High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/2772/2018allowed

Gurinder Singh v. State Of Haryana

2023-12-21Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari15 pages

# $ % !&'& ()"'*''''

',% -. #!'/0%102' 3/4+%2'

/ 3/%+ !,/2' 2".

+5432' !!4/2'

/ 6+0

&/%,// + 2 % % !

7 #2 / + 2 8%0 & + 0 +

, 9+

/ +

0 :;

<% /,) =:'

# ;2 #!.*6%,> :-;

<% /, ( ? :' #7;2 1/ -.2/ 0 , /,

+ % !

7'/ #> :;

<% /,/,

? :'

#@;> :;

<% /, @

:' #=;2 1/ -.2/ 0 !

A%, 2 6

+ / 2 % , / ? > &/ +

/ / - 0 +60./ ,%// ) / -

0/ 2

% -./ "B-0 !%+ %2

!"#"$% &

&/ ) 8%

= @2 6 -. 6+0C

+ 4%62 00 ,, / 2 / / +/ 12 6 0.2 $ /0 / 1, / +/ +

+ &/ 9/

2 / ) 2 +% /

! " #$

% & '

#( )

")" * +* & "

, * ( & - + (

. (

" ! "-/ +*&( "

" 01 (

" ( ** 22* -" 01 ( 2 ( " & +*

( (

01 ( * 2 .& * ( ( " , ( & 2* .

& "

, * 2* 3-" *) , , * 41.

% ( * ** 41.% (

3-/" .

* ( (

# (* * " ( & ! " 5#( +

2* ** ! " '

#( (* 6 "" " " " 2* ** %,! " '

&"0 !

#(* "

" 78 7

8% / 65, / / -

27 = @1 21/ %+2 + 6 6/

1 % +

, % !

7 / # 1 % &/ 2 3 6+ ,$+%0 02/ /$ /04021 % 21//+ / %

/2 +:' #;2 - +" 8"1 2

1// - +2 6%/ 0 . 2/

,, %,// +6/ 0!%, 2*6%,',0.2 13 26+ , '+ 02 #%

40 4%0D

!,/21 % 21//+ / %

/2 +

=:' # ;2- +" & * ", " ( "

&! , "* + 4 ,, * *"8 @ "1 2 / +

= +

.2 6%/ 2+ / - /&/ 2.

,/ !%+ #0 2*6%, 1 0 :' # ;/ 0!%, 2*6%,2/ -.

5, +/E/ %

/ / +

$ / F = ',0.2/ 0!%, 2*6%,

:' # ;4%0D

!,/'+ 02/ -.

5,/ 6, +/ 8%. + 1/ %

/1 / +/

06 0.2/ 3 26+ ,4%0D

!,/'+ 02 %-6 8%. + =

= :' #;21// 001,0% 2 * +" &

* ", " * ("

! , "* + 4 , , * *" &(8

8% 0.2 -

%+ / +2 / ) 1 , / 2% !

7'/ #2#! *6%,.2 *6%, ? ' / ) 2

,66 %+ 6+0 2 / )0 + % !

# 1 +

, /

&/ 2,+6

2/ 1 2

? 2 /,

+% /-0 % !

7'/ #21/// +0 ,%0.

06 0

"1 2 / 6, /, %

, /

+ ,, /6 % , / ? 21/ -.2/,

1 6 , /6&/ 6 %

/ 2/ + 1 6

-./ 0 !

A%, 2/%,/1, @

8% 0.2/ - 9 /

/ %2/ -.

5,/ 0 2 / 0 ,+,+//

&/ 0 %

0/ 2/ 5,/

- 0 2 %-6 /

+ / - ,0-0. /

8%. + 2% -./

6 0 - 2.

/ 8%. + ..%0+.+, &/ 2 6 0. %,,

20-0 / / / 1 +

/ 8% 5002 1/// +

/ +

22/ %/ 1 ,

0. 22/ 1 9 &/

+ / - ,05.%0+.6 0, / 2 .

,,, .+

/ ) , /

+ 2

%00.2 1 0 / 2

% -.

"B-0 !%+ %

'((

8% 0.2/

) 1 - ,8%

7 # 2/ 0 ! %

0/ 0 %

/ 6+0/ % 0.++

/ , 0 / 2/ ,%2// 8%. + =

= :' #; 0%

/// + 6 0./ 0+6 '

#/.

2/ 0 %0/ -

2/1 2 %// 0+ 1 05,&/ 20,// 8%. +2/ % 00 1// 6-, 21// /

/ ) - 0

@ &/ 0 %

0/ 6+0/ 0 +0 6 %.6 0 0,E'% + #%06.

+F21/

9 +% % 6( * " " " * ( * , / " 9 ( * * " "

( ( , " (:

" "

= (/ ,// - +/

%.6 02/ /

,%6 // %,//

510 , -%/ 00

/%0/ -

00 8%++ 50 / 6+0 2.2 ,%, %, . + %, .&/ 21, / +/ 2 ) / ,/0.-

-,6 0+ 63 2/ -.6 ,6+0 / ,% 0

++0

2 01

'((

0%,/ ,%6 2/ 0 ! %

0/ 6+0,%

// + 6 62 / +0 :

;

-./ 0 %

+ 0

/,/0. +% 8%

21//0.-

D% %,0 )*+,

&/ %/ / ,%6 -./ 0 %

/ +

/ 6 6 %0% % ./ "1 2- 66 ,+ 1.+ , /

0./ ) /

8% / 1,/,

, 2/ %

6+ 2/ D%% 2+%

,06+

/ 2

, !

7'/ #22 % + 01

? !

7'/ #21//+

/ +% /6 /.+ 2-.1// / / 2 - .!("/0 1 /$"/ 6 , * " ( ((

(

" "

" *

" * ; *

&/ "B-0 !%+ %

'(( / 0 1 9 / 01 0,1// 60 6 0 + /

2/ "B-0 !%+ %21/0 +0, 0

%+2$#34"

5(6" $/ # !##"

-78 9:7;*

%/ 0/6 0+ - 0600.0-0 %0

/ 50

2 50

26 0+ 6.- 0-0 0. / 065D%,6 2/ -

/ 0//

6,6 0 2 0 2$#'( ( / 8% +6 ++0-0 &/ %

2 6 / ,2

'(( +% / 2 *< ,* " , ( ,( ,:

" * , , +*, *, <( => " <= ($ 1 3 2""

-78%%: 7% !* 7 98

< * ( - ? ( * " *

*& (*

" *" * 9 "

* * " * ! (

( * " * & ( * , , , "

* ! ,

"" , * * & ( &! @ & " * &

& ; "

*" * !

( " * & & ;" & " * " * ( ( 2

* ,(2 9 * " * "( ( *"

" "A% B4

4CD &/

/ 0% 2 %66 %+-./ "B-0

!%+ %

'(( 2 / 6 +" * * (( * * (- " *9 & " * , "

; "(, &

" ? ((

** *

((

( *((

(( * , ( (#((( *(

( " , ( * , *

* " 2;" E ((E ( /D+ *.4% 9 * E( E

06 0.2 / "B-0 !%+ % / 6 /

,% 0

) 2, 6 0

+ 2% 60 :

; + ", "

" *, * % * * " (, " "" ( * (( " * 2,(( **

* " ((

* (( " " " "* *

( , ,9 * * " ;" (, "

" "" (< E * ,( + * ((

" (,

( F * * ( ,( * (, ,( **** " (

& *, *"

8 )%/ 6 2 )1 >( #$0

.<!!

/ "B-0 !%+ %/ 0/

* (" (, * (( ((" *

, *

" * *, :

" 8'0 21/0 %,/ -

'((

/ -

(( ( *((

( ( * , (

;" (( 8

( /D+ *.4% 9 * ( 8&/ 9/ D%,6 % 2% * " (

* ( " ( , * ((

((" *

" * *, :

" 8 7 ( / %/ / 01 0 1 -. / "B-0

!%+ %2 0 B 0% :; 1/ / +

% / 6

6+0 / ,% 0

%+;2 0 -./ "B-0 !%+

%2+ ) , / C22:;

1/ / 1 . / +/ 2 2 1/ %/ / -

0 2-./ 3 2 E,

F E . /,/ ,

F2 1//

8% 0.1 / +

%/ % !

/ # @ & 0% / - .2/ %/ 21// -0

00/ 0 %

++ ,/

6 6 %0% %./ &/ % 0 /

8% / 65, -.6+0C

+ 4%623 26+ ,$+%0 02 / /$ /04021 % 21//%/ /

0 +:' #;1// + +* ,( " * % G;

! " (

* " *

" 2*

& *

8 = "1 2 / - + 0. 9+0 / +/ 2/

,, , ++/ / 0!%, 2*6%,2/ -.

+',0.2 13 26+ ,'+

02#%

404%0D

!,/21 % 21// %/ /

=:' # ;-. , 001,+ 2 * +" &

* ", " ( "

&! , "* + 4 ,, * *"8 ! / 10. % 3 0 2 +:' # ;2+ / / 00 / 1/ 6 E F E,

%00.2 /

,, %,/ + +6/ 10. % 3 1/ 60

/%0- , +/ + 8% ./

,, 2 3 2 6' # 2 %

65 .66 2/ %,,

/ / +0 5 /

0 ! /

/ 3 /

%-0 +/

,, 2/

0 1 2/%,// !%+ #0 2*6%,2 , 8% + +6/ 3 1/ / %

/$ /01 % / + &/ 8% C8% . 0

' # 21// 0

-./ !%+ #0 *6%,2/ 0!%, 2*6%,&/ ' # +% / 72 * &

9 & (9 " * *)

((

" *

* & 8 ?

8% %+ +0 :' # ;2/ 0 !%, 2*6%,

0 :' # ;/ 3 2/ -. 5,/ 6, +/

8% . :

%+;2

-. / !%+ #0 "1 2 / 6 6- / 3 / /,/ %

2/ 2/ 6,16 6- / 3 2/%,/1,0 :' # 7;2 8%

0!%, 6 16 6- 2 -0,/ 6

%-6 / +

' # 72 / 0 !%, 1 0 :' # @;21/ -.2/ 6, 16 6- / 3 1 + +

8%. +/ -

/ / 1.2/ /8%.

+ =

=:' #;1 +% 616 63 "1 2/ /8%. +:' #;0 /

-0 /. / +/ % .,%/0,/ %0+-0 2 -

+ /

8%. +:' # ;20. 1 1 / 2 &(8&/

9/ /8%. +:' #; / 2 * +" &

* ", " * ("

! , "* + 4 , , * *"

" "($="/" "(( 8

,0.2

+ /

8%. + - ,+% -.

,,, .22

+ / / 60 ,./

,,, ./

+2 2/ %/ - , 0 - ,

0. /2 .

,,, .+

/ +

) , /2 0+

6/ 6/ &/ 26/ - 2 - 1//

++0-D /

,,, . 2- /

5, %6- 8%. + 2/ 6 0- / - 21

% %+ / 3 0 /

+ - % ,/ //

"1 2

%0 2/

,,, .%0

% . +

-0 // %0+-0./ 2 08%. +2/ 6 2

/E "* + 4 ,, * *" &(8 / 1

2/ 06/

,,, .

-0 /,/ %0+-0./ 2 'D.-/ 6 ,6

2' # =28%/

-/+/.

2 /6

022

2 * A2/ 6

)1 '(( (6/ "B-0 !%+

%/ 0/*

(( ( *((

( ( *, (

;" ((8 ( /D+ *.4% 9 * ( 8

21/ / /

8%. + /

,.%0+.0 / 2 6 0.

%,,

/ / / 1 +

/ 8% 5002 1/// +

/ +

22/ %/ 1 ,

0. 2/

. / % 0

/ 2 /, / +

0%.2- ,

2/ -. %,60 &/ ,

,/6/ )1 '(( (6 1// 0

* (" (, * (( ((" *

, *

" * *,

" 8 7 2/ +6 - /6,/ -

,% 0

-./ "B-0 !%+ %

'( ( 1 0 + 6 0+ 660% +

%2 %0+

%6 0+ 1%0

0. /

. @ '0 2G, 3 // "B-0 !%+ %*$" ?#" >(@3 A0

(7.

7!!

!" ./ 0/ + 06.8%. 8% - %

6 0 22/ .-D +

,+ 06.8%.

/ 6 0+ 6 %+ 0%% +

%&/

9 2 0

*$" ?#"'( D%,6 2 +% / ., **

- HH HH HH ,+ " " 9

" *

* 2( *" 9 -

% HH HH HH 5 (( HH HH HH8 =

1/ - 0 ,0++ 2%+0 1//

0- / - 2/ %/ /

0% // 0-0 %- / 06/

%// / 2 /, / +

0 %

200 1// +/ ,

21//6.

1 / - , +

% % !

7' / #

8% 0.2/ % 0./0// +

) / -

0/ ,% 0

'((

)00/ :

%+;2/ % 6 / + 001

8% 0.2/ + ())*+,- / ) =:' # ; -.

8% 2/ ? :' #7;21/ -.2 + / -

7'/ #2 / /,

? :' #@;2 2/ @

:' #=;21/ -.2/ 0 !

A%, 2 6

+ / 2 % , / ? 2 0 / -../(01,- 2

# -,456-,7

1,81,7 09,(:56;<7,(0*6,- ,0< * 1,81,7 7,9*78(=), ,0< *