Om Shiv Hari Chahar v. State Of Haryana
1
B8!
!'/'
! "#
B8!')"%+!% ! "# !& ! "# !& ! "# !& ! "# !& ! "# )*"
! "# )*"
! "# )*"
! "# )*"
( ( ( ( !'!% ( !'!% ( !'!% ( !'!% ( "%( "%( "%( "%( & 21 & 21 & 21 & 210 1 0 1 0 1 0 1
%,(
%,(
%,(
%,( ) * 10 1 0 1 0 1 0 1
5- 8
5- 8
5- 8
5- 8
- - - - 8 /% * ;
/' .0 + "& ! #"
"%!8 8 /!! %,0
"%! #" ! &")*
% 8 <<<<< <<<<< <<<<< <<<<< - - - -0 8 3-6 0 8 3-6 0 8 3-6 0 8 3-6 !'!% )!
' ! '!&"%+
!) /%+! !& "% 9 "# !
. / .' %
0 12 3 3#" '" 4 56 #" , % "#
"$ =
* " ! )!
"%!0 % & ! =!
%, "81@ + 788110 !, ' !!+ #" ! "##!%&!' )/%
=*! /%+! !& "%' 10 10 @1
%+ 1 "# # !
0 910 "* &!
"% !& " 0 & //, 8
"%! + !
))* + #" , % "#
! % :/ /!'
"%0 =!#"! ' "/ 0 > & > ' + ' ''!+ ' > + >% "% 981818
! !*!
% ) "# ! '
+ "+!
+'
' /%+!( ?8 ))!!%+ %,
!, ' !!+ #" "##!%&!' )/% =*! /
"* &!
"% !& "0 )!#!!+ ' )!
"% /%+! !& %
0 12 '!!.
%, )! !' =
*8
% "8@ + !+ 78811 /%+! !& "%' 10 10 @10 1 & //, A ! )!
"%! % 9 "#
. / .'
8 -!
%!+ &"/%'!*
%, #" ! )!
"%! '!!.' " > + > !
% %+ > * =! $ " # *!
#!' "% ! '
! & /'! "# "%0
# ! ,
%, =! ! )
&/* 'C+ !'8 +!!+ &&"+ %,*$8D 8
! ,
!% "# !
**!,
' &")*
% '0 C' +!$ $ "% & "0 %!' ) # !%, ,!+ &"%' /& !+ >".' > ! E 3F60 "/, ' ) %!'
+!$ $ !
%+ !!) . ! *"%, > C' G88
"% & "0 )") ! "' ) # & %, "% '
=/'
%!''0 '/=
&")*
% " ! " "%! "# "* &!0 //, 0 =$ '
%, !*$ /)"% ! !)!'!%
''/ %&!' +! =$ !
&&/'!+ )!'"%'0 !
&")*
% '
%'#!!+ '/='
"/% ' "/, = %.
%, & %%!*'
%+0 "% %'
' !%&! "# !
&&/'!+0 *'" +! &!
% ) $!% '
% & '0 ' !$ >!!
%#"!+ '/& & %'
"%' >!! %!&!''
$ " #
! ")!
"%'8 ! "
"/% **!,!+*$ )
+ =$ ! &")*
% ' " !
&&/'!+ )!'"%'
"/% !+ " ₹00110111C0 %&*/'
! "# ) %& *0 & ' &")"%!% 0
% !!' 0 ,!!+ ! /%'C)"# '8
' #/ !
**!,!+ &&/'!+ )!'"%' !H!&/ !+ !&!
) '
&.%">*!+, %, ! '
"/% '
''/!+ ! &")*
% ' !$ >"/*+ %+/& !+ ' ) %!'
% ! %, =/'
%!''8 ">!
!0 +!') ! !)!
!:/!' '0 !
&&/'!+ )!'"%' #
*!+ " !H!&/ ! ! )" '!+ ) %!' +"&/!% '8 )"% .
%:/
!'0 ! &")*
% '
**!,!+*$ + '&"
!!+
% I ' % + =!!% = %%!+ )/'/ % " "+!' "# !
"%5=*! /)!! "/ 0 &"% $ " ! !)!'!%
"%' +! =$ !
&&/'!+8
' #/ !
**!,!+ &!:/!'
''/!+ =$ !
&&/'!+ "> +' )
!) $!% >!! + '"%"/!+0 !!=$ & /'
%, '
,% % # %&
* *"''
!% * + ' !'' " ! &")*
% '0 >"
! '!% " &
J!%'8 ! &")*
% '
#/ !
**!,!+ &&/'!+ )!'"%' & !+ > + '"%!'
% !% "% #" !$ %&!) "%0 ))")
!+ !
!' !+ "/% '0 *'" !H !%+!+ !
' >!% !) $!% > ' +! %+!+8 -!
%!+ &"/%'!* #" ! )!
"%! ,/!+
' =!!% # *'!*$ )* % " ! % :/!'
"%8 -!
%!+ &"/%'!*
,/!+ ! )!
"%! ' =!!%
$!+ &&/'!+ "8 % ! :/!'
"%8 -!
%!+ &"/%'!* ' #/ !
,/!+
' )! )"'!&/ "% & '!0 "%*$ '80110111C > %'#!!+ % !
&&"/% "# ! )!
"%!0 "/, 0 "% 28128190 %+ ! )!
"%! *!
+$ %'#!!+ '/ "# '810110111C !
& " %.
%+ G .
' ! 0 "/, 8 -!
%!+ &"/%'!* ' #/ !
!+ !H&!) !
#"!'
+0 !!
' %"
')!& & "
& +!"%'
%, + '"%!'
% !% %&!) "% "# !
**!,!+ %'
"% ' =!!%
=/ !+ " ! )!
"%!8 -!
%!+ &"/%'!*
,/!+
"%! ' %" %, " +" > !
**!,!+ "##!%&! "# ''/ %&!
%+ + '"%" "# &!:/!' )!
%, "
&&/'!+ "8 %+ ! # **!,!+*$ %, ")!
!+ =$ 8 -!
%!+ &"/%'!* ' '/= !+ ! & % !* !' " &
* " &"!&
* + ')/ !
%+ ! !% ! & '! !' ' /)"% +"&/!% $ !
+!%&!8 -!
%!+ &"/%'!* ' #/ ! '/= !+ ! "##!%&!
% :/!'
' '
!+ " =! ))!%!+ % 190 >!!
'0 ! ' =!!% !, ' !!+ % !&!=! 110 8!80 # !
% /%!H)*
%!+ +!* $ "# "! % 1 $!
'8 -!
%!+ &"/%'!* !+
' !
+$ %+ > %, "
'/ "# '8@0110111C " ! &")*
% 8 288 -!
%!+ &"/%'!* ,/!+ %" ' " =! !&"
!!+ #"
"%!8 -!
%!+ &"/%'!* ' #/ !
!+
' !
+$
%+ > %, " I"
"%0 %+ %" )/)"'! >"/*+ =! '!
!+ =$ .!!) ! )!
"%! =! %+ = '8 % ! = ' "# !
#"!!% "%!+ '/= "%'0 % "# !
%'
% )!
' ) $!+ #"8 8 -!
%!+ ! &"/%'!* ' # *!+ '
/' !)" =$ > $ "#
##
!+ 7812810 % ! "/ "+ $0 > & .!% "% !&"+8
%, '/= %+! > ! '
+ '
/' !)" 0 *!
%!+ ! &"/%'!* ' "))"'!+ ! , % "# "$ =
* " ! )!
"%! =$ ,/ %,
**!,
'!+
! '!
"/'
% % /!8 !*!
% "# !
+ '
/' !)" !
+' /'( ?98 -
98 -
98 -
98 -
(
% '" #
' ! "*! "# !
' &"%&!%!+0
' '/= !+
"%! + )* $!+
! "*!
% ! &" "% "# ! )!'!% & !8 ! )!
&"%%
%&! > ! &" &&/'!+ )!'"%' + &!+ &"%')
&$ % "+!
" &!
%+ +!# /+ ! &")*
% ' =$ %+/& %, ! "
'/='
"/% '
)/)" !+ %, =/'
%!'' "% ! # *'!
''/ %&!
"# , ! /%'
%+ ) %!' )0 % )/'/ %&! !!"#0 '/ "# '80110111C %+ '80110111C > %'#!!+ % " ! = %.
&&"/% "# ! )!
"%!K' # 8 !!
# !0 %'#!!+ ! '
! " " !
&&/'!+ )!'"%'8
"%! > ' ! + !& =!%!#
$ "# ! +/)!+ "/% !!=$ =* !&
"* !!%
!&!
))")
%, ) "# ! &!
"/% 0 %+ +!') ! !)!
+! %+'0 %!
! ! /%!+ ! "%!$ %" #/*# **!+ ! )" '!+ "=*
"%'0 !#*!& %, + '"%!'
% !% "% #" !
!$ %&!) "%0 > *!
'/='!:/!% *$
"%0 %!&!''
&/' "+
% !",
"%8D -!
%!+ ! &"/%'!* ' #/ ! '/= !+
"%0 ! )!'!% & '!0 ' '
** /%+! > %+ ! )!
' $! " =!
!' !+8 '!0 ! )!
' !*!
'!+ "%
*0 !!
** * .!* ""+ % !#!! > ! )"'!&/ "% !
+!%&!C > %!''!'8
!% !'!
&/'
%&!'0 &/' "+
% !",
"% "# ! )!
')!%'
=*!8
!!#"!0 '/= !+ ! )!'!% )!
' +!
"
+ "# !
' *
=*! "
=! + ' ''!+8
@ 88 -!
%!+ ! &"/%'!* *'" # *!+ &")*
%&! !)" + L812810 '
%, !!
%
% &")*
%&! " ! "+! + !+781281 ''!+ =$ ' "/ 0 =" ! &")*
% '
! =!!% +/*$ )) '!+ ="/ !
)!%+!%&$ "# ! )!'!% )!
' >!** ' !
+I"/%!+ + !8 ">!
!0 %"%!
' & /'!+
%&! "% =! *# "# !8 @8
! !
+ ! *!
%!+ &"/%'!* #" !
* )
%+
,"%! "/, !
=*! !&"+ "# ! & '!8 8
>"/*+ =!
))"'
! " !#! !!
% "
I/+,!% ) ''!+ =$ "/
*!+ ' %, '8 ! "#
0 1326 %, '8 ! "#
0 1326 %, '8 ! "#
0 1326 %, '8 ! "#
0 1326 3
3
3
3 *6 @ *6 @ *6 @ *6 @0 !*!
% >!!"# !
+'
' /%+!( ?8 '
% !) *",/! " !
="
! /
"%0 ! #"**"> %, ) %& )*!'
!!,!( !&"%+C'/&&!''
"$ =
* )!
"%3'6 # *!+ /%+!
!& "% 29 "# 8880 L72 '
=*!
% * > F !%&! '/&
"% "/, %" " =! !I!& !+ '"*!*$ "% ! ,"/%+ "#
= $ !!"#8 /& '!&"%+C'/&&!''
"$ =
* )!
"%3'6
=*!
>! !
' ''!+
+ >%C+ ' ''!+ ' %" )!''!+C+ ' ''!+ #" %"%)"'!&/ " !
! )!
"% > ' + ' ''!+ "% !
'8 " ! '!&"%+C'/&&!''
"$ =
* )!
"%3'6 "
'/&&!!+0 ! )!
"%!C ))* % ' ** =! !''!%
**$C)!
%!% *$ !:/ !+ " '"> '/='
* & %,!
% & &/'
%&!'
%+ '"> "# !! '/)!#
* " "' !%'
=*! & %,! >"/*+ %" '/## &!8
" !H /'
! ,/ +!* %!' & % )"''
=*$ =! *
+ +">% ' "
> >"/*+ &"%'
/ ! '/='
* & %,!
% & &/'
%&!'
' !
!$ '! ' ">% /% :/! # & 'C& &/'
%&!8 &&"+ %,*$0 ''/!
' =!' *!# " ! I/+
* > '+" %+ + '&!
"% "# ! "/ +!
%, > '/& '!&"%+C'/&&!''
* )!
"%3'68
% & "/ &""'!' " , % '!&"%+C'/&&!''
"$ =
* )!
"%3'60 &",!% %+ */& + !
'"%'
%!% *$ !:/ !+ " =! !&"+!+ #" , %, '/& )*!
+!') '/& )*!
%, '!&"%+C'/&&!''
! )!
"%3'68 % " ! >"+'0 !
/'! #"
"/
%, '/&&!''#/**$ &"/% !% %&!+C!% !
%!+ '/& '!&"%+C'/&&!''
! )!
"%3'6 "/, " =! !
*$ %+ &*!
*$ +!& )!
=*! #" ! '
+ "+! ) ''!+8
%&!
)*!
#"
"$ =
* ' =!!% + ' ''!+ + >%C+ ' ''!+ ' %" )!''!+C+ ' ''!+ #" %"%)"'!&/ " + ' ''!+ "% !
' =$ !
, "/ 0 %" '!&"%+C'/&&!''
"$ =
* )!
"%3'6 ' ** =! !% !
%!+ =$ !''
"/ 8D
) #" %, '!&"%+
*0 ' )! ! & '! )/ #" % ! % :/!'
"%0 %+/=
=*$0 '!
"/'
**!,
"%'
! =!!% *!
!*!+
"%!8 ' )! )"'!&/ "% & %+ '
/' !)" # *!+ =$ *!
%!+ ! &"/%'!*0
' ="%! "/ "/'
%+ ')!& **!,
"%'
! =!!% *!
!**!+
"%!8
"%! )* $!+
%' /!% "*!
% ! &" "% "# ! )!'!% "##!%&!8
"%!0 % &"%%
%&!
! &" &&/'!+ )!'"%'0 &!+ * &"%')
&$ " &!
+!# /+ ! &")*
% ' =$ %+/& %, ! "
!' '/='
"/% '
)/)" !+ %, =/'
%!'' "% ! # *'!
''/ %&! "# , ! /%'
%!' )8 % #/ !
%&! "# ! '
+ &"%')
&$0 "/% ' "# ₹0110111C ₹0110111C >!!
%'#!!+ % " ! = %.
&&"/% "# ! )!
"%!5' # 0 > & >!! !!
# ! "/ !+ " " !
&&/'!+ )!'"%'8
"%! > '0 /'0
!& =!%!#
$ "# ! &!
"/% 0 &*!
*$ !'
=* %, "* !!%
% ! !&!
%+ ))")
"% "# ) "# ! +!# /+!+ #/%+'8 !') !)!
!+ +! %+'0 ! )!
"%! %!
! ! /%!+ ! '
"/% ' %" #/*# **!+ ''/ %&!' !H !%+!+ " ! &")*
% '0 !!=$ !#*!& '"%!'
% !% "% #" !
!$ %&!) "%8 / !"!0 ! )!
"%! ' !
+!+
"%0 %!&!''
%, &/' "+
% !",
"%8 788 / !"!0 !
' '
&/&
* '
,!0 &/' "+
% !",
"% "# ! )!
' &"%'
+!!+ %!&!''
$ " /%!
!
&")*! ! # & '
%+ "
'&!
"* !!% "# %$ " ! )!'"%' &"%%!& !+ ! & '!8
' $! " =!
!' !+ %+ , % "#
*0
' '
,!0 $ )!I/+ &! ! "%,"
"%8 ))!!%'
!H)!''!+ =$ ! )"'!&/ "% ! )!
"%!0 # !*!
'!+ "% =
*0
='&"%+ "
!) "
%#*/!%&! > %!''!'
*'"
' " =! %" > "/ = '8
!% ! '!
"/'%!'' "# ! "##!%&!0 ! '
,! "#
%+ )"''
= "# )!
%, > !
+!%&! " "=' /& %, I/'
&!0 ' "/ ' "# !
!>
"%! +"!' %" +!'!
! ! &"%&!''
"% "# =
' I/%& /!8
' =!#
%, " !% "% !! > *! &"%'
+!
%, )*!
#" , "# "$ =
*0 ! "/ ' " !:/ = ! =! >!!% '
#!,/
+/ , '
%+ )" !& %, '"& % !!' 3'68 ! "/ "/, " !&."% ! ,% /+!
%+ % /! "# ! "##!%&!A ! "*!
=/ !+ " !
&&/'!+A ! %!!+ #" #
%+ #!!
*'" ! +!!)!
%+ > +!
) & "# '/& **!,!+ :/
!' "% ! '"& ! $8 )"#
=*! !#!!%&!
% ' !, %, +! " ! + ''!+ =$ !
"%5=*! /)!! "/ *!+ '
% * 0 3LL76 7 97 ( LL7 3 6 12L % * 0 3LL76 7 97 ( LL7 3 6 12L % * 0 3LL76 7 97 ( LL7 3 6 12L % * 0 3LL76 7 97 ( LL7 3 6 12L0 ! /)!! "/ !*+ ' /%+!0 !*!
% >!!"# !
+'
' /%+!( ?8 E! # %+ #"&!
% ! '/= "% "# &/' "+
% !",
' :/
!*$ "! !*
"%"
!% !+ % :/!'
'/')!& >"
>!**!%'&"%&!+ >
"/ =*! "+! /%+! !& "% 29 "# ! "+!8
'! * .! '0 !##!&
% !",
"% "# '/')!& !+ )!'"% ' "# !!%+"/'
,!
% + % !
%, %$ /'!#/* %#"
*'"
*' > & >"/*+
! =!!% &"%&!
*!+8 /&&!''
% '/& % !",
"% >"/*+ !*/+!
# !
'/')!& !+ )!'"% .%">' ' >!** )" !& !+ %'/* !+ =$ )! =
* "+! +/ %, !
! !
% !", !+8 G!$ "# !% % !",
% '/&
&"%+
"% >"/*+ !+/&! "
!!
/ *8 ,/!% ! &/' "+
% !",
' # /, > ! + %,! "# ! )!'"% =!
%, '/=I!& !+ " + +!,!! ! "+' %!!+ %" =! &"/% !% %&!+0 #"0 '/& ,/!% & % =!
%&!+ =$ &&/'!+ ** & * & '!'8 ! "/ ' " )!'/!
!')"%'
=*! )"* &! "## &!' >"/*+ &"%+/& !'!* !')"%'
=*! %%!
%+ "'! !% /' !+ > !
'. "# + % !
%, "##!%&!' >"/*+ %"
&"%+/& !'!* ' "##!%+!'8D ' '
,!0 !!
' %"
* "% !&"+ " "*+
! & ' %" +! "/
"%!8 !
* > & ' &"!
"% !&"+ %+ )!*
"%0 " !'
=* '"% =*! = #" &&/'
"%8 /'0
' %"
))")
! " ,
* " !
"%!0 >"/*+ %!&!''
*$ & /'!
)!+ !% % !##!&
"%8
L8
%+/=
=*$0 ! # ' )!
"% 3#" , % "# "$ =
*6 )!#!!+ =$ ! )!
"%! > ' + ' ''!+ ' > + >% =$ ' "/ "% 981818
' >!** '! *!+
'!&"%+
* )!
"% '!!.
+!% * !* !# ' %"
=*! /%*!'' !!
'/='
* & %,!
&/'
%&!'
# ! ! + ')"'
* " > + ' )! ! I/ ')/+!%&! "% =
*8
! ,"/%+' /,!+ % ! )!'!% )!
" =! ! '
!
' "'! > & >!!
=*! " ! )!
! >!% ! !
! )!
"% > + >%8 % !
='!%&! "# %$ %!> # & 0 +!
!*")!% " & %,!
&/'
%&!'0 !% !
%, '/&&!''
! )!
"%' >"/*+ "/% " )!
!)!
!) ' #" ! '
! !* !#0 > & & %%" =! &"/% !% %&!+ % * >8
!!#"!0 %" > '
%, ! '/= "% !, %, ! "*!
=/ !+ " !
"%!0 ' "/ # %+' ! )!'!% )!
"% '/##!' #" !
&! "#
= $0 ' %" & %,!
% & &/'
%&!' ' =!!% +!"%'
# ! !
+ * "# ! !
* )!
"%8 &&"+ %,*$0 ' "/ %"
%&* %!+ " , % ! &"%&!''
"% "# "$ =
* " ! )!
"%!8 / !"!0 !!
' %" '/='
* & %,! % %$ & %,!
% & &/'
%&!'
> & $ >!
,0 % #
"/ "# !% !
%, !
%'
% '!&"%+ )!
"% #"
"$ =
*8 ,"0 !
%'
% )!
"% +!'!
!' + ' * "% ' '&"!
*"%!8 18
% ! # & / * !/ "# ! & %
!> "# '!
"/'%!''
"# !
**!,
"%!0 ' "/ # %+' %" &")!** %, ,"/%+ " !H !%+ ! =!%!# "# + '&!
$ !* !# " ! )!
"%!8 "!"
!0 &/' "+
% !",
"% "# ! )!
' %!&!''
$ #"
% !##!&
"% F " /%
!* ! / 8
'0 /'0 +!
"
+ "# !
' !!=$ + ' ''!+ ' ''!+ ' ''!+ ' ''!+8
L 8
" %, '
+ !!
="
! ' ** =! +!!!+ " =!
% !H)!''
"% "# ") "% /)"% !
' "# ! & '!C
"%8 8 !%+ ))*
"%3'60 %$0 ' *'" '
%+ + ')"'!+ "##8 3 - - - -6 & 21 & 21 & 21 & 210 1 0 1 0 1 0 1
E! ! ')!
.
%,C!
'"%!+( !'C "
E! ! !)"
=*!( !'C "