← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2835/1997allowed

(O&M) Union Of India, v. M/S Goyal Electrical And Metals And ORS

2016-03-10Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal10 pages

   

       

 !

"#$%$&'(')* +++ ,

)'))%'"

--$..")# /( 0 1". .$&#2'&".")% $#".(")%#3$2( $(-)%$)#(

 4* 56       2$($)#4*

 

    

   

   



!" ###    

 $ 

!%  

 

&





 '"'(%))*  

   &

  





'+'"%))"

,-.

/ 0

         

  

 &

 



 

 

-  , 





,



!"

,           

 1&

   $ 

!%

(



  

 '%%(%)22           

, 

  

    

 

, 

, 

 

%"+'''3-,   

 

  

      

4

    5 

, 

'%%(%)22 7         

     

   

 

%+%(%)22

 



 

  

  & 

 

,     

,



!%

(    

,   

 

 

/

 

 

 

 

            

 

  3 5  

()%(%)22  

 



 !%  

 (  

  

  









,  

  6 





   

 , 

  

  

,      

   

  '"'%%)2) ,

  0 

    



!(

'7'%%)2)     

  5    

  

 

  



 

  

    

4 

   

  

 & 

8         

      

 

 



!%

(

, 



   

  

     

 

 

           ,         ,  



 !%  

 (  

            ! ,&    

 ,  



 !%  

 (  

  

       



 %''(%)2)



!%

 (  

 



  !"   

    

   %"+'''3-

 





!%

 (  

       ,       9

   

   , 



 ,

 

, 4      





, 

4  



& 

,



!%

 (          0

 (7      

    3,   ,     

   ,

 

  

   )'  $ 

 

   )' 

  

   

     

         0

(7



!%

(

&

 

  ,







-        



,



!%

(

 $ 

  

   



 

   

$ 



,  

 ,     



 

+:%'''3- 

 %"+'''3-  

 

7(:'''3-  $ 

!"







 

,



0 



, 

  



;- % <      





 , 

    ,     

 



=>

, ?

( < 

    , 

 = $ " < 

 ,    

 

2'00=$ 7 <     ,

    



 !"   

  



 

, 

     =$ + <     



 

= $ : < 





 

    = $ * 1   4 0





&





'+'"%))" ,







 

-  

, 



"'%%%)22



    



 4 &



 0

 

  0 

+ /    



 



 4   

 (%%%%))*

  



, 

    

 





%'%'(''%          

 ,        



4  

 , 

,   , 







!%

(

 

  '+')('%( 



   

, 

         

 ,  

     @ A,



 0                   

 !

"

## $%&&'%((4    

 

  1&

 





 &

   '7%'('%(

 

 ,     

 !%  

 (   

 

    

     

  

         

 ,  

&

  50 4   

, 

,  0 ,



  

 

     

 

,1&

  >!

  ? ,  

!%

(/ 







 0 





7'"('%:

      1&



   



  

4 



'7'"('%:



;- B 



  

 

  !"    

   

   

,

@ A,  0 !

"

## $%&&'%((                



 %*'2('%%/  ,    0 

!%

( 



,   ,

   4   

,   -  ! 

 1&

 



!%

(    

 



 

 

 

  '7%'('%(    '7%'('%(  

  

 



 - ;- B  



                !

"

 ## $%&&'%((                   



!

"  #          

      $ 

  

   %                 $

!& 4            ,



,  0  

,

 

    &

%''"('%:     ,    

   1&



 





 

C

7 4  

           

  

 !%

( 



  

!"



    



@ A,  50    

 !

"

## $%&& '%((  ) *+!# ,   -.) /

!

"

## (01''%(1 %+ 4  



!%' 3  4



>

? 



;- '(   

#    #               #  )  *##

 #  

  



   +         ! # #  ##%  !

"    , "    -   )          '  &*           %                        !" 

   

 .!

! -       ,!

! -##

!

 #         -     #

/    %    0      !1   





         #      0

 !   

 ##  2   0   !"

      3  #      #      0  !1   #        ##

  # !" 

/   





 4 #

 # 5        62  6  





  

  

        ##     

/    )0  *  2      !      ##

                         7  - 

/ 



4 #        

/!

1

           ,            %                             #         

/    %        0   

    ##     2      0    #   

  + )!!

  



 4 *              

/!

8          ,                     

 

/!1 ##   

   



  ## 

  !  ##

   

    4      ## 

           4 



     

        !(   

4         

# 

        ,

   !  1  4     #        %

  

 

  ##    0         2 !         

    

           %     !  "      

   

  #          #

%  !  1       

          

/#

       #   

    ##          !&

,      2 .# 4 @ A,

 50   )*+!# ,    -.) / !

"

## (01''%(1

   

   ,

   

 3     4

 

>

?

 

 

;- '1      

     

          ##   ,   - #

  ### 

   

       #   



       

5           ##            !"     

  

      #                    !&

 

 

 

  





  

,  5       

      

 

     

   

 

  , 

 / 



 0     

5  

,

 

 





  

 / 



    

 

&





0  ,  

D 

  ,  

  %'('%:

  !