2

2 &

# 3

# # #

#" 2 (( < G

* +A7>!:+?2

# & &

# 2

2 '562

#& 9

# '5 (( '*(*

2 + B

2 & #

93 # & 2 &

< # 9

! &

(' < : 2 > 2

! " ? 2

&& & >

2 2 2

2 &&& >

> 2

" 2

& $ '* (' '*(+ 2 # EH $(" $'" $) $0 # & 2

# EH 3 # I J> $5

$1 K *6 *0 '*(4#

$("$ Page No.9

'" $)" $0 $6 <

2 *6 *1 '*(4 2 $

1* *+ '*(4 (1 2 #

J> $5" 2 2 H&$ $ G

H "

# #

"EH

/AB" G& # # 2 2 H

> " > 2

& " 2

(* (* '*(+H

# 3< "/ & G& 2 #

2 '

0) & # "

2 '

1( 89

2 & (BE#

2> #EH"2

3 1) <

2 $ ' (

'' % E % >? ; # " &

# $1

# # & >

# ! ? " / " G& () !

'*(+ & (4)0 " $1 #

# : $( A ! =$' EH 2 # $1 : ! =2 $+$3EH Page No.10

J> > & : ! = EH "

& 2

$1 : $( 2 /AB '6 '*(+ $1 : $(G EH#

G& $1 > I > I > $6" EH & # & : $( 2 2 G EH $1 #

# K &" ( !

'*(+" : $( A ! = $'

# ! =$' < # ": $ (A! $=$' 2 J>

$5 $1

;#:

$(A! =$'

> $6" EH 2 2

#EH # J> $5 $1

# : $( ! = $' #

$# #

> 2 L< LM 4 !

'*(+ $1 # : $(A! =$' 2

# EH3 #J> $5 # # & 2 G& ! & 2 2 $1 2 > & 2

/ &

: A! = B & EH J> > H : $( ! = $' 2 B

Page No.11

# $)$ $7 $0

? 3 2>" / (1 !

'*(+ " : $(" ! = $'" # $) 7 $0 2

# ! ? "/ &(4)0 () !

'*(+ 2# $1 : # # # EH 2

2# $1 2 2 :

;

$1 &

# > < & $1 #

# : $(A! =$' EH

# #

: $( ! =$' 2 # #

> # ! ? "/ () !

'*(+ < 2 2 # < ##

& #

&2>

& !

# #

(*$(*$'*(4 #

7@('*"('("('("'*( 3"!

(+"'*7

< # (*$(*$'*(4#

8N78 $( D () 2 #

2 &

$( A $' Page No.12

"2 &

&$( $'# C< D *4 *4 '*(+ 2# # 2 / "2 2 > 2

# )

" 2

2 @ # 2

2 &

#$( $ ' (0 & 2

2 $(" 2 2 G " $6" 2

## & &

" " 2

$' &

2 2 #

$ 8

" ; 2 2 $6

2 *4 *4 '*(+

# > 2

C< D # 2&

K $( $'

"$62 & #"2

' > &

& >

2 &

# $)

> "2

/ & # &&> 2

#$( $' < 2

&> # > #

" $(

2 &

! /$5&

Page No.13

> &

" $( $' 2 2 "2 2 &

;$64@( (6 ! #

# : # # C< D 2 & *4 *4 '*(+ H

F/ E # & # &

" 2 & < 2

2 &

"2 2 &$(A$'

3 3 :@! 3

> 2 () *4 '*(+

# # /AB" /

/AB &>

(5 !

#! =$' #

2 2 2 & >

(0 *4 '*(+& 2

2 2 & &

( 3

(0 *4 '*(+2 2

& 2 # !

! &

# #

(+ <

2 " " 2 2

" 2

>2 # Page No.14

& Investigating Agency

2 # &

" "

2 $ 2 >

2 2

# &

" &

" >

2 # # & &

2 >

& #

& & # " ##

('( ('( 3

# # (4 "2 # 10 2

# 5+2

"2 &

# &

$$&"

'( # 3 # '* "

# "2 #

> # #

# #

2 ?

" # " G

"2 # # #& #

& Page No.15

# #

G < 32

> ( ()'? >

)? #$

> @

M F

M Page No.16