Munasif @Munsab v. State Of Haryana



   
    


  

!

"#$#%& '

'






  STATE OF HARYANA


&

() '*
 *    

 


 !"# 
$"
%
&''" Ms. Deepali, AAG Haryana.

((((( *  + '

) This petition for bail is the second petition, filed by the petitioner  
#'"
*+,
"$
-%
'.

 / '0
 0%
 %' 
121,3

% 4
$'


5'%
/ 
"

''/
"
"$

"

)))

12 $"
%
#"

''"
"$
"$$#
&'% 
 
#'"
1)789)8+6
"$  #"'#
/

.#%""&'#
4 #
#
):+6
"

'#
 '" ' /5 
''#
%

'$ .
 '/
%
$ #
 /'/
$"

#"

% 
%

"$ %'
# 
#


'"
4'/

%
' #
"$
-;
'3
5%"
&"
% 
" %
4 '
"$

'&8"$$
/'!
4.

 
"#
""#.# 
5 
'#&


$"

%
&"'"
"$
""#.# 
' 
,92
4" 
"$
#" '
&%"&% 5
#"! , 
'
%
# 
"$
%
&"#'"
% 
& 
"
4"!8 '" #"!.
%
<''
$"

''
5'%
/ 
"
'=



'/
"$ #"  
/' '"
"$


$"


"$
%
##
5

&$" 

$%
'!'/ '"
 0
&
##" '/
"
&"#'"
'/ %
#"
"$
'!'/ '"
5%
%
4"! 
## 


.
- '$3
5 '"/  
%
$$

'# "
 
5%'
%
"


% &
&''"

%
&& '
"$
'"
 #"'#
4 #  #"

, #% Ms. Deepali, AAG Haryana
&& 
"
4%

$
"$
&" 8  #
!'#
"$
"'#
&"
%
 
'
%4.
'&
5'% 7" .
#'$'# 
% 
4
$'


4.
%

 
7"

%



4 0
"
#"
"
$"

& .
% 
4
$'


4.
%
 "5!
%


 
7"
% 
"

.
"&&"
%
&
&''"

> %
#"
% 
4
&
# $

.

+ '#
%
'!"


"$
&''"
'
%
&
# 
'
"
% '
"$
'# "
 
"$
#"8 ##
%
"4!

'"


'
%
# 
"$ - 






'/#
$$'#
'#" 
"$
! 

'/#3
12)+?,@
77
 '
7
>6>

 

%
'" # 
'
% 
4
%
4.
%

& 
7"
"$
 '

% 
% '# "
 
"$
#"8 ##
'
'

''4 / '
"%
## 
%
'# "
 
'
"

4 '!
&'#
"$
!' #
/ '
"%

## :

'


&'#'& 
% 
4

7"
"$
 '

'
%
# 
"$
-


 
"$
A 43
12)+?*@
7 ?7'

@
:,+
5%'
'
% 
4
%
% 
%
'# "
 
"$

##
# 
4

" .
/ '
%
&"

0'/
%




"
/ ' %
#"8 ##



)2 
-"$ 
'/%

 
"$


 3
121)?*@
77
)

"
' 
4
"4!
4.
%

% 
#"$'"

 
"$
##
#" 
 
#'"
9>
"$

#
# "
4

'
'
!' #


#"$'" )) 
&

"$
#"
%"5
% 
'
%
&
# 
$"

"5'/
 %
 
$ #"
5%'#%

<'
"
4
 0
'"
#"'  '"
$"

#''"
8 '@ 
%
&''"
'

 .
'
#" .
$"

&'"
"$
"
% $"

%

$
"%B ''@ that the only evidence collected against the petitioner is the disclosure statement of his co-accused and there is a big question mark with regard to credibility & admissibility of abovementioned statement in evidence, as the same was recorded when the co-accused of it was in police custody. Since pursuant to above-mentioned disclosure statement no recovery or discovery of fact has taken place, prima facie the same appears to be hit by Section-23 of Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam;

'''@ 
"%'/
% 
4
$
"
4
#"!
$"

%
&"'"
"$ &''"B '!@ 
%
'

'
"
'0 .
"
4
#"#  
'
 
$

"
"$ %
&"#'"
5'
% 
4
C

'
"
$ B !@ 
%
'"
"$
&''"
'
A '#'

"#08&
'
"
'0 .
"

!
.
$
&&"B !'@ 
%
'
"%'/
"
#"
"
%"5
% 
'$
 
"
4 
% &''"

.


&
5'%
%
!' #
"
'$ #
% 5'B !''@ % 
%
'
"%'/
"
#"
"
%"5
% 
'$
 
"
4 
% &''"
5'

"
#"8"& ;& '#'& 
'
%
'

)1 
%
&
# 
%
&'#'& 
"$

5

-

&
'
%
# 
"$
-

!
 
"$
 
 %


"%3
?12)+@
,
77
11


"
 
5%'
'
% 
4
"4! 
D
$



&"


"$
#'

A'& #
'
%
& &'"
"$ '"##
'/
%4.
% 

&"
'
4 '!
"
4
'"#
'

$" /'

.

"5!
%

' #
'
"
#'

5
5%

!
" 
4
&

#
"

##
5'%
/ 
"
"


&#'$'#
"$$#
4
% 
'

"%



"
"
 #
$"

%
$



&"


'
&# "$
"%
"$$#
E
"%
'

&" 
$ #
"$
"
#'

A'& #
' 
%
/ 
"$
4
'
%
/

 
&'/

&"
'
A
"
'

&'"
"
'

#"#'"
%"


?5%'#%!
C&'"
"

.
5'%
"
@
'


C#&'"
$" .
"


"$
%
4 '#
&'#'& 
&& 
"
% 4
"
'/%
"$
5'%
%
 
% 
"

"
&"

4'/ '# # 

$"
"/
&'" 
%'
"
"
"
.
/""
"
"
#'

A'& #
"
"
"
"#'.

%
'
"
"4
% 
%
/ 
"
'

"$
'
' .
%
'#'"
"$
%
A /
#"' '/

4
!
"
% C#'
"$
A '#'

'#'"
% 
4
#'# #'4
4.

/
 4
"$ #''"
 
4.
%'
7"

4.
!.
'/%
7"
'
%
#".

E "## '"

.
%
'

#'.
"
'"&#
5%%
.'/
4
"

##
&"
'
%
'/%
%'/
"
"
"
%
$ #

'
%
#'#  #
"$

F ), %
&'#'& 


%
& 
7"
"$  '

'
%
# 
"$
-  


'


7

 
"$
!'/ '"


"%3
?1211@
)2
77
6)


"
 
'
%'
# 

%

'"
# 
'
% 
4
"4!
% 
D%
 
"$
#"!'#'"
' #'


'
 '

'
4.

.
"5

&& 
"

% 
%'
$ #"
5'/%

.

"
%
'
"$
%
7"
5%'


#' '/
%
4 && '# '"
'

/ '! 
7"

"
%'0
% 
%
&"'4'

'.
"$

#"!'#'"
4'/
 
"

'.
4 && '# '"
5'

% !
"
4
#' 
'# .
#" .
"
/

&'#'& 
G
# "
'C
&
#"'  '"
"$

4 && '# '"
5%'#%
'
" &''!
'
 
5'%
% 
"$

&"'4 A '# '"
4.
5 .
"$
'


% #" .

 '


#<'

5'%
#"'
#" .
5"
4

"$
/ 'A'#F )* # .
'
%
# 
"$
- & 




'

 
"$ 7%% '/ %3
1216
77
 '
7
,11
%


"4!
% 
D'$

##
'
"
/

$'

! '#
$
'# # '"
"$ 'C
"
!
. 
'
A 

 '

&'"
%
$'' .
'
#"
4 '
% 
%'
'/%
"
% !

& .
'

 
'# 
1)
"$
%
7"''" 
4
'$'/ F

% 

"
4
"4!
4.
%

7" "$
 '

'
%
'"
# 
% 
D 

.

4
$"
%
##
C .
4
$"
%
!'#'


$"
 '


"#'.

$"
%
# '4'

'.
"$
" A'#
. 
5%'#%
'
!


H /

%


"$
%'
7"""


%
7'

"# 
7" 
&"!' 

.
""


$"
%
H /
"

' " 
"

% 
# 
&"#
$$'#' .F )6 "
 #'


$%
%'
7"
'
#"#'"
"$
%
4 '#
$



&'#'& 
"$

5
% 
'/%
"
& .
'

'

& 
"$
 " $ '

A
&"# 
%'
 
'# 
1)
"$
%
7"''"
"$
 '

%'
#"''"

'/%
# "
4
'
"
%
##



4.


&C
#"
'
D

5' 
'/%
!
 
"$
A 4

"%F 121*
77
 '
7
*,6*

)9 $
%
#

'!
$$#
"$

%
'"
$ #" '!"

!
'
%
' 
# 
'
 0
'"
#"'  '"
'

"

#"# '" 
%
&''"
'
' 
$"
%
4$'
"$
4 
% 
%
&
&''" !
"
4

"5 )> ##" '/ .
5'%"
#"

'/
.%'/
"
%
'
"$
% # 
%
&
&''"
'
%4.


%
&''"
'
%4.
" 
"

4
 
"
4
"
$'%'/
&"

4"

.
4" ?@
"
% '$ #'"
"$

'

7" "5!
%
4"! '
#"#'"
%

4 4A#
"
$"

"5'/
#" ''"8 ?'@ 
%
&''"
%

"
'# .
"
' '# .

0
.

' # 
% 
"
&"

'
"
.
&"
#< '
5'%
% $ #
"$
%
# 
"

"
' 
%'

"
'# "
#%
$ #
"
% 7"
"
"
.
"%
%"'.

?''@
% 
%
&''"
%


%
'


"$
C#'"
"$
4" 
$'% %

"
%
7"
#"#

%

"'$.
%
#% /
'


"
%
'

7"
'

%
$'

#''"
"$
%
'

B
?'''@
% 
%
&''"
%

"
!
 '

5'%"
&'"
& ''" "$
%
'

7" /*  0

 '

'

 G%%
& 0'/; " E;"

G%%
&" E;"