High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/2347/1998disposed of

Gurbachan Singh Etc v. State Of Punjab

2026-02-20Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja5 pages

$ &" $# &" $# &" $# &" $# 7A8E$#99:. F/ 7A8E$#99:. F/ 7A8E$#99:. F/ 7A8E$#99:. F/ 466$! 466$! 466$! 466$!7 7 7 7 7 77

77@

'' ((&!"

'$!, !"

'$!, !"./

!" #$

&3&(+,=$4&" "% &'' ((&!"

)!*&! %"&+,,( + )!

!*&- GGGG + . &(/ + . &(/ + . &(/ + . &(/

01 2 3&2$#' !"&'' &(+4%&(( !5 5 %&- !(&6,"$"% 3&,,& &" , 7 8 99:'& ,-2"% ( &! ,,,( 6"64 4"),5 +$%6&').% 6!&#"

"$ % ;

# !4 $)"</ - # ,&"% 6 #(2"&"6!5+6!"% ' !"4& +(&!,> &)6!5A &!&(6")& &" , 36"%6!"% = !

!) "&" $#=6((&5 )B6&!+ &,-&"$ 7+ %6(&!,6"

"64" $%6&')+ 4&> > "$ - &4?)6 , =6, $"

"6#64&"6$! ,&" , 8 @ 99A & &!, @ 99A6) ) ,)!, 4"6$!8F@$#"% &!,4?)66"6$!4"+:98.

.#$ %$""% ;:98 4"</ ' 4"6= (2#$"% ')-(64 4')'$ !&> (2#$D4$!")4"

"6$! $# $&, , %& .$)' / 4$!!

! 4"6!5 &%6(')B$%6&') & &!, $%6&')B %&5 &53&& $&, H3&,)!, 4"

"6$!$#"% :984"3&'& , -2"% &!,4 4?)66"6$!$(( 4"$.#$%$";

</$!9 @ 99+"% -2 , " >6!6!5"% >&C "=&() $#"% &4?)6 ,(&!

!,&)!, B

%& 6!,$#(&!, 6!,$#(&!, 6!,$#(&!, 6!,$#(&!,

&" ' &

&" ' & %&%6

9:78 &4 &4 &4 &4 IB' &4

& &6 0A1 55 &&!6

@A+7: &6)>C6! &"&

@A+7: IB' &4 IB' &4 H 56 = , "% $#+ "% &'' ((&!"

"B(&!,$3! 6!=$C , # !4 )!, 4"6$! :$#"% :984"+3%64%4&> "$- '&"(2&(($3 ,-2"% ( &!

! ,

# !4 $) "=6, 6"&3&,,&" ,7 8 9 99:+3%6( 5&!"6!5"% > !%&!

4 , 4$>' !&"6$!J J +@+IB' &4 #$4%& %&%6(&!,- 6, &3&,6!5&(($"

"% "&")"$2- ! #6"

"I6!" "6!"% 6#&=$))!, "

"% :984"

6B&"6#6 ,36"% 3&,'& ,- -2"% ( &! , # !4 $)"+ "% ' !"&'' &(3&' # , ,&" &!,$3!

"% 6!"&!4 $#( >'

')5!6!5 &#$ &6, 3& &,+ ( &! , 4$)! ( #$ &'' ((&!"I(&!,$ $3! )->6" "%&" "% ( &!

, # !4 $)" 3 !" 3$ $!5 %&=6!5 ,64&, , "% &( , , ,&" , 7 997 .K BA/ &!, 9 997 B8/ 3%64% % 3 -$"% ' "&6!6!5 "$ "% &> = !) "&" $# =6(( &5

)B6&!

& ! ,4$)! (#)"% )->6""%& &"-& ,$!"% &#$ &6, =6, !

!4 + "% >&C "=&() ) $#"% &4?)6 ,(&!,3& ?

?)6 ,"$- B, " >6! ,&!, ' !"&'' &(3 3&+"%)(6&-( "$- &(($3 , 01 ! "% $"% %&!,+ ( &! , "&" 4$)! ( )->6" "%&" "% 6 !$ 6(( 5&(6"2$' = = 6"236"%"% #6!,6!5 4$, , ,-2"% ( &! , # !4 $ $)" %&=6!5 65!$ , , "% &( , , ,&" , 7 997 .K BA/ &!, 9 997 B8/ & ! , "&" 4$)! ( '$6!" $)" "

"%&" 6!4 "% ($4&"6$! $# "% (& &!, '&4 (#$>6!5 '&"$#&#$ > !"6$! ,&( , ,6!4$>'&6$!"$"% (&!,)!

!, &4?)66"6$!3& !$" "&-(6% ,$! 4$,+&) )4%"% &6,&( "&!&4"6$!3 3 !$""$- (6 , )'$!#$"% ')'$ $#, " > >6!&"6$!$#>&C "=&() &!,"% %)+ "% 6>')5! , 3&, '& , -2 "% ( &!

, # !4 $)" 4&(( #$ !$ 6!" # !4

0@1 % %&= % &, ( &! , 4$)! ( #$ "% '&"6 &!, 5$! "%$)5% '&' -$$C&3 3 ((& 4$,$#"% 4& ./ #6!,)-"&!4 6!"% )->66 $! >&, $!- %&(# $#"% &'' ((&!"I(&!,$3!

0E1 ' )&( $# "% 4$, %$3 3 "%&" 6! "% ' !" 4& = =6, $"6#64&"6$!,& &" ,8 @ 99A&!, @ 99A 6) ,)!, 4"6$!8F@$#

&!,4?)66"6$ $!4"+:98.#$%$""% ;:9 984"</ ' 4"6= (2+A &!&( $# (&!, #$>6!5 '

'&" $# =6((&5 )B6&!+ &, ,-&" $ 7+ %6( &!, 6"

"64" $%6&')3& &4?)6 ,#$"% ')-(64')'$ !&> (2#$4$!")4"6$!$#

$&, %& .$)' / 4$!! 4"6!5 &% 6(')B$%6&') &!, $%6&'

')B

%&53&& $&,

!$, "$'$= "% 64(&6>+"% % &'' ((&!"I(&!,$3! '$= , ,$! 4$,"% #$(($3 36!5&( , ,B K%6-6"

K%6-6"

K%6-6" &" $#&( &" $#&( &" $#&( &" $#&( & & & & &( &( &( &( 4$!6, 4$!6, 4$!6, 4$!6, 997 &!&(

A+

64 '

64 ' &4 &4 &4 &4 6((&5 6((&5 6((&5 6((&5 , &"6$!

, &"6$!

, &"6$! BA 7 +IB

7+8+IB )B6 &! +IB

8++IB )B6 B8 997 &!&(

+ &! 0:1 $ ,$)-"+"% &'' ((&!"I(&!,$3!

,6,!$"'$,)4 &!26" '(&!

!"$ "&-(6%"% 4$> >'&&"6= ($4&"6$!&!,'$K6>6"

"2$#"% (&!,'&4 (#$>6!5'

'&" $#"% &( 6!"& &!4 K BA&!,K B86! (&"6$!"$"% &4?)6 ,(&!,'& 4 ( $3 = +&' ) )&($#"% 4$, #( 4""%&"

""% (&!,#$>6!5'&"$#"% - -$"% &( 6!"&!4 K K BA&!,K B83& (&" ,"$ $"% &> = !) "&" $#=6(( &5

)B6&!

)"% % >$ + "% (&!, '&4 ( $(, , =6, &( , , ,&" , 7 9 997 BA/3&'

&"$# 4"&!5( $ AI L3% &"% (&!,'&4 (&(6 !&" ,= =6, &( , , ,&" , , 997 .K B8/ 3& '

&" $# 4"&!5( $ ! ) )4% 464)>"&!4 + "%6 $)" 4&!!$" ($$ 65%" $# "% #&4" "%&" "% (&!, '&4 4 ( #$>6!5 '&" $# # "% &#$ > !"6$! , &( 6!"& &!4 3 !$" ($4&" , #& $##

&4?)6 ,(&!,3 3%64%3&'&"$# 4"&!5( $ :F9&!,&)4%+"% ( &!

! ,

# !4 $)"

"3& ?)6 ,"$ (2)'$!"% & &( 6!"&!4 K BA&!,K B8 ("

"%$)5%"% , " >6!&"6$!$#>&C C "=&() 6!"% ' !"4& (& &" "$ "% = !) "&" &!, !$" 5&,6!5 &!2 "$3! $ 46"2+ 2 " & & >&""

$# &-)!,&!" 4&)"6$ $! $ & "$ &44$)!" #$ "% , ,6"&!4 - "3 ! "% (&!, '&4 4 ( #$>6!5'&"$# &( 6!"&!4 ,&" , 997 B8/3%64%! ,"$- ( (6 , )'$!- 6!5"% &( "&!&4"6$!# "4%6!5"% %65 5% "'64 L&4)"J7M6&''( (6 , $= "% '64 '

' &4 , 6= , "% #$> 44 4$,6!5(2+ "% >&C "=&() $# &4?)6 ,(&!,& $!"% ,&" $#!$"6#64&"6$!)!, 4"6$!8$#"% :984"+4$> > "$ A+7+IB B' &4 01 !"

"% ' !"4& +!$, ,)4"6$!"$ $3&,>&((! $#"% (&!,'& 4 ( #$>6!5'&"$# K B86 ?)6 ,"$- &''(6 , ,&"% &> (&" "$ &!& &($# (&!,&!,"% "$"

"&( &4?)6 ,(&!, 6! &(2 A

&!&( )"% + 6! "% 56= ! #& &4" 6!4 "% &4?)6 6"6$! 6! "% 4& ./ 6! %&!, %& & - ! 4&6 , $)" #$ "% ')- -(64 ')'$ +!&> (2 2#$"% 4$!")4"6$!$# $ $&, %& .$)'/4$!! 4"

"6!5 &%6(')B$%6 6&')&!,$%6&')B %&53&& & $&,&!,&)4%+"% '$!, !" ,6,!$")## &!

!2($"$3&,$'"6>)>)"6(6N& &"6$!$#"% & &&4?)6 ,&!,& &($ ,6,!$"6!4) K K' !,6") "$3&,'$=6,6!5$# &,,6"6$!&(6!#&")4")&(&> !6 "6 !$4)""$3&,, , = ($'> !"4$"! ,"$- 6> >'$ , 01 44 4$,6!5(2+6!=6 3$#"% ,64) 6$!>&, % 6!&-$= +"% &''

' &( ' # ,&""% 6!"&!4 $#&'' ((&!"B(&!,$3!

6% -2'&"(2&(($3 ,&!, >&C "=&() #$ "% (&!,)!, &4?)66"6$!6& ,J A+7+IB' &4 & $! "% ,&" $# !$"6#64&"6$! )!, 4"6$! 8 $ $# "% :98 4"

! &,,6"6$!+ (&!,$3! %&( ((&($- !"6"( ,#$&3&,$#& &(("&")"$2- ! #6"&!,6!" "

"& '$=6, , )!, "% '$=66$! $# "% :98 4" .&> !, , )'"$ ,&" / %

(&!,$3! %&( (( &($ - !"6"( , #$$(&"6)> J AM - 6, &3&, $#6!"

" "% )'$!

071 O% % = "% (&!,$3! ./ %&I% %&= )!#$")!&" (2 K'6 , 6! &'' &(./I4$B$ $-* 4"6$!./&#" #6(6!5"% $# &!,"% ( 5&(% 6%&= !$"- ! 6>'( &, ,+ "% 2 2 %&(( - &" (6- "2 "$ C K 4)"6$! $# "% ' !" , 466$! -2 >$=6!5&''$'

6&" &''(64&"6$!./- #$ "% ( & &! ,K 4)"6!5$)"

0A1 (( ' !,6!5&''(64&"6$!./+6#&!2+ %&((&($"&!,,6'$ ,$#

-)&2 )&2 )&2 )&27 7 7 7++++7 7 7 7 "6C . . . . 7@ 7@ 7@ 7@ O% O% % "% ' &C6!5I &$! , % "% '$"&-( I$ I$