Balwinder Singh Etc. v. Bachan Singh
!"!
#$
%%& '(!# ) !#*+ # # + ) %%%%%,, ''#"
-"%
+# !#*+
%%%% ", # .$ /0 .%
.
.
% ! "
" ##$ #
#
%&
&#
""
# & () )* +,,-
( .
&"
& # "& "&#
++ )+ +,,-
.
"& #
/0
'"1 #&
& "&#
), ++ +,,*
"
"&
/
'"1 % & "
# "
#
& (
"
2"
# " &
# &
"
#& # "
"&
(
"
&
!
. # 4
'
5# "
" #
6
"6 # 5# "
#"
7())8 & & (9 )7 +,,)
%# +, ++ +,,) '2" %
(9 +( +,,+ :;< += " ! :
=
"
#"
2" "
"
" "
!
" &
&
&
#
&
"
% " "
&
"
>
# &
# % "#
"
&
"
%
" '
5#
%&
"
"
" " * ? #
@
# "
'
5# !
" "
"&
" +, ++ +,,)
#"
7())8
2"
4
A 9
-
& &
#
"# "
(9 )7 +,,) "
&
4 " "# '
5#
& "
#" A +,,-
% "
" "
?
&
# < "
" + B
# "
"&
"&
"
&C ? ( 4
% "& "C ? * B
#
% "
# "& "
& C ? B
" C ?.
4 "
&C ?.
-
#
B +
" E"
& "& :
= !
B (
"&
& "# %
;< +
(9 +( +,,+ ;< ( ' % +,77 7, ;< * ' &
.
< # " &
.B + &
%
A +
& A
F
"# %
"
# - G
& " A + "
& # "
(9 +( +,,+ :;< += B & " A ( "
" & "
"
&
&
"
" & " 4" A *
"
&
&
" "
2" %
% "
4" A 9
&
&
# % "
& 2"
# " "&#
), ++ +,,* &&
& "&#
'"
F " " "
#
2" % # 0
# "& "&#
++ )+ +,,- G 0
# &
(9 +( +,,+ :;< += & & "
"&
(
# A 3,89 "
<"
5# "
2"
"%
*:+= /! 4
+7,,1 : 6 +7,,6=
" % &
% "
G 0
&
&
' & 8
" & @
, G "
&"
% +,77 7, :;< (= " &
" '
5#
%# 2"
, #
"
"
" "
(9 +( +,,+ :;< +=
# "
" "
" ! % +773
"
"
8 4 "
&"
&
" #
& " "
" & # # "
" "
& "
"
?
&"
"
#
# "& # (D )* +,,-
& 0
" &
" # #
2" %
% &
"
" "
# 5#
%# "
& #
G "
#
&" # "
"
# %
G "
"
&" &"
'"
&" A 3
+)
4
&"
'" & & &
"
% " +773
# +) @
"
" "
& #
& "
2"
"
"
'" + B
"#
# "& "&#
'" & "
&
" C
( B
#
"& #
(D )* +,,-
#
&"
"
# <#
% C
!#
%$ ++ !
&
B + # "
"&
(
(9 +( +,,+ :;< += " ! :
=
4
6
"6 (9 )7 +,,)
7())8 " 5# +, ++ +,,)
2" %
(9 +( +,,+ " " B ( E"
& :E "&=
"& "##
&
" "
& "
! :
= &
;< +
"
" 6
"6
! "
"#
9D7+8HD
< #
#"
7())8
!
"
(9 +( +,,+ :;< += "
" ! :
=
"
-:-=:<= " & .
:.
=
+,3- / +,3-1 # "
+7 " & .
:.
= +,3-
/ +,3- 1
+(
& " % " #
+,3-
+,3- # " /&%
!#!!
#"
4 " < 2" :+=
< < < < :+ =
< < < < :+ = /
&
%1 "
" "
% 5#
5# 4
:= A *:*D= 448-)
*
" +,-+
A *:D9=8 448-) GI D +,-( := A 0 +7:9)=
8-+8 8'#
I (* +,-*
:= A 0 +7:9)=8-+ '#
I (, +,7* " "
F
:(= /"
'
1 "
J '" :"
'
= ? +,D)
" 3%
( )
)#"
) , 6*
'
,) , )7 :+= "
"
" ! :
= ! :
=
%
&
% :
=
< < < < :=
"
"
%
'
$ 5# # # # ## "
'
F := :=
< < < < :+ =
< < < <
:(=
< < < < :*= ;% ! :
= ! :
=
&
&
%
"
" " " :+=
#
" ? & " :9= 7,
& +,)7 :JH4 +,)7= 8'
(
!#!!
#" 4
" < 2"
:
= :=
< < < < := K L "
" "
&"
"
" & .
% "
" &
"
&"
"
"
" "
&"
"
"
:= :=
< < < < :=
K L
" ## "
'
"
%
'
$ 5# # # #F :=
K L
" "
:
=
KL
%
"
:#= :=
< < < <
:
'
'#
) ,) , )7 ;7 8 !
:+=
B
% " 4 44
444 '
2"
&
5# .
# # 5# .
# ' % '
% " 4"
"%
"
"
"
"
" ! :
= ! :
=
:(=
< < < <
:*= ! "
" "
&"
"
&
& " "
"
&
& := && "
'
<& 9) M
5 "#
:=
< < < <
:= && "
'
'
"
:9=
B
"
&"
"
## "
'
'
&
"
#
"
<
<
<
<
:D=
< < < <
:-=
B
%
"
"
" := 4
! :
= ! :
= := :<=
< < < <
:<=:
= 4#
& & :
"
" = :<=: =
< < < <
:<=
< < < <
:<= B
"
$ "
#
"
" ! :
= ! :
=
" #
#
<
"
;< !
#"
:
= B
"
"
% # " "
"
&"
% "
"
'##
< <
:= :=
< < < <
!
"
"%
" & "
" "
% "
" '
5#
6 & .
%6
! :
= # "& 6
"6 & #
"% " +,3-
# "
"
- "
#%
&&
& "
" 4
" 6
"6 (9 )7 +,,)
7())8
" 5# +, ++ +,,)
(9 +( +,,+ & & "
"&
(
# A 3,89 " "
-:-=:<=
& "&
'" "
&
%
%
(9 +( +,,+ &" "
" +7,,F &
&
4
& +,)7 : 6 +,)76= ; &"
@ "& " &
"
%
:;< +=F " 5# & & "
#
5#
"
2"#
"%F & " +7,,
+,)7 '2" %
& '"
(9 +( +,,+ :;< +=
"
<" "# "
"
% "
(9 +( +,,+ :;< +=
#
"
"
(9 +( +,,+
'
5#
!
&"#
"
%
"
&
" "&
# &
# % A ( %
"
%
" '
5#
%& "
"
4
2 % #
# " & &
"
.B +
%
%
A +8
&
.B +
&
"
"
"
"
"# %
! "
%& "
"
&
4 < #
#
" "&
(
& A 3,89 @ .B +
< # ! "
"F
" "
"
"
7())8
!
" &
"
#
& % "# %
G "
& #" " % +,77 7, :;< (= "
& "# " & 5" & "
&
"
"
G "
" & 8
A (
& # " &
&
@
&
&"# "
"
3 " &
&
F 0
& & "&#
" &
&
,
" /
<
< <
< 4
&
' &
" & 5" & 1
!
& 0
'"F
&
"
)3 +( +,,D
0
" &
&
&
A +(
*
&
& # /+ !
" & 5" &
&
!
( ! " &
&
* !
-
" & 5" & 1
4 % #
" +
& " & ( ' & &
&
!
. # 1
4 #
"
##
#
4
&
"
; &"
0
"
" &
&
#
" ? 9+
(3 ' '
& " & N & 5" &
!"
% " " & 5" &
% +,77 7, :;< (=
& %
& ;< *
& " & 5" & % +,7, ,)
"
! % % +,,) ,+
"
& " &
& " " "
&
& % +,,+ ,( " +,,-
:
& &=
"
% % ' & &
& "
! %
" ' & & % +,,(
"
& " A +,,-
(9 +( +,,+
; &
" & " &&
"
& #
+* '2" %
&"#
"
%
" '
5#
& "
;
"
# (9 +( +,,+
#
"
"
2" %
& #
" "&" 8
%&
"
"
2"
#%
&
!#
%&$ +9
"
(D )* +,,-
0
" &
#
'"
" /
'
% " &
"
"
" &
A # )7 )D +,,- .
# % "
" 1 +D ! (D )* +,,- "
"2"
&
; &"
%
0
&" A 3 7
+) & &
" /3
!
.
"&
# &
."&
%
+) )9 +,,D " ? 9+
(3 ' '
&& #" A ((*D
& " &
& 5" &
&
"
A (
$ # 2 A 97* (9 )7 ,)
&
" & A 3,89
A 3,89 :3E (=
""
&
A 3,89
!
() )D +,,D
!
.
"&
#
"& # "& "&#
&
" & 5" &
%
#
! #
" " & .
:.
= +,3-
#
+) !
.
"&
&"
%
&
% &
"
&
5 " ? 9+
(3 ' '
#
" #" & & " &
$ #
2 "# "&
"
&
"
&
!
.
"&
# "& "&#
"
""
4
&
" "
&
4 @6
& " " A#
& +,,*:(= G
*39 /'
#
# # "& "&#
B "# "&
"
& " "
%
" ? 9+
(3 ' '
"& < #
@ &
2"
# # &
##
# % "# "
#"
"&&
!"
"
" "
< #
.
"&
& %
&"
"&#
"
#
" 1 ! @6
H" '
+,,9:+= G
-**
@6 /4 "
" ? 9+
(3 ' '
A
&
"
! "&# "
"
&"
! " #
.
"&
#
&
" ? 9+
(3 ' ' 1 4
@6 '" # "& "&#
.
"&
#
&
1
!
<
"
&"
% 0
++ )+ +,,-
" ' A ++99 '8+,,- <" # "& "&#
"
"
)D )( +,,-
& " &
A +
& (D )* +,,-
A (
*
A ( "
&
)D )( +,,-
" /' A ++99 '8+,,- 4
A 3)38+,,- ( ! &" ## "#
#
&
& "
* !
"
"# %
)D )( +,,- ( ! &" ## "#
#
&
" 1 !"
# &"
"
"
A + +-
"
0
&
++ )+ +,,- % "& #" A ((*D & & " &
$ # 2 A 97* (9 )7 +,,)
;
F "
$ % # &
%&
"
"
"
& "
(9 +( +,,+ :;< += "
"&
& 2""
# &
'"
< &
# & & (D )* +,,-
& &" A 3
+) "
&"" "# %
& /
1
"
# &
! "#
"
"&
&
# &"
!
"
& " %
"
#
" " " #
4 &" A 3
#
"6
() )D +,,D
/
! & %
%
"
"
#
0
++ )+ +,,-
"&
;
# () %
& (D )* +,,-
&
" #
"
%
&
! "# G "
"
"& " # 2" # &
&
&"
"
)D )( +,,-
& % "
&&
(D )* +,,- "
& # &" A 3
+)
" #
" % /
1
+3 ! "
%
"
%&
"
" # # 5# "& 6
"6 &
## "
'
(9 +( +,,+
%
+7 A
+, 4 "
#
# <#
%
+)))))8 :
=
" &
< "
#
2"
!
& # %# "
"
"
#
2"
"%
()
& #
&
""
"
& # ##
# "
'"
% # "
"& / "1 "
2" ?
"
%#
% "
## .
& := # % % %
%
%& &
>" %
&2 " %
& &
&
#" &
"
"
"# &
"
#
&
"&
"
F "
#
" & "
"
%# %
&
!
" # " $
"
# #
&
(+ !" " ##&
"
"
#
"
&"
*9) ' '#
" +,3* : 6' ' 6=
"
&
#
&"
"
"
)D )( +,,-
&8
A +
&
(D )* +,,- &
"F
" "
<
%
.
"& # ++ )+ +,,-
((
&
"
" "
(* )+ ()+7
% % "
" ##& " +,* +,- ()) I (), 4
' 64'6 # "
&3 (*
&% "
#
A 3)38+,,- "& "
)D )( +,,- :"
" =
& ++ )+ +,,-
0
&
(9
' "&# ' % "
' % @ %
2" "&
/
"1
%
?8'# "%
"
2" #
"#
$
"
&
"
"
"
"
"
"
&
=.
> %%& . B &8
O8A
B
O8A