← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2969/1997disposed of

Bishamber Dayal And ORS. v. Duli Chand And ANR.

2019-05-30Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh7 pages

 

               

        



         

     

              !"#$%&'() %%*!)(($   

 !" #"$$

" %&'""#

& !"(&# )&*"&  !" #$   

%*!)(($+& +# $ "$$"

 &! !#"

, ","& -.,) " !"/00

(#12"$$"

$ ","&-.,)" ! " 3 4 $" 12 # &"

 . !&, .&   # "$$

"5$

(" "

(  -.,)"!" 3 4 ("&".& & 12#"$$

"5$

("&)& +# "$$

"5$

 !

"&) #" #2 " ( & $& ",&!.

."

"1"&,!", 

'&

" 0360 / 360 3 76

 760 )".&, 7 '""

 )" " &." & #  . "   &

", ".

 +#&  "".&  8&&! .,"  # 1"& ,&"

&$!(# )."& 743(""!& 

309&" #""$$

""& !.

& "&, $&   .& " &! & $.!#"  +# $5 " , 6$ # )."& " # ") (" -!/ 0 12#&!

 .

&!+#-!&

 )."& & &

,"

 .

 " &  +#2 $"2   &    $$."

&-.!& "&&, # $  "' !&1  " &

,"

$& #.& " +# $5 " &  # (& ") " .1)&#"#2  "2$!& &!'&

".)1#"$$

" " #2 (  & $&   "2 $!& &! '&

" .)1 +# "(&, $ " &)$   &

&" &

", " #2 (    #" $!& &! '&

" .)1 ( 1&, (& & # "   #  "

  & &

,"

 & " (&#. ".#&2  +#2 #"  & # "

,"& #" )."& (" (, 2 -! 12 # &!

  .

&! +# "$$

" &  $ &!"& " 6" #& !

"&) "&&#$ "&"! "

,"& #(&") +#&"

. ")#

(&,&.6

 :## # $

 " ( & $&   # .& """

,;  :## # .& &  )"&"&"1  & # $

);8 / :###.&&$$ 2 "

. #$.$ !. "-.&&!&;8 7 :###$

#"  !."& & # $.&;8 4 :###.&&(&#&&);8

  &  +#$"&($)&".! &!&.$$ #&$!& !&<" &,#"!. #$"&&#

/

&,# )"&"

! #&"

.!#.&#

(&, 

!6 =># $

 " ( & $&   # .& " # #.& #$

&!"" !<(  & &( #&&?@ &&# #" #$-.,)#"

!""(##.& " (&

1$"&&"),##"# 5$"&""A  #"1&!#&1 "$$"

$ 12 # "") 28.

&#"(""!!$12#&&"

8&&! *., .,"".&

"5$

("&)&+# "#"(&,#&#)& &$$

"."&# -.,)"!$"12#&"

.""& &$"" "

0 #-.,) .  # "$$

" (.

 ",. #" #  "  &@!.&

30(#&!#&#(&" ,&!.)"!& &!$2# &"$.1 &!!.)9&

.#",.#"#&$ &&&#9&"? &!!  &#B#!C#")""'&,$)&& #.$  " !.) 12 ("2   !"2  &!  &  # !" #(& "

 (&#&#$. &( "2 #!&&$!&1&!& 4 # !. (.

.#",.#" & &&.$# #"#2!" 1!)@!

.& ( #'#"".)1"& &#"

 #2!"& 21!)!6#"#@ ")".&,7'""

)" ""& -&$&#"@"

,(&##!6 #" #-&'#("5'#""+# ".1)&&)"12!. &

#"   & &&,   # $$

" . #" # "$$

" "  .!! .

$ #&$& "&D.&""

&) #2 (.

1& -&$&"".!#.& !

""&(&#. !

"&)&,  &    $& !" 1 "&  1 #& 12 @$ ""& "$$!&/7 #$!& &! & !

/ . $&,#$ #!"2 (.

.,#""#"$$

" "& "& 2#D.&) !

"." !& 4 #!#"&,&"

#"1  #2" & $  #") 12 ("2   !"2  &!  #  #2 !" &  "2 " "",  #& !& ) # !& & !$2 (#&!#&#(&")"'!.). #" #) 2",. #"$ "

"#"#2#" 1!)( #.& " #1"& $$.12#) .#, "

& &"1 &

)!&"

&#!.))"'E"&#"1$!& &!"

2!& #& #" #2 #"  @!. # "

   # 1"&   2 & ! .) $&9& .#",.#"&#-")"1"& &$.

"&!1(#&$ $"& #

"!" & &,# (#&$#1"& (#&!##(&#" 1$  &"!!"!(&# "( 9#" #"!. #$"& $.#$"$61' "&,&"

! +#& . &  " 0040  &. &!&  # 

&!   .1 ,&"  "".&  8&&! .,"  $.! # !&&,&"

$"&&, "&'"43 " 30,& 

30  "@"!# )""

(6

=+# 

&!   .1 ,&" "".&  8&&! .," & &!  $.! # ! & &,&"  $"&&,  %"&'"43 " 30,&

30 -.3040  +#,&2&&!.#""$"&  # "& 

&! "

, (&# &,&"

 ! & $!   # "

"& "&'" .)1 (.

 )"& $ 1  #& .#@" #"&,A 9$.."!#

#%&'"%)"

"$"&  ) #

&! .1,&" +#& "".& 8&&! ..,")$.!# &,&"

,&$"&&, "&'"4 /" 30,& 

30$."

#!$.!12#

&!&"

!.

#$&&$.#"!& &!$2

30 $.! 1  # &"

 . #" 1 !! 2 $$"

)#&,&"

" "& "1 &#! #&,&"

(",$.! )#

&! .1 ,&" !!  "2 1-!& "& 12 # $ (&# ,"  6")&&1& &2   !& & !$2  &&,   # & $$

".&#&,"!"2(&,# +#$5 "#" &@!.& # "

  & D.&   # !"2  #2 "& " $ " #" "'&, " "", #&&

&"!2 $!& &!'#"".)1(,&!$" & # "

  & D.&  +#& $ "   # $5 " !" 1 "!!$  ("   .

&!&  &!  +#& "$"  " $.)$&   !! & " "& "1   " ,& !.)

$"&!.

" 2))"12#,&&,".#&2? & $ " #$&"!!$#"#2&

$!& &!'#"".)1 .& "$ "

"&"!!$#"#2#"$.!#" $!& &!'#"".)1&!$"&#"

 &(.

1 

,"

 !D.! (# @")& & # &,#  $&&& "( #""

 #" 12("2 $!& &!'#"".)112"!6( (.

  &  #   !

"&) "2 1 &,# #" #"   #& ".!#" (.

$&# #& " 2 1!) " !6#" & # -& $$2  9 #& &(   # )" !& "& 12 !.  # $ D." $!& &! '#"" .)1(.

1 !D.! +#&1&,#.#!.!&"

D.&"(#"&,# (" & " .

"#1"&

30+#"$$

"#" $.! &!"1 &##" #$(!6(&#-&'#("#2())1 #$"&!1( #'#("!)$&&, ")".&, 7'""

)" " !1&$& $# ##" $."

!& &!$2 #"

)"'& &#" # ") )"'  !  2  ! .)   !.

& "& 1".2 '#"" '"#9"$$"#"#$" #&$2&,#& # "&D.&& " .

"9#& &( #)" "$$

"!"!

"&)#) 1( .& "#1"&  "

   !& & !$2 (#  & )"'6  <(   & &(  &!.&)"#&1 #2"& !

""&&$! #&-&$& "#@ 7'""

)" "# ") &)  &! # $ #"   "& "2 $ " #" "



@!.& #"

&D.& #2(  (&#"2&,#D."

")".&,7'""

)" " #$(.

1&  !

"&)"2.!#&,#& " #"

"&@& .. + 1 "&  # $  !.  #" &  )"' " $& #" .&  !

""& (&#. !

"&)&, $& &  )"&"&"1 &# &,# !&/7 #$!& &! & !

/ .  # "$$

" #"  !#"

, "!."

&&, 12 # $$

".#"#$

#"  "& $ #&$& "2 $"   # .& "  &! # .& " & $"   " -& '#(" (12"$"& (#&!#&

'#"".)1"!1& $&  "&.$

"!"'"!."

$& . #-&'#("&$"&&&"$$$&"$!&,9#& &(   # )"  !& "& 12 # $ (&# ,"  6)"&"&"1& &2 #.&& & )&""!!&, 2-! #$&#"1"& 9 &( (#"#"1&!.#&1 #"$$"

& $" 2"

(*.,)"!$"12# &$$

".& "&+#.& & 12#$

5"$$

"&$" 2!# 

!#"#2"&-&$& .& "#@ 7'""

 )" "  # 1"&   "

  " 30 ,& 

309#$!.

&" "!"!&!.)"! #$"&"   1"#&(!       

 B8 .

"&C        :##$"'&,5"  25 :##$"1   25