High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/26798/2017dismissed

The Mobile Store Services Ltd. & Others v. M/S Beetal Teletech Ltd.

2018-10-15Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan9 pages

"# $!%&'&"()

*+

+

,!

"-&.!

/ "0!

/!01&%!'

2 $+ ($ " ,!0'

+++! & &"(!0'

3!0'4'

5'

!! !.

!.! !%, 2 $+ +++!'6"($!( ) 7 2 / 3

/ /8

3

/ /89 + !

# $% &' '$&( )* +,-

##

&%/ 0 . 1 # &//& ) 20 1 3- # 0 '$%&,4

4'$&( $' $5 '$&( .

4 .

6. 7 8 4 6 .

7

'' $9 '$&5 )* +9-

#

'5 $( '$&(

:

. ;1

< # # = !

## 7 = !

.

; < # $' $5 '$&(

.

; <

7

;

< #

$' $5 '$&(

>

.: . ;1 <

$' $5 '$&( . 6

>

.: $' $5 '$&(

.

$/ $? '$&(

#

. .

!

. #

.

'5 &$ '$&( .# !

6 $% &' '$&( .# !

* # 0

@&

# A* @&4& A* @&4,? .

"

## : !

7 # $% &' '$&( ##

+

&%/ 0 1

... #. +# !

.

# !

!# &?

: "

. > ?9$$$$$$4+ ) !

: .!- : +# !

"

.B :

!# . $5 $9 '$&( ..

# &9 ! # . !

&$ $9 '$&(

!# '5 $( '$&( 6

## # $% &' '$&( 6

;

#

. # # '' $9 '$&5 6 ..

7 #

# .

.

7# .

! $' $5 '$&(

. #

$? $? '$&(

.!

: B

. .

1 # ## "

!

'$'

7 #

. .!

.

;

'' $9 '$&(

# .# .# 7 #

.

# $? $? '$&(

: B

. 1 .! . +#.

#

. .

.!

.# #

# .

.

"

..

# #

C

"

#

#

"

"

#

%&!'

"

( )

(

(

"

(*

+,%&!'

-.!/0 -.!/,%

#

"

# '0%&!'

-.!/,

$

"

0& && &&&/2

!+3 !0

*

0%&!'

-.!/,,

( !&0%&!'

-.!/,0

"

!'0%&!'

-.!/,'

!&0%&!'

"

#

"

0&

0& && &&&/2

%&!'

# #

!&+,&0 !&+,&, %0

#

"

" #

1

"

# (

#

"

#

% '%&!'

# 5 "

7

5 "

% '%&!'

# # 86 7 % %&!' "

% %&!'

# 86 7

6 ( 861 7

!%%&!'

!,% 9#:

#;

<= 2>

"

:

( =

"

#

"

#

$?

#:

#

9:

+?

=

#

(

#

(

?

:

6

8

"

"

#

+

#

#

(

" (

"

&

(

(

"

"

" !0

1

!&0%&!'

#

"

!'0%&!'

-.!/,'

#

9:

# %'0%&!'

!,% 9#:

#

@*# 1

(

1

A

1

A

#

# $ - A 1

A

%'+%&!

/

!,%9#:

>1

# (

%'0%&!'

$ #

#"

"

# % 0%&!'

# % '%&!'

# 5 "

#

@ 6

( =

#

#

# @

"

"

"

"

"

#

"

"

!'0%&!'

-.!/,'

!&0%&!'

"

# (

$

#

"

"

#

#

"

(

"

#D 2

#

" @

"

$

!,!

"

"

5

#"

#

"

E .

.

"

$? $% '$&( :

.!

# :3 ## $/ $, '$&( 6

. $( $9 '$&(

:

# !

"

#

. D&/E

&9 ! 6 $5 $9 '$&(

.!

&( $9 '$&(

:. &$ $9 '$&( 6 '5 $( '$&( .#

. .

#

!

# $? $? '$&(

6

# . .# . . # $? $? '$&(

. .

!

'5 $( '$&( . . = !

.

;

$' $5 '$&(

..

.#

&,')- 0 1 6

# .

..

'$'

. . #

3.

#

!1!($0 <&',(..

=.& 3'+

>0?!',

&@("($'

1 + 2 $+ ($ " ,!0'9

;

0.+

* .

4 $

D

#

!!

#

$$

%

# &'( )* #

&)

%

# &'' + ,$ -

.

!$ 1

/ 0# .## 1 2 0 # &# 444

#

4

444

$ , 1

+

"

9!:

$?

9%:

(?

:

(?

9,:

"

?

90:

( " !0

E 6

"

1

#

# !

#

! '$&(

.

* .!

3

/ /8 &9 &$ '$&/

@ :4 F40 @ . F40