High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/19693/2023dismissed

Harmeet Kaur v. Vijay Kumar

2023-08-25Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary9 pages

"#$%#&## # #'#

)*+,-./,0121-3 4 4 *56,,+7*85 4444,+1+1-3,5 9,5282 91:*;786*5 444,2<-3/,3+

#=> ?$@=A"

B #=# # '#& 5,2,3+ 54*3/,,<C13DEC*0E/,FGH/F-0*+,.-5+E,<,+1+1-3,5 IIIII #=# # '#&A"A 4 JE, <5,2,3+ <,+1+1-3 E*2 K,,3 .1L,/ 83/,5 C,0+1-3 ( 5444 .-5 M8*2E13D -. -5/,5 /*+,/ (4 G H33,N85, <*22,/ K; H//1+1-3*L C,221-32 O8/D,G H651+2*5 13 0*2, K,*513D H +1+L,/ *2 P*56,,+ 7*85 F24 91:*; 786*5QG RE,5,K; * 0-3/1+1-3 R*2 16<-2,/ -3 +E, <,+1+1-3,5 +- <*;

S -. 0-6<,32*+1-3*6-83++-+E,0-6<L*13*3+5,2<-3/,3+4 4 T,*53,/ 0-832,L 28K61+2 +E*+ * 0-3/1+1-3 .-5 +E, D5*3+ -. K*1L 0*33-+ K, 6*/, -3,5-82 .-5 +E, <,+1+1-3,54 JE, *<<,LL*+, -85+ E*2 0-661++,/ *3 ,55-5 *2 3- 5,*2-3 E*2 K,,3 *221D3,/ .-5 16<-213D * 0-3/1+1-3 RE1L, D5*3+13D +E, 282<,321-3 -. 2,3+,30,4 C+1LL .85+E,5G +E, 3-3/,<-21+ -. 0-6<,32*+1-3 0*33-+ K, * D5-83/ .-5 F*0*+13D +E, -5/,5 D5*3+13D 282<,321-3 -. 2,3+,30, 83/,5 +E, U,D-+1*KL, V32+586,3+2 H0+G 4 ,L1*30, 12 <L*0,/ -3 +E, :8/D6,3+2 13 +E, 0*2, -. WXYZ[ B\]^X Y_A `ab\[ =\]X^cd\ $\^[ @bcAe

3T13, G #f\g WX^ach]\^cd\ B]\] Y_A Bb\bZ ai =\]\d\_]bd\e

3T13, j-6 (*3/ 'XkXlBA'\]\^m[\dY_A`ab\[=\]X^cd\ aA @bcAe

nC 4

!"# $ % &' "' ) "

""' !' )""' *+ ' &&'

'! ' ,) '! )'

-&"' $ '! ./'"0# 1 ) 2&3 3

"' '!

& /

##4"##0 ')"&##,'&' ( "##,&&##56 7!' #8"/

' )"

'! & 3 " 4'

# 0

" ' 8' #8 ', '8"

"'"8'#834 "&

* 9:;< =>?@A >B CDD@EEFG@ H>IAG G> >AJ@A DFKL@MG D@MJNMOFDD@FEFOFNMPGQ>MRNQGN>M S TUVS .'4"

"/ , "/ &'" " ' '! ")"# '& 3 W

'! W$3 "

# 0, 4 /" &'8"&"'

&"' 3

## '

), '

## "

) 4 "&

## 0 )"") ) '! 4,

& '! !" ' &') "' 4 0, "# '

'8" )'

,0#

&"'

## 0 " ""' , "") &') "'

" 0,

## &"'$2

% )'

! "

0 &"'

## 0 " 4" "

"X, , !') '! '3 ' 4" "

& !

"' ' X&"/ ", , ), 0 "& 0, '

!!"&" &

0"/

'40,

## '

), "& # '! )'

" 0,

## &') #" ,") "/ &,'!

# '8" "!

## &( "3 '

## "& &') #" ,

## )'

# 3 4" " 0Y

0#"

0, 8 7Y '! 1"3

8# 0/""/ '! #8 !"&"# ,3 4" "

"X, , !') '! '3 ' 4" "

& !

"' ' X&"/ ", , ), 0 "& 0, '

!!"&"&

0"/ '40, &') #"6 2

3 " ), 0 &&

0Z& ' '! -&"' $ '! .1 2& 0"/ 0'

/ "' !'& 0, 2& .'

# 4

' &'8"&

-&"' .1 2&3

!"# $ %& ' ! (#"

)# !* #)!

!# #+ +#"! # ,"

",),

- # !* ,#) ! # "

# #, !"# .++/ 0* #1""# 23"

."!* !*

# #2! !

) .*" * 3"1 "! #1"+"

3 ! #1 !* #1""# #!*/// "

#!*4"

# "! !."!*!*"+#1""# / 5/ #"!2 2 ,+ !# !* ()+3, ! # 6789:;<8 69:=> ?<@ABC D@E F98<:;<8 GB:;>9H

! + !# !* I! ()+3, !J 24 # K2 0* ), #)!

.*"

L#) +"

3 !* .#+ M,4J )+ !* #"+ #1""# !# 2 # !)+ ) # *

3 1". !* !!, ! # #2( ! + # # , +"

3 !* "+ !"# / 1 !"

!*"3++!*) I/ %#. # !* )2,""# # 2* # !*

! !*! 1 # "+"

3 !*

3)3 )+ !"# $ # !* %/&/ ' ! , ++ !*

! #)! I,4J #+ !*

! !# +#"! ) * ), .*" * *

2 ,"

",), #

- # !* "

# #, !"# .++ 24 !* !" #)! + !* .#+ )+ "

#! I*

J + !*# !* +" !"# " 1!+ ."!* !* "!

! #)! !# +" ! !*

! )+ !# +#"! ) * ), + !*

! #)! * # !)+ "! , +!#4 .*" * #+"

3 !# !*

+ "# '+1# ! # !*

! .#) + 2 # !4 !# !* #1""# # !"# $ # !* %/&/ ' ! , ++ " # + # "+"

3 !* , ++ !"# $ # !* %/&/ ' ! .*# !# 2 + ."!* !* !!, ! #

2( ! + # # !* , +"

3 !"# $ # !* %/&/ ' !

!*#)3* "! " !) !*! , ++ !"# $ # !* %/&/ ' !

!* .#+ )+ " I,4J "! " 3

4 !# 2 # !)+ I) J # I*

J +

#! !# +" ! !# +#"! 24 !*

! #)! " L !"# # .*" * " # !# 2 "3 +/ 0*# , ++ !"# $ # !* %/&/ ' ! # #. )# !* '

! #)! !# #+ +"

3 !# +" ! !* '

! ' )+ !# +#"! !* ), .*" * *

#! 2

- # !* "

# #, !"# "!* # " !"# "

+ 24 !* #"3"

#, "

! # 1 # !* " !"# "

+ 24 !* '

! ' )+ ) + !"# !# ) + !* ! / 0* #"+ " O)"+ !# 2 # !)+ # "+"

3 !* ! !*! !* , ++ !"# $ # !* %/&/ ' !

",), #

- # !* "

# #, !"# .++ 24 !* !" #)! " +" !+ !# 2

& ' ( '&#

&&) & %

!" '!& & & *" + (

# ( $ &"

"!& '& !''

! % $(

- . &'&)

# /"

0-1- 2"

!& 3,(

# &

%!, &3

$4"

' ,(

0-1- 2"

) $!

, /"

0-1- 2"

- 0+

$, 1 &!# 2"

# '&#

&3 )

) ( , ' &,

''"' !&'" 5!---6 - 1

4!+# ) % , " & +

!#$& ' 4!+#

",! + 7898: ;<7=>=?@A=B

!& )

!"&

&# *,

,( $&3 , ! C---. &'&) " & +

# '

$4"

0-1- 2"

$3) !& 3

' /"

0-1- 2"

#) %

& '

0-1- 2"

#) ,, $

, $,

&& ' "3

" '&

''" !& /"

0-1- 2"

) 3

% &

"& #

, "#,

''" !& /"

0-1- 2"

%& , & &

## 2"

--) & &

- - - 1' !"

!& 3

)

$4"

!& '

0-1- 2"

%!,$'&! &

E ** ** ** E. &'&

# /"

0-1- 2"

"'& %& !

2,,

&& +

2,,

2""!

!# % " ,, $ ,

F '

& "#

, $(

& +

, "#,

& 3

, $(

2,,

2""! !& /"

&---

! "E ** ** ** E. &'&)

# /"

0-1- 2"

!& 3,(

# &

%!, &3

$4"

' ,(

0-1- 2"

) $!

, /"

0-1- 2"

- 0+

$, 1 &!# 2"

# '&#

&3 )

) (

!"# ! !$

!$ $"%

$&%' ( ! !$! % ! ) ! ! *) !$ %" %% % + !$ $"%

$&% % ! )

"# !$ " *!""# !) " !$ "#, " "-%! +

% ! !$ ) $"%

$&% +$ $ ! "

" * !. " % " !$

% ! "# ! !$ / % !$

$&% " $/"# * / !$! % $ ) $

. . !$ "

!!) !$

$&% ! " !", !$ ."! $ !$%#$! !

! ! ." !" 0 !$ 1'2' !' 4$ , % $ % / "! !!" +% * "

% !$ "

*- ! " " !$ ."."! " !" 0 !$1'2'3 !" ( !$1'2'3 !' ' 1+

!$ %*." " *$

"!,

)"# %" !" 5 !$ ''' !$! "

!$ #"! !$

"/ !" ,

" "!

/ * ""# " !$ % $ " ! 6 !$

" %#$! "! ! $/ *" " " % ! !$ */

%" !$ " !$ % ! " !$

7 (' 7$"%8

", !$ $ " %*!"

4$ ""# + ." !" 0 !$ 1'2' ! !$! 9"!+!$!""# ")!$"#

"!" " !$ ." % :';' 4$ !/ !$ /" !" 5 !$ ''', ""# * !$

% !,

"#"# !$

"/ !" " "!"

%" !" !$ 1'2' !, !$

% !

+!$ !$ + ! ! !$

"! ! ! % $ %. ""# +$ $ $

* .".%.

6 !$

" ."!"+ *)!$! % !'; ' 2! + !$%, %"&%/

) * / " $ " !$

<=>?@AB> CBDEFG

! -%#."!, !$! "

" "# !$ (!!."!

*- ! " " !$ ."."! " !" 0 1'2' ! " " % / "! !!" !$ , !$ !" .", $

* * /" " ! ! !$ #"! !$

"/ !" " "!"

%" !" 12 !, " +$ !$

. "! +

! !$ ."."! ! 1'

'', !

" % $ % / "! !!"

"# $%!

& '

) *$+ &%$!% , -

%.! & %!

* % $

/ ++ $% !! % % 0 + %

++ $!

!$' *

++ + !!

1 &

& % ' !

% + &+ "2

%0+ '+ %

+ &+ "2

++ $!

$ % &

%,,, !$!

, / &$%

% %%

+0$0 &

%.! ! %0

) &

/ ! * + % *

( &

"# ! !! &

0 ) &

/ *! 0.

*% 3'23 $!

!%$ ! 4%$+ 5 % 4!

++5 !

++ $% *! % % ! *$+ ! &%*

! +% !!% "

!!0 , , 7 !

89:;<=>: 8;<?@ A>BCDE F GHEI 88 A>BCDE JBI K;:><=>: LD<=@; D<= D<HM@>:N

( )

% & % % & %% !

4 #$0'

% %!

% % 0%0 !$! ! & !

. $ ! & 1 &

'$ & ' ! *

% # * + ! %0

#$0'

& K;J>O 8D@<;

!$% ! +! % + "2

+ % $!

+ &%

!*! 0% ++2

+ $! 4, -

#$0'

& $#" %2 0 $% P QRSTUPP VWXYRP *

% + "2

+ % $!

+ &%

++!

+"% +2 ! % "2

0 $%

'$0 #$0'

, 7 %0% ) &

'$0 #$0'

0 $% % !!

&% !0$!

P QRSTUPVWXYRPZW[TP , , -

0 $% ! %0 ! \$ ! ], ! &%'

P QRSTUPP VWXYRPP ZW[TP *! %% +2 ! % , ^

!$! ! & !

!" "

# $%& ! ' (! "

")! ! !''! (! ! '

! ! !* +(! ,( (

%! "!" (!

! ! ! "

# '!

$%& ! ' (! "

)!- ,!&& (&" ( (!

! ! !

)!" "! $%& !* +(! "! ' (! .""

& /!

! "!&

( "! $%& ! ' "

' "!%

' 1 ' (! $ ' $%!

! ! !

)!"

,!&& , ( (! 2

' (! /!

" ! 3!! $$ !" 3- (! .""

& /!

(!"!"!" *

* 4

' (! .%%!&&! ,(

! ! ! 5! && $%& ! " 5! %%% ! "!

* 6( "!

3! %

!" 3- (! .%%!&&!

( $ !

' (! .%%!&&!

"! " "! "!* ,!)!# $%& ! ' (! "

! ! !

! "!&!

! ! !

()

3!! )!"*7 * .

!8%

' &,#

"3 3&- (! .%%!&&!

$! ' &! # 3- ,- ' (! %,! )!

# ! %%!&& # ,( &!" %%!&

(! 2"

$! ' ) "! /! ' 94 . " (! "! '

! ! !# "!%

$$ '

1 ' (! ! $%!

,"!"3-(! &* * +(!

' (! %! ! 3-

:;<;= >? :@A@BCD@E

% !

/! ***# ,

"!!"

(! ! ' >CE;BFGE :GHI@<

$! "! "!" * * # ,(!!

, 3 !)!" (# J9,

3!(&' ' (! %%!&& # !&-

% /! ' (! *** ( ! (! %%!&

(! "! ' )

%!'!!"# !

!)!3&! %! "

%%!& " (!!'!

( "! ' "!%

' 1 ' (! ! ( ()! 3!! %

!" "

%% ' (! 3)! !& ! %&!" % (! "!

' (

(! ! 'K LMNMOKK PQK

!" #$"#%&'(#)*!$#) %()"!+,')" #-. / 2)$23& '( $#5)$% '! '(# 6+%51#"'

" '(# )# !* 789: ;<=>?@A9=?B9 CA9A

+D$)&

'!! 4) !"

%#$#% ,3 !"E,2# F(# 0+D$#1# !+$'

" '(# )# !* CGBH=?HB C<=IA JHKL9M

"% 6+%51#"' )"% (#2%

'! ,# "!' 2)3 "5 %!4" 5!!% 2)4& '(+ '(# $#2 )" # '(#$#!" )2! ,3 '(# D#'

!"#$ %!# "!' (#2D'(#1'!*+$'(#$'(# $+,1

!"&'(#$#2#N)"'D)$)$#)%'(+ O / P"!*)$ ) '(# 6+%51#"' !* '(# Q!1,)3 5( !+$'

" RST UVWXYX Z[ 4( ( () ,##" $#2 #% ,3 '(# 2#)$"#% !+"#2 *!$ '(# )DD#22)"'&

+**

#"' '! !,#$N# '()' '(# 5( !+$' % % "!' ()N# ,#"#* !* 6+%51#"' !* '( !+$' %)'#% / /

" Z VX\ ZV] \^_`a / F(# 6+%51#"' !* '(# Q!1,)3 5( !+$' 4) %#2 N#$#% !" b/ / 4(#$#) 6+%51#"' !* '( !+$'

" )DD#22)"'E )#

%)'#% / / / P" N #4 !* '(# 2)4 2) % %!4" ,3 '( !+$'

" Z VX\ ZV] \^_`a %# %#% !" / / & '(# 6+%51#"' !* Q!1,)3 5( !+$'

" RST UVWXYX Z[ )""!' ,# ) % '! ,# ) 5!!% 2)4

"!*)$ ) !"#c+#" # !* "!" !1D2 )" # !* !"% !" !* +D#"

!" !* #"'#" #

!" #$"#%/. b/ F(# )DD#22)"'& 4(! ()N "5 ,##" !"N '#% +"%#$ 0# '

!" !* dP e '&

'! D)$' '( )" )1!+"' !* * "#f !1D#")'

!"& D#"% "5 '(# )DD#)2& 4( (

" "! 4)3 )" ,# !"'$+#% '! ,# +"*) $ )"% +"$#)!"),2# !$ )1!+"' '! ')g "5 )4)3 !*( +,')"'

N#$ 5('/ / e () ,##" !,#$N#%

" '(# )*!$#$#*#$$#% 6+%51#"'& '(# %#2)3 () !1D$!1 #% '(# )" '

'3 !* '(# (#c+# '$)") '

!"& '(# )DD#22)"' 1)g "5 )''#1D' '! #N)%# ), '3 )"% )+ "5 5$ #N)" # '! '(# !1D2) ")"'& '(+ *!$ + ( $#)!"& '(# )$2 )1#"' '(!+5('

* '! )1#"% 0# '

!" b !* '(# d/P/ e '/ F(# eDD#22)'# !+$' () '(# D!4#$ '!

1D!# '(# !"% !" !* %#D!

) D)$' !* !1D#")'

!" 4( 2# +D#"% "5 +D#"

!" !* #"'#" # )"% !" "!"%#D!

'& '(# )1# 4!+2% # '(#$ )+'!1)'

)223 ,# N) )'#%&

* D$!N %#%

" '(# !$%#$ !$ '(# ) %

" "#

$ %"!" & ( )

" ) "

% * )" ) "#

$ !"

$ !% "

+! , &&&* - . ." "

/ ) %( $0!

) "# # & 1) ) ! %- )" )

.." )" /) .( ! )

2 )!# " "#

# ) % 34'! & & %- ) "$% !

* ) " )"% / "

)

!"* "

! "/"

)

& 5 .(* )

)$(#$ /$ # & 67879:;7<=;7>?@ A<=BC DEFGHFDGDI &J"#" K) ) "L /M" NM3 K) ) "$. NM3